Take a Break: Shemitah and Loan Amnesty, Lesson 1
| Podcast: | Subscribe to Binyomin Bitton - Talmudic Principles |
| Audio: | Listen to Audio | Download this MP3 |
| Podcast: | Subscribe to Binyomin Bitton - Talmudic Principles |
| Audio: | Listen to Audio | Download this MP3 |
loopholes and workarounds, just a thought
Shalom,
I agree with Shalva T. I am afraid of the loopholes HASHEM could create for all the work arounds that are placed during the centuries, by us. Did anyone think about that? Why not leave the responsabilitie of the Torah, where it should be, and we let go of workarounds in all matters of our lifes...accepting and embrasing what comes from Him.
I do not have concrete answers it was just a thought. By the way, i am not a Jew by birth; I belong to the Gentiles.
Let us love HASHEM with all our mind, hart, body and soul and our fellow humans ( far and close) without anyone excluded as He has loved us.
Word Games ~ How sad! When dealing with loopholes, one must be exceptionally accurate, lest he fall into one and be hanged by his own words! As angering as embarrassing is that our people strain themselves to devise 'word games' (Pruzbuls) designed to circumvent the spirit of the Torah, while scrupulously attending to its letter! From what is recorded in Torah, it would seem that the Creator of the Universe may have found it irritating as well! (And the Jovel has been totally written out of the equation, as 'not applying in our time'?!) You say, This would suffer! That would suffer! What is so on fire it cannot wait 1-2 years? You say lenders would no longer lend, yet we are forbidden to close our hands to our brother: if we have, we must lend 'sufficient', not for his want, but for his need! Courtesy of the 'loophole'. it can be 'business as usual'! All that is needed is a 'kosher strawman' ...Sad!
Making Sense of the 'Pruzbul' Thank you all for your comments.
This discussion deserves indeed a proper response, based on a better understanding on Torah & Rabbinical law, and the relationship between the two; a better understanding of the 'Pruzbul' enactment and how it relates to the Biblical law. Much of it, is beyond the scope of a written "Comment".
I see that your comments are based on the very first lesson, and I would encourage you to listen to the full series, giving you a better understanding of the 'Pruzbul' and how it relates to the original Biblical law of Shemittah.
Just a short note, to put things in perspective -- several opinions explain that the 'Pruzbul' system is in fact a Biblical concept, and that Hillel (the rabbis) did not added, changed or invented anything new. This of course raises the question: If so what was Hillel's point? This has been already thoroughly explained in the Talmud and its commentaries, and some of it will be discussed in the forthcoming lessons.