Download Now »

Intermediate Talmud: Lesson 28

Don't Split Up the Group

Autoplay Next

Intermediate Talmud: Lesson 28: Don't Split Up the Group

In this class, we begin a new Mishnah, the discussion of which centers around the idea that when individuals convene for a meal, they may not go their own ways without joining for the group recitation of the Grace After Meals.
Listen to Audio | Download this MP3
Talmud, Berachot, Zimun

Join the Discussion

Sort By:
1 Comment
Moe Cohen Hong Kong July 28, 2020

I'm a little confused. During the last 12 minutes of the lesson Rabbi Mendel Kaplan makes the point that the three individuals that left their groups and formed a new group of three are not obligated to make a mezuman. Thereafter, he mentions, that although they're not obligated they should do the right thing and make a mezuman anyway.
Towards the end of the lesson, Rabbi Mendel Kaplan states that the new group of three no longer have an obligation to make a mezuman and they can no longer do so.

I would appreciate your help in clarifying whether the new group of three have the option to make a mezuman or not.

By the way, I truly enjoy all the classes presented by Rabbi Mendel Kaplan. It's a real pleasure and privilege to learn Torah from someone as knowledgeable and articulate as Rabbi Mendel Kaplan. Reply

Learn how to study Talmud line-by-line and word-by-word. In this intermediate level class you will learn to understand the unique give-and-take style of Talmudic argument. Text for this class is Chapter Seven of Tractate Brachot (folio 45a).
Related Topics