Click here!

Intermediate Talmud: Lesson 5

When One Leaves the Meal Early

Autoplay Next

Intermediate Talmud: Lesson 5: When One Leaves the Meal Early

What do we do if the third person in a group of three left before zimun was recited? What about the tenth person in a group of ten? What if the person has not yet left but wishes to do so? Does the rest of the group recite zimun early because of him?
Talmud Berachot 45b  
Intermediate Talmud: Lesson 5 (English)  
Listen to Audio | Download this MP3
Talmud, Berachot, Zimun

Join the Discussion

Sort By:
1 Comment
Cohen Benjamin La Varenne, France July 12, 2012

Zimoun...again or not Rav Kaplan,
if I am right, two people can ask (or force) the third one to stop eating in order to do the zimoun together.

The opposite does not work, but if the one who stops eating first ask the two (or three) others to do the zimoun with him and they accept, should they do the zimoun again?

Benjamin Reply

Learn how to study Talmud line-by-line and word-by-word. In this intermediate level class you will learn to understand the unique give-and-take style of Talmudic argument. Text for this class is Chapter Seven of Tractate Brachot (folio 45a).
Related Topics