ב"ה

Why, Oh Why, Must We Suffer?!

Autoplay Next

Why, Oh Why, Must We Suffer?!

Concerning the future Redemption, the prophet declares, “I will offer thanks to You, G-d, for Your wrath,” for at that time, the good hidden in all mankind’s suffering will be made clear. But why must this be concealed from us until then?
Tisha B’Av, Redemption, Yearning for and Anticipating, Galut, Talks by the Rebbe: 21 Tishrei 5744, Lubavitcher Rebbe
Why, Oh Why, Must We Suffer?!
Disc 195, Program 779

Event Date: 21 Tishrei 5744 - September 28, 1983

Concerning the future Redemption, the prophet declares, “I will offer thanks to You, G-d, for Your wrath,” for at that time, the good hidden in all mankind’s suffering will be made clear. But why must this be concealed from us until then?

A possible answer: G-d wants Man to cry out with deepest sincerity, “We long for You, all day!” If a person could grasp in any way the “goodness” of exile, he could not cry out for the Redemption from the depths of his soul.

At the same time, a Jew is expected to serve G-d with genuine joy - and through this he tears down the barriers of exile. To spare a single Jew even a moment in exile is worthwhile; how much more so when all Jewish souls, since the Giving of the Torah, are all waiting in a state of exile, yearning for redemption.

You may also be interested in...


Join the Discussion

1 Comment
Newest Oldest
Daviid August 2, 2025

Powerful Reply

Please consider becoming a member of Living Torah today!