Prior to Shavuot we read the portion detailing the harsh consequences for forsaking G-d and His Torah. Is there another way to process these unsettling words?
Curse; CursesBehar-BechukotaiBechukotai
Join the Discussion
3 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Danny MEastonMay 23, 2025
I agree that the Creator cares and loves. But where does moral free will come into play if that is the case. Nobody wants to be punished. Thanks.
Reply
Rabbi Shalom PaltielPort WashingtonMay 23, 2025
in response to Danny M:
That's a great question, touching upon the very difficult question of free will vs destiny. Much is written on this very large subject. One approach might be, the reward and consequences of our actions are NOT immediately apparent, thus it takes a measure of morality and free choice to make the right choices. If reward and consequence was immediate, even animals can do that. Think dolphins doing flips and being fed an instant reward. Humans are charged to make choices even though most often we don't see how mitzvahs are good and immorality is self destructive; instant gratification can argue to the contrary. Yet, we choose the high road, and in the end the blessings result from it. i hope that's helpful
Reply
I agree that the Creator cares and loves. But where does moral free will come into play if that is the case. Nobody wants to be punished. Thanks.
That's a great question, touching upon the very difficult question of free will vs destiny. Much is written on this very large subject. One approach might be, the reward and consequences of our actions are NOT immediately apparent, thus it takes a measure of morality and free choice to make the right choices. If reward and consequence was immediate, even animals can do that. Think dolphins doing flips and being fed an instant reward. Humans are charged to make choices even though most often we don't see how mitzvahs are good and immorality is self destructive; instant gratification can argue to the contrary. Yet, we choose the high road, and in the end the blessings result from it. i hope that's helpful
Yes it is . Thanks a lot.