Dr. Reuven Feuerstein (1921–2014) was a globally acclaimed cognitive psychologist.

Born into a Jewish family in Romania, he narrowly escaped the Nazis in his early twenties and eventually settled in Mandatory Palestine. There he observed immigrant children, many of whom were either Holocaust survivors or refugees from North African countries, struggling in their studies, and he realized that their difficulties extended beyond language and cultural barriers. He came to the conclusion that these children, having grown up in tumultuous environments, had missed out on crucial stages of cognitive development—but that these deficiencies could be corrected with proper psychological support.

His observations propelled him to challenge the era’s prevailing belief that a person’s intelligence is innate and unchangeable. During studies in the 1950s in Switzerland, under teachers including Carl Jung, Karl Jaspers, and Jean Piaget, he began formulating a method—today called the Feuerstein Method—to develop cognitive abilities in children considered intellectually challenged and hopeless.

As his theories were germinating, Feuerstein said, “I started getting referrals from the Rebbe. Wherever I came, wherever I visited for work in my field, people came over to me saying, ‘The Rebbe wants you to see our child.’ Sometimes I would myself receive a letter or message from the Rebbe concerning a particular case.”

Seeing the types of children the Rebbe insisted were capable of considerable growth broadened Feuerstein’s horizons and emboldened him. “My belief that even people with genetic or chromosomal disorders can be turned into normal functioning individuals—I got that very much from the Rebbe. At the time it was very daring. People didn’t believe it was possible. They would ask me, ‘Where did you find the courage to say this child will be able to speak, will be able to read, will be able to finish school?’ Much of this belief, I must say, came from my interactions with the Rebbe.”

One such referral Feuerstein recalled vividly. It was the hardest case of his fifty-year career. “This boy was falsely diagnosed as mentally defective in the country of his birth and was placed in a school for ‘deficient’ children. There he lived among troubled adolescents and began to imitate their behavior. Consequently, he became a real problem, and nobody believed he could ever function as a normal, independent human being.

“At some point, his father went to see the Rebbe, and the Rebbe told him to bring his son to me, which is what he did. Thank G‑d, all went very well, and we felt we had been successful.

“But after he left us, he returned to his old friends and slipped back into reckless habits. He went to a place from which few people return. They were involved with drugs, crime, and promiscuity, and there was no transgression they didn’t commit.

“When I heard what had happened, I contacted the Rebbe, who said, ‘Don’t let him out of your hands. Send somebody to find him, bring him back and continue.’ I didn’t believe a rescue effort would succeed, but the Rebbe had instructed me to try, so I did. I sent somebody to take this young man away from these people, and we successfully coached him back to a healthy and moral lifestyle. He was lost but he came back, and today he is the father of four children.”

Recounting this episode years later, Feuerstein reflected:

“As a psychologist, I would never have believed that such a turnaround was possible. Usually, in such cases, we just raise our hands and give up. But the Rebbe did not give up.

“Psychology is very limited in its understanding of the other. It is very much affected by, and related to, our understanding of ourselves. But the way the Rebbe saw the individual, the reason he suggested and felt empowered to say, ‘Yes, do it,’ stemmed from an entirely different way of seeing a person: not as a reflection of the self, but as a spirit that comes from Above.”1

Divider

The Rebbe devoted much time and effort to lifting people out of entrenched despair. He showed them there is reason to be hopeful—because change is eminently possible.

Higher Than Angels

The great Jewish prophet Zechariah (4th century BCE) received a prophetic vision with an ambiguous message about the potential of human beings: “I will give you [the ability] to walk among those [angels] standing here.”2

Classically,3 the verse is understood to be describing just how high a person can climb spiritually. Angels embody the ultimate level of perfection, while human beings are inherently flawed. The greatest spiritual level the verse can ascribe to a person is the ability to attain angel-like status—to walk among the angels.

However, the Rebbe often pointed to a different interpretation of this verse,4 wherein human beings are considered far greater than angels: “I will give you [the ability] to walk, among those [who only have the ability of] standing.”

Angels are static beings. Sure, they are immensely spiritual, but within the realm of spirit they are stationary. They don’t struggle and stumble, and therefore quantum leaps are simply not possible. They stand still. Human beings are entirely different. Yes, we make mistakes, but we have the unique capacity to completely transform ourselves—the capacity to walk forward and reach entirely new places.

For the Rebbe, this wasn’t merely an interesting interpretation; it was a call to action. He believed in the ability of every individual to transcend their status quo, to move beyond the present—to stop standing and start walking.

“Even if you are correct with your assessment,” reads a letter to a young woman dejected over her perceived spiritual decline,

the solution is not to feel dispirited, inadequate, or inferior. On the contrary, this ought to evoke within you the determination to bring your inner powers to the fore to overcome this decline and grow even greater than before.

A person is charged to go from strength to strength and to “walk forward” their entire life. And since this is the duty of man, the Creator of man certainly gives a person all of the strength necessary to fulfill this role.5

A letter to a woman who recently lost her job reads similarly:

Human life does not always proceed in a straight line. Being that a person has the ability and aspiration to ascend—this itself also presents the possibility for descent. Thus, one should not be fazed and dispirited, Heaven forbid, when one encounters some level of descent….

On the contrary, a decline should awaken within you deeper powers of faith, which manifest in courage and equanimity in the face of an unpleasant phenomenon, especially one that [in your case] will last only for a very short time.6

Divider

One of the ideas that can give us the courage to make the shift from resigned “standing” to determined “walking” is that renewal is built into the very fabric of existence.

New Beginnings

The Baal Shem Tov, the founder of the Chasidic movement (1698–1760), would educate his students through pithy teachings that conveyed a new paradigm of the world, the self, and the Divine. The meaning of his teachings, and their application to the human experience, have been unpacked by generations of Chasidic masters.

One of these foundational teachings was that the world is divinely created anew at every moment of time.7 The world of a second ago does not naturally spill over into the present moment. It is actively brought into existence again and again.

Think of a rock that is thrown into the air, explained the fifth Lubavitcher Rebbe.8 It won’t continue to fly forever—rather, considering that an object flying goes against the laws of gravity, the rock must be actively pushed forward by someone or something. When the energy that thrust the rock into the air runs out, the rock drops. Similarly, considering the profound novelty of the universe’s existence—being something in the place of nothing—the world and everything within it must continuously be “pushed” into reality by a constant infusion of divine energy. If that divine energy would cease, the world would simply return to its natural state: not being.

Internalizing this, the Rebbe taught,9 can help us break free from the shackles of the past. Every day we are renewed and given a clean slate on which to draw our lives. Our choices yesterday do not determine our choices tomorrow. Yes, the past teaches us, impacts us, and may even scar us, but it does not define us.

This is the reason human beings were designed with the need for sleep.10 On the surface, sleep seems like a pointless waste of time. We would be so much more productive without it! But without intervals of sleep, life would be one long chain linking our past selves to our present selves in a seamless continuation. Going to sleep and waking up reminds us of the above truth: Every day is truly a new day, the past gone and slept away. A new present—imbued with new divine vitality and new personal opportunity—dawns.

This is also reflected in the natural flow of seasons. Winter is a time of gloomy stagnation for trees, vegetables, and plants. For long months they remain naked and dormant. Yet, despite this long hiatus, spring comes and a remarkable metamorphosis takes place. Fruits ripen, flowers blossom, green leaves grow, and the smell of revival is everywhere.

“Applying this idea to the human element,” reads a 1951 letter,

there can be a state of winter—of apparent unproductivity—in the life of a person.

But no individual should consider themselves—and certainly should not be considered by others—as having terminated their usefulness, even though a long time of fruitlessness has elapsed. Given the proper inspiration and stimulus, the state of winter can easily and suddenly be changed into spring and blossom time, which eventually will ripen into good fruits for G‑d and man.11

This is true also of those who feel the bloom of their life has passed and only an unproductive winter awaits.

Jerry Grafstein, a businessman and longtime member of the Canadian Senate, was once in New York on a diplomatic trip. He scheduled an audience to consult with the Rebbe about his public affairs.

“The Rebbe listened to me with visible interest,” Grafstein said, “and gave me some practical advice on my activities. However, he saw that something was pressing on my heart. When we finished discussing the questions I had brought up, the Rebbe asked me what was bothering me.

“I told him that I was no longer young and I was starting to think about what I had managed to do in my life and what I still had time to accomplish.

“Upon hearing this, the Rebbe asked me if I knew how old Moses was when he began his career. I did not. The Rebbe banged on the table and passionately said: ‘He was eighty years old!12 And you are very far from that age!’

“From then on, whenever such thoughts trouble us, my wife and I think of these words from the Rebbe.”13

Despair’s Seductive Attraction

There is a certain allure to thinking we don’t have the possibility of change, personally or communally. In surrendering to our present condition, we relieve ourselves of the work that is required to progress. Despair can thus be relaxing, excusing us from the effort growth demands.

The Rebbe cautioned many people about precisely this pitfall. As one response explains:

For then [i.e., when a person has resigned] what can be demanded of him and for what reason should he try? Why, he has already declared (to others as well as to himself) that he has given up all hope, Heaven forbid.14

Moreover, in the face of hardships, we can sometimes start feeling sorry for ourselves, falling into self-pity. Here, too, we must ask ourselves if we’re choosing the easy way out, embracing our perceived helplessness instead of considering what can be done to better the situation. As another response puts it:

It is understood from Tanya15 that self-pity is one of the most successful enticements of the yetzer hara. A person says to themselves, “Seeing as G‑d created me in this manner—this is my situation—and seeing as I am to be pitied more than any other human being, there is therefore nothing that can be done and I’m relieved of all obligations.”

The underlying point in all of the above is [as the Sages taught]: “If one says, ‘I have tried but I haven’t succeeded,’ do not believe them.”16 This applies to all matters in life, in all their details.17

No matter how ensnared in a negative cycle someone may have been, no matter how hopeless and pitiful they felt, the Rebbe tried to instill in them a firm confidence in their own potential to transcend their current situation. As one letter to a respected Israeli writer explains:

One who has faith in man and in the unlimited powers of his soul… also has faith that in a short time every individual can reach great heights, no matter their condition a moment earlier.18

It was the 1980s, and Avraham Krishevsky was living happily in Beitar Illit, Israel, with his wife and children, when he received a distressing phone call from New York City.

“On the other line was a family member of an old friend of mine,” Krishevsky recalled. “Last I knew, he was in business, and married with kids. His relative informed me that my friend had recently fallen into serious substance abuse, as well as other lowly activities, and he was hitting rock bottom. All sorts of interventions had already been tried, to no avail. The family heard we had a relationship, and they were wondering if I could help.

“I packed my bags and took a flight to New York.

“When I arrived, I went to visit my friend. He was in a truly wretched condition. He was lodging in some forsaken basement—his family couldn’t stand living with him anymore. I sat with him for many hours, but I wasn’t making progress. I realized that I could not help him alone.

“On one visit, I coaxed him to write a letter to the Rebbe with me.

“For the entire night, we sat together working on the letter. I told him, ‘To the Rebbe you bare everything, there are no games.’ He detailed all he had gone through—everything that had led him to hit this point in life. But he made one condition with me. He didn’t want the letter to be delivered through the secretariat. He was concerned someone there would read it, and he felt ashamed. I gave him my word that I would deliver it personally.

“When he finished writing, I made my way to the Rebbe’s home to deliver the letter. I also added a letter of my own. I wrote to the Rebbe that I had left behind my wife and children to come help this friend of mine, and I couldn’t return home and abandon him like this. I wrote, ‘You are like a father to me, and I want a blessing and advice on how to save my friend.’

“It was 7:00 a.m. when I knocked on the door. The housekeeper opened it and I explained that I had letters for the Rebbe. She got upset. ‘This is not the way to do this,’ she said. ‘Drop it off at the secretariat like everyone else!’ Then she closed the door. I knocked again. When she opened it, I simply placed the letters in her hand. Begrudgingly, she took them inside. I hoped they would reach the Rebbe.

“After dropping off the letters, I walked to 770 and waited near the Rebbe’s study. When the Rebbe came into the building, he saw me. He looked at me with deeply penetrating eyes and then entered his study. About a half hour later, I was given the Rebbe’s answer to our letters.

“He wrote a warm but pointed response, of which I will quote only the ending. My friend had written in his letter that ‘my struggle with drugs began in the last six months.’ The Rebbe added a star near those words and wrote in the margins:

This means that until six months ago everything was okay with you, [despite] not using drugs. How, then, can you tell yourself that it is not in your ability now to abstain from them [and you can’t live without them]? You have the ability to overcome these habits, and [it can happen] with much more ease than you imagine.

“I went back to my friend. We sat together and read the Rebbe’s response. He started to break down, he started to cry. It touched him to the very depths of his soul. He began to come back to himself.

“Not too long after, he returned to his family, regained a healthy lifestyle, and put this whole period behind him—as if it never was.”19

The Atomic Power Inside Us

“Our Sages assure us,” explains a letter to an American businessman who was considering making a difficult life change,

that “nothing stands in the way of the will.”20 This is understandable, since every human being is endowed with immense potential powers. If material things have tremendous atomic powers, how much greater is the “atomic” power of the soul, which, as the Torah defines it, is “truly a part of G‑dliness Above.”21 It is only necessary to actualize it; and this is a matter of the individual’s own will and determination.22

On this note, let’s conclude with a story.

It was the winter of 1971, and Tzvi Hersh Weinreb, a young father in his early thirties, had recently received a PhD in psychology and was beginning to work as a clinical psychologist in Silver Spring, Maryland.

“I suppose I was too young for a midlife crisis,” Weinreb later recalled, “or maybe I arrived at it earlier than most—but around this time, I was deeply torn with pressing questions.

“I was highly uncertain about my career. Should I even continue in psychology? And if so, should I make a career in private practice or accept an offer from the county’s social services?

“I was at a crossroads in my relationship with my wife. How could I do better? How could we get closer? We’d been married for six or seven years now—but how could I make it a bond that would last for sixty or seventy?

“I was confused about the right way to raise my children. What type of attitude should I take as a father? To which schools should I send them?

“I also had my own share of doubts on faith. The age-old question of why bad things happen to good people plagued me. Not in a philosophical way, but in a deeply personal way.

“I was confused to the point of depression.”

Weinreb turned to his close friends for advice on navigating this crisis, and one of them encouraged him to consult the Rebbe. He was initially skeptical, but feeling increasingly desperate, he figured he had nothing to lose. And so, one day, Weinreb found himself calling the Rebbe’s office.

“The Rebbe’s secretary answered the phone in English, with a simple, ‘Hello, who’s this?’

“As I was talking to the secretary, in the background I heard the Rebbe asking in Yiddish, ‘Who’s calling?’

“‘A Jew from Maryland,’ I replied.

“I told the secretary that I had many questions I would like to discuss with the Rebbe—questions about what direction my life should take, questions regarding my career, questions of faith…. I explained that I was at a very uncertain stage in my life and I didn’t know where to turn.

“And then I heard the Rebbe say in the background, in Yiddish: ‘Tell him that there is a Jew who lives in Maryland that he can speak to—his name is Weinreb.’

“The secretary asked me, ‘Did you hear what the Rebbe said?’

“I couldn’t believe my ears. I knew for sure I had not given the secretary my name, but the Rebbe had just said my name! I was taken aback and I wanted to hear it again. So when the secretary asked whether I had heard, I said no.

“The secretary repeated the Rebbe’s words: ‘Tell him that there is a Jew who lives in Maryland that he can speak to—his name is Weinreb.’

“So I replied, ‘But my name is Weinreb!’

“And then I heard the Rebbe say, ‘If that’s the case, he should know that sometimes one needs to speak to himself.’”

With that, the call ended.

Weinreb went on to become a respected psychologist, an esteemed scholar, and a prominent leader in North American Jewry (amongst other roles, he served as the president of the Orthodox Union—a leading Orthodox Jewish organization in North America).

Recounting this phone call forty years later, he said:

“I think about this phone call a few times a week, if not every day. If I could put words in the Rebbe’s mouth, I think he was saying, ‘You’re looking for answers outside yourself. You’re not a kid anymore; you’re a man. You are thirty years old; you are a father; you are a teacher. With all your problems—philosophical, career, family—the answer is within you. You must be courageous. You must overcome false modesty. Don’t become arrogant, but never put yourself down. Realize that you can do it. And you can do it today.’”