Post-Revolution American Jewry was almost microscopic, just 2,500 people out of a greater population of 2,000,000. Jewish life centered around the synagogues in New York, Philadelphia, Newport, Richmond, Savannah, and Charleston.
But as is typical of the Jewish experience, individual Jews had an outsized impact relative to their numbers in society. The lives of Jewish men such as Hyam Solomon, Judah Touro, Mordechai Sheftall, and Gershon Mendes Seixas are some examples. Lesser known, though, is the life story of Israel Baer Kursheedt, an individual who arrived in America after the guns at Yorktown fell silent, but who played a critical role in developing the American Jewish experience. Perhaps most importantly, he brought with him the knowledge he had gained from years of rigorous European yeshivah study to a land that was sorely lacking bona fide Torah scholars. This is Israel Baer’s story.
An Orphan in a Small Town
Israel Baer was born on April 6 (the fourth day of Passover), 1766, in Singhofen, a little town in the Rhineland. When he was only a few years old, his father passed away, and his widowed mother relocated to the village of Kurtscheid, 56 miles away. It was Kurtscheid that left an indelible mark on Israel Baer, giving him his last name, Kursheedt. It also contributed to his future growth in Torah; when his friends in the town’s cheder (Jewish school) noticed his intellectual prowess and diligence, they reasoned that such a promising young mind must go to a proper yeshivah rather than stay in a small, out-of-the-way village with limited academic prospects. Somehow, Israel Baer’s mother was convinced to send him to Rabbi Nosson Adler’s yeshivah in the famed and ancient Jewish community of Frankfurt am Main.
Promising Yeshivah Student
Rabbi Adler, a renowned sage and Torah scholar, ran a prestigious yeshivah out of his home, where a select group of students studied Talmud and the accompanying commentaries in great depth with tremendous diligence. Israel Baer flourished there.
Rabbi Adler’s most famous student was Rabbi Moshe Sofer—known by the title of his works Chatam Sofer—who would go on to become a major halachic authority as well as the leader of Hungarian Jewry. It is possible that Israel studied alongside the Chatam Sofer, although it is unclear.1 Two of his other yeshivah friends would also go on to make big names for themselves: Rabbi Abraham Bing, who later became the rabbi of Wurzberg and taught the next generation of German rabbis,2 and R’ Wolf Heidenheim, who printed the Rodelheim Machzor, a High Holiday prayer book that became extremely popular among German Jews. With peers like these,3 and a natural affinity for in-depth Talmud study, Israel Baer developed into a formidable Torah scholar.
Disrupted by the French Revolution
Israel Baer’s peaceful years of Torah study were disrupted by conflicts following the upheaval of the French Revolution and the declaration of the New French Republic. In 1792, Frankfurt found itself occupied by an invading French army, and Israel Baer was unable to continue his learning.4
Forced to choose an occupation, Israel Baer obtained a contract to supply the Prussian army with provisions. For the next several years, he had to navigate a landscape crisscrossed by hostile armies, sometimes finding himself close to the front lines. During later years, Israel Baer would regale audiences with his experiences.
But in 1796, following a peace treaty at Basel, all of the armies withdrew or disbanded, and Israel Baer was left without a job.
Mistaken Trip to Boston
Searching for something else to do, he traveled to Hamburg intending to continue on to England, but while in Hamburg, he heard about a small ship heading to Boston. Having (falsely) heard of a Jewish community there, he decided to try his luck. That he didn’t know English was no problem; he would pick it up easily, he reasoned. As a matter of fact, the High Holidays fell out while he was at sea. In order to explain Yom Kippur to the captain, he got his hands on an English Bible, and because of his thorough knowledge of the Torah, was able to point at the corresponding passages mentioning the holiday. The sea captain, realizing that his passenger was a holy man, treated him with respect and kindness, something Israel Baer would recall frequently throughout his life.
After a journey of over two months, the ship docked in Boston, but Israel Baer was in for a disappointment. He had come with a letter of introduction to Mr. Hays of Boston, but he soon discovered that Mr. Hays was the only Jew in the city. After a very short stay, he departed for New York, where he was assured that one could find a minyan.
In New York, Israel Baer became acquainted with Gershon Mendes Seixas, cantor of Congregation Shearith Israel, famous for his Revolutionary War exploits. Seixas, who spent his entire life in the US and never had the opportunity to learn in a yeshivah, immediately appreciated the newcomer’s erudition. Now he had someone to turn to for halachic guidance. Seixas frequently consulted Kursheedt on matters of Jewish law, and the newcomer became well respected in the community. Eventually, the relationship between the two transformed into a familial one when Kursheedt married Seixas’ oldest daughter, Sarah, in 1804.
Library Taken Captive
In the summer of 1812, Israel Baer, Sarah, and their four children, Elkaleh, Jeanette, Asher, and Alexander moved south to try their luck in Richmond. We don’t know why the Kursheedts left New York, although given Israel Baer’s yeshivah background, it is highly possible that he was invited to assume the post of cantor at Congregation Beth Shalom. (Keep in mind that in those days of early American Judaism, the cantor performed all of the religious functions of the community, serving as a quasi–rabbi.)
Preparing for their southern migration, the Kursheedt family sent their possessions down by ship aboard the fourteen-gun USS Nautilus. The War of 1812 had recently broken out, and the Nautilus had the dubious honor of being the first American ship captured by the British navy. The British then sailed the ship to Bermuda, where they sold all the baggage, including the Kursheedt family’s possessions. That would have been difficult enough, but an even harsher blow was the loss of Israel Baer’s library of Torah books that had been packed away on the ship. This was a considerable loss, as Hebrew bookstores did not yet exist in the US. To replace such a library would involve significant expense and may have been almost impossible at the time due to the wartime conditions. For a man like Israel Baer who was deeply committed to Torah study, the loss must have been incredibly difficult.
Setting Down Roots in Richmond
Nonetheless, the Kursheedt family proceeded with their move to Richmond with whatever things they did not ship by sea. Incredibly, or perhaps miraculously, part of Israel Baer’s personal library was eventually returned to him along with his Masonic Insignia which had also been packed away on the Nautilus. How this happened is a mystery.
In Richmond, Israel Baer threw himself into the community. During his tenure as cantor, the congregation flourished and Kursheedt was heavily involved in the construction of the synagogue building, which was completed in 1822. He also continued to do business with his father-in-law and became involved with various local business affairs, operating as a mortgage broker and running a lottery and exchange office. Throughout his Richmond years, his family continued to grow, as Sarah bore an additional five children. While taking care of her growing family, she maintained an ongoing correspondence with her father, as well as with an aunt back in New York. It is interesting to note that in one of these letters to his daughter, Gershom responds to a request from Israel Baer for a quote from a particular book pertaining to the laws of mourning.5 Perhaps, we can presume, the reason why Israel Baer needed to turn to his father-in-law was because his own copy had been captured by the British.
A Second Congregation in New York
In 1824, after a twelve-year stay in Richmond, Israel Baer and his family returned to New York. The reason for the move is unclear, but by this time his father-in-law was no longer alive.
In New York, Israel Baer remained committed to community service, particularly in regard to the growing number of Ashkenazi German immigrants. While America’s first synagogues were Sephardic, by the early 19th century most of the newcomers to her shores were immigrants from Germany and were very unaccustomed to the Sephardic prayer rite and pronunciation. They needed a service that would accommodate their needs. Kursheedt joined a group of fellow Ashkenazim and made a request to the board of New York’s only synagogue to allow additional services conducted in the Ashkenazi rite. This would allow everyone to feel comfortable in the synagogue, and all of New York’s Jews could continue belonging to one shul.
After deliberating, the board came to a unanimous decision to deny the request. This was not done out of malice to their Ashkenazi brethren, but out of concern that allowing changes would eventually “destroy the well-known and established rules and customs of our ancestors as have been practiced in said congregation for upwards of one hundred years past.”
The Spanish and Portuguese congregation was determined to ensure that their cherished heritage would not be lost by an eventual Ashkenazi takeover from within.
Kursheedt and his fellow committee members decided to organize an Ashkenazic congregation instead, and 1825 marked the opening of Congregation B’nai Jeshurun, the first Ashkenazic Synagogue in New York City. Although congregational splits always involve some tension, all in all, relations between the two remained friendly and supportive. After all, the Sephardim did understand that the Ashkenazim were entitled to pray according to their customs. They also saw that cross-Atlantic immigration was picking up now that the Napoleonic wars were over, and the old building would eventually be unable to accommodate the annual flow of immigrants. (Indeed, nine years later in 1834, Shearith Israel itself would move to a larger building.)
Israel Baer became a leading member of B’nai Jeshurun and gave a series of Torah lectures there. He also continued to answer questions in Jewish law, and when the occasional situation came up where he did not know the answer, he wrote to Rabbi Solomon Herschel, Chief Rabbi of England, for guidance. But despite leaving the shul where his father-in-law had so faithfully served as cantor for decades, Israel Baer continued to take an active part in it, such as overseeing the congregation’s matzah baking before Passover and becoming a founding member of its Chevra Terumat Hakodesh, a society organized to raise money for the poor of the Holy Land.
Letter to the President
In 1840, the Damascus blood libel shocked the Jewish world. The disappearance of a French monk in Damascus led to allegations that the Jewish community had murdered him. The community rabbi and other prominent community members were arrested and even tortured in an attempt to extract confessions. Thankfully, the men were eventually released following a significant international outcry, including from the famed philanthropist Moses Montefiore, who exerted much effort in obtaining the prisoners' release.
When the news of what was happening reached the US, American Jews were astounded that such an event could happen in their “enlightened” times. For the first time in its history, American Jewry came together as an entity to protest what was happening to their brethren overseas. Israel Baer, in possibly his last act of public service for American Jewry, convened an unprecedented meeting in New York on how American Jews should respond to the events in Syria. It was decided that a letter would be sent to President Martin Van Buren, pleading with him to act on behalf of the Damascus Jews. The president sent back a reply that even before receiving the petition, he had already instructed the US consul at Alexandria to do everything in his power to help. This prompted a second letter to the president expressing appreciation for his actions.
Final Years
During the last few years of his life, Israel Baer was mainly confined to his home due to ill health. He passed away on Friday afternoon, April 30, 1852, at the age of 86.
Israel Baer spent his last hours surrounded by family and friends. Like the Biblical patriarch Jacob, his children gathered around his bed and he blessed each one individually. As he felt his last moments approaching, he said his final prayers with the help of Reverend Samuel Meyer Isaacs, a close friend and former cantor at B’nai Jeshurun. As his soul departed his body, a bystander, overcome by witnessing the serene passing of this righteous individual, blurted out the verse, “May I die the death of the upright, and may my end be like his.”6
Eerily, that week’s Torah portion was the twin portion of Acharei Mot–Kedoshim, which can be read to mean, “After the death of holy ones,” perhaps echoing the loss of this holy individual.
Israel Baer was laid to rest the following Sunday in the Beth Olam cemetery in Queens, NY, where his grave can be visited today. His passing was reported in the Jewish media of the time.
Israel Baer Kursheedt lived in an era of transformation. He was an eyewitness to the vibrant Judengasse (Jewish street) life of the Frankfurt ghetto, and saw it transformed by the upheavals of the French Revolution. An early immigrant to America, he watched as American Jewry developed from a handful of fledgling congregations into an entity capable of coming together to express itself.
Though little known today, Israel Baer was the first bona fide Torah scholar to make the move to America. May his memory be a blessing.
Sources:
First American Jewish Families, Malcolm H Stern third edition, 1991
Correspondence—Sara Sexias Kursheedt and Grace Sexias Nathan, 1814-1821
Encyclopedia of the war of 1812, David S and Jeane T Heidler,Naval Institute Press, 2004.
Gershom Mendes Seixas letters to his daughter Sarah Kursheedt:
Israel Baer Kursheedt papers in the center for Jewish History
Obituaries in the Occident and Asmonean newspapers:
The Damascus Affair and the Jews of America 1840, Publications of the American Jewish Historical Society, No. 10 (1902), pp. 119-128
The History of the Jews of Richmond from 1769- 1917, Herbert T Ezekiel and Gaston Lichtenstein, Richmond 1917