Contact Us

A Rift Extending Across History

A Rift Extending Across History


The conflict between Joseph and his brothers, particularly that between Joseph and Judah, runs like a seam across the entire history of Israel. At times Joseph gains the upper hand, at times Judah prevails, but the schism always resurfaces. Our sages even speak of two messiahs, each with a role to play in the final fulfillment of Israel’s mission—a messiah descended from Joseph, and a messiah from the royal house of David, from the tribe of Judah.

The conflict has its roots in Jacob’s marriages to Leah and Rachel. Jacob’s preference lay with Rachel—she was his first love and the one he regarded as his primary wife. But Leah was the first he married, the first to bear his children, and the one to emerge victorious in the sisters’ competition to provide Jacob with the most sons. All of Leah’s six sons were born before Rachel’s firstborn, Joseph; Rachel had a total of two children, as she died while giving birth to her second son, Benjamin.

As Jacob’s firstborn, Leah’s son Reuben is initially slated for leadership in all areas of Jewish life. But Reuben sins, and his firstborn’s rights are transferred to three of his brothers: the priesthood goes to Leah’s third son, Levi; the kingship to Leah’s fourth, Judah; and the “birthright” (the right of the firstborn to a double portion in his father’s heritage) to Joseph. Thus Joseph’s descendants comprise two tribes, Manasseh and Ephraim, and receive two territories in the Holy Land.

(Reuben’s sin is itself an outgrowth of the Leah/Rachel rivalry, as Reuben interferes in his father’s marriage arrangements in protest of Jacob’s giving precedence to Rachel’s maid, Bilhah, over Leah.)

Jacob transfers his love of Rachel to her son Joseph, demonstrating his greater preference toward him over his brothers—as he had demonstrated his preference of Rachel over Leah. The brothers’ jealousy is augmented by Joseph’s dreams, which Joseph insists on repeatedly describing to them and to his father—dreams which foretell his mastery over them.

This the sons of Leah are determined to prevent at any cost. Shimon and Levi plot to kill Joseph; Judah prevents this, but oversees his sale into slavery.

But the brothers’ victory is short-lived. Soon they find themselves in Egypt, at the mercy of a harsh viceroy who, unbeknownst to them, is their banished brother. They prostrate themselves before him in fulfillment of his dreams. Judah confronts Joseph, but finds his considerable physical might and intellectual prowess bested by his younger brother. Then comes the moving scene in which Joseph reveals himself to them and is reconciled with them.

Joseph is now the undisputed leader of the fledgling nation. He is their protector and their source of sustenance. Even Jacob bows to him.

When the people of Israel emerge from the Egyptian exile, it is under the leadership of Moses and Aaron, both Levites. But it is Joshua, a descendant of Joseph, who leads them in their conquest of the Holy Land. Several generations later, another descendant of Joseph, Gideon, liberates them from foreign rule and governs them. For 369 years the Tabernacle, which as the forerunner of the Holy Temple serves as the spiritual epicenter of Jewish life, is situated at Shiloh, in the territory of Joseph. When the people of Israel ask for a king, a descendant of Rachel, the Benjaminite Saul, is endowed with the crown.

Then, after centuries of Josephian ascendancy, the pendulum swings once more. David, the scion of Judah, is anointed as king; his struggles with King Saul are a replay of the age-old Leah/Rachel rivalry over the leadership of Israel.

For seven years David reigns in the Judean city of Hebron, while a son of Saul is the recognized king in the north. But then the sovereignty of David is accepted by the entire people of Israel. David makes his capital in another Judean city, Jerusalem. His son Solomon builds the Holy Temple on a part of the city which straddles the boundary between Judah and Benjamin. The schism seems to be healed, the people united, with the leadership firmly in the hands of Judah.

But once more the conflict resurfaces. Following Solomon’s death, Jeroboam, a descendant of Joseph, leads a revolt against the royal house of David. He even gets other tribes descended from Leah to join him in the renunciation of the Judean leadership. For the next 240 years, the Holy Land is split into two kingdoms: the northern kingdom of Israel, encompassing ten breakaway tribes under Josephian leadership, and the southern kingdom of Judah. (Interestingly, the tribe of Benjamin remains loyal to the Judean throne.) The sons of Joseph are simply not prepared to accept the sovereignty of Judah.

(This is most emphatically illustrated by the following Talmudic account (Sanhedrin 102a): “G‑d Himself grabbed Jeroboam by his robe and said to him: ‘Repent, and I, you and the son of Jesse [King David] will stroll together in the Garden of Eden.’ Asked Jeroboam, ‘Who will walk first?’ ‘The son of Jesse,’ [answered G‑d. Said Jeroboam,] ‘If so, I’m not interested.’”)

The breach persists to this day. A century before the destruction of the first Temple, Shalmaneser, king of Assyria, overran the northern kingdom of Israel and exiled the ten tribes to an unknown place. They were never heard from again. The rest of Jewish history, as we know it, is the story of the surviving tribes of Judah and Benjamin, a significant part of Levi (whose priests and Levites lived in cities throughout the Holy Land), and a small number of Jews from the other tribes who lived in the kingdom of Judah.

But the prophets promise that there will come a time when the rent halves of the people of Israel will be reunited. The messianic age will be heralded by a messiah from the tribe of Joseph and a Davidic messiah from the tribe of Judah; ultimately, however, the sovereignty of Judah will be established once and for all. In the words of the prophet (Ezekiel 37:22–25): “I will make them into one nation in the land . . . and a single king shall be over them all . . . My servant David shall be king over them, and they shall all have a single shepherd . . . and My servant David shall be their prince for ever.”

Chassidic teaching explains the Joseph/Judah conflict as a dichotomy that extends to every area of life: the conflict between growth and self-fulfillment on the one hand, and subservience and commitment on the other.

There are many identifiable motives to human actions, many formulas for the articulation of a purpose to human life. All, however, fall under one of two general categories:

  1. For ourselves (to enjoy life, realize our potential, achieve transcendence, etc.).
  2. In service of something greater than ourselves (society, history, G‑d).

Indeed, we sense both “a” and “b” to be ever-present forces in our lives. On the one hand, we are strongly driven to better ourselves, to “get the most” out of every experience and opportunity. We also sense that this is not a shallow selfishness, but something very deep and true in our souls—something implanted in us by our Creator as intrinsic to our identity and purpose.

On the other hand, we are equally aware that we are part of something greater than ourselves—that if our existence has meaning, it is only because it serves a reality beyond its own finite and subjective self.

We find both sensibilities expressed by the Torah and in the words of our sages. On the one hand, the Torah (Deuteronomy 11, Leviticus 26, et al) repeatedly stresses that G‑d’s program for life is for the good of man, both materially and spiritually. “The mitzvot were given only to refine humanity,” says the Midrash. The Talmud even goes so far as to state: “Every man is obligated to say: ‘The world was created for my sake.’” Chassidic teaching describes the saga of the soul as a “descent for the purpose of ascent”—the soul’s entry into the physical state entails a diminution of its spiritual faculties and sensitivities, but the purpose of it all is that it be elevated by the challenges and achievements of earthly life.

On the other hand, the highest praise that the Torah has for Moses, whom Maimonides calls “the most perfect human being,” is that he was a “servant of G‑d” (Deuteronomy 34:5). Our sages repeatedly exhort us to strive for altruism in our lives, so that everything we do is permeated with the recognition that “I was created only to serve my Creator” (Talmud, Kiddushin 82b).

This duality is also discussed by our sages in terms of “learning” and “deed” (or “Torah” and “mitzvot”). Thus the sages of the Talmud debate: Which is greater, learning or deed? Learning involves the development and perfection of self, while doing entails the servitude of self to the task at hand. Why was man placed on earth—to better, refine and perfect the self, or to achieve the abnegation of self in service of the Creator?

Rachel, “of beautiful form and of beautiful appearance,” embodies the drive for self-fulfillment and self-realization, while the humble, submissive Leah represents our capacity for servitude and self-effacement.

Rachel’s qualities were strongly emphasized in the handsome, charismatic, enterprising Joseph, who unabashedly relates his dreams of greatness, and proceeds to turn his every circumstance into a personal success. Sold as a slave, he soon becomes overseer of all his master’s possessions. Thrown into jail, he rises to a high position in the prison administration, and from there to viceroy of the most powerful nation on earth. His external beauty and successes mirror an inner spiritual perfection, as he perseveres in the face of moral tests and retains his righteousness in the most corrupting of environments.

Judah, in contradistinction, displays the humility and commitment of one to whom life is a duty rather than an achievement. He steps in to prevent the murder of Joseph. He readily owns up to his responsibility for the sale of Joseph, and to his culpability in the incident with Tamar. He pledges to be accountable for Benjamin’s safety, and when the latter is retained by the Egyptian viceroy, offers himself as a slave in his place. He is the acknowledged leader of his brethren, but his is a leadership burdened by responsibility and sustained by commitment, rather than one that is buoyed by self-confidence and driven by ambition.

So Joseph, whose name means “to add,” represents growth and achievement, while Judah, whose name means “to acknowledge” and “to submit,” is the paradigm of commitment and self-abnegation.

These two forces vie for ascendancy in our every thought and feeling, in every choice we make and every action we take in the course of our lives. At times the one gains the upper hand; at times the other rules our lives. On the macro-historical level, these are the two contrasting forces at play in the history of our people, as Judah and Joseph vie for the leadership of Israel.

There is, however, a point at which these two forces converge and unite. This is the point at which it is recognized that the refinement and perfection of the self can itself be an altruistic enterprise—when it is undertaken solely because this is what the Creator desires from us. When it is appreciated that (as the Talmud resolves its above-cited debate), “Learning is greater because it brings to deed.” A better self—a more knowing, sensitive, accomplished self—is a self better equipped to fulfill its purpose in creation. Indeed, the making of this better self is the fulfillment of its purpose in creation. Ultimately, improving the self is the ultimate service of G‑d.

Chassidic master Rabbi Zusha of Anipoli is reputed to have said: “If it were offered to me to exchange places with Abraham our father, I would refuse. What would G‑d gain from this? He’d still have one Zusha and one Abraham.”

Rabbi Zusha’s life was driven by the burning ambition to become an Abraham—but only in order that G‑d should have another Abraham. If the end result is that there’s only one Abraham for G‑d, what’s the point?

When a person attains this acme of love for G‑d, the Judah and Joseph in him are in full harmony with each other. His Judah reigns sovereign—the ultimate criterion is service of G‑d. But the Joseph in him is not silenced or suppressed. On the contrary: its passions are cultivated, its ambitions are encouraged, its selfhood is fully integrated in the selflessness of the Judaic self.

And when this integration is achieved on the universal and cosmic level as well, we shall enter the age in which “I will make them into one nation . . . and My servant David shall be their prince forever.”

Based on the teachings of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson; adapted by Yanki Tauber.
Illustration by Chassidic artist Michoel Muchnik; click here to view or purchase Mr. Muchnik's art.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with's copyright policy.
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
1000 characters remaining
Simcha Bart for Los Angeles July 14, 2016

Actually, they are two distinct individuals - one Messiah descended from Judah and a different Messiah descended from Joseph. You can see this in the article above as well as at the link in my previous comment.

Eunice Forsman July 13, 2016

Wow that's awesome. Thanks. I see now. He is from both :-) Reply

Simcha Bart for Los Angeles July 10, 2016

The Messiah descended from Joseph is mentioned in Midrash and the Talmud. For more details about this Messiah and sources, please see this link and the footnotes there. Reply

Eunice Australia June 29, 2016

2 Messiah's Great article. Note however I only ever saw reference to one Messiah in scripture, from the tribe of Judah. Can you confirm where the idea of a second one from Joseph is noted please Reply

Hanah Rivkah USA June 29, 2016

Subtle and powerful Thank You for the clarity your essay brings to our most bitter inner conflicts. As an Observant Jew, like me constantly in conflict between Yoseph's force of desire for self realization and Yehuda's force for the sense of duty, responsibility love and commitment to HaShem's commanded Torah.
At my age still on the battlefield of these powerful drives. At every breath, every step checking in with Him before new situation. Could the expression, "Not a dull moment" mean a reminder that Hashem Wills us to keep transcending our past successes and failures and future planning designs? Reply

Anonymous November 24, 2014

bibliography would you be able to provide me with the references from this article, where i could find the original text from the Rebbe. i would truly appreciate it Reply

Anonymous November 9, 2013

source Where can I find the sicha this essay is based on? Reply

Anonymous LONDON, UK June 14, 2012

Lost 10 tribes You write that "a century before the destruction of the first Temple, Shalmaneser, king of Assyria, overran the northern kingdom of Israel and exiled the ten tribes to an unknown place. They were never heard from again."
Just to point out that there is another opinion in the gemara that Jeremiah the prophet brought them back to Eretz Yisrael, the Land of Israel. Reply

efraim tampa, florida December 31, 2011

moshiach very nice may he be revealed to everyone very soon Reply

Nancy Duong Forest Hills, NY/USA December 29, 2011

Joseph and his Brothers Thank you very much for the calm explanation of the story of mankind. Thank you very much for explaining to me the basic and essential differences between Joseph and Judah. Thank you very much to give me much hope when the L-rd is going to make two as one as He is One. I put your writing on my Facebook and pray the L-rd continues to keep the teaching afresh in me especially as we go into 2012. Reply

Cindy Passaic, NJ December 28, 2011

To hmmm... Let's not compare... Right?
Amazing and very insightful article!
Thank you Rabbi Tauber!
However, I fail to understand the short anecdote of Rabbi Zushe. Reply

john smith fort lauderdale, fl December 28, 2011

hmmm... so i guess..when christians and jews are getting along and are trying to attain the same goals...we are close...

interesting.. Reply

Esther Liba NJ December 28, 2011

More Power to Yanki Tauber! Yanki you hit a home run with this one--definitely Divinely inspired. There is so much "meat" here, it is a full, multi-course meal!

Wishing you continued success in your ability to take the Rebbe's words and add imagery, relevance and meaning without changing a single thing. Reply

Eileen Lowey Aurora, CO December 23, 2011

warmed on this cold Chanukah night "The making of this better self is the fulfillment of its purpose in creation. Ultimately improving the self is the ultimate service of G-d" Reply

Jane Leong Miri, Malaysia December 22, 2011

Thank you! Very enlightening for a non-Jewish bible reader. Thank you. Reply

Max Rambow Battle Creek, MI USA December 17, 2011

Your brother From a number of angles I thought this was an excellent article. The one that surprised me most is how much the description of Joseph reminded me of America! My conclusion is we're your brother, long lost but, alive and well just as G-d promised. Reply

Geraldine Torf Boston, MA/USA December 15, 2011

Joseph and his Brothers This shows how important it is to have altruism informed by self interest, Too much abnegation can result in the blocking of grace. Reply

Anonymous Manchester December 12, 2011

Very well written. Bravo! Reply

Cheryl Blossvale, NY June 7, 2011

AWESOME! Thank you. Reply

Cynthia Hollywood, Florida September 8, 2010

Joseph and his brothers Thank you for this. I have attained a greater understanding of this important story and will pass that understanding to the children I teach. Reply

More in this section
Related Topics