Enter your email address to get our weekly email with fresh, exciting and thoughtful content that will enrich your inbox and your life.

A Jew is a Jew

Autoplay Next

A Jew is a Jew

There are some who believe that by hiding their Jewishness they will be protected from anti-Semitism. The Megillah teaches us a lesson: When Haman persuaded King Achashverosh to issue the decree against the Jewish people, he argued that...
Purim, Jewishness; Jewish Identity, Assimilation, Antisemitism, Lubavitcher Rebbe
A Jew is a Jew
Disc 98, Program 391

Event Date: 14 Adar 5720 - March 13, 1960

There are some who believe that by hiding their Jewishness they will be protected from anti- Semitism. The Megillah teaches us a lesson: When Haman persuaded King Achashverosh to issue the decree against the Jewish people, he argued that those Jews who acted as “one nation” – refusing to assimilate – deserved the decree because they were different, while those who were “scattered and separated among the nations” – who did assimilate – deserved the decree because they tried to imitate their non-Jewish neighbors.

The Sages teach: “It is a natural law that Esau hates Jacob.” Even if the “Jacob” imagines that his identity is hidden, the “Esau” will sense it, all the way down to the Jew’s greatgrandchildren – as we saw in our own generation, in the persecution in Europe…

When an evil phenomenon takes place in the world, it exists only to intensify its parallel in the realm of goodness. Why, in fact, does the non-Jew sense the Jew, even one whose family has been assimilated for several generations? Because “A Jew, even if he has sinned, is still a Jew.” No matter how many generations have passed, he still possesses a Jewish soul, “A part of G-d Above.” Nothing can destroy the Divine spark within a Jew’s soul – and because this is his essence, his eternal self, the non-Jew will always sense it.

Living Torah

You may also be interested in...


Join the Discussion

Sort By:
4 Comments
Katherine Rothschild San Francisco February 9, 2020

I have been the victim of anti semitism and many of my ancestors by my father side perished in the holocaust. The Jew hater always has a way of knowing that you are a Jew Amistael chai Reply

Rabbi Dr. katherine Hans Von Rotes Schild Zitler San Francisco, Ca/usa March 8, 2012

Jewish It is to be further stated that Hitler went back 10 generations to remove the Jews. My father who is a german Jew had many of his great foreparents destroyed in that day of wrath. Reply

Monir USA February 4, 2020
in response to Rabbi Dr. katherine Hans Von Rotes Schild Zitler:

How could someone live with this state of mind? This embedded animosity and hate could ever decimate and be resolved for one to live in peace and harmony with humanity, or is this a curse just to proof to oneself and others that they are chosen superiors above all others, even if it keeps bringing disaster on oneself and many others? If we look back to history ,it seems that catastrophic results have been the prevailing aspect of such path of wanting to single out one kind over all other humanity!
Does anyone sees it this way or is it just me? Reply

Katherine Hans Von Rotes schild Zitler San Francisco February 9, 2020
in response to Monir :

Being a Jew means we have a special mission in the universe Reply

Please consider becoming a member of Living Torah today!