What is the Origin of the Bar Mitzvah celebration?

Does anyone know when a boy in Biblical times brought his own sacrifice to the temple? Was this connected at all to his "coming of age," or to being head of his own household? Some of my students asked me this, and I have no idea! From other reading I'm doing, it seems that boys were not restricted from religious participation in ancient times; it was only not required of them. Reply

Ber-Mitzvah Do you really, seriously, believe that when the Torah says - "pashut-p'shat" that "weaned" means "no longer sucking at the breast of his mother", that this actually intends to be twisted into a proof-text for Bar-Mitzvah? Let us please not confuse an exegetical, allegorical lesson with the pure text of what the Torah is actually saying! Reply

Re: Thomas Children are our legacy! Children are pure and loving!
No one has said otherwise.

All that was said was that we were given by G-d the natural instinct of survival and self-preservation, which you also agree to. Someone else comes next.

That is, unless we let our selfless G-dly soul which comes in full at Bar Mitzvah kick in.

Those who have allowed for themselves to be selfless for a day, realize the difference between that lifestyle and their instinctive "purity" of "self-preservation". Reply

Psychology Let us, for the moment, forget Freud and animal instinct. I have studied psychology and philosophy only to the extent that I do not allow it to sway me from logic and reason. I love animals as well as my fellow man but we are made in the image of God not an animal.

As adults we too often fool ourselves into believing that we have all the answers. Not true. In my heart and soul, which my creator instilled in me, I find true love for our children and no manner of psychology or philosophy can bring me the joy I find in the innocence of childhood.

Instinct is as a guess or supposition. I place no great amount of reliability on instinct. Man, by his nature will do what he can do to survive. This came from God not instinct. The love of oneself and consequently the love of all others is God given. I do not guess or suppose it I believe it as God has allowed me to by the nature as a man he has given me.

Children will be our our legacy if we show by love & example. Reply

Are children self-centered? While this may not be the most prominent characteristic of children, this is basic Freudian psychology.

Instinctively, the primary focus of the human being is self-preservation. Education and societal influence (such as parental example) can train someone to be concerned for the good of others as well.

This is also familiar to those who study the Kabbalah. Every child is born with an animal soul, and only at the age of maturity fully develops their selfless G-dly soul.

The purity of children lies in the fact that even their animal instincts are not as coarse and crooked as the adult animal soul. Reply

Giving I dearly love this piece posted by Ann Arlosoroff. This grandfather took from his mouth the sustenance that the boy needed to survive and there can be no more loving act than this. I learned similar things from my mother who raised seven children on her own and literally gave food to her children that they might survive. We would say to her "mom, you are not eating" and her reply would be "I am not hungry". As children we accepted that but later in life we realized how much she sacrificed for us that we may not go hungry. God bless the mothers and fathers that teach their children by example.

Thank you, Ann. Reply

"He gave me the BREAD out of his MOUTH!"

His zeyde didn't hug him, but he showed his love in the most primal way. Did my father love his zeyde?

Absolutely!

The young person might be unable to make it on his own, to support himself, to survive without the aid of adults.

He is UNABLE to put the needs of others before his own because, if he did so, he might well not survive. He needs others to put his needs before their own, so he can survive.

When the whole family was starving anyway, my father's grandfather used to say, "Give it to him. He's a growing boy, he needs it." It was true. He NEEDED it. This was not selfish. It was his duty to grow up and bring Yiddishkeit into the next generation. In fact my father never reached his full height, as exemplified by the fact that I, a woman, am taller than he, and my brother is over six feet (MUCH taller than my father). But he survived, because his grandfather "gave me the bread out of his mouth." Reply

After Thomas Eby Thank you so much for your commitment and grandfatherly comments.

Treasure treasures, bring up these gem-like treasures in yourself, even, for children are, most certainly our greatest treasure.

Why after 13? Yikes!! For the prey of Mammon, Babel, Baal and such doth come .. all matter of temptation, and yes, also 'hormones'.

May g-d bless you for your wisdom in seeing beyond the harsh realities of adult life. Reply

children I am an advocate of children and their welfare and I must disagree to some degree. I have watched little children on up to their pre-teen years and even after where they have been generous to their siblings and friends and shared with them without hesitation. It is true that some children have not learned this. And how so? Because their parents (adults) have not given them good examples as they are growing. The parent that is loving and kind and shows by" EXAMPLE" that love and kindness is far more successful than those who are demanding of their children and says do as I say not as I do.

As you can probably tell I have a great love for all children no matter what race, religion, color or background they come from. As Father Flanagan of "Boys Town" fame said "There are no bad children only bad examples shown to them. Reply

Jewish children I am just curious why it is pointed out in this article about Bar Mitzvah that the boy under 13 is selfish and egotistical? Is there a reason that you would put it this way?

Personally, I find children to be loving and very curious about everything around them.
I say this of course from the viewpoint of a man 72 years of age tho I have always felt that way about children. They are our most prescious gift from God and it is only when they are really introduced into the adult world that they become selfish and egotistical.

I have often felt that if God would take away all of the adults from this world and let me raise the children I would see to it that they would never learn prejudice, lust, envy, hate and the myriad things that affect all adults. That is how much I treasure children. I know this is an impossible dream but oh what a world it would be.

God Bless Reply