Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info
 
Chabad.org » The Jewish Woman » Childrearing » Joys and Challenges » From Harvard to Homemaking
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment22 Comments

From Harvard to Homemaking


From Harvard to... homemaking? It was not a big jump down- as most people assume...

After graduating from Harvard University at the top of my department in 1977, I went on to medical school- responding, seemingly well, to the intense "nouveau" pressure for young women like me to succeed professionally. But during my first year in medical school, I started to panic. It felt as if only my outer self was moving ahead, leaving the most intrinsic, characteristic parts of me behind. It was as if I was starting to remember the way I used to be- before the societal influences shifted dramatically.

Couldn't I choose not to become a professional career woman? Couldn't I still have a choice, I wondered? Couldn't I choose not to become a professional career woman? Could I actually work up the nerve to do something extremely embarrassing- like devote my intelligence and creative abilities to building a good marriage and trying to raise my own children in an exemplary home? Was that option still available- even though I never heard it mentioned anymore? The more I let myself wonder about it freely, the more I knew it was what I most wanted- even if everyone else at that time thought I had flipped my lid.

Today, people no longer think that I'm nuts. Today the value of my choice is clearly evident. Not in shining glassware or sparkling clean floors like a stereotypic 5O's homemaker might have squealed about. It is evident in the shining character traits of six children, now grown big, and in the extra sparkle that's in their eyes.

Through the years, many people have asked me how a Harvard grad, a woman who loves to think, could become a homemaker. I feel that in order to be devoted to being a homemaker, a mother, a guide to trusting souls, a woman has to love to think. Being a homemaker, with an awareness of the potential inherit in the position, is the most challenging intellectual pursuit I could ever envision.

While I cannot possibly counterbalance the many influences that devalue homemaking by considering it a mindless endeavor that anyone can do, I can hopefully open up a few minds, at least, to the fact that in order to do a great job as a homemaker, we really have to make great use of our most prized mental capabilities- and that homemaking is far from simple or mindless.

Homemaking is far from simple or mindless In marriage and in parenting, we are given the opportunity to create something far, far more beautiful than a Rembrandt masterpiece. We have the chance to help create a real live masterpiece of a human being. A gigantic amount of thinking is required in order to shape and mold fine character traits. Even though some people are born with easier dispositions to work with than others, there is so much room for growth in every person. Each individual holds many hidden treasures. And in digging for them carefully we invariably end up uncovering some of our own.

It takes much time and thought to guide children to become truly good people. And it is still possible in this day and age to raise pure, appreciative, joyful children. The thing is- it requires a lot of brain power to override the abundant influences working against achieving this goal. We need to understand well who each constantly evolving individual child is in order to be able to guide him or her along the unique pathway that can lead to the fulfillment of his or her highest potential.

More than most of us realize, in a myriad of ways, parenting is as systematic as a science. In other ways, it is an art. Art is defined (by my little Random House Dictionary) as "the production and expression of what is beautiful." That's one side of parenting. Overwhelmingly, though, and unfortunately, it is becoming a lost art.

What kind of intellectual skills are needed in order to strive toward greatness in parenting? There are the finely tuned skills needed to assess whether or not a child is capable of moving on to his or her own next stage of development. There are the perceptual powers required in order to determine the best time to step forward and help out a child, or step back and let the child try, without our involvement. And there are cognitive abilities that are a prerequisite for teaching children the skills that will enable them to make themselves happy in life. These are the skills like transforming negative experiences into positive ones, working through angry emotions, and learning how to appreciate all that they have.

Today, people no longer think that I'm nuts There is a tremendous amount of pre-planning that goes into good parenting, and there is also plenty of on-the-spot quick thinking needed, too. Parents have to figure out the most effective ways to help their children understand how to get along with others- how to circumvent fights, and how to feel confident being themselves. Parents also need to study well and know when to implement the systematic skills that help minimize whining, tantrums and disrespectful behavior from children.

Everyone readily admits that parenting is physically and emotionally demanding. But, intellectually demanding? That's overlooked. The ironic part is that parenting would be dramatically less demanding physically and emotionally if more of our intellectual abilities were utilized in the process.

Then, there are the people who tell me that with today's economy the way it is, it is no longer a viable option for women to be home with their children. I'm here to prove that it is still a wonderful choice readily available, especially for women with intellectual prowess. We live simply, but with a much higher quality of life, I think, than most harried families, who are always rushing about with no time to enjoy what they're hurrying after.

In a myriad of ways, parenting is as systematic as a scienceA lot of ingenuity, resourcefulness, and creativity does go into our daily lifestyle. Clothes, leftovers and even those little plastic sandwich bags get "recycled" again and again through the family. But our children have an enthusiastic appreciation for even the smallest of things. And that, I believe, is one of the most valuable gifts a person can ever receive.

A synthesis of values from the homebound 5O's, freeing 6O's and 7O's, and overextended 8O's, 90's and 00's can now, hopefully, begin to culminate into a much deeper and broader view, encompassing all the options from which a woman can honestly choose.

As women come to respect parenting more, making their theoretical priorities a reality, they can devote more of their talents and concentration to their children. When we help our children grow up beautifully, we will at the same time be helping ourselves to grow- in the most authentic way possible.

We can still have fulfilling marriages. We can still have respectful, responsible children involved with us in a mutually rewarding relationship. But too many minds still remain shut to the intellectually stimulating potential of homemaking. Well, they always told me that my Harvard education would open doors. These are the closed doors I hope to open.

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment22 Comments

By Bracha Goetz   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Bracha Goetz is the Harvard-educated author of several children’s books, including Remarkable Park, What Do You See in Your Neighborhood? and The Invisible Book. You can contact Bracha for presentations or questions here.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

22 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: July 21, 2009
I love this article! I am a single working mother. I was divorced 18 months ago due to my husband's alcoholism. Though I must now work to provide a home for my children, I have a strong desire to be at home and be a fultime homemaker as the Bible describes.
Posted By Bev, Renmark, Australia

Posted: May 21, 2009
for Sa'rah
Your husband is very, very blessed, B'H! And so are you :)
Posted By Bracha Goetz, Baltimore, MD

Posted: May 21, 2009
At Home with No Children
All of these comments are insightful, but I feel the need to make a comment on the comments. You guys all focused on the parenting aspect of homemaking. What do you think of stayijng at home to be a wife and to fulfill you wifely duties whether or not you have children and whether or not you can even have the children?

Reason I asked this is because I just graduated (undergrad) last Sunday, and ,when asked the big question, my answer was "I'm going to be a homemaker." Well, I already am a homemaker and I am already married...I just do not yet have children. And my parents and their friends had various responses: some got up and left while others spent hours telling me how stupid of a decision that is. I simply said that it is a religious conviction and there is no arguing about it. Of course, it's more than that though.

I want to hear some other comments on this issue (even though I will not change my mind). Dont even ask why I went to college; my mother made me do it
Posted By Sa'rah, Morrow, GA

Posted: May 17, 2009
Valuable Perspective
Mrs. Goetz's perspective is important. Not only does it appear that she possesses all of the necessary love to successfully parent, she explains, rather cogently I might add, that much thought should be devoted to the job of parenting.

Parenting should be a very focused endeavor and the more one devotes a systematic and intellectual approach to the oldest and most noble of professions, the more their children will benefit.
Posted By Anonymous, La Quinta, CA.USA
via chabadpalmsprings.com

Posted: May 16, 2009
Sort of unfair to others
I'm glad the author is fulfilled, but she needs to understand that many, many people want to get into medical school and there are many more applicants than spaces. When she was accepted into medical school, this means one other person did not get in. This person may have desperately wanted to be a doctor. The author isn't using education much longed for by others.
Posted By Katherine Lipkin, Copley, OH

Posted: May 15, 2009
Women's Choice
My daughter-in-law, a Yale Graduate and mother of four (two girls), and me, a scientist mother of two boys, were discussing this very topic yesterday. Whenever we talk about women’s choice, only abortion issues come to mind. However, a much tougher concern for educated women pregnant or not, Harvard or not, is to choose between family and career. The question is, will our highly educated girls feel forced or coaxed by peer pressure into choosing career over child rearing even though they may find happiness in rearing and raising kids. By using your own life as an example, you make a very strong case that child rearing is an intellectual exercise. My read is that women should have the power and social support to choose and that education should help her in that decision rather than blocking her from making the right choice.
The question to ask, however, is if child rearing is such an intellectual exercise, why should men be deprived of making similar choices.
Posted By subha

Posted: May 14, 2009
Thank you for all these insightful comments!
How To Make A Real Fortune

by BG

The hardest work,
Gets the lowest pay,
In this topsy-turvy world
Today.
Feel you're getting
Nothing
For all you do?
Someday all will wish,
They were
As rich
As you.
Posted By Bracha Goetz, Baltimore, MD

Posted: May 14, 2009
I read all your comments and I tell you if I had visited Harvard and got the best job I wouldn't have noticed my experiences which I made with my children, partner, dog, and parents and sisters as I did it waiting for a job. But this phenomenal experiences and thoughts brought me to an understanding for people and our world that no university can reach. Thanks to all of you and I wish you will enjoy your family life - one day we will sit together and I discuss with you the real Intellect.
Posted By Inge Reisinger

Posted: May 13, 2009
Also Harvard
I graduated from Harvard too (Law School, 1990). The sad fact is that even if we moms want to stay home and raise our children, there are bills to pay. Yeshiva tuition forces most Orthodox Jewish mothers out of the house and into the working world for increasingly longer periods. It's tough also for someone believing in meritocracy to like homemaking: you can't earn better pay by doing a better job. Husbands don't give their wives bonuses for baking challah. While it's true that all of one's income is really from HaShem, homemaking is pretty unique among the professions in that our hishtadlus, our own effort, has absolutely no effect on how much money we make. Another frustration is that untrained inexperienced women are prized more highly, in the reverse of other professions. Wealthy men seeking wives want slim supermodels, not veteran homemakers. Women need better onramps, ways back into the working world, after leaving to raise their children.
Posted By Judy Resnick, Far Rockaway, NY

Posted: May 11, 2009
Thank you
Thank you so much for writing this article. Graduating college this semester and already a mother of a one year old girl I have been struggling with what I want to do with my future. Should I go back to school for a further degree or develop some career? all I really want to do is be home with my daughter. I've always been at the top of my class and I really enjoy being intellectually stimulated so staying home seemed to be "wasting my talents" as somebody has said to me. Reading your article has reenforced my notion that staying home is also intellectually stimulating. I see how important it is to use your cognitive skills in raising children as well. Thank you for the strength to do what I really know is right but was having difficulty coming to terms with.
Posted By Anonymous, NJ



 


Joys and Challenges
The Juggler
Learning to Mother Again After Losing My Baby to SIDS
The Importance of Space
From Harvard to Homemaking
Fasten Your Mask
Pickles in the Shower
Nowhere Else I'd Rather Be
Showing 24 - 30 of 89