Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info
 
Chabad.org » The Jewish Woman » Women's Narrative » Editorial & Commentary » Who Am I?
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment15 Comments

Who Am I?


One familiar, modern-day phrase is "Identity Theft" and is defined as the unauthorized taking of one's every means of proving who you are, and the inherent rights and privileges. These things comprise your passport in life. There are cards for everything: driver's licenses, credit cards, debit cards, insurance cards, social security cards, Medicare, and the list continues.

You can walk up to a bank clerk as a total stranger, but as soon as you present your identification, you are at once able to get what you need, take what you want, and prove you are so entitled. With mine, I can say, "I am Shirley Coles."

There are countless roles from our earliest years which tell the world who we are. I was child, grandchild, student, cousin, girlfriend, fiancé, wife, mother, graduate student, member of Phi Beta Kappa, secretary, avid reader, sometime painter, member of Jr. Hadassah, counselor, teacher, volunteer, home owner… widow.

The list of the roles I play has become shorter and shorterJust over one year ago, I lost my mate of almost sixty years. During those many years, when asked who I was, or when being introduced to others, there was that long list of roles from which to select and identify the woman I had become. I was Shirley Stoler-Coles, mother of Mark, Bruce and Debra, wife of Edwin J. Coles, grandmother, counselor, school teacher, literacy volunteer, Jewish woman, and owner of so many little plastic cards.

It's almost impossible to realize how much you depend on these roles to identify yourself – even to yourself – until they no longer apply! If we cannot feel the security of belonging in our own minds, presenting ourselves to the world at large can become a daunting process. When that becomes the case, it is as though we don't know who we are. Take, for example, the departure of all our children as they go off to build their own lives. "Mother" may still be accurate, but the role seems less sharply defined, and that leaves us uneasy. So much so, that it has a name; it becomes a syndrome called "the empty nest." As a widow now, the list of the roles I play has become shorter and shorter. The changes have been, and continue to be, traumatic.

I know I share this experience with widows and widowers the world over. Looking at the list above, I decided to see what is left if I subtracted all the roles which are now retired or outgrown. I can no longer claim to be a child since my parents died many years ago. Despite my age, I sometimes long for that feeling of being someone's child who can come for a special hug and comfort. But life took that away from me. I now have children of my own and I am still mother, but rarely called upon to function as such. The maternal role is one which exists now mainly in my heart. So is my role of grandchild. All four of these wonderful people are lost to me. Now I have grandchildren, so I can say I'm a grandmother of four wonderful girls. I seldom see or hear from them; they've grown and are scattered in their various pursuits.

No longer a student on any level, I teach, although this task, which I love so much, is performed as a volunteer. It's a solo pursuit, but this one can stay on the list. There are appreciative responses, but it's not enough to nourish my need to belong. Not enough.

I am relocated now, from the east coast to the southwest. It will take a while to once again become neighbor, friend and someone whose work is noticed, valued and sought after. It will take a while for me to be recognized when I go into the city to shop, to the library, the community and senior centers, to the residential community where I offer my tutoring services. How I miss hearing someone call out my name and ask about my family!

I have to go forth every day without my safety netTo be sure, I am still Mrs. Ed Coles. That is the name I sign on this form or that. But no one here knew him. He lives in my heart and memory now. Being somewhat shy, I used to bask in his sunshine with people. When we first met at the Jewish Community Center, he was sitting at a piano, surrounded by friends and would-be friends. I was on the fringe of the group, but he met my glance and the rest was history. He is no longer at my side, at a piano, standing in front of a group as an entertainer. He loved making others laugh while I stood there kvelling. I stand alone now.

I have to go forth every day without my safety net. The ground does not feel solid under my feet. Who am I? It's as though I don't know for certain, and if I don't know for certain, how can I convince anyone else? Throughout my life, I was not fortunate enough to have been taught what it meant to be a Jew. I knew I was Jewish, because my mother told me so and it was a given that I would marry a Jewish man some day. Other than that, I was on automatic pilot, so to speak, going through motions without emotions, such as joining a Jewish women's group, or being at family tables during holidays. Seen and not heard.

Moving about the country in pursuit of my husband's career opportunities, I had often wished for the company of other Jewish women. But it was not something he wanted to be part of. As a matter of fact, he shied away from any contact the congregations would try to make. I did not pursue it on my own. We remained religiously anonymous. But it was always with me. Always. When I would hear about the plight of Jews the world over, or the music, a huge lump would form in my throat. I was always at a distance from something that was part of me.

Now there is a role for me which has been there all along. I have only to reach out and claim it. I have to do it on my own, and then perhaps I will not be on my own. I have to look through the glass less darkly and remember that a Jewish life makes one a part of something worldwide, ready to embrace me. I am a Jewish woman. I feel it calling to me, and I know I would be invited to sit at the table of an Orthodox Jewish family on a Friday night anywhere in the community of Judaism, and be welcome. Someday, I may be secure enough for it to be my table.

I could be the Jewish woman who is someone's mother, able to share and pass on what I learn about this life. I could be the Jewish woman who is grandmother to four bright, young girls who know nothing about their heritage. I could be the Jewish woman who finds new friends in a community which has history and roots beyond comprehension. I could be the Jewish woman who volunteers, teaches, studies again, who writes and shares her new self with readers of this site. To claim this role, I have only to take a deep breath and walk through that door.

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment15 Comments

By Shirley Coles   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Shirley Coles, formerly of Rhode Island, now resides in Flagstaff, Arizona with her two cats and her favorite pastimes: reading, writing essays and poetry, and volunteering as a tutor of ESL, Spanish, and Creative Writing. A graduate of URI with a masters degree in mental health counseling, she is a member of Phi Beta Kappa. She has three married children and three granddaughters.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

15 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: June 17, 2008
Identity Shmi-dentity
I was about to make aliyah when I was told that, because I was over 60, I would have no help as younger olim do. I am totally competent to contribute, but I do not have the financial resources to make the move. Oh how I miss Jerusalem!

Meanwhile I am alone. My friends have had to take jobs in other cities. My beloved has died, and so have my parents. My only child and his wife and child are a thousand miles away. I struggle to live on less than $800/month. As for identity...identity shmi- dentity. If I could just live and be well and be with people.
Posted By Dinah

Posted: June 16, 2008
Catching Up
I'm catching up on emails. This article brought a tear. I've found some really amazing treasures in Chabad Chassidus and hope you do too. The nice thing about the Torah is that the more of it you learn the better and deeper it gets. Best of everything.

Posted By Moishe

Posted: May 1, 2008
What a beautiful story! And always remember that in life, everything should be done one step at a time.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Apr 26, 2008
Who is she? In spite of loss
Each of us, underneath it all, is truly something else altogether--a sacred soul, a spark of Gd. Everything else is roles we play.

What if we focus not on the roles but on the central truth? What if we live from that spark? What does that do for all our relationships, our jobs, our activities?

Can we live from that spark and still participate in this world? I think somehow we can. I am beginning to take baby steps in that direction but do not know how far it can take me.

I did get the house ready for Pesach and enjoyed both my only child's visit and the sedarim more than ever before.
Posted By Susanna

Posted: Apr 24, 2008
Who Am I?
We always have to reinvent ourselves in life. Reading about your struggles with that make me feel better about my own.

Thank you.
Posted By Tina Fiedler, Whittier, CA/USA

Posted: Apr 16, 2008
PESACH SAMEACH
You are so lucky and always have been. Why have you never moved to Israel? I am twice widowed and hard of hearing and legally blind and now an American Israeli and proud to be Jewish.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Apr 16, 2008
beautiful
I am young, still in my 20s but I appreciate the beauty, stength and the courage in your optimistic outlook! thank you so much for sharing! I am happy for the people in your life who have the opportunity to benefit from you. Best wishes
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Apr 15, 2008
Loss
It was a heavy blow when my beloved died. I walked blindly putting one foot in front of the other. I did what needed doing. I wanted a man, any man, and I didn't want anybody, because nobody else was him. And so I was alone. My mother had died one year before he did, and then my father died 2 1/2 years after him. Those were hard, hard years. The only comfort was the minyan and saying kaddish. We all knew each other, even w/o thinking of death.

Now, I've joined a Hadassah chapter, but I find little chance to connect with these women as I had hoped. But though I am working three part time jobs and struggling to get the house clean for yomtov, and though my only child and his wife & baby are coming, I still feel alone. What to do?


Posted By Susanna

Posted: Apr 15, 2008
Who am I
Shirley.
All pertinent questions to ask ourselves. Are we merely the glimmerings of our moments wrapped in identifications or is it much much more? There are so many facets to this diamond we are all a part of,and yes we have linear time experience to participate with, be molded from and in right timing to shed oneself of not to shed yourself of yourself but to become more and greater of a human being with change and transformation. Looking at life from a new lens is difficult yet part of how life is made in order for us to become more and better through our experience. Bless you in this next phase of becoming sounds like you are not just at the side but speaking with and touching a new circle of lives. Toda for sharing yourself in such a beautiful way. You know your heart is doing what it has long put off, being a part of a vibrant Jewish learning center and you are so appreciated. I am sure you are being put in a direction that the Holy-One and your soul desire you to be in. Bless you in every possible way and may all the lives you touch be blessed through you.

Posted By Connie Schiller, carmel, IN

Posted: Apr 15, 2008
Unmasked
Very well put. We are all we have been - since our creation - by G-d. We all focus on our present role, as it transforms into the next. Take comfort we are all one, as Jews, and with G-d. A fine article, may you write many more. All is by Divine providence, there is lofty comfort, in this reality. All is for our best. To bring us to G-d.
Posted By Tone Lechtzier, Trail, Or US



 


Editorial & Commentary
Beauty of the Beast
Why I'm Not a Rabbi
Spilling the Truth
Baring More Than Skin
This Year in Jerusalem
What's the Rush?
Day In, Day Out
Who Am I?
Sneakers, Shots... and Skirts
Dear Rebecca
Who's To Blame?
Does G-d Care When I'm Sad?
The Red Carpet
Remember Me Forever
Repairing Our World
Showing 37 - 51 of 70