Here's a great tip:
Enter your email address and we'll send you our weekly magazine by email with fresh, exciting and thoughtful content that will enrich your inbox and your life, week after week. And it's free.
Oh, and don't forget to like our facebook page too!
Contact Us

I Want to Get Married! (Modern Men Won’t Commit!)

I Want to Get Married! (Modern Men Won’t Commit!)


Dear Rachel,

I’m going on 40, and I’m afraid I’m never going to get married. It’s not like I don’t want to get married; I do!Everyone seems to be grappling with an availability issue But all the men I meet are either commitment-phobes or unavailable. I found out that the last guy I was dating didn’t even have his get, his Jewish divorce (when he told me he was already divorced), and had no idea when he would. The guy before was an older man who’d never been married, but assured me he was ready to take the plunge. Then he decided to go to India for six months. There are the guys with whom I don’t hit it off, but the ones I do all seem to have some sort of commitment or availability issue. Please don’t tell me I’m like them! I want to get married.


Dear Committed,

I’m sure there are similarly aged men out there who want to marry as well. The challenge is how and where to go about meeting them.

You haven’t told me anything about yourself or about where you meet these men. The Jewish shidduch (matchmaking) system that’s been around since biblical times assures that the basics are in place before the couple meet. If you meet a guy on your own in a bar, for instance, you have no choice but to believe what he tells you. If someone you know well (a friend, colleague, mentor, matchmaker) sets you up, you can at least be sure that the man is truly available, and that his personal details jibe with what he says. Also, someone who sets you up will know something about both of you and have some reasons for suggesting the match in the first place.

As a general rule, people aren’t committed in one area of their lives and not others. Does the guy you’re going out with have a steady job? Does he keep in contact with his family and friends? If he’s divorced, does he see his children and make regular alimony payments? Does he have his own place? Does he have a pet? DoesDoes he talk about the future and his plans? he make plans in advance or tell you that he wants to do things spontaneously? Does he talk about the future and his plans? Does he volunteer anywhere regularly? Is he member of a synagogue? Does he have a men’s night out or some other regular weekly social commitment? All these things are indicative of someone who is committed and ready to commit further.

What about you? Maybe you are committed in your heart, but how do you answer the questions above? I suggest that you evaluate your own life and find places where you can insert a few commitments. That will put your feelings into action, and your personal energy will broadcast that you are a committed individual.

Sometimes, women find men fun on dates—interesting and charismatic, but not marriage material. I know it sounds like a cliché, but if you want a nice guy—a dependable guy who is husband and father material—you shouldn’t be dating the photojournalist going to Africa for a safari shoot, the pilot who only lands in town every few weeks or the aspiring actor who will be out rehearsing every night. These kind of men aren’t conducive to domesticity. OK, I know that dependable, regular guys aren’t as exciting as others you might date, but they are indeed the marrying kind. I’m not saying all marriageable men are boring. But maybe give a chance to a guy who might not sweep you off your feet at first.

Judaism has the concept of a bashert—the one person destined for you. But you have to make yourself open to meeting him. And you have to talk to G‑d and tell Him how much you want to meet this guy already.

To sum up:

  • Ask people to set you up, sign up with a matchmaker and don’t be shy asking for a reference when you happen to meet a guy you like to make sure that everything is on the up and up, and he is truly available and looking for a commitment.
  • Evaluate your life for how you express your sense of commitment and see if you could make some changes in that regard.
  • Try dating a different type of man than you’re used to. Give a chance to a type that might be less intriguing, but more emotionally available.
  • Don’t forget to pray and ask G‑d for a husband who will help you build a loving and stable Jewish home.

Praying you have a mazal tov soon!


Rosally Saltsman is a freelance writer originally from Montreal living in Israel. Click here to email Rosally.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with's copyright policy.
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
1000 characters remaining
Baruch Atta September 7, 2017

"...The guy before was an older man who’d never been married, but assured me he was ready to take the plunge. Then he decided to go to India for six months..."

Obviously your question is about the men that you date. You don't indicate that there is anything in your personality that might give men second thoughts. So let's just talk about the men.

Your "go to India" man seems typical. Over 40 and never married. Why not? Did you discuss this with him? It may be his wish. What does he have to gain by marriage? And especially, what does he have to gain by marrying you? And what does he lose? You, (and perhaps him also) seem to not see the other's point of view. Which is a necessary trait for a successful marriage.
In the end, you have some work to do on yourself! And I do not mean clothes and makeup. Reply

Yochanan Norfolk June 26, 2017

Join clubs or societies where you will meet people of like minds and interests.
Getting married can be wonderful. On the other hand it can be like getting a beautifully wrapped present. It fills you with anticipation and excitement, but when you finally get it unwrapped, it turns out to be a disappointment..
Does marriage define you as a person?
I don't think so.
What defines you is that you are made in the image of G-d and you have a lot to give: to your family, your friends, the community at large. There you will find fulfilment until a man worthy of you comes along.
I'm a guy by the way. Old and very happily married! Reply

Lisa Providence, RI June 10, 2017

It sounds like you're always running into "bad luck." Did you talk to your rabbi about this? Did he or she give you any helpful advice?

I read in Good Housekeeping Magazine about a woman who had 3 relationships after her divorce and all 3 of them broke up when she asked the man for a commitment. She wondered if she was too possessive, but she was told that she could have been rejected as a child and continued to seek out men who would reject her the same way.

You need to assess your situation, and hopefully, you will find the man of your dreams! Reply

S United Kingdom May 24, 2017

Thank you, Rachel for this article, it is really sound advice. Marriage, is a lifelong commitment and should not be rushed.

I think, also, one should not dwell on dates that are not suitable for one or the other person. Look forward, and know in your heart HaShem loves you first and foremost. Reply

Related Topics