Contact Us

My Fight with Cancer

My Fight with Cancer

When Vinegar Burns

Chana Laine
Chana Laine

I strike a match, kindle the flame, and watch as the holy Shabbat flames set the golden oil aglow. The daughter of Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa mistakenly substituted sharp-scented vinegar for the glowing oil that I see tonight. Her father, the great sage, was unperturbed. “He who says that oil shall burn, He shall say and vinegar will burn,” he declared. (Talmud, Taanit 25a)

It is a declaration that resounded through the generations, one that I had the audacity—and the faith—to repeat when doctors told me that I would never have children.

I’ve been living on miracles since I was 14 years oldBut then, I’ve been privy to miracles of oil—the wonders that doctors attempt to explain. And I’ve seen vinegar burn, too, when those very doctors throw up their hands and shake their heads in disbelief.

Oil and vinegar. I’ve been living on miracles since I was 14 years old.

Miriam is not leaving this clinic until she has a blood test,” my mother declared. I was 14 years old, and my mother was making a scene. I was mortified.

“I promise you, everything is perfect. There’s no reason to worry,” the doctor told her. The fatigue, fever and cramps were nothing more than the virus that had hit all of Montreal, he assured us yet again.

Still, he referred us to the hospital’s blood clinic. Sluggish with fatigue, I followed my mother onto the Metro to the Montreal Children’s Hospital. The fresh air and movement did me good, and once I’d done the blood test, I told my mother that I wanted to go back to school. I wasn’t a motivated student, but I was a popular one, and during the weeks I’d been curled up in bed I’d missed my friends.

The results came sooner than we expected. My white blood cell count was high, too high, the hospital told my mother just a few hours later. I was expected at the oncology clinic at eight the next morning.

My mother blanched. My mother’s cousin had succumbed to leukemia a few months before; the realization that I had similar symptoms threw my mother into a panic. She came to school and pulled me out of class, insisting I come home to rest. A happy-go-lucky ninth grader, I rolled my eyes and assumed that, like all mothers, she was overreacting. I wasn’t even perturbed when, that evening, our house filled with relatives. “You’ve been sick for a while. They want to see how you’re doing,” my mother explained. Amazingly, I did not question her explanation.

As I walked through the oncology ward the next morning, I felt a sense of disconnect. I was surrounded by gaunt faces and bald heads—a frightening and disturbing sight for someone who had never even heard of, let alone seen, kids with cancer. Still, there I was, full head of luxuriant hair, striding through the ward. These kids had no bearing on my medical situation, I thought. They were in cancer world. And the cancer world was a planet more distant than Mars.

The oncologist administered a painful bone-marrow test. He sent the results to the laboratory, but he took a small sample to examine by himself under a microscope. And then he delivered the blow.

It was leukemia. Chronic myeloid leukemiaIt was leukemia. Chronic myeloid leukemia.

I was looking straight at the doctor when he told us. “Oh, okay,” I said. “So now, what do we do about it?”

“We start chemotherapy.”

“Wait!” There was something missing here, some connection I couldn’t make. Chemotherapy . . . that was what cancer patients were treated with. “Is leukemia cancer?” I asked.

The doctor nodded.

I ran out of the room. My parents tried to stop me, hug me, hold me, comfort me, but I pushed them away. In the next room there was a phone, and somehow, despite my shaking hands, I dialed my friend’s number. I was sobbing: great, huge, racking sobs that shook my body and stole my voice. My friend’s voice was tinny, unreal.

“What?” she called. “What is it?”

“It’s Miriam. I have cancer.”

It was all I could say. We cried on the phone together. Eventually, I hung up, took a deep breath, and walked back into the doctor’s office.

I looked at my parents, who sat, silently weeping, and I shook my head. No, I said, I would not succumb. A primal instinct took over: I had to protect them, be strong for them. Singlehanded, I would hold back the avalanche of emotions that threatened to crush us all.

“So, what are we going to do about this?” I asked.

Slowly, clearly, the doctor gave us all the facts. Chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) is a cancer of the white blood cells, he told us. It rarely affects children; in fact, I had the dubious distinction of being one of three children in all of North America who suffered from it. My doctor would consult with other specialists and devise an experimental treatment plan. It wouldn’t be straightforward, and there was a strong chance I would need a bone-marrow transplant somewhere along the line, he told me. We would meet again the next morning, to begin chemotherapy.

Chemotherapy was tough. The drugs ravaged my body. I was sick—a deep nausea that began deep in my belly and swelled through me. After each shot, I would shake uncontrollably. My mother would lie down beside me and wrap her arms around me, holding me tight until the pressure and the warmth of her body eased the spasms.

Worst of all, the chemo didn’t help. We switched drugs, amended treatment plans, but my body didn’t respond. The doctors shifted gears and began preparing for a bone-marrow transplant. It was my only hope.

Around the world, Psalms were said for me, 24 hours a dayStill, I never thought, I’m not going to survive this. I just thought, I have to get through this. After all, I was 14 years old. I had plans. I had to graduate high school, go to seminary, get married. My parents made a conscious decision to go public about my situation, and the result was a tidal wave of love, support and prayer from the entire Jewish world. I was supported by the wonderful staff of the Ohr Meir Foundation, and an organization called Hands On for Children hooked me up with a school in Boro Park, which sent me cards and pictures, letters and albums. I was showered with support—and distraction, too, which helped keep my spirits buoyed.

At one point, I questioned my parents’ decision. I knew people who hid even minor medical issues. To go public was revolutionary, iconoclastic. Why did they do it?

My mother’s answer was simple, and it typified her rock-solid faith. “I want their prayers,” she told me. I nodded, suddenly proud of her. And she was right—people prayed. Around the world, Psalms were said for me, 24 hours a day. My principal, Rabbi Aisenstark, organized a round-the-clock Psalms vigil. “If you can get up at 3 AM to go on a field trip, you can get up at 3 AM to say Psalms for Miriam,” he told the entire school.

To this day, I can’t fathom how many millions of prayers were said for me in those dark days. Neither can I fathom the result of those prayers: I was lifted upon their wings and carried from treatment to surgery, from surgery to remission, from hope to despair to hope once more.

As summer approached, a representative of Chai Lifeline, an organization that helps families and children with cancer, persuaded my parents to send me to Camp Simcha, a camp for kids with serious illnesses. Camp Simcha saved my life. For the first time, I met kids like me who had been through chemo, surgery, transplants—fellow fighters all. There, I finally lost my hair. As if it were the most normal thing in the world, my friend simply took a broom and a dustpan, and kept sweeping away those deep brown locks as they fell from my head. We sang, danced, and I was so happy, that I didn’t realize my condition was rapidly deteriorating. On my return, I was taken directly to the Montreal Children’s Hospital to receive my bone-marrow transplant.

Away at camp, I wasn’t witness to the multitude of medical, technical and legal hoops through which my parents jumped to make the transplant happen. Miraculously, two of my sisters—my married sister Guila, and my eight-year-old sister, Leah—were exact matches. Leah was chosen to donate.

In preparation for the transplant, I had to undergo full-body radiation and chemotherapy to kill all the cancerous cells. I was in strict isolation—my mother was allowed in the room, but my siblings, relatives and friends could only wave through a glass window and talk through the intercom. I affixed a huge poster of my Camp Simcha bunk to the wall opposite my bed. These were my friends—they had survived. Despite my bald head, yellow skin and overwhelming weakness, I would survive, too.

Despite my bald head, yellow skin and overwhelming weakness, I would surviveI still remember the day the doctor walked into my room with a printout of my blood work. Zero, zero, zero, zero, I read on the paper. The figures boggled my mind. In preparation for my transplant, they had destroyed my blood cells. All of them. I was a living corpse.

I received the bone marrow intravenously; it didn’t look any different from a regular blood transfusion. “How does the bone marrow know where to go?” I asked my doctor. I imagined the cells circulating around my system, without ever finding their way to the inside of my bone. “They just do,” he replied. Though the doctor took it for granted, I was astounded. What a miracle! That the cells gravitate to where they’re needed, that they can adopt my body as their new home and then create and infuse my body with healthy blood—it was the vinegar burning bright and clean.

For five weeks after the transplant, I was a caged bird. I sat in my room, staring down at the street below. I wonder if any of the passersby ever looked up and saw the little bald girl watching them, wishing she could be part of a humdrum existence. You can walk! I wanted to yell through the glass. You can talk! You’re a part of the world! Appreciate it!

My naturally feisty nature pushed me toward recovery, and I decided that I would spend Yom Kippur at home with my family. On the eve of Yom Kippur, when my mother went home for an hour to cook, I prepared to leave. I took down my poster, packed, dressed, and sat, waiting.

The doctor laughed when he saw me. I was only five weeks post transplant, and I was expected to stay for between two and three months. A few hours later, he came running into my room with the latest blood results. The transplanted marrow had engrafted, and my blood counts were at a safe level. I could return home.

Just a few hours before Yom Kippur, I opened the door of my isolation room and pushed myself out in my wheelchair. Everyone cheered—and gaped. The nurses had never seen a transplant patient push her own wheelchair home.

I spent the next nine months in home isolation, and my mother, a talented artist, helped me create a magnificent sculptured painting. I would hang it in my future home, I decided as I worked. Was I naive? Or did I simply refuse to recognize the difference between oil and vinegar? I still don’t know, but then, riding on the crest of recovery, I had no idea what lay in store.

Riding on the crest of recovery, I had no idea what lay in storeI graduated school, went to seminary, and met the man I wanted to marry. We just had to meet each other’s families, and we would announce our engagement. I was standing at the threshold of my dreams.

I flew home from a vacation in Israel on a Thursday, and on Friday morning I had a routine appointment. The oncologist on call took a blood test, and she came back, white-faced. As I looked at her face, something inside me froze. I began to shake.

The cancer, she told me, had returned.

No! No! I was just about to get engaged. I was waiting to step into my future. How? How could it have happened? Why was G‑d doing this to me? What did He want from me?

I sat down, reeling from the shock, the horror. It was a mistake, it was a lab error, it was . . .

It was true.

I called up Zev, my soon-to-be groom, and I cried down the phone. He got into a car and drove seven hours straight, from New York to Montreal. Never once thinking of himself, he was there for me—listening, crying with me, talking, supporting me as I tried to process the fact that once again my life was in question.

I couldn’t bring myself to tell my parents. I knew that when I told them, I’d have to play strong, and I was too raw, too broken. Thus, I re-entered the isolation ward for one more Shabbat—I played along with the charade of meals and Shabbat songs, while hermetically sealing my emotions in a place that no one could enter.

By Sunday, I felt strong enough to tell them.

They cried.

Monday morning found us back at the Montreal Children’s Hospital. The oncologist was not hopeful. The only option, he told me, was another bone-marrow transplant.

I shook my head.

My parents and Zev looked at me in shock. What was this? How could I refuse the only lifeline I was offered? But I knew myself, my strengths and my weaknesses. Some instinct told me that my body wasn’t strong enough to take another transplant. The radiation and chemo would kill me. We returned home, wondering if this was it. Was I slowly walking to the end?

Zev returned to New York, and for the next four days he didn’t eat or sleep. He found doctors, opinions, information, trials, experimental drugs. He was determined to find some ray of hope, some new treatment, something, anything.

A year later, in an explosion of joy and music, Zev and I stood side by side under the chuppah, our marriage canopyFour days later he returned to Montreal, with a stack of new studies, doctors’ phone numbers, and the name of a brand new drug, that just that month had begun trials in New York. At the time the drug was identified as STI‑571 (later it was called imatinib, and sold as Gleevec), and it was an innovative chemotherapy targeting the specific abnormal protein found in CML cells. The drug wouldn’t cure the cancer, but it would inhibit the growth of cancer cells and allow me to live a normal life. The drug had not yet come to Canada, and it required tremendous help from Above to organize my being the first-ever Canadian patient to be involved, long-distance, in the drug trial.

The drug did its work. My condition stabilized. The timing, the incredible scientific knowledge and knowhow it took to develop the drug, Zev’s involvement . . . all melded together for one purpose—to grant me life. A year later, in an explosion of joy and music, Zev and I stood side by side under the chuppah, our marriage canopy.

Before we married, we talked about having children; after my having undergone full-body radiation, the odds were stacked against us. But I wasn’t concerned. I had an inner conviction that I would have children, and I just went right back to the vinegar-oil principle. When a wick floating on golden oil burns, we say it’s nature. But who decreed that oil would have the properties that make it burn? G‑d. The same G‑d could make vinegar burn, if He so willed.

G‑d had split the sea for me so many times. Was it so different to ask Him for a child? After all, every child is a miracle.

When a fertility organization that worked according to Jewish law visited Montreal a year or two later, Zev and I went to see the specialist. He shook his head. There was nothing he could do for us.

I was crushed, but I was angry, too. How could a G‑d-fearing man ever say that he didn’t think we could have children? But the years that followed seemed to prove him right. We visited the most eminent specialists in the field; we spent tens of thousands of dollars on treatment. Nothing.

In the meantime, I went back to school. I completed a BA in liberal arts, and then moved on to study psychology and social work. Someday, I told myself, I would tell my children that when things didn’t go as I planned, I made the most of that time. Still, when Zev came back from synagogue with tears in his eyes, it cut me like a knife. How he longed to have a child of his own to bring under his tallit during the priestly blessing, to lift high on his shoulders and dance with on Simchat Torah.

Two years later, I scheduled another appointment with my fertility specialist. “I’m happy, I’m fulfilled,” I told him, “but I want to know if anything’s changed.” The doctor ran tests, and he delivered the results with a shake of his head. “Go home, Miriam,” he told me. “There’s almost zero chance of you ever having a child.”

Once again, my hopes were cruelly dashed. I called up my naturopath and told her what had happened. She was unperturbed. “Miriam, your doctor has just challenged G‑d.”

“My doctor has just extinguished my hope,” I countered.

“No,” she said. “Don’t give up hope. Now we’re going to see a miracle.”

“Go home, Miriam,” he told me. “There’s almost zero chance of you ever having a child.”Zev and I went on vacation soon after that—it was just before exams, and I was thankful for a break, even though I wasn’t feeling good. When we got back, I went straight to the naturopath. I was sick, really sick, I suspected, and I was looking for reassurance and comfort.

“I think you might be pregnant,” she said. I took a home test, and then a blood test, and—while my heart was palpitating, and I was more scared than I had ever been in my life—a light entered Zev’s eyes and lit up his whole face. Our incredulous doctor confirmed: we were going to be parents.

But . . . there were so many buts. What about the chemo? What about the baby? What about me? My oncologist was scared. I was cramping. I didn’t want to continue taking the Gleevec. Was it safe? Were there trials? Would my oncologist work with me? Questions, a whirling flurry of questions and doubts and fears and euphoria. And above it all boomed the voice of my fertility specialist. “This is G‑d’s miracle.”

The premier oncologist who had created Gleevec, and the head oncologist at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center (who had treated me in Camp Simcha), agreed to work with me. I flew to New York every two weeks to have my blood checked and my situation assessed. I begged G‑d to take care of me. I surrendered myself into His loving arms, and I asked Him to carry me. And He did.

For the first five months of the pregnancy, my blood work was stable, and the doctors hesitantly agreed that I could stay off Gleevec. I spent time cultivating a vegetable garden—feeling the soil between my fingers, smelling the fresh scent and watching the seedlings develop and grow. The process mirrored what was happening in my body, making it real and alive, and connecting me with the cosmic process of birth.

When I was five months pregnant, I relapsed. I needed to go back on chemo, but I resisted—what would the powerful drugs do to the fragile life growing inside me? The pressure and tension were crushing. Again, I asked G‑d for help. I spoke to Him in my own words, the way I’d talk to my closest friends, with an intensity that stemmed from the knowledge that only He could get me through this. Two weeks later, back in New York for more blood work, the level of cancerous cells had dropped. For the rest of the pregnancy, the level of cancer cells vacillated, but I managed to avoid chemotherapy.

After eight years of waiting, I held a baby in my armsFive weeks before my due date, I was in New York for the unveiling of a dear departed friend’s stone, when my waters broke. Zev was in Montreal, I was away from home, and it wasn’t safe to attempt the journey back. Once again, I begged G‑d to be by my side. He was. My sister-in-law, who doubled as my doula, located a midwife, and I had a home birth with no medical intervention. After eight years of waiting, I held a baby in my arms. Our daughter, Chana, was born in a moment rich with love and gratitude and wonder.

Choosing a name was easy. Chana, the mother of the biblical Samuel, was the woman who taught us to cry when we pray. Our Chana had taught me the same lesson. In addition, Chana was the name of the mother of the Lubavitcher Rebbe. Amazingly, I was able to stay off Gleevec long enough to nurse Chana for a full three months.

Today Chana brings such a piquant sweetness to our lives that while the shadows, when they come, seem a darker shade of gray, the sun is brighter and the world shimmers with color. Cancer and chemo have become a part of me, and I have adjusted in the same way one might adjust to a limp—at first rebelling and denying the disability, and eventually learning to pace myself and live with it.

There are times when I feel tearful and anxious. Recently, when Chana was two, I had such a moment. My body became immune to Gleevec, and I was once again face to face with my fears. I was feeling good, and I had been taking Gleevec for over a decade. To be told that it was no longer effective was devastating. Thank G‑d, by that time sister drugs had been developed that combat the cancerous cells.

Living with cancer is to live with uncertainty, but every person who walks this earth lives in the shadow of death—some are more aware of it than others. Of course I’m afraid, but life has taught me its natural rhythm—anxiety and sadness are invariably followed by joy, hope. I’m humbler now; my life follows G‑d’s plan, and any agenda I might dream up is laughable.

Most importantly, I’ve learned to appreciate G‑d’s miracles, both the glow of oil and the flame burning clear and clean in a goblet of sharp-scented vinegar.

Miriam Laine is a wife, mother, and social work student at McGill University in Montreal.

This article was originally published in the Family First section of Mishpacha Magazine.

© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with's copyright policy.
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
1000 characters remaining
Mosheh Wolfish Baltimore July 25, 2016

Rosh Chodesh Rosh Chodesh begins when the "new" moon reappears after having been gone/erased. Perhaps to remind us of the verse in Ha'azinu - Machatzti va'Ani Erpah, "I smote and I will Heal".
Mazal Tov on your engagement, Miriam!
Izak's Uncle Moishy Reply

Anonymous December 23, 2015

Wow an amazing story with an amazing lesson to learn..... NEVER GIVE UP!!!! Reply

Lisa Providence, RI February 10, 2014

Fighting Cancer Miriam Lane, you beat tremendous odds to have a baby and you should be commended for it! Reply

Jeanne Lunkowski Ormond Beach Florida February 7, 2014

HaShem, Miriam and Cancer When I received a message from Chabad that there was a new comment in Miriam' story, I thought....oooh, it has been nearly two years that I had read and commented on her remarkable story. Today, I sat and re-read it once again. This account by Miriam is as touching as ever. I also want to say that it is a little bit like TANAKH...each time you read it, something else stands out. What was lit this time was the fact that for 24 hours Psalms were recited for Miriam, and I would like to say that the feeling she had about being supported on wings was so truly genuine because it was from HaShem. I can attest to this wonderful event. And then just last night as I was reading, these words grabbed me even though I cannot say how many times I have read them....listen: "On their palms they will carry you lest you strike your foot against a stone..." The delivery of this promise is what Miriam experienced as did I. Let us all continue to pray for her, and Zev and Chana. Reply

Lisa Providence, RI February 5, 2014

Fighting Cancer Wonderful story! I believe in miracles, because they really do happen! Reply

Anonymous Miami September 10, 2013

I pray that one day I can as strong as you. You're an incredible neshama, I am speechless, At loss of words. May you, Zev, and Chana only know good from here on. Thank you! Reply

Ruth Housman marshfield hills, MA June 5, 2012

the silver shofar There is a silver shofar for sale on another website that deals with Judaica and I just saw this before this return, of commentary and your deep, life story. The shofar to me looks just like a bird and I do deepy believe all Creativity is about this, the possibilities inherent in what we see, the endless creativity that hearks back to our Shema, about ONE.

I hear the word answer in cancer, and I think there are many answers to a deep, life-threatening and troubling illness that is strangely about the immortality of cells. The He La cell story is still running, that these cells are still alive and multiplying.

It could be, and I see it, that this story is not over, and those who left, who were wrenched suddenly and slowly from life, gave us the courage to go on, because their dignity shines, and the love we feel for them.

In exist is exit, and i feel their presence wherever i go.

Whatever side of the rainbow we occupy, I know the greater story is about LOVE.


Mykem B. Cotonou, Benin June 5, 2012

I'm grateful My heart is filled with eternal gratitude ....
To Hashem, how I love and marvel at His love
To You for such a wonderful faith ... Thank you so very much for sharing your testimony. It has blessed my life beyond words, and I will share it every time I have an opportunity.

and to, for such a wonderful platform.

Dear Miriam, I will be praying for you and your family, convinced that Hashem has allowed all that in your life so that He can reassure all of us that He is indeed everything we know Him to be. Reply

Yossi Englewood, NJ May 17, 2012

After reading your story and wiping my tears, I just felt I had to say something to you, but I realized that there aren't many things a person can remark about your life and what you have been through, other than to be astounded at what you are capable of. You set the bar incredibly high! I wish for you to continue to have nachas (joy) from your daughter Chana and she should continue to have nachas from you.
With respect, profound admiration and ahavas yisroel (love of a fell of Jew).
Yossi Reply

Teaneck NJ May 16, 2012

Speechless This is beyond powerful, or inspirational. Way beyond.
You and your family are a blessing to the world. Reply

Deborah Bienna, Va May 16, 2012

Blessings I'm crying reading your story! May HaShem bless you and your loved ones with health and strength, love, miracles and blessings! Reply

Anonymous Tampa, Fl May 16, 2012

Miriam After reading your miraculous story I will
say a Prayer for you, Zev & Chana every day.
I am a cancer survivor for over 30 years and
I know that you will live a long joyous life.
Your faith and fate is unbelievable.....
May you continue to have Blessings for good health, happiness and success........
. From a 81 year old Bubbie

Jeanne Lunkowski Ormond Beach, FL May 13, 2012

Cancer Miriam: Cancer, one of the most dreaded words for humanity...but the power of G-d is awesome, and you are a witness to it. Blessings on you for sharing it with us. Words cannot describe my feelings while reading your story because His Power never ceases to amaze me. Ahava to you and Chana, and Zev. Reply

Esther Samama Brooklyn, NY May 13, 2012

Such an inspiration You are such an inspiration to everyone. Your faith is amazing and may Hashem bless you and your family from now on only with the best of everything! May you share with us soon the good news about Chana's brand new sibling :) Reading your incredible story makes most of us see life thru different lenses, and gives courage to those in worse predicaments. You are precious to Hashem and an asset to all of us...Thank you for having the courage and the heart to share your story with us Reply

Anonymous Baltimore May 13, 2012

What is your Tehillim name? Reply

Anonymous May 12, 2012

May your lives always be blessed with only happiness and may you merit to raise many more children with true complete health according to the ways of the Torah. May Hashem shower you with only blessings, giving you the strength you need to overcome your struggles. May we merit to see the revelation of Moshiach now when eveyone will be cured and their lives only blessed. Reply

Rivka Dor-chay israel, jerusalem via May 12, 2012

I am in awe of you! I read this article holding my new baby girl in my hands. You have truly inspired me with your life story and most of all your strength. It has made me appreciate what I have. May you continue to give people strength like this. You are very much a needed, special person in this world!

Kol tuv
Rivka Reply

Hana Austin, TX May 11, 2012

G-d BlessYou! Oh My G-d! What you have gone through. I hope your health will become perfect and that you suffering will be over. Thank G-d for keeping you alive. Reply

Kyle Austin, TX May 10, 2012

Vinegar Goblet What a story! Never have I heard such a tale of life. I hope and pray you stay well, you are an incredibly strong woman!! Reply

J.Sperber encino, california May 10, 2012

miriam's story so much adversity, and yet you didn't give up! may you live a long and happy, well deserved life. Reply