HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info
 
Chabad.org » The Jewish Woman » Women's Narrative » Editorial & Commentary » Jillian, Have a Baby!
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment39 Comments

Jillian, Have a Baby!

A Response to Jillian Michaels

Celebrity fitness trainer Jillian Michaels was quoted earlier this week telling Women’s Health Magazine that she plans to adopt instead of birthing her own children because, in her own words, “I can’t handle doing that to my body.” Appalled on behalf of mothers everywhere, I decided to write her a letter.

Dear Jillian,

You would think your decision to adopt a child so to spare your body from pregnancy wouldn't surprise me considering you're part of a high-profile, celebrity world that worships image and, moreover, that you're famous for guiding people to better bodies on the hit show The Biggest Loser. But with today's celebrities bearing more than a few children, looking great and cherishing motherhood, your comments do stand out.

You say "that" like pregnancy is some horrific, unnatural and purposeless procedure foreign to womanhoodYou say you can't handle doing "that" to your body. You say "that" like pregnancy is some horrific, unnatural and purposeless procedure foreign to womanhood. I know you're a successful gym superstar, but can you really be so vain?

No mom is going to fight the notion that bearing children takes its toll on the body. A human being comes out of you - your body changes. Duh. But, as a fitness guru, you of all people should know best the body's ability to bounce back after surgery, weight gain and certainly pregnancy. And you're obviously capable! I mean, come on, look at you – every mother would love to snap her fingers and have your body, let alone your commitment and energy for fitness.

Who are you to fear the physical ramifications of pregnancy? There's no doubt you'd be one of those super celebrity moms who strut about town showing off a flat belly days after birth. Come on, Jill (can I call you that?). You can do it. I believe in you.

Obviously, your sentiments stem from your all-consuming commitment to your perfectly trim and toned body. Your body is your career, and you don't want to sacrifice that. But as a woman, your body has a calling of its own. Everything from our wide hips to our womb within beseeches us to birth children.

But your comments are insensitive to more than your own female body, but to the countless women in the world who can't handle not doing "that" to their body; women who suffer from the painful reality of infertility. They would wreck their bodies a million times over to bear a healthy child. They would take acne and obesity any day over their childless existence. And you? You're actually willing to forego the gift of motherhood--all for a six pack you can easily rebuild post-partum. And worse, you're not afraid to admit it.

You're actually willing to forego the gift of motherhood--all for a six pack you can easily rebuild post-partumThe unabashed way you share choosing your body over baby makes me worry that your mindset is not foreign to many women in today's body-first culture. And that's scary. So I'm writing because I'm convinced I represent most mothers out there – whether beach babes or soccer moms – who love looking good, feeling healthy and still feel that birthing a baby is our body's ultimate purpose (imagine that!).

When you think pregnancy, all you imagine are stretch marks. When you hear baby, you just see flab. To you, growing a child is a "that" - not a feminine experience. This attitude is the antithesis of all that is womanly. You may have a great body, and you certainly work to keep it that way, but you're no female role model.

More and more studies confirm the fact that the pinnacle of the female body's experience is growing and birthing a baby. It's confirmed both scientifically and certainly from personal accounts that our body's health is enhanced – our years lengthened! – via the physical experience of becoming a mom.

Jillian, you’re thirty-six years old. Hopefully before menopause, you’ll consider giving your body – and mind and soul – the gift it deserves. Don’t just keep doing your jumping jacks, denying your feminine self. Do something truly great for your body - have a baby. And after you do, I’m sure we’ll all see you again on the cover of Women’s Health Magazine, sporting a belly that is just as flat and toned as it was before – but a heckuva lot happier than it ever was.

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment39 Comments

By Mimi Hecht (Notik)   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Mimi Hecht (Notik) is a young mother living in Brooklyn, New York. She is a freelance writer, with a passion for portraying the truth and humor in being a woman, wife and mom.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

39 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Dec 16, 2010
Jillian Michaels has a reproductive problem! shes not adopting for no reason!!
Posted By Anonymous, monsey, ny

Posted: Dec 8, 2010
I've just accidentally This is disgusting to read all your comments, it really makes me sick. You don't have any damn right to judge anyone. We all have a right to choose what we gonna do with our lives: give a birth, adopt a child, buy a puppy, get married, suicide, whatever. Why do all americans love to interfere with other people's lives? Oh, Gosh! Is this your nature? She doesn't want to have a baby, she wants to adopt, so that's her own choice, that's her life! It's none of your business! You're a loving mom? Good for you! Go forward and have another one and another and three more. Who cares? I can't just figure out why all of you are so spiteful, hostile to her for living her own life. Let's be more positive and kind towards other people. And one more, I truly believe that if she ever adopts a child she'll be a great, loving and caring mom.
Posted By Valeria, Kiev, Ukraine

Posted: Oct 18, 2010
Make some sammiches, woman!
Considering some of the awfully catty comments from the pro-birthing, anti-adoption women here, (I take it these women think adoption means your child isn't good enough because It's Not Your Own!) I guess the next step they would take would be for them to tell "Jill" that she has to get herself in the kitchen and make some sammiches for her husband.

What are you waiting for, Jillian? Do your womanly duty, and get in that kitchen and make your man some sammiches!

Seriously, ladies, women are MUCH MORE than a just uterus and a pair of ovaries.
Posted By rox

Posted: July 22, 2010
love it, you go girl!
Posted By danielle behar, hollywood

Posted: May 24, 2010
Motivated or Steamed?
Righteous anger should cause one to take positive action in her own realm of influence.

Perhaps, giving birth is a mitzvah Ms. Michaels is not yet able to undertake. It doesn't mean love and emotional progress won't change her mind and it certainly doesn't mean we should gather stones and head to her house.

LOL

Obesity is a big deal. It affects every aspect of life, not just whether one is able to provide a loving home. Fat people, (whether they are hindered medically, nutritionally ignorant or covering some pain) are not treated the same as people who are not fat and are continually judged.

As far as I am concerned, it is a good thing to parent children who are ALREADY HERE, rather than to mindlessly reproduce when seeing oneself reproduced could be the worst possible injury.

Indignation is powerful, but without G-dly reasoning it only spins its wheels.
Posted By Rebekah, near Chicago

Posted: May 15, 2010
Article
James, you said it all and you said it best. Kol Hakavod to you!
Posted By Anonymous, Brooklyn, NY

Posted: May 13, 2010
Nobody decided her real reason, she annunced it. and it was that she "could not handle doing that to her body," in reference to pregnancy.
Posted By Christie, Des Moines

Posted: May 12, 2010
James, Jillian SAID this.
She flat out said her ONLY reason for adopting was so she wouldn't "ruin" her body.
She's NOT doing it as a mitzvah. She's doing it out of selfishness and vanity.
It's not judging when the person CONFESSES. Which is what Jillian did. She CONFESSED that she was adopting so she would not get FAT.
Maybe before you judge US you should learn to read what's already been written repeatedly.
I'll make it clear -
JILLIAN
FLAT
OUT
SAID
SHE
WAS
ADOPTING
TO
AVOID
GETTING
FAT!
Period.
Posted By Jami, Costa Mesa, CA

Posted: May 12, 2010
I'm pretty appalled by the assumingly "religious" people on this board here making judgements about Jillian.

I think Jillian should do whatever she wants. I think it's terrible (not to mention Lashon HaRah) to decide her "real" reasoning for adopting.

Adoption is among the greatest mitzvahs you can do. (Almost) anyone can have a baby. Very few people can handle adopting a baby.
Posted By James, New York, NY

Posted: May 10, 2010
And what about...
If she's worried about what pregnancy will do to her body, I'm worried about whether she's ready to be a mom at all. After all, even without the 9 months, there are the sleepless nights, the putting your child's needs ahead of yours, the commitment to be there for at least 18 years. To me, it sounds like she may be too selfish to be a good mom. Maybe it would be better to stop trying to convince her to get pregnant, and start trying to convince her to forgo parenthood entirely.
Posted By Lindsay, Miami, FL



 


Editorial & Commentary
Top Ten Articles from 2008 on TheJewishWoman.org
Readers Share
Writers Share
Religious? Not Me!
Knowing What’s Important
The Incomparable Joy of Being Heard
Can You Define a Jew?
Jillian, Have a Baby!
Elizabeth Edwards' Resilience
Big Bullies
Getting Back Up
Emotional Translucency
The Mask of Protection
From Wall Street to Main Street
Hatred at the Supermarket
Showing 7 - 21 of 70