Here's a great tip:
Enter your email address and we'll send you our weekly magazine by email with fresh, exciting and thoughtful content that will enrich your inbox and your life, week after week. And it's free.
Oh, and don't forget to like our facebook page too!
A new online course
Starting January 22nd
Register »
Contact Us

The Contributing Factor

The Contributing Factor

Fulfilling Our Potential as Creative Women


When Rachel saw that she had borne no children to Jacob, Rachel became envious of her sister and said to Jacob, “Give me children or else I die.” Jacob’s anger was kindled against Rachel and he said, “Can I take the place of G‑d?” (Genesis 30:1-2).

It is perhaps the Nachmanides who best sums up the response of all of us to Jacob’s words when he writes, “I am astonished.” Apparently, it is not only humanity that is shocked by this conversation. According to the commentators, G‑d Himself asks, “Is this the way to answer the troubled?”

And yet, we know that there is something to be learned from the words of our forefathers and mothers. Yet what can we possibly learn from this exchange? No one who has ever experienced the pain of being childless needs this story to understand the intensity of such a longing, and no Is this the way to answer the troubled? one who is blessed with a house full of children is really going to get what it feels like to be barren after reading these words. And as for Jacob’s reply . . .

The commentator known as the Akeidat Yitzchak (Isaac Arama, a Talmudic scholar who lived in Spain at the time of the Expulsion) sheds light on the story of Rachel and Jacob based on the account of the creation of the first man and woman, Adam and Chava (Eve).

Adam and Chava were originally created as one being, male and female joined back to back, sort of like Siamese twins. After blessing them to “be fruitful and multiply,” G‑d states “It is not good that man be alone,” meaning, that man and woman can not really compliment one another in the best possible way when joined together too closely. It is necessary that G‑d separate them, allowing a face-to-face relationship. So He places the man/woman in a deep slumber, separates one side, closes over the cut and builds the removed side into the first woman by adding an extra measure of bina, understanding.

When G‑d wakes Adam from his sleep and brings the woman to him, he proclaims her isha and after she gives birth he proclaims her Chava. Of what significance are these titles? When G‑d brings all of the earth’s animals before Adam to be named, it is taught that he named them through the power of prophecy, that he was able to see their spiritual essence. Indeed, it is taught that the world was built using the letters of the Hebrew language and that the Hebrew name of each part of creation is composed of those letters used in its construction and reveals the essential nature of the thing itself, because the essence is bound up with the Hebrew letters with which it was formed. Significantly, only human beings are given two pairs of names.

The first name given to woman, isha, is related to the name given to man, ish. This reveals that a woman, like a man, must develop her spiritual and intellectual potential to the fullest. Other exegetes have pointed out that the difference between ish and isha is the use of a yud for ish and hey for isha. The hey is a more developed letter and, in fact, the yud represents that first burst of undirected intellectual energy or insight whereas the hei represents the ability to develop that energy/insight in meaningful and practical ways.

The words ish and isha both contain the word aish, Hebrew for “fire.” Just as the flames of a fire constantly reach upwards, so, too, the essence of the ish/isha role is that we direct ourselves upwards, always striving for greater heights in our spiritual growth, ever seeking a deeper connection with our Source.

A woman must develop her spiritual and intellectual potential to the fullest

A woman must cultivate a relationship with her Creator and use her mind to its fullest capacity. Only then, asserts the Akeidat Yitzchak, can a woman fulfill her second role as Chava, “mother of all life,” a role which crowns the role of isha.

It is important to note two details in this commentary. First, he emphasizes (or rather, in his commentary Jacob emphasizes) the need for a fully developed isha to preceed Chava. Bear in mind: In those days, there was an obvious connection between the physical and the spiritual, and this in no way implies that women today who are infertile are lacking in their relationship with the Divine, nor that all mothers today are perfect. The relevance for us today is clearly in its insight into the mother-child relationship, into the power of a mother to convey the warmth and the light of Torah, of Shabbat, of bath time, of sunsets, and of every detail of Jewish life.

Yet the Akeidat Yitzchak seems to suggest even more—that how a mother works on herself prior to birth is bound up with bringing the soul of a child into this world. By giving your child the best you that can possibly be, you empower him or her to be the best that he can be—starting with the spiritual journey he makes into this world. And once here, it is on her intellectual abilities and practical savvy that a child will most heavily depend.

The second detail which is interesting to note, and which sheds light on what makes a marriage a Jewish marriage, is that the Akeidat Yitzchak places the role of wife within the isha role. What he is suggesting is a relationship which is both intellectually and spiritually charged, a relationship of two equals striving together towards the same higher goal. It is a relationship which calls to mind a line from the blessings traditionally recited at a Jewish wedding, “these two loving friends.”

Parenthood, then, which is truly the most beautiful, most important, and most challenging role two people could ever undertake, is ideally meant to crown two people mature in their relationship with G‑d and with one another.

We can learn a great deal about ourselves—and the role of a Jewish woman—from the exchange between Jacob and Rachel. Stated more gently, every woman has a vibrant contribution to make to this world whether married or single, whether blessed with children or still waiting. And every mother has more to give her children, spiritually and intellectually, than she’s ever imagined.

Chana Kroll is an alumna of Machon Chana Yeshiva for Women in Crown Heights, Brooklyn. Prior to moving to New York, she taught at a boarding school/shelter for runaways and young people whose families were homeless.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with's copyright policy.
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
1000 characters remaining
Rhona Lewis, Beit Shemesh Beit Shemesh, Israel November 23, 2009

Women and learning Thank you. I enjoyed reading how vital it is to develop our intellectual side. Too often this gets left till last or lost in the piles of dishes, laundry and tooth brushing. Now I can take time to develop this side and feel great about it because, ultimately, it's for the good of the family. Reply

Chana Kroll June 6, 2009

chava and chaya She was not given the name Chaya at all. Chava was not the name given to her after eating from the Tree of Knowledge- it was given to her after she gave birth- very important difference. Reply

Anonymous June 4, 2009

Chava and Chaya Thank you for this article and I liked the way you brought these commentaries.

I believe that Chaya is the name meaning "Mother of all Life", whereas Chava is the name she acquired after the forbidden fruit was eaten, is it so? Reply

Anonymous June 4, 2009

To Boulder, CO Because a portion and a half is better than a portion. Reply

Anonymous Boulder, CO February 10, 2009

The Contributing Factor Great article and I love this story. My only thought is: why did G-d feel the need to give Chava an extra measure of understanding/bina?" If Chava was from the original whole being, why the extra portion?Thank you! Reply

Taylor M Alameda, CA December 2, 2008

Rachel and Jacob Maybe Jacob felt Rachel was putting undue pressure on him - to not only "give" her children, but to make that the deciding factor as to whether she lived or died. So if she didn't have children, he would be forced to live with the guilty consequence of her death? I think he sidesteps the issue and points out, rightly, that it is not up to him. But on the other hand, no one can blame her for being frustrated with her body. In those days, having children was important, and not doing so meant that a woman was not "doing her job." I think, Chana, that you have done a wonderful job pointing out how some of these ideas persist, and how there are other ways that a woman can fulfill her personal and spiritual potential without having to be the physical mother of children. Thank you. Reply

Anonymous Brisbane, Australia February 28, 2007

article I thought the article was good, but i say this to you, we can go further than our minds can imagine. I believe as husband, and wife we can have a relationship with G-d as you said. But imagine if we could have a two way conversation with G-d, and fall in love with him in a way we cannot fully imagine, as it is beyond our physical love to know. For him to touch our hearts, where you know no one else could have known but G-d. To laugh with him alone, not having to share it with another human being, as it was an inside joke that you shared only with him. To touch his finger, where a spark of lighting come off the tip of your fingers. To hear his gentle loud voice speak your name, and to know that he who created you knows you, and can speak to you. To feel his joy, and his peace as you rest in his arms, as you never have to be concerned again for what man can do. Can we truly feel these things? I am telling YES, YES we can. What is my identity in G-d, not physical indenity Reply

lightning Dallas, TX November 28, 2006

man and woman I liked your article "The Contributing Factor". You wrote with much insight about man and woman and their creation. Reply

Related Topics