Here's a great tip:
Enter your email address and we'll send you our weekly magazine by email with fresh, exciting and thoughtful content that will enrich your inbox and your life, week after week. And it's free.
Oh, and don't forget to like our facebook page too!
Printed from
All Departments
Jewish Holidays
Jewish.TV - Video
Jewish Audio
Kabbalah Online
Kids Zone

Meaning and Chaos

Meaning and Chaos


What is the relationship between goodness, kindness, selflessness -- and material success? Does goodness lead to health and prosperity? This question, at the heart of mankind's search for meaning, is frequently discussed in Jewish teachings.

The Torah presents us with a firm statement on this subject: "If you walk in My statutes, I will provide you with rain at the right time and the land will bear its crops and the trees will provide fruit... You will live securely in the land... But if you do not listen to Me and do not keep these laws... You will plant your crops in vain, because your enemies will eat them... you will flee even when no-one is chasing you..." (Leviticus Ch. 26).

In a few brush strokes, so to speak, these passages outline two pictures: one of "Redemption", i.e., national and individual wholeness, the other of galut ("exile") - fragmentation and conflict.

The first picture, that of Redemption, depicts a state of union between the spiritual and physical aspects of life. A good action produces a good effect in the material world. Body and soul are in harmony on every level of being. The people serve G-d, and therefore the crops grow and there is peace. Life has meaning.

The second picture, that of galut, comes as a punishment. Yet the state of galut is not simply punishment and suffering, but chaos. Galut is the separation of spirit from matter.

In the situation of galut the goodness of the individual, or of the community, may well not be rewarded in immediate material terms. Sometimes the crops will grow, sometimes not. Even if they do grow, sometimes the enemy will capture them. There is constant uncertainty. Galut is a dislocation between matter and spirit, body and soul. Good people might be stricken with horrifying disease and pain; the wicked often seem to enjoy peace and prosperity.

On a deeper level, even in the state of galut there is a relationship between one's actions and the events which follow. Yet it is governed by an infinite Divine logic not completely accessible to our minds. To understand it we would have to be able to take into account spiritual realms, the world of souls. We would have to be able to appreciate certain processes in existence which have to unfold. If the full spiritual panorama were accessible to us, we would indeed see precise reward for each individual action. But this is not apparent in the physical world which we see before our eyes.

Yet the fact that we know that there is a deeper reality is itself a step forward. Although we are living in the world of galut so harshly depicted in the "Rebuke" outlined in Leviticus, a world in which the Holocaust could take place, we can be conscious that waiting beyond the shadows is another way to live, the world of Redemption. And in the closing verses of the Rebuke the Torah promises that Redemption is the state we should be in, and the one to which we will return.

Hence we should do what we can to help our practical daily world attain that state in which soul and body, spirit and matter, G-d and existence are one, unified. Every step in observance of Torah brings that realm of Redemption closer.

© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with's copyright policy.
1000 characters remaining
Email me when new comments are posted.
Sort By:
Discussion (5)
May 2, 2013
Redemption vs. Galut
Very important message, so beautifully explained. Thank you!
May 18, 2012
You mentioned the Holocaust. Holocaust survivors basically fall into 2 groups :

1. Lost belief in G-d

2. Increased belief in G-d.

I can't argue with any of them. I am not impressed by those who would. Walk a mile in their shoes and then you might have something to share.

It is only this minor point i am discussing. The overall article is really interesting and offers hope. Hope is an ultimate goal on Earth.

Good Shabbos !
May 17, 2012
Totally inadequate
The writer suggests,"we can be conscious that waiting beyond the shadows is another way to live, the world of Redemption. "
This is simply not true for everyone:
1. The Holocaust victims themselves -
murdered without any opportunity to gracefully "be conscious that waiting " etc.
2. the baby who suffers an agonising painfull brief life and dies without "can be conscious that waiting beyond the shadows is another way to live, the world of Redemption. " This and many other similar writings are grossly inadequate attempts to put a "palatable" spin on grotesque suffering. Does the writer have the audacity to suggest that the newborn infant has somehow failed to keep the covenant ("If you walk in My statutes")? Ony the individual can answer that question for themselves - do not dare to apply that judgement to 6 million Holocaust victims or newborn babies who die! The Rebbe was very clear on this - go read and learn. But even his writings fail to provide solace to the dead!
Avraham ben Rafael
San Diego, California
May 14, 2009
very inspiring and meaningful
Dear Rabbi,

very powerful and meaningful messages indeed.

toda rabba
May 27, 2005
Meaning and Chaos
Thank you for this excellent article. It helped me begin to understand the question why bad things happen to good people. It seems that the Shema reflects the same concept of unity vs chaos.
Ithaca, NY
This page in other languages