Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Weekly Torah (Parshah)
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Weekly Torah (Parshah) » Shemot - Exodus » Va'eira » Parshah Columnists » Parshah Moment » Two Rabbis One Shul
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment12 Comments

Parshah Moment
Two Rabbis One Shul


Sound like double trouble? Over-employment? The latest synagogue sitcom? Probably; but Jewish history is never probable.

We started that way. Moses could not, would not, lead alone; Aaron had to be there. Moses' older brother never was quite his associate rabbi. Aaron was vastly more popular. He was the nice guy: arbitrator in congregants' business disputes, mediator in spousal clashes, peacemaker in sisterly spats, and conciliator for anyone with a teenager at home. Mr. Nice.

Moses was more the patrician than the paternal. The teacher, not the counselor; the lawgiver, not the therapist. Mr. (sorry relativists and wannabe brides) Right.

Moses embodied truth; Aaron embraced peace. Truth demands integrity; peace requires compromise. Torah insists on both, hence a team was needed for the making of a people -- not an individual.

Moses rarely enjoyed public support; his method, leadership qualifications, and integrity were regularly challenged, and accusations of nepotism drained him. Aaron was rarely taken to task, and then only because of his association with you-know-who.

The brothers' dichotomy did not abate with their deaths; the turnout at Aaron's funeral nearly doubled Moses's. Not surprisingly, it was only upon Moses's passing that despair threatened the people. But while Aaron's popularity earned him a larger funeral, Moses's instruction earned him the role of leader. Aaron's passing evoked mourning; Moses's passing created a terrifying void. Leadership, like money, is appreciated when you don't have it.

We need our Aarons and we need our Moseses (including our intra-personal, internal ones). One without the other is unbalanced. If we favor the peace over truth because peace doesn't demand of us and truth does, we'll get neither. It might not play well in the sitcoms, but Jewish legacy is not a sitcom.

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment12 Comments

By Shimon Posner   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Shimon Posner is the director of Chabad of Rancho Mirage, California.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

12 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Jan 12, 2010
Excellent!
Looking forward to your next essay.
Posted By Rivki Hazan, Milan, Italy

Posted: Jan 3, 2008
Fabulous! Keep writing
Posted By Tay
via chabadhoboken.com

Posted: Jan 1, 2008
I'm coming around o thinking that the discipline required by observant Judaism is an essential component to a successful life, like Moses' leadership. I've always been attracted to the loving, soft, compassionate side of my religion- and felt I had a choice whether to do the rest. And I have tried keeping Kosher and dressing modestly all the time and even that little was very very hard. It involved putting my ego last- hour after hour , day after day. And for an ex-model, very involved in the secular world, who thrived on people's admiration for years, deliberately dressing to appear ten years older and twenty pounds heavier was a revelation. I did enjoy being able to relate to people not on the basis of looks, and getting to know some wonderful , incredibly wise religious people and a cultural tradition I had heretofore missed.
Posted By Anonymous, brooklyn, ny

Posted: Jan 1, 2008
peace vrs truth
This is an excellant way of explaining the difference between the two. Thank you for writing this. The fact that peace doesn't "demand" of us is a revelation to me. Now I see why so many cry "peace" when there is none! I am longing for peace but unwilling to sacrifice truth to get it.
Posted By Arielle, Bristol, TN/USA

Posted: Dec 31, 2007
Two Rabbis one Shul
Truth and integrity should always go together, at the same pace, at the same place, at the same moment, at the same situation, among the same people. If the contrary happens, neither peace nor truth would exist.
Thank you, Rabbi Posner, for this great story
Posted By Luisa Zitzer, Buenos Aires, Argentina

Posted: Jan 20, 2007
Re-reading the article
To the reader Natan,

The article wasn't discussing the Rebbe, or Misnagdim. It might be helpful to reread the article as well as the comment above yours, with a clear, open mind.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Jan 19, 2007
You need to get Rabbi Posner's point
How can you misinterpret this article and accuse the author of underestimating the greatness of Moishe Rabbeinu? On contrair. The point so eloquently brought out is that the job of a true Rebbe is extremely tough (unlike a king or ruler or president) and he needs to "stick to his guns" in spite of powerful elements trying to influence him.
It is said, that any Rebbe without 'misnagdim', is not a rebbe!
And yes, the Rebbe zt"l had many misnagdim from various elements, but he strongly kept his derech hakodesh, in spite of them all.
Thanks for the great article, and to Rabbi Posner's misnagdim<g>: Please reread the article.
Posted By Natan, Brooklyn, NY

Posted: Jan 17, 2007
Emanuel isn't the only one who felt the article was written in poor taste, and highly inappropriate.

I've enjoyed Chabad articles, until now. Other streams of Judaism have stooped to protraying the holiest people in ways that appeal to modern day pettiness; my mouth literally fell open when I saw this on Chabad. We get uncomfortable thinking of our holy leaders in our nation's history; it's a dissonance that refects on our much lower level, mine included.

But when we seek to interpret their lives through the prism of our own all too human natures, we have crossed a line of self pandering and "feel good" analysis.

We need to humble ourselves, and not "use" the Torah to fit into the themes we wish to write about. We can write good articles that work to develop a theme and position without resorting to analogies from our greatest people that arise solely from the imagination.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Jan 17, 2007
Distastefull? - True and to the point
I actually thought Rabbi Posner's way of simplifying a somewhat abstract idea of leadership and the different often complicated roles we each have to play, was brilliant. It makes so much sense and sits so well, that I laughed of satisfaction when I got to the end
Posted By Gary, Miami, FL

Posted: Jan 16, 2007
Perhaps Emanuel can explain what he found distastful?
Posted By Yossi, New Haven, CT



 


This Week's Torah Portion: Va'eira
Parshah Va'eira
Exodus 6:2-9:35
Text of Haftorah
 Parshah in a Nutshell
 Haftorah in a Nutshell
 Weekly Aliya Summary
 Text of Parshah with Rashi
 Parshah In Depth
 Kehot Chumash
 The Chassidic Masters
 Parshah Columnists
 Family Parshah
 Audio Classes
 Parshah Print Version (PDF)

 RSS Feed RSS Directory

Parshah Home » 


Other Parshas

Browse All Parshas