HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Weekly Torah (Parshah)
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Weekly Torah (Parshah) » Bereishit - Genesis » Noach » Parshah Columnists » What Do You Think? » Wrong Time for Building Legacies
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment9 Comments

What Do You Think?
Wrong Time for Building Legacies


Reality has just been turned upside down, the waters of the flood have erased all life off the face of the globe, and humanity has to start all over again.

This is not some apocalyptic terror film, but the story of the world after the Great Flood. Noah and his family were the only living people in the world, while every other person who had been living just one year earlier—including their neighbors, friends, enemies and everyone else—was gone.

When the flood gates closed, the waters settled, and the people emerged from the floating box, they quickly went ahead to rebuild civilization, having children, building homes, accumulating wealth, and just getting back to routine.

Why not, they thought, build a huge tower that will reach the sky?Not too long afterwards, they hit upon a wonderful idea. Why not, they thought, build a huge tower that will reach the sky? After all, we have the technology and the manpower! Let us build a legacy for ourselves! Let the future world know about how awesome we were!

The vote was unanimous to build the tower, and the people of Babel set out to make their dream a reality. Things started out smoothly, and they were making headway, when G‑d decided to put a stop to the project. He mixed up their languages, dispersed them all over the world, and turned some of them into apes1 (oh, so we are related . . .).

And you ask, what was the big deal? Why did G‑d react so angrily to such a harmless cause? Where did these visionaries go wrong? Could there be something wrong in wanting to build a legacy?

Yes! There was something very wrong.

Think about it, friends. The world had been destroyed, and now the society needed a lot of help. Children needed schools, places of worship needed to be built, traumas had yet to be settled . . . and all these people could think about was their legacy!

Who has time for building legacies when there is a hungry man next door? Was there nothing more important than building a tower, so that four thousand years later, when a scientist would excavate a site somewhere in Mesopotamia and find remains of a big tower, he or she would write in the history books that this was a strong and advanced nation?

How could they think of a legacy for the future, when the present needed so much help? And, for heaven’s sake, if they desperately desired to make a legacy, then at least they should have made something worthwhile! Why not open the world’s first hospital, make a beautiful house of worship, or build a school? Why, oh why, erect a pointless, unneeded tower?

And that question lingers for all time . . . 2

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment9 Comments
FOOTNOTES
1.

Midrash cited in Me’am Loez.

2.

Based on a talk of the Rebbe, published in Likkutei Sichot, vol. 3.


By Levi Avtzon   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Levi Avtzon lives in Johannesburg, South Africa, with his wife Chaya and their son Aharon. He regularly blogs his thoughts and ideas on the weekly Torah reading, current and past events, and the imminence of the Redemption on the Jewish website Chabad.org.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by our content partner, Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Oct 30, 2011
compare I sons
People do judge and decide that some professions are more worthy than others, which is truly judgmental. To look at life's diversity of professions, of what people do to earn a living, to also engage in personal joys, is to see we need everyone, and those who pick up the debris at the side of the roads, and who come to garden for those who do not have time, or work in the stores... well, we need them all.

These comparisons as mentioned above, by anonymous, are insidious and lead to problems such as a terrible erosion of self-esteem. We need to see everyone as valuable, and as doing a necessary job in a most complex society. Recognition of the other is very important. Creativity itself can reside anywhere, and one of the most creative people I know is my hair dresser. She's also the best therapist, and her sunny kind disposition makes having one's hair cut a joy.

We tend to place a value on some kinds of learning and doing over others, let it be, kindness and love wherever expressed.
Posted By ruth housman, marshfield hills, ma

Posted: Oct 28, 2011
good point ... why oh why
And i am always left wondering, why Noah is unfavourably compared to Abraham.

Why oh why do we need this comparison ? Human nature, loshon hora, a failure to see these two men in a proper context. But every year, up comes the comparison, a passion to denigrate.

My son is a world famous doctor. What is your son ?
Posted By Anonymous, w

Posted: Oct 26, 2011
Babel
When we speak of Babel today we speak of it in terms of a cacophony of words that do not make sense. There is in this Magazine an article on the Bible Code. Is there a Bible Code? Meaning depending on how one reads the letters, there could be inserted within the text of Torah, a story, new insights, names, something hidden which comes to light. This will be elucidated. Luce for light.

I feel we are "ABEL" to do many things with words, and that being whirred too, there is something of magic about language, and certainly the Hebrew letters, a Heady Brew.
Resh for head.

Perhaps even, in the words B'reshit, within, is a clue. I think it could be VAV, a palindrome, for six, six letters, containing AV, for Father. In the words of T.S. Eliot, his Four Quartets, the end circles beautifully back to the beginning.

The other day I heard a man being interviewed on NPR, who is a genius with palindromes. To follow a straight line: VAV.
To draw down the light. The Lulav. Sukkot. Simchas Torah.
Posted By ruth housman, marshfield hills, ma

Posted: Oct 26, 2011
Jason Schwadel
Good going, there fella.

No, it was not the hungry who decided to build the tower. Opens up a few doors...does it not?
Posted By Bonnie

Posted: Oct 26, 2011
To anonymous in Jerusalem: There may have been a 250 year break between the flood and the tower. However, in those 250 years, the people did nothing worth marking for eternity, nothing to record in the Torah. Their first major project was the tower and it wasn't a holy or healthy one.
And it's very true about our building efforts and the rebbe's vision post the holocaust flood.
Posted By mh, Brooklyn, NY

Posted: Oct 25, 2011
dor hafllaga
millions of dollars are being spent for space exploration while people are dying of diseases that do not have a cure yet-deja vu. Well put as usual and thank you for the naches
Posted By tante Malkie, Brooklyn, New York

Posted: Oct 25, 2011
Babel
It could be all of these things, and also more, because G_d is a Master Storyteller, and now the languages that were dispersed are coming together. I write about this. It could be the Storyteller knew, what we do not, and that soul lessons will be taught along the way, but the end of this story, before the sequel, of course, would be a new truth, a re examining of all stories, in a new light, because, there are powerful metaphoric connects running up and down all Creation. To read the same book years later, is to experience it differently. The Book of Life is a Book of Wonders.


Posted By ruth housman, marshfield hills, ma

Posted: Oct 25, 2011
Not too long after?
Without getting into the details, there are about 250 years between the flood and the building of the tower. Seems like a lengthy span of time.
Only after reading the Rebbe's original sichah did I understand that he was using this analysis to say something to the generation after our present-day "mabul"--the holocaust. The Rebbe was urging that building for the cause of erecting monuments is not enough, but should go hand in hand with deeper purpose, and according to the sichah that is places of learning.
I don't know if you can find a reference that would show that the Rebbe would approve of adding hospitals to the list.
Posted By Anonymous, Jerusalem

Posted: Oct 24, 2011
Timely
Your article brings up the question of who made the decision to build the tower. Did the hungry man decide? Probably not. Your argument speaks loudly to the present day.
Posted By Jason Schwadel, Indian harbourr beach, Fl



 


This Week's Torah Portion: Noach
Parshah Noach
Genesis 6:9-11:32
Text of Haftorah
 Parshah in a Nutshell
 Haftorah in a Nutshell
 Weekly Aliya Summary
 Text of Parshah with Rashi
 Parshah In Depth
 Kehot Chumash
 The Chassidic Masters
 Parshah Columnists
 Family Parshah
 Audio Classes
 Parshah Print Version (PDF)

 RSS Feed RSS Directory

Parshah Home » 


Other Parshas

Browse All Parshas