HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Weekly Torah (Parshah)
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Weekly Torah (Parshah) » Bamidbar - Numbers » Bamidbar » Parshah Columnists » More Parshah Articles » Who Cares How Many Reubenites There Were!
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment16 Comments

More Parshah Articles
Who Cares How Many Reubenites There Were!


Question:

It is that time of year again. We will be beginning the Book of Numbers, and during this week’s Torah reading in the synagogue we will hear verse after verse of numbers: 46,500 for the tribe of Reuben, 59,300 for the tribe of Simeon, and so on. Why the detailed counts of the Israelites? Who cares?

Response:

I have often wondered the same thing. What value is there in knowing exactly how many Reubenites there were at a specific time in our history? How is this even remotely relevant to me?

Here is a thought: In my neighborhood there lives an elderly lady who lost her husband a few years ago. She has been retired for years, and lives far from her children. Whenever I meet her in the grocery or on the street, the first thing she does is whip out her pictures of her grandkids. “You see that little boy?” she crows. “He goes to Hebrew school, and can read the prayer book like a pro.” Pulling another picture out of her wallet, she continues with delight, “And this young lady is almost finished high school, and she is going to Israel next year.” And on she goes.

I listen politely to her patter, smiling and nodding when it seems appropriate. To tell you the truth, I’m not really paying attention well enough to know when to smile and when to nod. One thing I do know, however, is that this woman truly adores her grandkids.

G‑d loves us dearly—each and every one of us. So He counts us, like one who counts precious diamonds. The numbers may not be terribly relevant to you or me, but they are very important to Him. After all, each number accumulated represents one of His beloved children. And every year, as we read these numbers in the synagogue, He listens again with delight.

Now that is relevant.

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment16 Comments

By Menachem Posner   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Menachem Posner is a member of the Chabad.org Ask the Rabbi team.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by our content partner, Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

16 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: June 1, 2011
To Roberta
You ask a very good question. Why were women not counted? I recommend that you have a look at Don't Women Count? by Chana Weisberg.
Posted By Menachem Posner for Chabad.org , Montreal, QC

Posted: May 27, 2011
Question on how to respond
This was my son's Bar Mitzvah parsha a year or 2 ago and in his Dvar Torah said something like this too. "He counted us because he loves us." which I thought was a beautiful thought. A friend was at the Bar Mitzvah and asked, then why were only the men counted - doesn't G-d love the women too?
Posted By Roberta, Fairfax, VA
via chabadva.org

Posted: May 26, 2011
Who cares how many...
That is our family. Most people know how many children and grandchildren they have. They know how many brothers, sisters, nieces and nephews. They know how many were in their parents families and sometimes their grandparents families. While it may take some time, they may be able to tell you how many first cousins (or an approximate number) they have. They might not have met each of these people or know their names, but they know how many.
Posted By Anonymous, Oak Park, MI

Posted: May 26, 2011
teammates
I am reading this Bamidbar post for the first time.

Your answer to the question is " Heartwarming " as noted above. We all count to Him.

The comment by R.Tzvi is also ispirational. The Rebbe was a phenom. We all counted to him too. To be at his enlightened level provides wondrous leadership for hundreds of thousands of followers, the Moses of his generation.

Good Shabbos !
Posted By Anonymous, w

Posted: May 26, 2011
Thank you Rabbi posner!
yes, there are many possible answers and the're all true and inspiring. But looking at Torah from a point of view of a book of life, a book of direction- this answer is by far the most relevant, i feel, to my personal service.
Thank you Rabbi Posner!!!
Posted By Anonymous, tzfat, israel

Posted: May 24, 2011
What a beautiful answer, Rabbi Posner. Thank you.
Posted By zeynep alangoya, istanbul

Posted: July 7, 2010
Math & Halacha
Don't forget that the census was a commandment for that generation. Each tribe in its own right comprised so and so many souls. Each number in Torah is significant. The entire Torah can be seen as an algorithm, since each letter is also a number. This is all part of the deeper dimension of Torah, and only becomes relevant when studied along with commitment to the Giver of Torah, through the halachic method.
Posted By Mor, Jerusalem, Judea

Posted: June 7, 2010
How many Ruebenites?
As a military history buff, why not think of a Shevet as a kind of "division" in a sense? It would be essential to know how many
"soldiers" you have.
Posted By michael pell, Los Angeles, CA/USA

Posted: May 20, 2010
nice work
I believe there is no problem giving a bit of constructive criticism to anyone.
The point of the article is well taken as the point of those who placed the comments.
This is the reason why I love the internet we can all learn from each other in such beautiful ways.
We are all human beings aspiring to follow in the footsteps of the great Rebbes.
Shalom
Posted By Nosson, Beijing

Posted: May 20, 2010
With all due respect to everyone involved, I think the writer was trying to make a point about detailed lists and loved ones.

And...

Wouldn't you think that most people speak to find empathy and not just to hear the sound of thier voices? One can usually tell if someone is listening or not.

I think the point is very clear and I appreciate the article. :)
Posted By Rebekah, near Chicago



 


This Week's Torah Portion: Bamidbar
Parshah Bamidbar
Numbers 1:1-4:20
Text of Haftorah
 Parshah in a Nutshell
 Haftorah in a Nutshell
 Weekly Aliya Summary
 Text of Parshah with Rashi
 Parshah In Depth
 The Chassidic Masters
 Parshah Columnists
 Family Parshah
 Audio Classes
 Parshah Print Version (PDF)

 RSS Feed RSS Directory

Parshah Home » 


Other Parshas

Browse All Parshas