HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Society & Living
 
Chabad.org » Society & Living » Current Events » News Archives » Tragedy in Mumbai » News » Mumbai Jewish Family Killed








  News   Personal Reflections   Sharing Memories   What Can I Do?   Video   Donate

UPDATE: Mumbai-Based Rabbi and Wife Killed in Terrorist Attacks



Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg, the beloved directors of Chabad-Lubavitch of Mumbai, were killed during one of the worst terrorist attacks to strike India in recent memory.

561 Comments Posted
Reader Comments
Posted: Nov 28, 2008
What a loss
I can't express how sad I was in finding this story. While their seemed to be no shortage of information, this one point hadn't yet been confirmed yet, and I held out some hope for the Rabbi and his wife.

My thoughts are with their families.
Posted By Avron, London, UK

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Filled with Sadness
Oy Vey, may G-d avenge their blood. I am filled with a terrible sadness. May the Holtzbergs memories only be for a blessing and may their families, and all of us, be comforted among the mourners of Zion and Jerusalem. May we merit the coming of Mashiach very soon.
Posted By Erica

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
baruch dayan haemes.
Posted By Anonymous, ny, usa

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
We mourn the loss of 2 bright stars
This is a loss for all of us. Blessed be their memory.
Posted By Boston

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
I'm so sorry for your loss
Dear family of Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg, and Rebbetzin Rivka Holtzberg, including dear sweet Moshe Tzvi,

I am so sorry for your loss and so sorry that these beautiful, giving individuals lost their lives. I feel close to the chabad family. My parents and I are less observant, but were immediately welcomed into a chabad shul over 20 yrs ago and pray there still.

May G-d bless your family with everything that you need to heal and go on. May Moshe's light continue to shine so bright, as I know your son and daughter's beautiful spirits live on in him

My deepest condolences,
Posted By Nechama (Nadine)

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Unarmed Jews baffle me
This is not news, this is old history. More dead unarmed Jews.
When I got married, everyone in the wedding party, including the Rabbi, had a concealed weapon.
Please learn from these and millions of our dead kin, arm yourselves!!!!
Posted By LOTAR, FTL, fl

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Painful
Perhaps these two souls agreed to leave here in order that many of us could live and return to G-d. G-d bless their holy souls...we should each take advantage of each day G-d blesses us with and use it for His will. May we be mercifully redeemed...
Posted By A Fellow Jew

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
No mercy from evil doers
May G-d speed Jews' salvation, Amen!
Posted By Norma, Brussels, Belgium

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
I'm So Sorry
Looking at Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg's faces you can see the hope and optimism radiating out from their faces. Maybe a final tribute to them would be for me to stare into their gaze, and somehow absorb the goodness in humanity which they expressed, and to have them help me in this time of such sadness and despair. I have a feeling that is what they would want. God bless them and take care of them, and give strength to their beloved child....
Posted By Barry, Danville (SF), California

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
May their memory be blessed
Last March, I was welcomed by the Rabbi and his wife for an entire shabbat as I was in Mumbai on a business trip.

They were the purest incarnation of selflessness, entirely dedicated to providing Jews of all horizons a home in Mumbai, a beacon of Jewish light.

I remember playing with their adorable son Moishe, the happiness and the warmth of their home. They made everybody feel comfortable, and their kindness had no limit.

G-d help their son, my thoughts and prayers go to their families.
Posted By Melanie, New York, NY

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
My sincere tears
G-d counts each precious tear that we shed for the holy martyrs. These two precious holy people, who gave up their lives during their lives for the good of our nation, will now be in the chamber of the famous Ten Martyrs. May G-d avenge their blood and may our tears and prayers and the holy blood of their sacrifice bring Moshiach now, Amen.
Posted By Chaim S., Brooklyn, NY/USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
May God Take Revenge on the Sons of Yishmoel
It must be a real emotional period for your Lubabitch Community, especially when one of youngest, purist and most innocent and beautiful children have been murdered in cold blood. Especially, when it occured immediatly after the Conference of Shiluchim.

May God, with the Rebbe at his side, look out for you all and bless your families, mutiply you and keep you stronger than ever on your mission of love and kindness.

Baruch Dayen Emes!
Posted By Anonymous, Brooklyn, NY

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Rescue was doomed from the start
We all mourn the loss of our fellow Jews in Mumbai. The rescue operation was so badly designed and performed that there was no chance of success. As a former Army NCO, I can say that if my men perfomed as the Indian troops did, I'd shoot them myself. And if they'd brought me a proposed ops plan like the one used, I'd transfer them to someplace they couldn't get anyone hurt, like postal clerk school.
Posted By Eliyahu

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
May their memory be for a blessing
Words fail me at this senseless tragedy.

May G-d avenge their blood and may our tears and prayers and the holy blood of their sacrifice bring Moshiach now, Amen.
Posted By Burtb, Irvine, ca

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
May G-d avenge their blood
Posted By Levi, Los Angeles, Ca.

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Be Strong Isreal.God is with us
Hello dear brothers and sisters. My heart cries out to the Living God of Isreal. My prayers are with all those who lost their loved ones and those who were in Mumbai. Be strong take courage and trust in the Lord. May God bless Isreal. Amen.
Posted By Isaac, visakhapatnam, A.P

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
condolences
I'm not even Jewish but my heart goes out to the family of this man who was just trying to share his beliefs with others in a non-violent way. The animals who did this, and those who share their beliefs, will pay for this.
Posted By Will, New York, NY

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
With much love
I send the most sincere love and light to the Rabbi and his Rivka on their travels to be with G-d.
My heart aches at the loss that their child must bear. May we hold all those lost in this tragedy in our hearts and pray for the lost souls who caused it.
Posted By Andrea, San Francisco, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
i grieve for Rabbi holtzberg and his wife rivka
me and my whole family are deeplty hurt upon hearing the deaths of rabbi gabi and his wife rivka, over the past two years they have been teaching my family the laws of orthodox judaism, we have learnt so much from them, and people like them are truly sent by G*D and come once in a lifetime, we also pray for moshe their beloved son that he has a wonderful future ahead of him, we share with u in grief the losses of rabbi holtzberg and his wife rivka.

shalom
Posted By Shmuel Ahron Avraham, Jewish convert from, mumbai, India

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
How they lived should be remembered
Let me add my thoughts and wishes for the their families and friends. May how they lived outshine the tragedy of how they died.
Posted By PJ, Atlanta, GA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Horrible news
Since I first read about the Rabbi, his wife and child, I've prayed that they would make it out alive. My condolences to not only their immediate family, but also to the many people who were part of their extended one.
Posted By CSW, Boston, MA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
RIP
Such a beautiful couple. My heart goes out to the Rabbi and his family. May your name live on forever and your sacrifice & dedication inspire others. G*d bless, little Moshe.
Posted By Victor R, Temecula, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Shining examples of compassion
Our heartfelt condolences to the family and Chabad community on the loss of Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg and his wife, Rebbetzin Rivka Holtzberg. Faith in G-d's wisdom and goodness will prevail over hate and senselessness.
Posted By The Gluzermans, palm springs, ca

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Tragic and Sad
I am familiar with the wonderful work of Chabad in Toronto, Canada. That they appear in all corners of the world to help the Jewish nation is so amazing and loving..

So the death of the Hotzbergs, such a giving and outstanding couple, is all the more tragic and cruel.

May their families find strength and faith at this time. My heartfelt sympathy to all who are suffering now from this act of terrorism. .

Shabat Shalom.
Posted By Esther, Toronto, Canada

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolences
My sincerest condolences to their families and the families of all who were victims of these execrable crimes. May all rest in peace and consolation soon come upon those who they leave behind, especially Gavriel and Rivka's little Moishe.
Posted By Hector C, McAllen, Texas

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Such devastating news
I am so very sorry to hear of the deaths of the Holtzbergs. They and their families, particularly their little boy, are in my thoughts and prayers. I have a little boy at home myself, so to imagine something like this...
Posted By John Grund, Portland, OR

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
my condolences
My family prays for the family and for all of you.

My hope is for justice to be brought to these butchers. Hopefully, my country's new presidential administration will be fully supportive of any actions needed, and be unwavering in it's support of Israel.
Posted By John Morris, gettysburg, Pa, USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
G*d's Children
My heart aches for the Holtzberg family. May their child be brought up with compassion and reconciliation in his heart. Bless the youngster's caregivers and know that G*d has the the Rabbi and Rebbetszin within his warm embrace.
Posted By Derek Davis, Rochester, NY, USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
This is totally devastating. We send our most sincere condolences to the Holtzberg family and pray for for the capture of these disgusting terrorist cowards. May G-d punish ALL those who hate Israel and ALL those who sympathize with these cowards! Amen.
Posted By The Medinas, McLean, VA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
I feel bad about their 2 year old son
Hi, I'm from Bangalore, India. I came here to mention that right now I'm feeling very bad for Moshe, the 2 year old son of the Holtzberg. It's not fair at all to inflict such a cruel wound on such an innocent life. I hope he finds peace with his grandparents in Israel and I hope Israel takes good care of him. Apologies and condolences on behalf of all Indians.
Posted By Karthik, Bangalore, India

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Deepest condolences
It is with deep sorrow that I convey my condolences to the Chabad House, and the Holtzberg family for the tragic loss of Rabbi and Rebetzin Holztbeg.
Our hearts and prayers go out to them as is our deep appreciation for their selfless work, care and compassion,
Posted By Alex Chelminsky and family, Newton, MA/USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolences
My deep sympaty and Condolences are with Chabad family all over the world . the victim families and the orpen son .
the rabi and his wife gave the ulimate price their life for the Love of G-D
my their soul will rest in peace .
ת.נ.צ.ב.ה
Posted By Yeret Family , Israel

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
A True Loss
Our condolences and prayers are with you.
Posted By Craig, Tyler, Texas

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
condolences
Sincerest condolences from Helsinki Finland
Posted By Michael Hulden, Finland

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolences
Our heartfelt condolences to the family and Chabad community.

As a fellow indian, i am sorry. Indians are going to avenge this. 1 billion people are going to avenge this we promise.
Posted By John, Delhi, India

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
It's so sad
In what kind of world do we live, how do these things happen and why?

We will never understand how people do bad things without thinking about it.

It's sad to see this and how are our brothers are suffering.
Posted By Henry Pesatty, Aventura (Miami), FL

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Blessed is the True Judge
ברוך דיין האמת

May Hashem avenge their blood, and may He comfort the mourners of Zion and Jerusalem, and redeem us speedily in our days, amen.

Shabbat shalom.
Posted By Avital, US

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolences
Our sincere condolences to the family and community of Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg and his wife Rebbetzin Rivka Holtzberg. We extend our hearts to you today and to their son and his grandparents. We join you in choosing light to fill the darkness, oh that we could learn ourselves to do this.
Posted By Jones family, Hesperia, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Mumbai tragedy
Sincerest sympathies to the Holtzbergs, especially their poor wee son, Moshe, and to all their relatives, friends and colleagues. The world does not need this; all religions should tolerate each other.
From a Gentile in UK.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
more than 2 victims
while the writers must be congratulated for this thoughful accout, i'm deeply disappointed that they failed to mention even in passing any of the other jews who were killed in the Chabad House. Religious or not, Chabad or other, Israeli or American, they all were Jews, and should be equally mourned after their tragic death.
Posted By Anonymous, boston , ma

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
may G-d bless their souls may this tragecic event remind us once more to unite as fellow jews and continue to study torah and do mitzvas. As every jewish mother and daughter around the world light candles this sundown may we look at our spiritual flame and be reminded that we are G-d's chosen one and we will serve him forever, may moshiach come speedily.

shabbat shalom
Posted By brigitte pomarlen wayne nj

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
To Rebbe Gavi and Rivka 's Family and Friends
My heart mourns with you, the loss of your dear children. I am aghast at what has happened in Mumbai.
I respect all of the Rebbe's and their wives who lead the Chabad- I am a Christian woman from Canada- but my daughter in Israel converted Orthodox (Lubavitch) to marry a man from Israel. I was honored that she did this and Chabad was so very good to me there in Vancouver.
A community that welcomes and teaches- your son and daughter have , then, made many memories for the people around them and have left their mark on the world.
I will pray for you all-know that there are people as far away as I am that care about you and your small grandson. And may your children, of blessed memory, rest in peace. With Love,
Posted By Gayle Pard, Edmonton, Canada

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
chabad
anyone who has ever interacted with chabad knows that these people live to give like no others i have ever known. their purity of spirit shines in their eyes, they don't judge you or preach to you they are simply there for you when you need it most.
may their son be blessed and live a life of joy, and may they rest peacefully.
the madmen who perpetrated this deed remind us all that as Jew's we need to be vigilant!
shalom
Posted By david, santa cruz, ca
via chabadbythesea.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
prayers
May he comfort you with all Israel morners
Posted By Daniel Klutstein, Wainae, HI

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolences
I´m neither Indian nor Jew, but my heart is feeled with saddness and sorrow....My heart is with their son and family...and pray that we can find some confort, amen
Posted By Ana Curado, Brazil

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
terrible terrible terrible
we mourn this terrible loss and pray for the family and the world as it is
G-d help everyone
Posted By Zach, New York, New York

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Chabad,
As someone who has been shown much friendship and kindness in the past by the Lubavitch family.

Please, be not afraid.

Many blessings
Posted By Karl Yehuda Ben-Jedi

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Murder in Mumbai
What was the "reason" given by the murderers for their crimes? I know- we all know- that there is no valid logical or religious reason for murder. But it might help to know what the murderers' stated reason(s) was/were.

May G-d's peace protect the victims' son, and receive the victims' souls.
Posted By Anonymous, Indianapolis, IN, USA
via lubavitchindiana.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolences
My prayers and sympathies go out to the rabbi, his wife, his family, and his friends. I have seen the great work of many rabbis and i am sure he just as good or better. I may have not known him, but for every jew that has their life taken, a part of me is also taken. Love to all.
Posted By Greg, Fort Lee, NJ

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Our Deepest Sympathy
I just read of this tragic and senseless act upon your brother and sister. We are very sorry to hear of your great loss. We offer our prayers to you and our support. We're new to the Chabad since the High Holidays, but appreciated your warm services and your community-minded spirit. May g-d's hand go out to you and give you strength in your hour of need.
Posted By Helene , Pikesville, Md.
via chabadom.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Sadness & hope
I too am saddened by the loss of the Chabad rabbi and wife in India. It is a terrible tragedy, and few could be as innocent as the great people of Chabad.

It is, however, heartening, to see that in the midst of a situation where it would be so easy to answer hate with hate, the expressions here are of sorrow, not calls for revenge. Not expressions of hate. It makes me think that despite the horrors of individual deaths, the spirit of life will win in the end.
Posted By Mykel Board, New York, NY
via chabadot.org

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Tanchumim to their families and the chabad family
May G-d avenge their blood.

May G-d keep safe all the Chabad emissaries, our brothers, all over the world and their families.

May G-d keep safe and strong 2 yr-old Moshe, their son.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Wishing the families long life
Watching events unfold in India I am numb with disbelief. The murders of so many people, the orphaning of at least one child. I struggle to believe that G-d takes the good and leaves the bad. What justice is served by this? Rebbe Gavi and Rivka sound such expectional people that I can't belive that their work was finished. I only hope that their families can take some comfort from their lives. I am sure that the amazing community of the Lubavitch will help in easing some of their pain. But are we back to the days of being scared because we are jewish. I pray not. My thoughts and prayers are with us all in these dark times.
Posted By Anonymous, london, UK

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
condolences
my condolences to the family of rabbi holtzberg & his wife, rivka, as well as to the chabad community. what a tragedy to lose two persons committed to helping others. my thoughts and prayers are with you. may their memories be honored.
Posted By Sarah, ellicott city, md

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
My heart is breaking with pain and am filled with deep tears by this tragic occurence.
Please god bring comfort to the rabbi and his wife's families and may their son be blessed with comfort , love and the knowledge that he is not alone...we are the nation of Israel, we cry together and we will stand together again!!
Posted By caryn koster, new york, NYC
via chabadic.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Sadness
Over the past few years I have come to know the Chabad movement, after moving from a richly Jewish area of the US to Texas. My initial trepidations have been quashed, not by bible thumping; rather through unending LOVE which Chabad has shown to not only Jews but to the rest of the world. Today, the world has decided to repay that kindness. Again, I turn to Chabad for solace, and am relieved to read the statements are not the emotional knee jerks I have felt; they are in fact utter LOVE for fellow Jew and man. If all of us can emulate only a fraction of Chabad, the world will surely be a better place.
Posted By Anonymous, Houston, TX

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Heartfelt sympathy
I was so shocked and saddened to hear about this tragedy. My prayers go out to their families. I lost my brother this February and Chabad was there for us to help us cope with our tragedy. If it wasn't for the people of Chabad and all the good that they do I don't know how my family would have coped. g-d bless Chabad and all the good they do for all the people they help and may Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg rest in peace and thank you both for all the good work you did again rest in peace.
Posted By Susan, Encino, USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Murder
This is tradegy beyond proportions.
This hits us deep in our hearts and souls and our prayers go out to their families.
A sad day in the life of every Jew.
Posted By Gary R FInder, Encino, CA
via chabadofthevalley.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Grief We Share
I cannot believe the tragedy of this event. I pray for their families and for us all as a people. I cannot even fathom what I'd do if I lost my rabbi and his wife, they are a cornerstone to our existance and continuance. God bless them and all who lost their lives in this unthinkable violence. May we one day find peace.
Posted By Anonymous, Los Angeles, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Sadness
My deepest condolences to the families of Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg and Rebbetzin Rivka Holtzberg; and the community of friends that loved them. This is a tragedy.

I hope that their son's life will be filled with good health and he is surrounded always by loving people.
Posted By Deborah

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolences
Please accept my condolences on the loss of those wonderful people. The work continues as a tribute to them.
Posted By Karen, Bronx, , NY/USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Terrorist Pic
Pease take the nasty picture of the terrorist out of the article, there is no need to have his picture on the same page as this beautiful couple.
Posted By Evelyn, Santa Cruz, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Deepest condolences to the Holtzberg family
To the whole Chabad family:

I send you my deepest condolences on the barbaric slaughter of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg in Mumbai, India. I pray for your orphaned two year old son Moshe. I will not forget him, and I will not forget you either.

My heart goes out to your family in this time of horror and sorrow for the whole Jewish nation. The slaughter marks a loss for the whole Jewish nation. I stand with you in solidarity as a fellow Jew in mourning along with you.

With deepest sympathy,
Posted By Rebecca Witonsky

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Of blessed memory...
All of my prayers are with the families of all the innocent who lost their lives so needlessly. What a terrible tragedy. My prayers go out for their small son. My prayers go out to the entire community. What can one say in the face of such a tragedy? Jews all around the world will light their Shabbat candles tonight with heavy hearts...but we will light them. And we will remember them. And we will go on.
Posted By Leah , Norwich, CT

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
CONDOLENCES
Kindly add a prayer for me
Thank you
Posted By law ed, NYC, USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Please don't just give us news. Tell us something, not to comfort us, but to reassure us.
Posted By Rina, LA, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
My condolance to the family of the slains
We in India sheltered the Jews and never prosecuted them while they faced horrors in the rest of the world. But today I feel bad that we could not be good host and save our guests from these monsters. A guest to us is like God and these terrorist went after the tourists knowing fully well that it could hurt the pride of any self respecting Indian.
Being a mother of two year old son, my heart bleeds for the little orphan child.
Posted By Chaitali, Kolkata, India

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
God bless you all
While I too am Christian, I am praying for your lost members (and all others lost in this terrible incident) and their mission in India which seemed to be doing such positive things. I hope that their son finds a new home with relatives and with an appreciation for his parents' sacrifice, a clear path to his destiny.
Posted By Anonymous, Brockville, Canada

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
יהי זיכרם ברוך
נשמתם עדן צרורה בצרור החיים עים שאר אחינו בית ישראל כאב לב ממש
Posted By פנחס, מונטריאל

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Why are prayer unanswered?
Why were our prayers unanswered? Why does a two year old have to celebrate his birthday tonight as an orphan?
Why do such people, committed to goodness, have to go so early?
When people like that are taken away, it is not only a boy who looses his parents, parents who are loosing their children, or siblings loosing their siblings. It is a loss for the whole world.
Our heart is with their family, specially Moshe.
Posted By Anonymous
via chabadflamingo.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
The Holtzbergs
I am not Jewish, but a Christian in Oklahoma. My heart grieves for the families of Rabbi and his wife, Rivka, who gave their lives for others.
I pray for the chabad community, and all who were touched by the Holtzbergs, and especially for their precious son. Their legacy will live on in him and in the accomplishments they made in their work.
Posted By Sherydee, Perry, Ok

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
with love
My heart breaks for the youth who have died, serving Judaism.
They have lived and died in peace and innocence.
Posted By sue, Kanata, ON

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Gavriel and Rivka and Moshe Holtzberg
The person who left the first comment has said all that I am feeling as the tears roll down my cheeks. I know we aren't supposed to mourn on Shabbat but how can we not cry for this innocent child's loss of his beloved parents and for his grandparents loss of their beloved children. Life and sometimes death are such mysteries.
Posted By Ethel Schwartz Bock, New York, NY
via chabadbriarcliff.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Again such a dark day...
I'm deeply shocked what happened in Mumbai.
Chabad showed me what it means being Jewish...Chabad gave me so much and in today's world we know that terrorism exist, that people were killed who haven't done anything to anybody else....I was shocked after the first breaking news....and thought that this is another small terrorist attack....but now?
I don't know what I should say...but my thoughts and prayers are with Rebbe Gavi's family, the Chabad movement worldwide and the people who lost their beloved ones in the Mumbai massacre. And I still pray and hope that the people some day live in peace....together. Shabbat Shalom...we need it!
Posted By Kay, Strausberg, Germany
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Terrible Loss
My prayers go out to the young boy Moshe and the family of this young couple. They looked like such nice people, trying to do good things for people. India is such a warm, friendly country that invites people of all backgrounds and religions. It is such a shame that this violent, unprovoked attack happened in such a peaceful country as India.
Posted By Dan, Rockville, MD
via chabadalexandria.org

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Thoughts and Prayers from Michigan
During our Thanksgiving Day we prayed for the best. We are devastated to hear of this outcome. We send our love and condolences to the families involved and the entire Jewish community.
Posted By Eden

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
baruch dayin haemet
it brings me to tears to hear what happened. a man and his wife committed to judaism and trying to bring more people to the religion have to die like this. as much as it pains me to hear that they have passed on, it makes me happy to know that they died because they would not stop standing up for G-d and for the rest of the jewish people. May G-d bless them in heaven. Let's just hope that the moshiach comes soon and brings us out of this terrible mess. My thoughts and prayers are with the Holtzberg family.
Posted By Joshua Goot, Ocean, New Jersey

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Indian
I am Indian. I am so sorry we could not protect you against these animals.
Posted By Rajesh

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
I am overwhelmed with grief for the entire family and all of Israel. My praying this Shobbos will be with all of you in my mind and heart. This was a the ultimate sacrifice for these two wonderful Shluchim in a very scary world. Their souls are surely in Gan Edan for eternity. We pray for Mochiach NOW so that we will all be reunited with our loved ones!
Posted By Anonymous, S. Paul, MN/USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
committed to goodness
Why is it that a couple who are just doing good in this world are cut down like weeds without any thought. All these animals did was to kill a little bit of us all.
Posted By coatesmoe, Fischbaachtal, Germany

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Shocked
I am shocked to see that Rabbi and his wife are killed.I pray to G-D that their child has a good future and be blessed.

We Indians will take revenge for their death.

We will not leave terrorists who killed innocent and good people like Rabbi and his wife.Persons behind the attack will pay price for this.
Posted By Prakash, India

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
I Wonder
I wonder what kind of religion is the one that teaches people such hatred of "infidels"...This poor family was doing nothing bad,and they were murdered just because they were jews!
It doesn't even seem the murderers and the victims believe in the same God,considered their opposite way of serving Him!
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
SAD DAY
The loss of the Holtzbergs feel like the loss of our own family members. We need so many more people like them.
I am sure we all feel that way today. Such acts of pure evil, hurt the entire Jewish people, we all feel like a little part of us, died with them as well...
Somehow we are all related, especially when awful events target some of us...
The Holtzbergs family, their little boy and all the other victims.
Let's not be angry at all Muslims, because of the acts of some who do not even realize they are making all the other Muslims look so bad.
It would be unfair and we will not be better than the terrorists.As Jews, we know better.
We all have to concentrate now, in becoming better people. We owe this to Rabbi Holtzberg, his wife Rivka and all their friends...
Let's all enjoy this coming Shabbat, the best way we can during this painful day.
For them....
Posted By Muriel Salengros & Yossi Kassap, FAIRBANKS, ALASKA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Could it be?
Could it be that we Jews as a people have sinned against G-d’s commandment that we were to be a Nation? Not a Diaspora, but a Nation. Have we become not only disparate, that by G-d’s command we are now desperate?

Have we forsaken a command we did not understand? Should we all be in Israel? I do not know, but what I do know is that we are being murdered by the very people who live not by G-d’s words.

Where do we go from here? We pray, of course, but is that enough when we see this ravenous creature destroying us handful by handful? What have we done except (as 1/4th of 1% of the human race) given science, peace, philosophy, Nobel Prizes and love to the world in a proportion far greater than our numbers?

All Jews cannot move to Israel. We have work to do elsewhere. But our survival is at stake, and as G-d has promised us, we will flourish in the land He promised us. Let us not only pray for His help, but fight as He has commanded us so many times before.
Posted By Reuven Levi, Phoenixville, Pa.
via jewishchestercounty.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
My deepest sympathy
My heart is heavy with the news. Surely they will live on in Moshe. Bless him.
Posted By Anonymous, washington, dc

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Candles
I never light Shabbat candles, but I will light them tonight. It breaks my heart to see the photographs of that young couple.
Posted By Anonymous, Long Beach, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
tragedy
I would like to know why there was absolutely no security at site where the terrorist caused the death of the Rabbi his wife and 5 Israelis? if there had been security the terrorists might not have struck there or been so successful. I want to know what chabad is going to do in future about all there other locations outside of united States and Israel about putting security in place in form of metal detectors and armed guards. The time to do this is now before G-D forbid it happens again.
Posted By M. Gerald fried, Skokie, il USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
G-D Bless little Moshe
Even as a student of Kabbalah I am numb and at a complete loss over this atrocious and senseless slaughter. I too prayed and scanned last night for the Holtzbergs; and I am trying hard to understand while all of our prayers went unanswered. But I am certain that we have to continue forward on this path, and not let this derail us from purging chaos from the world. May little Moshe still celebrate his birthday, and always feel his parents right there with him.
Posted By Anonymous, New York, NY

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
The religion of peace strikes again.
Posted By Brandon, Il,USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolences
I extend my heartfelt condolences to the families of Rabbi and Rivka Holtzberg. Every time I look at the pictures of this sweet, gentle couple, and their baby, I break into tears. However, it's clear that they were greatly loved and will not be forgotten.
Posted By Asher

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolance
I have big heart for Israel. I have lived there and I know the Jewish people. I am very sad about this incident. My heartfelt condolence to the rabbi’s family. I am sure god will bless Mosha with lot of blessings.
Posted By Alwyn Noronha, mangalore, INDIA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
So Sad.
I have a 2yr old baby girl. I think of how strong my wife's and my love is for her. I am sure their love was equally strong for Moshe. He needs to be told that every day and I am sure he will. I am not of any denomination - however I am very spiritual. Our prayers are with the entire family and everyone in the community and world affected by this tragedy. I can't imagine anything worse happening to such good people. My heart TRULY feels like there has been a hole put in it from this story. Stay strong. I know this is not the time and place but I am outraged by this. I know it is anger and violence that caused this so I try to bury it; yet I am only human. I am SO sad for everyone involved.
Posted By Anonymous, Phoenix, AZ

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Deepst Sympathies
As a Christian, I wish to extend my deepest sympathies and prayers for the Hotlzberg family and all who loved them. May God grant them eternal peace and provide their child with the grace and love to know happiness despite this dreadful atrocity.

May all people of faith, goodwill, and compassion join in solemn covenant to stand against such mindless barbarity and sinful crulety. May the memory of the Holtzbergs and other martyrs inspire them to determined courage to resist hatred and violence.

The only power that can overcome the depth of human sin, as the height of divine grace and justice. Masy we all become vessels of thst grace.

Shalom
Posted By Rev. Robert Morwell, Quincy, IL

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Sincere sympathy
My condolences to the two surviving children, and all the family and friends of these good people, who were senselessly taken from this world. I find it impossible to forgive the barbarians who commited this atrocity. May God watch over these little boys.
Posted By Anonymous, Catskill, NY, USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Our Tefilos Are With Your Family
We are all so saddened by this horrible tragedy to your family. We know the work they accomplished and their dedication to the Jewish Nation. May their children grow to emulate their parents and may you know no more sorrow and be comforted by the mourners of Zion and Yerushalyim.
Posted By David & Rachel Joseph, Valley Village, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
The Ultimate Sacrifice
My condolences go out to these two strong individuals who their faith ahead of themselves. My heart is filled with grief and my heart goes out to all affected.
Posted By Anonymous, Mount Kisco, NY

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Murder in India
My most heartfelt sympathies to the family of the slain Rabbi and his wife.
There are no words to describe the outrage felt at this terrible loss.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Rabbi & Mrs. Holtzberg
To the family of these wonderful and kind brave souls, please take comfort in the fact that your family memebers made a difference in other peoples lifes. Please remember to share this with their 2 young children when they are old enough to understand. May G-d bless and comfort you during this time. Shabbat Shalom
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
all prayers are with you
As always my prayers are with Moshe..May he know how great his mom was
Posted By Anonymous, New York, United States
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Fallen Soldiers
A beautiful couple, they stood in the lines at the front of the war, with a message of peace and the desire to bring their message to all who seek. It was a sacrifice they knowingly made, from their hearts and souls and they know our gratitude. The survival of the smallest is a victory, light in the darkness. They shall live on through him, and he will be blessed.
Posted By Sarah, US

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
my deepest condolences
My heart broke when I heard the news...

I grew up in Baltimore, Md... When I was twelve years old, my mom began the journey of becoming an Orthodox Jew. The local Chabad embraced my mom's journey and today she is happily remarried, living in the orthodox community, and continues to live her life by the example she was taught; from the local chabad, her first rabbi and the incredible warmth of the Jewish community. I mourn today, not only because a beautiful Jewish couple was taken to soon; but because the mission of the chabad community truly changes peoples lives for the better. A bright light has burnt out today... My deepest condolences to the family and to the entire Jewish community
Posted By chava Shapiro, san diego, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
A Note
It's extremely difficult to look at this couple and not shed some tears. How innocent and beautiful they look together. One day and I pray very soon the governments in this world will destroy these terrorists everywhere and anywhere they live. Why they haven't done so yet is unbelieveable!
Posted By Ray, NY, NY

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
ברוך דיין האמת
ברוך דיין האמת
Posted By Anonymous, Revelstoke, Canada

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolences
Dear Chabad community,

I am so sorry for your loss, and even though I am not from your faith, its very sad to hear about this tragedy that happened to a religious leader. I am Muslim, and I am upset, embarrassed, and confused as to why these cowards are calling themselves Muslim.

I am praying for this community to heal, for his families success, and for peace on Earth.
Posted By Anonymous, Washington, DC

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
May their loss hasten the Era of Redemption
It's a modern day tragedy that both Giby and Rivky deaths are needed to clarify and enhance expression to our most basic feeling of Jewish identiy and its importance to us as a people.
Posted By Randy Emet Turrow, Malibu, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Prayers
My prayers for the beautiful Rivka Holtzberg
Posted By Sloan Bledvic

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Time to beef up security
Time to beef up security at Chabad houses in all countries.
Posted By Gershon Wolf, Rocky Point, NY

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
My Condolences and Prayers
My thoughts and prayers are with you all, especially little Moshe and his family and friends. My prayers also for his nanny. Bless her.
Posted By Maggie Goff, Bisbee, AZ

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Condolences
I am so sorry for your loss. We are grieving with you.
Posted By PinkMuslimah

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Murder of innocents
I am a British Anglican and wish to offer my sincere condolences for the theft of these innocent lives. The world needs to understand that people like this Rabbi and his family don't just give to people of their own faith: they provide something beautiful to the whole world, because they give of themselves without self. I am so saddened and angry by what happened in Mumbai and promise my prayers and my continuing support for Israel and Jews everywhere. Peace be with you all.
Posted By Anonymous, Cambridge, UK

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
My heart aches in response to this tragedy. I offer my condolences to the family of Gavriel and Rivka. The loss suffered by their two children is immeasurable; I hope that one day, knowledge of their parents' good works and productive lives will provide some comfort and be the source of pride. The senseless brutality of those who committed these attrocities is impossible to understand. But talk of revenge and acts of revenge simply perpetuate this horror. People of good will, regardless of religion or nationality, should join together to fight terrorism in more productive ways. --
Posted By Estie, Los Angeles., Los Angeles, CA
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
God Knows
We should to remember that only God knows and sees everything. Our prayers are with their families.
Posted By Ana, Porto Velho, Brazil

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Hard to believe these two beautiful people were murdered for their religion. Stop the violence! Hated never ceases by hated but by love alone is healed...
Posted By Carly
via westvillechabad.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
There is no name for such a brutal and criminal act. I hope the relatives will find some consolation and take care of the baby who deserves all the best in this world.
Posted By Anonymous, San José, Costa Rica

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
FEAR NOT! My Jewish brothers and sisters!
"Be strong and courageous! Neither fear, nor be dismayed of them, for the Lord, your God He is the One Who goes with you. He will neither fail you, nor forsake you."
Any weapon whetted against you shall not succeed, and any tongue that contends with you in judgment, you shall condemn; this is the heritage of the servants of the Lord and their due reward from Me, says the Lord. He has told you, O man, what is good, and what the Lord demands of you; but to do justice, to love loving-kindness, and to walk discreetly with your God!
MOSHIACH NOW!
Posted By Aaron Shemper, Memphis, Tn/USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg
Such a terrible tragedy to the families of Gavriel and Rivkah!! All news accounts indicate that they were both very special and accomplished much in their short lives. It is just such a heart-breaking time for even those of us who did not have the honor of knowing them. They obviously were doing God's work in the service to so amny others.

Although I am, also Jewish, their families should know that millioins of people of all faiths are deeply saddened by their passing and the world has lost two very special people.

May they rest in peace and may their memory live on for eternity.

In deepest sympathy,
Posted By Bobbie Knauer, Sunrise, Florida
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Peace to You
I am truly sorry for your loss. Tonight I watched members of your community speak on our local news about Rabbi Holtzberg. Their stories were encouraging despite the awful circumstances in which Rabbi Holtzberg and his wife passed.
Posted By Nancy, St. Louis, USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
With sadness in my heart
My heart breaks for the loss of such dedicated and loving young people.. A young family with hope and so much to give were taken away from the world, a world that so obviously loved and appreciated them. A world that needs their energy. I looked at their faces and felt that anyone would have been blessed who had the fortune to be in their presence.
My heart breaks for their child, and for their community of family, friends. As Jewish woman this loss affects us all, whether a member of Chabad or not.
May their spirit in life be a reminder to us all to give unselfishly in a cause that gives to our world.
Posted By Devorah, Pittstown, NJ

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
carry on.
nice people going about their everyday life, never expect the worst horrors.
May their legacy make the community stronger.
Posted By Ivan., Japan.

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
I write this as a mother of a toddler just like Moshe, may God wrap you in his love and give you peace and strength to go on and may those who care for you gain strength and peace in their journey. The world weeps with you and prays for you. God bless you all now and always.
Posted By Mwikali, Kenya

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
God Bless
We need to look at this in a positive light. Yes, it is sad what happened to the Rabbi and his lovely wife but look at all the positve things they have done and will live on forever. The child is not orphaned. He has a wonderful family. The childs parents lives through a magnificent legacy they have left behind for the child. This child will continue the legacy once this child grows to be a strong, young, man.
Posted By Anonymous, Irvine, Ca

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Our sincerest condolences
May G-d hold the loved ones who are left behind, a bit closer to His heart during this terrible time. Our prayers go out for the vicitms and their loved ones.
Posted By Anonynous, Long Island, New York

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Sadness
My heart goes out to the families of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg at the loss of two precious people doing such mizvahs. I think about their two-year-old son, Moshe, and think of what he faces.
I have tears; and my heart breaks. I cry out to G-d: When will all this madness end?
Posted By Perry J Greenbaum, Montreal, Canada

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
So sorry
I am so so sorry. That is all I can say through my tears.
Posted By Anonymous, Oakland, CA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Faith
...it is events such as this that truly baffle the mind and ensnare the spirit.

We will never know the reasons "why" things like this happen, but we simply must keep the faith that G-d has a plan... that there is some sort of reason. We must simply accept the fact that we will never truly know.

Much love from Cincinnati, Ohio (where our own Chabad house is filled loving people who are pure of spirit and strong in their resolve).

We will remember all the people in the Mumbai Chabad house who have been lost... if they are anything close to our local Chabad house then they will certainly be deeply missed by all who knew them.
Posted By Adrienne Davidson, Cincinnati, OH
via jewish-discovery.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
A terrible loss
The world lost two beautiful and pure people today. I am saddened by this heartless act of hate. May God Bless their son, Moshe. Brothers and Sisters,we must learn from this as a world. We must come together as Jews and Gentiles. This is only the beginning.
Posted By Lucy, CT

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Rest in Peace
My sincere condolences to the families who lost their loved ones in the Mumbai Attacks. I cannot even begin to imagine how difficult it must be for you at this difficult times. My heart goes out to the young one left behind. I am so sorry
Posted By Nicky

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
The Senselss Deaths
My condolences to the family and to the community. It is a sad day for all of humanity.

We must be thankful for small mercies: that the cook/nanny had the frame of mind to escape with the young infant is nothing short of a micricle. She should be applauded and thanked for her heroic effort - what a lady! I can only hope that his parents knew that he was safe. At least it would have brought some solace to them, knowing that should they not live, their son will...and indeed he will.

What a sad place we are at this time - we should be able to live and let other live. We should be celebrating life, not inflicting death - what sad creatures those terrorists are!
Posted By Kowlasar Misir, Edmonton, Canada

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Senseless Violence
I'm Indian and it breaks my heart to see such senseless violence by such cowards occuring in Mumbai. India is a very diverse, peaceful and tolerant country.

Sad that innocent people have to die.

My prayers go out to Moshe. I wish nothing but good things for him. And bless his nanny for saving him.
Posted By anonymous, cerritos, ca

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Prayers
It is hard to understand what compels some people to participate in unspeakable evil, and what compels others to serve others in the name of God. The Holtzbergs served God and their only concern was to help others. They died in that pursuit. I hope that their children's grief as they grow to adulthood will be tempered by that knowledge. I am a Christian, but am constantly awed by people like the Holzbergs who sacrifice so greatly for others. May God hold them close to Him.
Posted By Anonymous, Boston, MA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
God is One
God is One. How is it we cannot see this and live in peace? Sincere sympathy to the Rosenberg and Hloltzberg families. Theirs were such beautiful children.
Posted By anonymous, USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
I Grieve Over the Murders of the Holtzbergs
Honourable Friends, I read with horror and sorrow over the murders of Rabbi Holtzberg and his lovely Wife. Although, not Jewish, I weep to read over the loss of the lives of this loving, compassionate couple who dedicated their lives, and, finally, offered up the ultimate sacrifice, for the sake of their Faith. Although not Jewish, but a Russian Orthodox Christian myself, I have been blessed with many loving Jewish friends, friends who have stood beside me in my personal joys and sorrows since we were children together in Japan, having all been either raised or both born and raised, in that beautiful land.

My profound condolences to all of the Chabad Lubavictch Community, and to the family and loved ones of the Holtzbergs. My especial thoughts and prayers go to their precious little Boy, who, thankfully, survived this horror, but who has lost his beloved Father and Mother.
Posted By Serafim Evgenievich Yusupov, Taipei, Taiwan

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
what can I say?
I am a Hindu native of Bombay, married into a Jewish family and now living in the U.S. My second son will have his Bar Mitzvah next year. I have watched my beautiful city in flames and have heard news of relatives of friends, who have been killed in these attacks.

what can I say?
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Common Enemies
First of all my heartfelt condolences to the deceased family in Mumbai.

Secondly, my apologies to all the Jews worldwide that our commando's couldn’t save your people.

I am a Hindu and for a hindu our guests are like gods, forget killing we dont even think to insult our guests. My heart weeps out for your people more than indians. I am feeling like criminal.

Now is the time for action...India , US and Israel have common enemies...the fundamentalist Islamic terrorist who live in fools paradise and think they will be able to rule this world one day.

God is great and shall deliver justice to these foolish Islamic terrorist.

"Forgiving a terrorist should be left to god, but fixing their appointment with god is our responsibility " SO never shun this responsibility.
Posted By Rajeev, New Delhi, India

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Murder at the Chabad
To John in Delhi, India:

We share your grief and outrage and we're counting on your people to keep that promise to help completely destroy this global metastasized cancer, John.
Posted By David and Nancy , West Hempstead, New York 11580
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
I Grieve Also over the Others Murdered
I also grieve for the Others so brutally murdered in the Chabad Lubatitcher Centre in Mumbai. In the past, I have too often misunderstood Israel. These dreadful murders in Mumbai has at last, and with great profundity, opened my foolishly blind eyes.

The Jewish people have so long, in so many places, including, which for me is a source of horror and deep personal anguish, in Orthodox Christian Russia, been tormented and brutalized for the sole reason that they wish to keep their Faith and Tradition. They have, wherever they have lived, been fountains of great contribution to the arts, sciences, philanthropy, and cultures of the nations they have lived as upright and loyal citizens.

Now, it is clear to me. The great Jewish People do NOT, as too many others do, fight or kill or shed blood except when it is necessary for self-defense. May Israel find Peace, and may the great people of Israel be covered with the Protection of Heaven.

Save us all from persons of cruel violence!
Posted By Serafim Evgenievich Yusupov, Taipei, Taiwan

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
condolences
I am a reform convert to Judaism but I have not deeply considered my attachments to Jewish community; this senseless tragedy has deeply moved me and many others. I grieve for your loss and I pray that little Moshe will find happiness with his grandparents. Please know that every decent person mourns your loss, and prays that justice will be done. I am deeply sorry.
Posted By llevine, carmel, IN

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
God Bless Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg
While I am in Hindu from India. I understand the great work Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg were doing for there community in India and for its members travelling to India. My heart goes out to there 2 yrs old son and the entire Jewish community on this great loss. But I know as always the fellow members of your community will continue the great work of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg
Posted By Gaurav

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Their sacrifice is a testimony for the rest of us!
Scripture says that the 12 Tribes - Israel are to be a light to the Nations. From reading their obituary and earlier watching the news, The Holtzbergs completely emulated this with their lives and now in their death, they are truly an encouragement to me personally. Is there any wonder that this "Light" was deliberately sought out at the start of the month of Kislev - our Festival of Lights month? And just as in days of old, we, all Israel, must unite and stand together - Hinei Ma Tov Umanaim Shevet Achim Gam Yachad, How beautiful and sweet it is when brothers sit together. We can stand in confidence because if G-d is for us who can be against us? An extra special blessing of shalom this Shabbat to the families of these two remarkable people!
Posted By Kelly A., Temple, TX

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Big tragedy.
This is a big tragedy for both families, for the little boy who lost young parents......

I and my family are filled with sorrow.

Shabbat Shalom, and God Bless.

Amen.
Posted By Oleg, Los Angeles, CA

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
We all have to thank a woman who risked her life to save Moshe. While none of us will ever know the exact circustances, what she did was very brave and very unselfish. And should be remembered.
Posted By Anonymous, Los Angeles, CA
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
I was in India two years ago and visited chabad in pune: god bless the people at chabad there to help with the many visitors from israel.
To all the chabad family, condolences for the rabbi and his family.
I pray for no more terror and the return of peace on earth.
Posted By claude hayot, miami, usa

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
condolences
My deepest regards to all the families and friends to the murdered human beeings in Bombay and everywhere this terrorist regard themselves as the soldiers of god. In Sweden we light our first christmas candles today. All my candles I will light is a prayer to the God who wants everyone to live with respect and love for others.
Posted By Elsa Israeli, Stockhoom, Sweden

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
mumbai tragedy
What a terrible tragedy and loss. I want to extend our sympathy to the families even though i dont know them. All Jews need to stand united to fight the terrible face of terrorism.
Posted By Anonymous, sydney, Australia

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
A blessing not only for the Jewish people
Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg would help anyone who came to them for assistance, Gentile or Jewish individual. These are two people who have made the world a better place and they will be very missed. We stand with the Jewish people and will help to stop these atrocities. Little Moshe is loved all over the world. We stand with him and all who have lost someone in this terrible, cowardly act of violence in the name of what? Evil.

SHALOM
Posted By Julia, Kent, England

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Very Painfull..
Hi, I am from Pakistan and a muslim by my religion. I believe in the oneness of God and believe that there is no god but God. I am 29 and I have never been taught even to hurt someone let alone kill innocent people. Our sympathies are with all who have lost their lives. Being a Pakistani let me clarify to the world that its not always us who do these dreadful acts of terrorism. i would like to say that the world is seeing what happened. Lets all pray for a peaceful place to live.
Posted By Bilal K Qazi , Lahore, Pakistan

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
CONDOLENCES
My prayers with the community and the family of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg in this sombre moment.

Lets us not forget the Rabbi was killed only because of his faith by these Islamic terrorists. Lets hope India's political and bureaucratic shaken from its deep slumber and avail this opportunity to redeem themselves. Let the Community not be lulled into a sense of satisfaction by empty words.
Posted By Kumar, New Delhi, India

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
We are praying for you all
I am deeply saddened at the death of Rabbi, his wife and other members of the Chabad House at Mumbai. As an Indian, I am very depressed that my country was targeted by the terrorists and killed such innocent, peace loving and importantly guests of my country.
Posted By Pavan Kumar Vutukur, Hyderabad, India

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Only deepest sypmpathy to these Wonderful people
Gavi and Rivka hosted me a few moths ago during my visit to Mumbai. I have never enjoyed such genuine out pouring and love for fellow man as this couple demonstrated for all their visitors. They did not judge, but welcomed all Jews even their Non Jewish friends, to enjoy their warmth hospitality, and teachings. Many may have abused the privileges offered, but there was never a hint of resentment. They gave so much , and many thousands must have passed through their doors like me, and knew them, who would be feeling like I do today, so sad, so proud to have known them. There can not be a person out there that would ever say that these Lubavich Jews were not the kindest and most genuine and caring people that walked this earth. I join the many Mourners of this tragedy in expressing to them and their families, my heartfelt sympathy, they will be remembered with deep sadness, and I am proud to have known them as my life is better for it.
Posted By Meor Ben Zvi Hacohen, Adelaide, Australia

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
My prayers are with the entire Chabad community during this time of tragedy and loss. This murder of innocents diminishes us all -- Jews and non-Jews.
May God grant comfort to those who mourn, and may He bless that precious child as he grows up without his devoted parents.
Posted By Sherilyn Jones, Houston, TX
via chabadtexas.org

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Condolences to the Chabad House:
To the dear people of Mumbai and the Chabad House:

I send you all my most sincere condolences.

At the moment I am even beyond words in sadness and outrage at what has happened in your beauitful city. Over the weekend I will Upload a music video in the memory and honour of victims of such a viscious attack, which was more than reminiscent of the violence of the National Socialists in the time of Hitler's Third Reich in Germany beginning on November 9, 1938 (The Pogrom of Kristallnacht or "The November Pogrom")!

Your Dorothea
Posted By Dorothea, Berlin, Germany

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
terrible tragedy
Shalom everyone and my deepest sympathy goes to Chabad for the loss of their Directors of the Lubavitch in Mumbai. may their memory be blessed. together with all that lost their lives by this agents of evil.

we should not ask questions why our prayers are not answered but we should ask why we are allowing this terrorists to live in this precious world. i do believe that there are more good people that evil ones. we should hunt them down till the last one. and we should do anything we can in order to prevent future attacks like the one in Mumbai.

best regards,
Posted By florin, Prishtina, Kosovo

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
deepest condolences
Words can not express the sorrow and horror of this tragedy. Perhaps the brutal deaths of the Rabbi, his wife and others can move the world to unite in love, compassion and peace. My heart goes out to their son. No one can replace the good work Chabad does all over the world. These were good people who dedicated their lives to fulfill a mission of compassion for others. May their memory be for a blessing.
Posted By Miriam, new jersey

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Our Prayers to the Family
Psa 121:4 Behold, He who keeps Israel shall neither slumber nor sleep.
Their Redeemer is mighty.

We from India and all over the World are humbled by this righteous family who trusted in the The Lord God of Israel. We pray for the protection, peace and restoration of Israel. We are all blessed because salvation has come to all of us through this chosen race, a holy nation.

Truly Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg are beacons of light shining ever so brighter in our hearts for what they believed and have stood for. Our prayers for Moshe at this moment that The Lord will be his supplier and comfort.

God Bless Israel and its children forever. Amen
Posted By Vimal & Priya, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Unfathomable
I will never be able to fathom the mindset of people who murder. Do they really think that the higher power they believe in would condone the slaying of others? They are utterly arrogant in believing they have the power of life or death over other human beings.

I did not know this couple but they seem to be exemplars of human kindness. My heart bleeds for their family and friends, the people they so selflessly served and especially the son they left behind at such a tender age.
Posted By Karen, Cleveland, OH / USA

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Grief and horror
As secular and observant Jews argue amongst ourselves, we are reminded that we must stand together as one. The rest of the world surely does not make the distinctions between our various branches. We are all Jews. We are all mourning today.
Posted By Julie, Wilmington, DE

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Only G-D knows the answer.
I pray for the lost jewish couple and those that lost their lives in such a evil event. But I also pray for Moshe, who will be left behind and never see his parents again. And I know somewhere down his life, he will cry to G-D. Why did this happen to my parents? For only G-d will have the answer.
May G-d mend the hearts of those who lost their loved ones in this terrible event.
Shalom and prayers
Posted By Yisrael, orlando, fl.

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
how kind
i am christain and have some jewish faith,
i wanted some details on judaism and when i called the chabad house once, i spoke to the rabbis wife who was so helpful. (at that time of our phone conversation i have heard the child crying - this comes to my memory now.)
i am shocked with this incident, and i am more worried about their child
Posted By sheeba joseph, chennai, india

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
My heartfelt condolances
I have been following this story since Wednesday night. It is very sad that people who do good are taken away and two innocent children are orphaned. I have lit a candle in front of my house in Noida not only for the extraordinary commandoes and police officers (who lost their lives) but also for our 'guests' Gavriel, Rivka and others who were killed by some perverted, senseless animals from our neighbouring country. May God bless their souls !!
Posted By Girish, India, Noida, India

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Response to: "Why our prayer unanswered"
Truely my heart is full of such grief over the loss of 2 extraordinary young people who were a beacon of love and hope for all.

I have turned this same question over in my mind and have come to the conclusion that while there is always an element of evil ( which the world has witnessed ) the hand of God is still at work and does triumph over acts of violence. Their son is alive and it is truely a miracle that the nanny was able to rescue him and bring him to the safe and loving arms of his grandparents. He is the tender legacy of 2 outstanding lives and he shows to us all that God is still at work in the world.

I see hope where there is easily despair and I pray that you will too.
Posted By Sheriel, Scarborough, ON/Canada

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
A prayer
Dear God in Heaven, may the families of Gavriel Holtzberg and Rivkah Rosenberg Holtzberg never know such tragedy again in their lives. May they only know joy and peace. Heal their aching hearts and the hearts of all those suffering from the loss of loved ones as a result of this terrible event. Have mercy on us all.
Posted By Anonymous, Poriyya, Israel
via chabadic.com

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
condolences
it is indeed tragic that innocents have to pay with their lives for no fault of theirs.
the only justice we could offer them now is to bring the guilty to justice.
it cannot be done by declaring a mindless war.
Democracies of the world should get together and flush out fundamentalists who preach hatred, arm and train young people to go out and kill.
Posted By romi, punjab, india

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
2 lights of purity are gone again
Gavriel and Rivka were 2 lights in the darkness of India. They were here to help people and to give them hope for their lives. They were 2 lights in Torah and now they're gone. G-D certainly knows, why they are gone, why two pure souls had been taken so young leaving an orphan. We don't know. Someone tells me that it's in G-D's accounts. Ok, but it's hard to accept. Make them rest in peace and help their little boy from where they are.
Posted By Hanna Simha, Ashdod, Israel

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
brave nanny
God bless Moshe's nanny for getting him to safety.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Mumbai
I am so sorry to hear of the tragic passing of Rabbi Gavriel and his wife Rivkak Holtzberg. It hurts me and my soul. I so love the Jewish people and I know that I would not have my religion without them. I pray for Rabbi Gavriel and his wife. I pray God's presence will be with them to help them this awful time in their lives. Also their son Moshe, God always be with him throughout his life.
Posted By Richard, Danville, VA

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Baruch dayan haemet!
I admire this couple! They did a really great work! May G-d give their family strength!
Posted By Ilanit

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Baruch Daayan Emet!
Their deaths was at the hands of monsters!
Posted By Miriam Goodman, Netivot, Israel

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
THE WORLD IS CRYING
my heart goes out to the son who will have to grow up with out his parents May HASHEM GIVE THE GRANDPARENTS the strength to go on
THE WORLD AND THEIR PRAYES ARE WITH YOU
Posted By a heart broken mother and grandmother, pretoria, south africa
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
memorial for the holtzbergs
I came across memorial sites for rivka and gavriel and it looks like it could be a real comfort to their families and create a real legacy for their children. Look at yizkor.com.
Posted By gitty

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Sadness
My heart is filled with sadness at the senseless loss of this dear couple. I cannot stop crying. I hope they, and all who perished for their religion and nationality in these acts of terror didn't suffer.

May their memory be for a blessing and may we redouble our efforts to follow their examples of chesed and hospitality. In that way the terrorists won't win
Posted By Anonymous, London

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Having spent a day in Bombay on business i was fortunate to experience the amazing hospitallity of the Holtzbergs. The food I brought with for my trip had gone off due to the heat. I have immense gratitude to have been able to have a hot filling meal meal before taking my 10 hour flight back home. May there holy souls be a Maylitz Yoisher for there family and all of Israel.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
RIP
My heartfelt condolences to all affected by this atrocity.

I trust that retribution is sure and swift.
Posted By John S, Chelmsford, UK

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
RAV HOLZBERG
I am glad I had the opportunity to know Rav Holzberg and his wife.

I was at the Bet Chabad roughly one month and a half ago for yom kippur, and Rav Holzberg spent the night to prepare the lulav for me before I was leaving.

I wont forget him and the wonderful person he was.

He was a Rav, a friend and a family for every jew in India.

Thanks Gabi and Rivka, I wont forget you and your kindness..
Posted By Nathan Salvadori, Jerusalem, Israel

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
answer to number 1
our prayers are not always answered the way we want them to be answered. the allmighty knows better than us what is the best for us. we can only be sure that this great sacrifice wasn't a waste, there is no question that good things will come out of it. just wait and see.
אין שום ספק שהקרבן הזה לא היה לשוא
ונקיתי דמם לא נקיתי. א-ל נקמות השם
על אלה אני בוכיה עיני עיני יורדה מים
קדשו שם שמים בחייהם ובמותם
הרוגי מלכות אין כל בריה יכולה לעמוד במחיצתם
תהא נשמתם צרורה בצרור החיים ויהי רצון שבזכות הקרבן העצום הזה נזכה כולנו לראות במו עינינו את מלך המשיח בן דוד בעצמו תיכף ומיד ממש
Posted By Anonymous
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
murder in mumbai
To the wonderful people of Chabad:
where ever you go in the world the door is always open at chabad. This is terrible for jews all over the world; lessons have not been learnt and it is very frightening. Thank g-d for Israel and the Israeli people that despite a lack of support from the diaspora
are always there for us. G-d bless America and lets hope it will carry on being a friend to Israel.
Posted By Anonymous, dorset, uk
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
May the God of Israel comfort the hearts of your community and the families of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg. My prayers are with all of you.
Posted By L. Jerguson, Canton, GA USA

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
The Nanny Who saved Little Moishe
Praying for the whole family.
I just hope that the Chabad organization honors the nanny who grabbed little Moishe and got out. I pray Chabad will honor and care for her. She could have been killed just opening the door to grab the baby.
Their legacy still lives on. Little Moishe will carry on his parents legacy.
Posted By Rivki Beck

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Admiration and love
I have nothing but admiration for the Chabad Shluchim who do so much to bring Judaism to those who need them most. I may not be a Chabadnik but this senseless murder of a wonderful Rabbinic couple emphasizes why we need more love in the world, not more hate. And Chabad, whatever one's philosophy, provide love. “Ahavas Chinam.”
May the Ahavas Chinam of this wonderful couple inspire us all to show humanity in the face of such atrocities. Let our reaction not be revenge, or hatred, but love of humanity and a desire to spread the Jewish values they loved and spread with love, in our own lives.
Tiyhe Menuchatam Kavod, Vyhyu nismotam tzerurrot bitzerror hachayim.
Posted By Rabbi Zvi Solomons, Reading UK, Reading, UK
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Salvation
This world will only be saved when each human being practices what Rabbi and Mrs. Holtzberg practiced...love. Pray daily, show love, display humility, eschew hatred and greed. Then G-d will triumph.

My heart hurts for the families. My prayers encompass their lives. We must learn from Rabbi and Mrs. Holtzberg...go forth and do the work of G-d.
Posted By Tana, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Our depest condolence to the Chabad people
I am an indian and would like to express my deepest condolence to the Holtzberg family and the Chabad community. May god give them strength in their time of grief.
Posted By AG, Philadelphia, USA

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Sad Sad Sad.....
This is a very sad event which has robbed a child of his parents and many others of their lives, i am a muslim and nowhere in our religion are such acts justified.

My thoughts are with Moshe.....
Posted By Anonymous, Glasgow, UK

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
My love, support and prayers, though I'm not Jewish I'm in this website all the time. I was very, very upset and saddened but I have faith that their work will continue speaking even after they have left the world. May G-d bring justice but may the world also be a better place because of them.
Posted By diana, houston, TX

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Condolences
Our thoughts and prayers to the entire Chabad Community, the Holtzbergs' American and Israeli families, as well as to ALL of us, the entended family.
Our hearts are broken to see the evil perpetrated on the Holzbergs, innocent and beautiful souls whose only crime was being Jewish. We must vow to be strong and never let these EVIL monsters win.
Posted By Barbara Stiller Baer and family, Raleigh, NC/USA
via jewishraleigh.org

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
I am sad
I am sad at the destruction of precious life at the Chabad center. Chabad has a special place in my heart.
Posted By Supporter

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Where was their security?
How come India was so unprepared?

Will this happen again? Here in the USA?

Maybe we should get a Jewish CIA together. Apparently we are like sitting ducks everywhere.
All Jewish organizations need to have a staff of security on or near their premises. Sad but true. We need "Lookouts" all over. even at home.
Posted By Anita, Ft Lauderdale , fL
via jewishpoconos.com

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Very sad
Reading this article of this terrible tragedy has filled my eyes with tears. I wish that all terrorist networks should be destroyed before they try and strike again and kill more innocent people.
Posted By Rivka

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
we should nominate the Holtzbergs
We should nominate the Holtzbergs and the Chabad World Wide Organization for the"Heroes" CNN. This would be an important memorial to their valiant lives and great unselfish deeds for the good of others.
All of us grieve their loss deeply with their families and with the Chabad which does such good in the world. I remember as a child the ad, with the song,"you've got to be taught to learn to hate." When will the Muslim world wake up that the ones among them teaching hate need to be stopped by their very own people?
If the terrorists had stopped only for a meal with the Holtzbergs they would have treated them with the same kindness and hospitality that all others received. Instead they killed them, never comprehending they had come into a house of peace and goodness. Where are the terrorists mothers and fathers? They did not teach love. May the memory of the Holtzbergs be a blessing for our people and their sons needs all of our love. Blessings for their brave courageous nanny.
Posted By Anonymous, New York, NY
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
glimmer of light
I have read all these comments and my heart is warmed even with tears in my eyes. Already the love of people of goodwill is triumphing over evil. I do not mean to diminish this tragedy but the love of and for G-d is glowing from these words of faith and sympathy. I am not Jewish but I am honored to be in this company of good people. I feel safer knowing all of you are in the world.
Posted By jeanette, usa

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
My wife Leah and I watched and prayed to G-d that these two beautiful people, beloved of G-D, would be released. Our hearts our grieved and cried out to G-D enough! when will it stop with your people. Our prayer is now for the family, that G-D will give them strength in the weeks to come.
Posted By yochanan, Rio Rancho, NM

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Chabad, a Light unto the Nations and Jewish People
It was with deep sadness that I read about the fate of these beautiful people who ONLY MEANT TO DO GOOD! They are a light unto the world, a beacon of hope. My father of blessed memory and mother always taught us to be tolerant of others that were different than us, one of the many good qualities that Chabad Lubavitch teaches. Chabad never judges what type of person or Jew you are. They are there for you. My parents prayed by Chabad for many years and always received a warm welcoming from the Rabbi and his wife and their lovely family. G-d Bless the Lubavitchers, they are true Jews, out there taking care of others, putting actions to words and not just talking about what they should or could be doing to make things better. My father used to say, "Talk is cheap, DO something!" Well, Chabad does something everyday to make this a better world and bring Moshiach! To all the shluchim out there, be strong! G-d will watch over all of you and keep you safe. Amen.
Posted By Eva Becker, Los Angeles, California

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
We must continue where they left off
They exemplified a great generosity of spirit and kindness. You can tell it was truly a labor of love . I hope to commit in their honor to do more acts of kindness.
However, that said , the awareness of increasing dangers in the world trouble me.
Unfortunately, world leaders are not taking them seriously enough. I bid all my good brothers and sisters of the world to stay safe and walk this world aware of some of the more unsavory possibilities that can afflict us.
Posted By Anonymous, teaneck, New Jersey

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Rabbi Gavi and Rivki Holtzberg
Sadness and tears have been in my heart since the news Friday morning. They were wonderful people. You can see it on their faces. May G-d bless little Moshe. May little Moshe be blessed by the memory of his parents and be blessed by what they stood for and the sacrifice they made to care so much for our people and for all peoples.
G-d bless those families it was such a great lights gone out of this world.
Posted By Rivka Sari, Eugene, OR

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
No words and so many words
My heart is aching at this tragedy. I went to bed on shabbos not knowing the outcome and only after shabbat was I able to find the news.
I can't help but believe that G-d knows best the reason for this tragedy and while I am sick with grief over the loss this young child has suffered, I am positive that G-d has something good in store for him.
Please remember the heroic actions of his nanny and may we honor her as a tzaddika, one who truly saved a Jewish life.
Chabad has been so kind to me and my family. It was through Chabad that I met my husband.
Posted By Tamar, Ashdod, IL

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
In memory of the Holtzbergs
Let it be known that all the darkness in the world can never ever extinguish the flames of the Sabbath candles nor the Jews of the world! We mourn the loss of two people who did so much for not just Jews, but for all who they helped. May G-d grant you eternal peace! To Rabbi and Rivka's parents our hearts go out to you in this sad time. To Moshe may you know that your Ema And Aba did such great work and we pray that you will go forth and carry on in their footsteps in time to come. Our hearts go out to you and we pray that you will find comfort and peace. With love from all who care enough for LIFE ! ! !
Posted By Anonymous, Durban, South Africa

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
i am saddened by this tragedy. I don't understand why people cannot live together in peace. We need to bring moshiach as well as peace. Peace among all the nations is what must happen in order for moshiach to come.
Posted By Rochel Sarah, La Mirada, CA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Baruch Dayan Emet
May we pray to G-d that today's tears of grief are replaced soon with tears of joy. I hope that this shocking tragedy, will make us all work harder for the nation of Israel. I hope and pray that Chabad continue and strengthen their work throughout the world and this does not deter them from brinigng the light of torah to places where most fear to step
My thoughts and prayers are with you
Posted By laibel david ben meir ha'levi, Manchester, Israel

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
My deepest condolences
My deepest condolences to the families of all the departed.

I've no words to express my appreciation for the unconditional work that Chabad and all of its members do, on a daily basis, in the most unusual places were we, the Jewish people, decide to temporarily or permanently be.

Thank you.......
Posted By Daniel, Mexico City, Mexico

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
My heart goes out to you. all of you!
Although not of Jewish faith, I am so sorry at the loss you have suffered and pray the children will be raised to remember their loving and brave parents. Once again hatred has attacked love. But we know that God's love is bigger than hate. My thoughts are with you and all of the victims and the survivors of this tragedy. May God grant us peace and let us live as brothers and sisters.
Posted By Lara, Quincy, Florida, USA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
The Tragedy in Mumbai
My condolences to all who were hurt.
Posted By Samuel Margolies, Las Vegas, Nevada/USA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
May G-d comfort you
Our condolences to the family of Rabbi Holtzberg and his wife, Rivka, as well as to the Chabad community. Our thoughts and prayers are with you. May their memories be honoured. The terrorists will never win.
Posted By Jonathan Hoffman, London, UK

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Part III One Within G-d’s Heart
For the Soul is what’s forever in the fields of Heaven’s time
But you may not understand this, for your ways are not Mine
For the Soul is My Candle, now I will now hold these in My Arms
And they will shine forever, safe from earthly harm
These lights taken from you, shining as the stars
The Soul here within Me, One within My Heart
The Soul that I create that man cannot take apart
Yes, Moshe,
Everything is One and shines as Love within My Heart

And then the L-rd took two small pieces of Light and placed them within the One young heart of Moshe, and He knew he would be a Light among the Land.


In Lasting Memory,
Posted By Eric Sander Kingston, North Hollywood, CA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Rest in peace
May God provide Moshe's grand parents the patience and the strength so the child does not miss his parents. May God bless them and heal them all.
Posted By Sajid Hussain Saiyed, Mumbai/Jeddah, India/KSA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
I write with tears....
May G-d's light shine forth through his people, as it was by Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg and all of the Chabad family. It is the only way we can chase away the darkness. To all of the grieving who have written on these pages, whether Jew, Christian, Islam, Indian or any race or religion - this is not the fault of any one people. This atrocity was caused by the darkness inside of madmen... May we all continue to pray, to do mitzvoh, to practice now keeping Shabbat in preparation for the ultimate Shabbat to come, and to remember in our prayers these self-sacrificing individuals who stood, un-armed before their attackers.

Blessed be the one true judge.
Posted By Kelly Rae (Leeba), Sydney, AU

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Very Sad...
In my experience, the Lubavitch are warm and welcoming people. My condolences to the families.
Posted By Sean Finnegan, Portland, OR

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Respects
My condolences to the families of those who were murdered.

The love, wisdom & justice of G-D shall prevail.
Posted By Graham Warrener, Goch, Germany

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Senseless Murders
May the Holtzbergs find a place at the right hand of G-d. May their son gow-up to remember and treasure his parents. May their light be carried by others. G-d bless them all.
Posted By Fredric P. Eiss, Scottsdale, AZ

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Deepest condolences
I would like to express my deepest condolences to the family of Rabbi Holtzberg and to the Chabad community worldwide.

I am not Jewish but have been familiar with your work. I am also a mother of a two-year old and was praying for little Moshe's parents to be returned to him. It was not to be.

What a senseless tragedy. May G-d bring peace and love to little Moshe and your community.
Posted By Maria, Brooklyn, NY

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Sad and sickened
I am absolutely sickened and beyond sadness from all of this. I pray at a Chabad center and thank G-d for these people. Without Chabad, I would find it very difficult to have any interaction with other Jews. These people are dedicated to good and to have such evil is just beyond comprehension.

I wish we could do something for little Moishe. My wife "sings him to sleep" when she is singing our own two-year-old son to sleep. It's all she feels that she can do for him, and she has barely been able to stop crying about it.

I don't understand why G-d would take Moishe's parents away (who were good people) and let other children suffer in bad family situations.

The older I get, the less I understand about this world.
Posted By Menachem Har-Zahav, Velbert, Germany

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Murders in Mumbai
These murders of over 180 people including 6 Chabad people in Mumbai is an outrage and a demonstration that we must be diligent in seeking out and eliminating these terrorists.

I think I share not only the Jewish perspective but all people in their outrage and their disgust at these murders of innocent people.

The Rabbi and his Rebbettzin and the other Rabbi and Jews that were murdered in the Chabad facility leaving a 2 year old child in blood is extremely disturbing and needs to be an indicator of our final resolve to this situation.

These indiscriminate murders have been perpetrated by the evil forces in the world lead by Muslim extremists. And this situation must come to an end before there is more bloodshed of innocent victims.
Posted By Moishe Alexander, Thornhill, ON
via jewishyouth.ca

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Moshe
Hello,
I am a mother of 4 children 25, 22, and twin girls 10 years old.
We are observing Jews and will be happy to adopt Moshe or give him a home untill a solution will come.
We live in Los Angeles and will make sure the boy will be raised in an orthodox manner.
Please contact us if you need help.
Sincerely,
Posted By Pnina and Maurice Labi, Los Angeles, CA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
May G-d comfort you along with all those who mourn in Tzion.
Posted By Hannah

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Heart Broken
It is with much sadness that write these words. The senseless loss of innocent life is beyond human understanding. At these times we must reach for a higher form of explanation, G-d. He works in strange ways.
I pray for the safety of little Moishe and his brother in Israel. We are grateful for the selfless heroism of Sandra, his family housekeeper. Her brave escape spared him from destruction.
I am proud that Israel has reached out to accept her. She has been witness to the profound example of true Judaism.
Again, with tears in my eyes, I wish to share my grief and send condolences to the families. This has brought us closer.
Posted By Shira, The Golan, Israel

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Can't stop my tears rolling out everytime I see little Moshe's picture and realize what he has lost. I am an Indian Hindu and urge all my Jewish brothers not to stop coming to India and open up hundreds of Chabad houses across the country as a fitting reply to the perpetrators of terrorism in the name of relegion.. God bless the soul of Rabbi and his wife.
Posted By Sachin , Delhi, India
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Deeply Saddened
My heart goes out to all of the families who lost their loved ones in such a brutal manner. The Holtzbergs were murdered because they were Jewish. My heart breaks for lil Moshe and their family. As a convert to be, I know what great work Chabad does for Jews & even non-Jews.

I hope hatred in the world ends NOW!!!
Posted By Anonymous, NYC, NY

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
murder at chabad in mumbai
My heart is broken over this tragedy. Chabad is to be commended for setting up these outposts around the world where every Jew is welcome. What a terrible terrible disaster to take away such young and gifted people in such a senseless way. There are no words adequate to describe this horror. The tears are flowing. May the familiies of those murdered find comfort in their sorrow.
Posted By Mark Meirowitz, New Yori, NY

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
We started saying tehillim on Thursday.....
At Bais Menachem of North Miami Beach we started saying tehillim for for Gabbi and Rivki on Thursday, 29th of Cheshvan. Without knowing the outcome of this barbaric act, we prayed for their well being.

Members of our shul were going through emails for any information. We found out what had happened after Shabbos.

I know that CHABAD will stand strong in the face of terrorism just as we stood strong in the face of communism!
Posted By Anonymous, North Miami Beach, FL

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
I've never met the couple, but like so many Jews around the world, hearing stories and watched videos of who they were - I feel very connected to them. When someone passes on they transmit a part of their divine service, their love for Israel, love for G-d, etc. This terrible occurrence means that every Jew who feels connected to them nonetheless gets some type of illumination in their divine service, even the smallest. Like I said, I never met them but after this terrible incident, I can only say that it must be inspired from them. This goes beyond adopting one mitzvah but rather an increase in all matters of mitzvos.
Posted By Avraham

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
At the going down of the sun
At the going down of the sun and in the morning we shall remember. Such a terrible loss, and more so for poor Moshe. May they rest in peace, and may Moshe live to honour their bravery, dedication, compassion and selflessness.
Posted By Lee Goddard, Godollo, Hungary

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Not jew against muslim
Let us remember that the majority of people killed were indians and non-jews. It is very important in this sad time not to make this an "us against them" issue. We are all in solidarity as a world. This was an attack on the world, jew and non-jew alike, and I am deeply saddened as well for the innocent Indian, Filipino, New Zealand and Australian lives taken. May Moshe grow to accomplish great deeds for G-d.
Posted By Andrea, San Francisco, Ca

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Kedoshim
The first thought that came to my head upon hearing the news that they were murdered, was how holy their souls must have been. It is the greatest possible merit to die al kiddush Hashem (for the sanctification of G-d's name), and they surely went straight up to Gan Eden with no further questions. In their lifetime they sanctified G-d's name, and in their deaths they did that as well. The pain we feel is so enormous- I feel like I have lost a close relative, even though I never met them. May G-d transform all of our tears of pain and sadness into tears of joy with the coming of the redemption very very soon.
Posted By Anonymous, brooklyn, ny

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
My heartfelt condolences
I am a Hindu and want to convey my heartfelt condolences for the loss of Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg's lives. May little Moishe be able to overcome the loss of his parents. It is so sad to see when good people who do selfless service fall victims to senseless violence.

What all of these teaches us is that terrorism has no borders and need to be tackled by all countries jointly. Piecemeal solutions would not work as elimination of terrorists at one place will shift them elsewhere. Also while it is not possible to police every inch of the earth, we can at least try to block all the illegal funding sources and regain the mind-share of disaffected youths from the hate-mongers.
Posted By Jyoti, Pasadena, CA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
I cannot believe how these people attacked like a rabid dog. It was thoughtless. The attacked all over the city and then landed onthe Chabad house and snuffled out lives there. Why? What cause or hurt is great enough to warrant such actions? There is no reason to do this ever! No ideology, no religion, no persons are so important that it can give people the right to go out and kill people. None of the people that were randomly shot deserved such a thing. The wonderful people at the Chabad house in Mumbai definitely didn't deserve it. I hope that G-d, the peers of those responsible for planning this killing spree, or the cold winds of life turn their hearts so that they will know that what they did was wrong. My heart goes out to all those who have been hurt by this horrible event
Posted By Anonymous, Spokane , Wa

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Putting my son to bed
I put my 18 month old son to bed tonight and started crying at the thought of the little Moishe that lost his parents. I thanked G-d that all my family is in good health.

I prayed that little Moishe should have a good and happy life. I also prayed for all the other families that were affected by this terrible incident.

I hope we won't have to see these kind of incidents again, but as Churchill said: "hope for the best and prepare for the worst." All Chabad shluhim should be armed wherever the local law allows it and should be trained to respond to terrorists.
Posted By Jonathan

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
I am shattered
I was never privlidged to know the Rabbi and his Rebbitzin however, the fact that this young man learned ritual slaughter and circumcision in order to work in a far-flung Chabad house far away from family, friends, and all of the comforts we enjoy living in large Jewish communities makes him all the more amazing. I will forever be touched by the amazing stories that are already coming out about this remarkable couple. I hope that in their merit that people can take on one, however small or large, mitzvah and add it to their lives. This couple along with all of the other Jewish people who were senselessly slaughtered should never be forgotten. May they look down from heaven and receive nachas from their children. May they both grow to be living testiments to their parents and their ultimate sacrifice.
Posted By Yaakov Goldsmith, Baltimore, MD

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Absolute Evil
As an African American convert to Judaism by about 7 years, the Chabad House system has been a blessing to me and I can't imagine having a sacred place where the Rebbe of Blessed Memory's mission is brought to a halt by such senseless and meaningless bloodshed. Baruch Dayan Ha-Emet, that Rabbi Holtzberg and his wife Rivkah should rest in Gan Eden and their son Moshe should be blessed in their merit. I hope this shows the world that militant Islam is at the heart and not the periphery and has to be stopped. We need Moshiach now, esp in times like this...
Posted By Akiba Ben Avraham, Michael Twitty, Rockville , MD

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Condolences
Dearest Israeli Friends

Please accept our sincerest condolences on the death of these beautiful children of God in the hands of murderous hate filled terrorists from Pakistan

India has been a safe haven for people of all religions for thousands of years. Some of the original lost tribes of Israel found shelter and success in India. Zoroastrians persecuted by Muslims in Iran found shelter in India 100's of years ago.

I feel so sad that such good people have been tortured maimed and brutalized over the centuries -- first in Europe -- then now in the middle east.

I want to assure all my Jewish friends to know that this was the work of hate filled terrorists from Pakistan -- and not the work of Indians

We Indians not only tolerate -- but accept with love people from all faiths -- including the loving Jewish people

Please again accept our most sincere condolences
Posted By Prabhakar, New York, USA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Little Moshe~
My heart is broken for you little child....your light dimmed but not for long... may you grow up to be a very confident and courageous young man and may you profess to the world that G-ds Love endures for ever and ever...Bless your grandparents as they prepare to take care of you and also may G-d bless Sandra your nanny who loves you and cares dearly for you. May you be at peace and much love to you little Moshe....Im very sorry this happened to you little dear.... very sorry.
Posted By Tina Farber, Jacksonville, USA
via chabadbeaches.com

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Mumbai
The only way for us to fight hatred us through love- don't give up.
Posted By Chesky, Alon Shevut, Israel

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
The first Chabad Rebbe said we have to live with the times, meaning look to the eternal truth of the Torah portion for insight each day. The first line of today's reading and Rashi's commentary provides a clear teaching:

"And Jacob left." Scripture had only to write: “And Jacob went to Haran.” Why did it mention his departure? But this tells [us] that the departure of a righteous man from a place makes an impression, for while the righteous man is in the city, he is its beauty, he is its splendor, he is its majesty. When he departs from there, its beauty has departed, its splendor has departed, its majesty has departed. And likewise (Ruth 1:7): “And she went forth from the place,”.

Gavriel and Rivka, you will be in our hearts forever.
Posted By Shachar, Venice, Italy

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
with tears...
my dear gavriel, dear rivky,
I hope you are able to read or to hear what it said now on this earth but I just want to tell you that my heart is full of pain, you look so happy in your holy occupation, a meaningful life stoped by those evil, those criminals.
I wish that our Rebbe was physically here, to explain to us what happened... Should G-d keep your soul and your wife's soul and should G-d keep your little Moshele. G-d bless you and your family
Posted By Anonymous, paris, france
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
I am very sad for them and cried
I am not habad but respect habad, I respect every Jew believing in G-d. I want you to know I am sure G-d gave them a place near him in Gan Eden, they were a wonderful couple. I prayed for little Moshe, that he grows up strong, and that habad will take care of him forever. I am sure Moshe will be our next leader. I hope he will have a beautiful life.
Habad please, send guns and training to your emissaries in dangerous places. King David prayed and had a sword too...
Posted By Eric, Charenton, France

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
I've never met the Rabbi or his wife, but hearing that good people died break my heart. The world need more good people. I also want to thank the Chabad organization and to Rabbi Mintz from Colorado who knew Rabb Holtzberg for their warmth and for letting me into his Purim party for free. Thet thought me that religion it's not a scary thing and help me get closer to my Judaism.
Posted By T

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Sorrow
I am so so saddened by this news, the loss of two amazing blessed people. I have no words, but those of gratitude for Chabad, and sincere condolences for this terrible terrible loss.
Posted By Vanessa, London

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
G-d's work
Gavriel Holtzberg and Rivka did nothing wrong to deserve this. The mistery of why G-d let this things occur is something not revealed to us, for the moment. They gave their lives, the most precious gift we can give. G-d bless them.
Posted By Raul Avalos, Guatemala, Guatemala

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Mumbai tragedy
Like many citizens in the United States, I watched the Mumbai tragedy unfold on my TV screen. I never knew your friends, but I did pray for them to receive a miracle in their time of need. Even though many died, their little boy was spared! Praise the Almighty! As a dedicated Christian, I pray regularly for the peace of Jerusalem and her true citizens throughout the world. The Jewish community has suffered so much for so long; but yet, you have given the world so much. This week another wonderful gift was given by several of your Rabbis during interviews on various news broadcasts. How impressive and touching it was to hear the love in their hearts, even toward those who have unmercifully inflicted such horrible pain on them and their loved ones. It was the most beautiful witness of the goodness of God that the world has heard in response to the evil actions of sadistic men. Your Mumbai friends did not perish in vain, but the good Lord used this horrible tragedy to demonstrate His enormous love for mankind. I pray for you to be comforted and encouraged at this time of great loss. There are non-Jewish people who really do care about you.
Posted By Debbie , Mesquite, Texas

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
I have no experience with them, but have always admired the work that Chabad emissaries do. However, I feel like I did know them, it has affected me so much, and what happened there will never be forgotten.
Posted By Chana Leah, Brooklyn, NY

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
With a heavy heart
I was away celebrating the Thanksgiving holiday out of town and I was glued to the TV in my hotel room and in the coffee area. During the morning, I had occasion to speak with non-Jew from Tulsa, Ok.The woman and I began to speak about what was happening and she said that she could not believe that people were so mean and horrible and her heart went out to the families, especially the children of the the Rabbi in India. This woman was a woman who was very devout and it did gladden my heart a bit that other people, who are not of our faith, feel for the tragedy that has befallen us. She told me that on Sunday, when she was going to church she was going to light a special candle for the Rabbi and his wife. My conversation with this woman, gave me hope that in the midst of this terrible time that a small glimmer of tolerance might emerge. May we know no more sorrow and we have only celebrate Simchas together.
Posted By Cynthia, Little Neck, NY

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Fitting Response
After the anger and desire for revenge has died down the Jewish world has responded in only the way Jews do, not by apportioning blame but by reflecting and looking at ways that we can improve our actions to merit a 'kinder' response from G-d in the future.
People have taken on to perform extra mitzvot and deeds of goodness and kindness. Every mitzvah we do brings more light and enlightenment to a bedarkened world in sore need of it.
Kudos to everyone who has already taken on to do their part in correcting the situation, and come on you others if you have not yet committed to helping.
The husband and wife team were special individuals - emissaries of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, but as the Rebbe pointed out often, every Jew is a shliach and representative of G-d in this world. After the events settle I am sure we will see many eager to fill the 'large shoes' of these two unfortunate souls who died 'Al Kiddush Hashem' - for the sanctification of G-d's Name.
May we all continue their unfinished work.
Posted By Kashrut, Melbourne, AUSTRALIA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
What we should all learn from this tragedy is that good people, be they Jewish, Christian, Muslim, Hindu, etc, need to stand together and put a stop once and for all to world terrorism. It is time to say enough to the people in our world who prey on innocent, G-d fearing men and women (and children) who are trying to do good in the world. Jews especially need to stand together! May G-d bless the families of the Holtzbergs, the nanny,and protect Moshe.
Posted By Chaya Rivka, CA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
I never knew them but...
I was on a cruise ship when we heard about the tragedy. Because of the wonderful Chabbad family that I had the honor of knowing well for many years, I know the dedication it takes to do their work. We had services on the ship Friday night and said Kaddish for the Holtzberg's. There were Jews from England, Russia and the US...various beliefs that came together in mourning. That is the essence of Chabbad...bringing us all together as Jews. It has been incredible reading all the stories about this wonderful couple. What an amazing sacrafice the Holztzberg's made. The saddest part is Moishe will never have the memories of his parents that every child deserves. I hope when he is old enough someone haw put all these letters and articles together in a book that he can read and know how loved and awesome his parents were. There are so many people that admired your parents Moishe, yet never had honor of meeting them...
Posted By Karen Fedder, Marietta, GA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
May G-d Comfort them and give us strength
What a sad tragedy considering how good and selfless sacrifices that Rabbi and wife gave to communities.

May G-d comfort the families and give strength to overcome these.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Martyrs for the sanctification of the name.
How tragic and how incomprehensible. What harm had Rabbi and Rebbitzen Holtzberg done that they should be targeted? All they were trying to do was good, facilitating observance for the Israeli businesspeople and encouraging young Jews seeking spirituality in Eastern faiths to find it in their own. I can only square this by seeing them as examples of martyrdom for the sanctification of the name. How tragic that it still happens!
Posted By Susan, Fayetteville, NC

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
happy birthday
god bless the orphan child
Posted By jerome, leeds, uk

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
This great tragedy is a also a triumph for Chabad and the Jewish people. I am amazed by your organization and your representatives can be serving Jews and Jewish communities throughout the world. Thanks to Chabad, Jews can live almost anywhere in the world and live as observant a life if they so choose. They can learn about our faith and teach their children. These victims did not die in vain. The world knows that Chabad is everywhere.
Posted By Dan

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Chazak Chazak..Be strong and let us continue to strengthen one another to build and lift and cheer one another...as Rabbi Holzberg and Rivki did in Mumbi..
Shalom shalom and full comfort to the grieving families and Chabad community all over the world.
Posted By Anonymous, WA/usa

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
We Hope on our G-D
HEAR, O ISRAEL! THE LORD IS OUR G-D THE ONLY ONE AND SUPRIME G-D.

We are Roman-Catholics and we love our jewish brothers, We are very sorry about this terrible lost of the Rabbi and his wife and are praying for them and their son.
Posted By Carlos Manuel & Ophelia Gomez, Miami, Florida

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Our heartfelt condolences to all affected
Im a practicing Muslim and an Indian, and have friends from all over, Israel, and Pakistan included. I would like to say that I am truly saddened by the recent attacks in Mumbai. My heart reaches out to all affected, the many Hindus and Muslims and people of other faith who lost their lives.

I am also deeply saddened by the death of the young Rabbi who was working to bring the true message of the oneness of God to the Jewish people in Mumbai.
Posted By Zahir Adil
via chabadsudbury.com

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
deepest condolences to the family -
and indeed the entire community.
Indians and israelis have been friends for a long time - but politics has hindered a closer relationship - political or otherwise.

May the two young souls rest in peace and may their little son know their parents love and dedication from the grandparents who will raise him.
Posted By Anonymous, bangalore, india

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Broken Hearts
I am grateful to chabad.org for providing a forum for us to comment. It is heartening to see goodness and kind words from all over the world expressing sorrow and condolences to the Holtzberg and Rosenberg families. Along with so many Jews, my heart is broken.

In the words of our beloved Rebbe " Broken hearts can be repaired...with actions to build in light and goodness."

Baruch Dayen Ha Emet
Posted By Rivkah Rochel, Austin, TX

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Hashem Yinkom Damom!
As Rabbi Manis Friedman says regarding the ideology of the pertetrators of such violence - if something is good, it will good in the extreme. And, if someting is evil in it's extreme, it wasn't good to start with.
Posted By yonason, tampa, FL/USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
All civilized people worldwide share your grief
Greetings:

as a Hindu and as someone who was born in Mumbai, all mem and women of principle stand with you in your moment of pain and offer our prayers as well for the speedy healing of your community.
Posted By Vivek, los alamos, NM

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Condolences
As an Indian (non-Jewish), I am saddened particularly by the targeting of Jews by these mad men. These Jews were probably the only Jews these barbarians saw in their lives. In India we grow up respecting the intelligence and entrepreneurial spirit of Jews around the world. My humble condolences to everybody who suffered and I trust that Jews would keep coming to Mumbai and other parts of India.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
There is tomorrow
The terrorists did not win. They killed two precious lives, but they only destroyed the present. The future is alive. Moshe lives. Their child, left with a legacy of sorrow, is also left with a legacy of grace. Given to him by his parents and the example they set as Jews and as people of great commitment.
Please remember....tommorow lives and a child shall lead them. May those that perished rest in peace, and may those that survived, find resolve and focus and determination in their lives.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Terror in Mumbai
Our deepest felt condolences to the Holtzberg family and the rest of the victims families. It has been difficult for my wife and I to digest a tragedy like this befalling such a selfless family and our worldwide Chabad community.
Posted By Steve Rodin, Encino, CA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
mumbai
I am a hindu living in Mumbai. I want to express my sorrow and apologise for the tradegy in Nariman house Mumbai, India.
Posted By ashok, Mumbai, India

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Simcha Holtzberg
Let me keep this short. The tragedy is so enormous. Many people in Israel have thought of Simcha Holtzberg of righteous memory when hearing about the tragedy in Bombay. Is the Gavriel Holtzberg family related to him? Simcha, "Awi Hapetsu'im", father of the wounded, was extremely well known and loved in Israel. Couuld all of this be connected to him? Thank you for your answer in advance.
Posted By Lea de Lange , Jerusalem, Israel

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
To Am Yisrael
I would like to send to the Chabad community and to all the Jewish nation, a message of strong support and encouragement, to keep on performing your service of spreading the testimony and word of the Almighty G-d in this world. Even in this moment of sad news, I am sure that the Jewish Nation WILL PREVAIL.
Posted By Joel Català, Barcelona, Catalonia

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Tragedy in Mumbai
My heart goes out to the families of the Rabbi and Rebbetzen. My initial reaction to news of their death was that why should this evil be done to people who only wanted to do good in this world. May they and the others who were killed rest in peace
Posted By Sue Soloway, London, U K
via lubavitchofedgware.com

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
A humble suggestion
Jews all over the world have been shocked by this terrible tragedy. Perhaps their emotional energy can be harnessed for Torah study through a world-wide campaign to learn Mishnayot in memory of the victims of the attack?
Posted By Berel Dov Lerner, Kibbutz Sheluhot, Israel

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Moeshe
My thoughts and prayers go to Moeshe. Seeing the images of a happy Moeshe and then seeing the images of him crying tear me up inside. What a wonderful family enviorment he would have grown up in. His parents were genourous, brave and excellent examples of parents. I hope that when moeshe grows up his family will share with him the love and support pouring out to his family in this very difficult time.
Moeshe your parents loved you more than anyones words can describe. May you always feel their love.
Posted By Dan Sadowski, newington , CT

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
My Great Condolence.
My great condolences for the death of Rabbi Goltzberg and his wife, i pray for their son to grow strong in G-d and i wish peace to the whole world. Amen.
Posted By Anonymous, Jakarta, Indonesia

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
tragedy in Mumbai
A deep sadness envelops my heart - such a beautiful young couple, goodness radiates from their faces - to be so brutally cut down - having done so much in their short, young life, with so much more to do - had they been given the chance - when will the world learn to live in peace - my heart goes out to the orphan children and the parents of Gabi and Rivka- and I worry for all our children and grandchildren - G-d give us the strength and wisdom to go on and to do good deeds..
Posted By edith gruen, ny, usa

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
We Should All do Something
I felt very sad to hear the story of the Holtzberg, I was following the news that tragic day as if he was one of my family members, the truth is we all Jews are connected one another and should do something to stop this kind of abuse from happening again, Why can we just defend our self from this terrorist who are just waiting to do harm to us, until when are we just going to sit and enjoy been murder, abused, humiliated and discriminated, we should all do something to defend our self and bring Moshiach soon. May G-d keep the Holtzbergs in Gan Eden and give comfort to their son Moishe.
Posted By Yoram Torres, San Salvador, El Salvador

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
sympathy
My family and I feel deep sympathy to the relatives of the victims and for the tragic loss of these wonderful people.
We hope one day happy people to live - a life with no pain and hardships.
G-d bless you all .
slavyanka and venny
Posted By slavyanka nickolova, Petrich, Bulgaria

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
tragedy
We cannot fathom the intensity of this tragedy until we understand why people murder each other.This is not why we are here.
Posted By Steve Finson, West Haven, Ct/US

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
I send my condolences
I would like to send out my prayers to all the families who were hurt by this terrible event.
Posted By Anonymous, NY, USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
LIGHT LOVE and LIFE
Jewish law tells us not to place ourselves in danger, yet expects all of us to enhance G-d's light around the world, in every corner of the globe, to call to Judaism's 'lost souls'. Here is a perfect example of how brave and strong we need to be, in the face of danger, to constantly spread light, love and Jewish life into the homes of our fellows who are devoid of Torah guidance and life's blessings.
May G-d elevate the souls of this brave loyal and caring couple who impacted the lives of so many in this world and now beyond.
Posted By Dr. Chanah Butler (meyer), South Africa / Jerusalem, Israel

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Ahavas Chinam
The only way to battle senseless hatred is with senseless love. The Holtzbergs are a shining example of pure unconditional love for others. We will learn the lessons they have taught and this will be the greatest way to honor them.
Posted By Rochie, Behthesda, MD

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Tragedy in Mumbai
I see this tragedy has a reminder that there are people who are evil that want to hurt people that are good. People in the U.S. have short memories and treat 911 as a distant memory. The war on terror must continue and we should never undermine those willing to stand up to evil. We should never pander to people that want to destroy what is good in our world. Either you are with us in this fight or against us. There should be no wavering or pandering to terrorist. There is no excuse for these actions. We should all be united against terrorism. Judeo Christian values have been seriously violated !
Posted By Ken Gardner, Parkland, FL

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
God bless Jews
I didn't know the rabbi's family but i feel sad like every Jew in the world for this tragedy.

God bless Jews.
Posted By Michael , Paris, FRANCE

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
moshe
i wish i could take him home because deep inside i know how it feels to lose someone like that because my father died in a car crash. i wish a good life even though it will be hard
Posted By linda
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Deepest Condolances
Our deepest condolances to the whole Hertzberg family. Our prayers are for all of you and especially to little Moishele. We pray that he will recover and that Sarah Samuel will be a comfort to him and he to her.
Posted By Sema and Sam Stein, Niantic, CT/US
via chabadect.com

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Kiddush Hashem
Rabbi and Mrs. Hotzberg both lived and dies for the purpose of Kiddush Hashem: Sanctifying the Divine Name and Idea.

As a traditional/ Modern Orthodox Jew, I travel to numerous countries. I always check to see where the local Chabad House is, and understand my options for Shabbat, kosher meat, etc. This is Kiddush Hashem.

I do not subscribe to the beliefs held by some on Chabad about the Moshiach, politics, etc. But the role that Chabad plays -- to be the spiritual ambassadors of the Jewish people, often alongside the Israeli diplomatic presence, in place with little or no organized Jewish presence -- this is Kiddush Hashem.
Posted By David, teaneck, NJ

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
We weep with the entire Jewish community, especially the family and close friends of the wonderful and warm people who have been taken from us in this terrible event, people who did only good, helped mankind, helped fix the world, and we ask G-d, "Why?" Perhaps this is the incident that will awaken the whole world to realize what the Jews and Israel have been enduring for centuries at the hands of these terrorists while the world turns a blind eye to their suffering.
Posted By Robert A. Epstein, Houston, Texas/USA
via chabadtexas.org

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Sparks of Light
May the Divine light of G-d be caused to purify this world by the loss of the beautiful light taken from this world when Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka left it.
May their memory create many angels!
Posted By linda cucher

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
We Need More Jewish People In India
I am a US citizen and grew up in Bombay. My ancestral home is in Cochin, Kerala and I own a home in Jew Town there. I am a hindu by birth. I live in Florida now.

I am still overcome with sadness and also anger at what these people did to my beautiful city and to destroy so many innocent lives.

I have many Jewish friends and I feel sadness that in spite of living such peaceful lives in India without any persecution etc, that most of the Jews of India migrated to Israel.

I did my part and contributed what I could to the Chabad effort and this is my earnest plea to all my Jewish brothers and sisters globally.

Go to India. We love you and will always will do so. Rebuild the Chabad house and continue doing the great work. We cannot let some misguided people destroy our lives in India, Israel or anywhere else.

In the end, victory will be ours. Long live Israel and India.
Posted By ravi nair, lake worth, FL/USA
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
I will always pray for Moshe
My husband and my children and I lived in Mumbai for two years. We know the difficulty of making a life there. Just that they could make a life and have such an impact on so many speaks volumes. My youngest son, Nathanael, was born in Mumbai and will be two in a few weeks. Little Moshe will always be in my prayers as I think of how much his mother loves him. She hears him and will let him know her love for him. I think his name is amazing given the story of Moses. Bless you all.
Posted By Lisa Martinez, Westerville, Ohio
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Mumbai
As members of Chabad in TOBC for many many years, it brings us saddness to hear of this tragedy of this young couple and the other Rabbi. Chabad has brought us so much joy, support, love, spirit. Our Rabbi Lypzc and his wife Brochy have enriched our lives and so many others. We feel so connected to Chabad and the wonderful things they do around the world. Chabad has been so welcoming to us no matter how far away from home we have been. We have so much saddness about the slaying of these wonderful people. Our community as a whole and humanity have suffered a tremedous loss but we will do mitzvot in their name. Moshiach Now!
Posted By Barbara Greene, Plainview, NY,USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Mumbai
As members of Chabad in TOBC for many many years, it brings us saddness to hear of this tragedy of this young couple and the other Rabbi. Chabad has brought us so much joy, support, love, spirit. Our Rabbi Lypzc and his wife Brochy have enriched our lives and so many others. We feel so connected to Chabad and the wonderful things they do around the world. Chabad has been so welcoming to us no matter how far away from home we have been. We have so much saddness about the slaying of these wonderful people. Our community as a whole and humanity have suffered a tremedous loss but we will do mitzvot in their name. Moshiach Now!
Posted By Barbara Greene, Plainview, NY,USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
A few thoughts
I do not know the Rabbi and his wife. I am not a converted Jew but I have read Torah on my own for years now. Since this has happened, my faith in G-d, prayer and the need for Torah study has only strengthened. Peace and love to their little one, in particular, and their family in this trying time.
Posted By Anonymous, Milwaukee, WI
via chabadwi.org

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Baruch Dayan Emet
My heart bleeds over the tragedy in Bombay, India. Such a waste! I did not have the pleasure to know Rabbi and Rebbetzin Holtzberg, but somehow I can mourn them as family.
Posted By Zepporah-Mushka Berger, Durham, NC, Durham, NC/USA
via jewishraleigh.org

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Long live Moshe
I am an Indian (born Hindu, not very religious) and ashamed that we were not able to prevent the brutal killing of Moshe's parents. Moshe is the future of humanity and we stand as guilty for depriving him of his parents. I sincerely wish that Moshe would grow into a wonderful human being, his tears would turn into smiles, would be able to forgive us all and heal the world and make every one of us proud.
Posted By Keval, windsor, canada

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Solidarity and condolences
As an Indian, I wish to express my condolence to the Jewish community. I wish to express my solidarity with the Jewish community of India and beyond. The Jewish community has been part of the mosaic of my country India and their contribution to my city of Mumbai has been immense. I hope that the Jewish community always feels welcome in my city of Mumbai and in my country , India.
We have to stay united to win against the perpetraters of this dastardly crime.
I cannot express my grief at the loss of life of the Rabbi and his wife.
My thoughts and prayers are with their son.
May the almighty grant them peace.
Posted By Shenoy, Mumbai, India

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Condolences from an American-Muslim
I am an American-Muslim from Washington, DC and I wanted to express my deepest condolences to the Chabad and Jewish communities. This was an act of cowardly proportions and these men do not represent Islam. They thrive off of the exploitative brainwashings of extremist networks and they have no regard for life. My community here in the US tries so hard to represent an open and peaceful image of islam through our daily interactions with our colleagues and neighbors and we move forward ten steps in a year. The terrorists set us back 100s of steps in one day. I hope your community emerges stronger from this tragedy and i hope Muslims and Jews can work together in confidence, as children of Abraham. That will be far more damaging to the terrorists than any bomb we throw their way.
Posted By Anonymous, Washington, DC

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
To my Israeli friends !!!
I dont know if Israel and India have had a longstanding and a good relationship or not but I do know that we do have many many Israelis visit India. And they are always welcome to India !!! But I would like to see India a secure safe country to travel to and live in. I would like to see them take beautiful memories of india and its hospitality and share them back home. I felt very very sad for the millions of victims of the holocaust and i felt very sad also for the victims of the mumbai attack. These people are so terrible and sick.

If there is anything I can do to help lessen the lifelong pain, I shall be very glad to do. Forever.
Posted By Sangram , Bhubaneswar, India

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Hotzbergs Officiating at Wedding Photo
After watching, listening to, and reading endless reports of the Nariman House tragedy, the most poignant image to me was that of Rabbi & Rebbitzen Holzberg officiating at the wedding of one anonymous couple.

Who is this couple? Were they travelers through India? If so, why did they choose to get married at that time? Was it planned in advance, or, as the bride appeared in her spontaneously-planned attire, was it a spur of the moment decision? Did Gavriel and Rivka inspire them to make their relationship valid, while they were on vacation? Or, if they were living in Mumbai, did the Holtzbergs convey to them to importance of sanctifying one's relationship through marriage?

The devotion to the event that emanates from the faces of the humble rabbi and rebbitzen, as well as the anticipation that radiates from the couple, is telling. That they chose to get married in this simple manner, as opposed to the massive, obsessively planned, grand events that weddings have morphed into (& that oftentimes are the stuff of the proverbial wedding nightmare!) speaks volumes.

We don't know who the couple are, but we do know this: that something about the Holtzberg's inspired them. And now this couple will forever live with the joy and blessings that such a selfless Rabbi and Rebbitzen performed their vows.
Posted By Elisheva, Los Angeles, CA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Community
May all the love and support to Moshe enable him to grow into something great in response to this tragedy. Through such pain can come a great light to fight off evil.

My condolences to the Chabad community for their great loss. I love going to Chabad and I know how much they bring to the world. I can thank them for my deeper understanding of Judaism.
Posted By Amy Altman, Richmond, Va

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
To YOU my G-d
I am sorry for all bright lights that were lost during this tragedy, during tragedies before. When, oh when will You, Our G-d, will notice our sufferings????!!! When You, Our G-d will collect the debt that is long overdue !!!!!!!!??????
Posted By Anonymous, los angeles , CA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Sad
May their names be for a blessing and may all those who mourn be comforted! this is just heartbreaking!
Posted By Anonymous, Richmond, VA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
WHY???
We can ask why but there just is no answer. This is simply the worst type of tragedy and the steps that the Jewish people take to fight this egregious threat I fully support and I'm sure all honest, compassionate and decent human beings do as well. The world, especially the Jews, are again dealing with subhuman, animal-like beasts. These beasts are the real untermensches. Despite their grief, the Jewish people should stand strong and unite together in peace and harmony in their own land once again. It's very pleasing and beautiful to see so many caring people from all walks of life come together and demonstrate that this world is not really so ominous but rather full of hope. G-d should bless all of you who want to make this world a better place. Lets take a lesson from this tragedy and show these animals our strong resolve by doing acts of kindness in the name of the rabbi. They were so beautiful. The soul's of the rabbi and his wife should continue to rise higher and higher HY"D.
Posted By Evan Honigsfeld

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
What to say?
There is nothing to say.... G-d has certainly taken some of our best, My prayer is for some immediate good to come from this. They were young, vibrant, optimistic and so good for the community...

The world should point their fingers at the evil that has caused this and bring forth much light.
Posted By Anonymous, West Saint Paul, MN

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Non-representative Muslims
I don't write this in the heat of the moment nor with any malice, however, to say that these acts perpetrated by Muslims in the name of Islam is not what Islam is about may be true theoretically, but it just doesn't ring true. Not until Islamic leaders, Imams and others en-mass publically distance themselves from similar acts and say so categorically, will statements that they are not representative of Islam impress or mean anything. If what you say is true, why do we constantly see similar acts repeated time and again in the name of Islam?
Posted By Kashrut, Melbourne, AUSTRALIA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Non-representative Muslims
I don't write this in the heat of the moment nor with any malice, however, to say that these acts perpetrated by Muslims in the name of Islam is not what Islam is about may be true theoretically, but it just doesn't ring true. Not until Islamic leaders, Imams and others en-mass publically distance themselves from similar acts and say so categorically, will statements that they are not representative of Islam impress or mean anything. If what you say is true, why do we constantly see similar acts repeated time and again in the name of Islam?
Posted By Kashrut, Melbourne, AUSTRALIA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Unarmed in a Terrorist-ridden World
Jews and Chabad emissaries in particular should know how to use handguns. G-d forbid, but don't think this won't make other emissaries possible targets; they are too easy to find. May we all do more mitzvot, give charity, pray and learn to use guns. I keep one handy in my home and when I travel. Call me a redneck Jew, but I can defend myself AND you!
Posted By Elisa, North Port, Florida

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
so sorry
I am so upset with the human race. Is there no heart, is there no thoughts, is there no remorse? G-d be with them always, and G-d stay with us, we need you to guide us to greener pastures.
Posted By Ellen, PA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
No words
This is a tragedy on a universal scale, and yet all too personal. Please G-d bless all the victims of the Mumbai massacres and let little Moshe have a blessed, happy life full of joy and inspiration from the example of his parents, whose own beautiful lives were cut short tragically and senselessly.

This is a hole that will never be filled.
Posted By Alan Loren, New York, USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
True Heroes
Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka were true heroes. They gave their lives spreading education and Judaism...great people who I wish I had met. My husband and I join everyone in mourning these beautiful human beings in this senseless, barbaric act of hate and terrorism. May their Jewish souls be blessed and may they be remembered for their mitzvot.
Posted By Yohana, Milford, MA/USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Mumbai Massacres
How sad and heartbreaking for all, this shows me that we are not safe anywhere in the World!!!!
Posted By Gerald Cohen-Napole, Pawleys Island, USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
I have no words only tears and faith.... Today we are all Chabad...
Posted By Talyah, Boca Raton, FL

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
So sad
May G-d avenge their blood. In order to counteract the evil and terror with which the terrorists inflicted onto this world, I take upon myself to learn Sefer Hamitzvos until 19 Kislev.
Posted By Chana, Montreal, Canada

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Mourning
I am praying for their holy souls and for the welfare of their child.
Posted By Catholic Guy, Detroit, MI

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
As if they were my own children.
My heart aches and I have cried as though they were my own children. Please accept my deepest condolences. May their memory be blessed Shalom
Posted By Ariel Avraham, champion, MI
via chabadwi.org

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
There are simply no words . . . our dear colleagues, brother and sister, Rabbi Gabi & Rivka Holtzberg have been murdered.
They lived the ultimate of self-sacrifice, culminated their physical lives down here on this earth with the true sanctification of G-d's name - being murdered simply because they were Jewish.
The voices of Rabbi Gabi & Rivka’s blood “is crying to me from the ground” (Genesis 4:10).
At a time so painful like this, we cannot remain silent . . we cry out to G-d and ask him to bring the pain and suffering to and end, bring an end or exterminate all fanatic terrorist, and send us our righteous Moshaich, who will usher in an era of peace and tranquility to this world.

We mourn the loss of modern-day heroes and us at Chabad, we resolve to grow strong and continue to stand as the beacon of light for the Jewish world today.
Rabbi Levi, Rivky & Chayaleh Gansburg. May G-d avenge your blood, and may your memories be a blessing.
We are crying along with all Israel.
Posted By Uzziel Zeev, Toronto, Ontario

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
For Elisa - I don't consider you a "red neck Jew", but rather an AMERICAN who will defend himself and his family and each one of us through the Second Amendment. May G-d bless you and welcome those who were slaughtered in India.
Posted By John, Tamarac, FL

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
find peace of heart
May G-d give favour twith our departed Jewish family, and may peace be with the families of the departed. May G-d sending an angels to guard our people through-out the world until we all return to our Home and the Temple is built to Praise our G-d. We pray that that all Jewish people meet again in Jerusalem at G-d's appointed time. .
Posted By Charlie Abraham Wright, Kuala Lumpur , Malaysia

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
make another spark flare
A tragedy beyond the human tongue. Yet Chabad's, our, reaction is not for vengeance but for mitsvah...not for blood but for goodness. I'm so proud to be a Jew!
Posted By Dr. Maurry Epstein, Montreal, Canada

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
How cruel could people be?
This is a tragedy for all Jews around the world. May we only get stronger and defeat the terrorist purpose. United we stand! My condolenses to the families and friends and all associates of Chabat. We all feel the pain. May the children of the terrorist feel our pain in 100 fold. Amen!
Posted By Fay, Valley village, ca/usa

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Standing in Unity
The tragedy in Mumbai has deeply touched me. On Sunday, as a Christian pastor, I addressed the issue of the great evil that is in the world, sharing with two congregations the story of the Holtzbergs and reading from one of Rabbi Freeman's articles on their tragic death.
At the end of the services, I lit a candle, praying to G-d that we did this act "in defiance of the darkness" that is in the world, and committing ourselves to being bearers of light.
May G-d continue to bless the work of Chabad Lubavitch in Mumbai, and may the blessed memory of the Holtzbergs inspire us all to greater service and devotion to G-d.
Posted By Rev. Jim Thompson, NC, USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Blessed Memory
As a mother/parent , I can imagine wanting to shield my child from harm..is this what happened..Perhaps little Moshe had to crawl out from under...he was found with much blood on him.
Blessed is the nanny who took action to save this little one who will now be a very 'famous; orphan in the orphanage that his grandparents operat facilitate in Israel..
I am so sorry for our loss.
Posted By gloria maria

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Why?
I have been absolutely heartbroken by this tragedy. How is it possible for human beings to be so ruthless, so completely devoid of compassion and humanity? I cannot imagine the terror and pain those poor people must have gone through during those terrible hours. And that little child---Moishe--what scars will he bear from this terrible ordeal? I pray to G-d that this terrible experience be erased from his mind. And I hope that his poor parents at least had the comfort of knowing, before they died, that their little one had been salvaged from the carnage! I cannot bear to write anymore.
Posted By Talia, Studio City, CA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
tragedy
this is a tragedy of incomprehensible dimension - based on the confession of the one terrorist captured alive their goal was to murder at least 5,000 innocent souls-so thank G-d they were prevented from accomplishing that - the Rabbi and his wife were indeed magnificent young people whose lives will be sorely missed- but so will the others whose lives were taken as mercilessly and brutally within the confines of the Chabad house and their names should be memorialized as well - I also feel that showing the photo of the survivng terrorist does noone but the murderous people who planned this horrific act any good- his face and name should be removed to let him remain anonymous in his depravity- Another unmentioned tragedy exists here- the Holtzbergs recently had a child die of Tay Sachs disease and another who is living with it in Israel- I wonder whether they had genetic counseling? My prayers,sympathy, and condolences go out to the families of all those whose lives were taken.
Posted By Claire, Fl ,USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Condolences from my Indian dental student
I called my dental student at the University of PA to ask if she had family in the area, and her family thankfully lives in Bangalore about 700 SE of Mumbai. She thanked me for my call, but expressed her deep sadness that Jews had been attacked. She is an Indian Christian (a very small minority in India) and she believes in the Biblical injunction that one should be kind to G-d's Chosen people, and so was very distraught about the attack on the rabbi and his family. I didn't know them personally, but I extend me deepest sympathy to them and their community.
Posted By Rachel Garber, Phila, PA USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
WHY?
Having been involved with Chabad for quite sometime, I have come to realize that the Shlichim who run Chabad house everywhere, are the most giving and most beautiful people I have ever met. this saddens me so much. There are no words to describe the loss and anger and sadness.
Posted By Batya, Rancho Cucamonga , Ca

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
May G-d be with you
So sorry to learn of the atrocities done in Mumbai and more innocent people killed without any mercy.
These animals will surely suffer as they have made so many suffer for their insane beliefs that lead to useless murders of families and young children. My heart goes out to Moshe, he should lead a normal life after such a traumatic event in his young life. He should know how much he is loved and cared for in a time that must be confusing and difficult for him.
May Rabbi Holzberg and his wife Rivka rest in peace knowing that their child will be well looked after and may they dwell with the angels in heaven.
Posted By Talia, San Francisco, CA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
The actions of these cowardly sub-humans will only encourage other groups to do the same thing...unfortunatly, I think this is only the beginning...We must be vigilant, strong, brave and get ready to fight for our lives..With G-d's blessing, we will prevail as we have for almost 6,000 years...love our brothers and sisters no matter what their observance level is and G-d will make us victorious over our enemies and may the innocent blood of those martyrs in Mumbai be avenged quiclkly and with no mercy.
Posted By Shlomo Leibish, USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Still Crying
Baby Moishe,
I pray for you that
G-d will make whole that which
has been
torn apart
I pray that you will
remember
your parents' arms
a circle of warmth
of healing
and forget
what you saw after
their souls ascended
doves above the slaughter
I pray that the courage of
Sandra Samuel
will give birth to
courage for you
and that the love
she showed
will be
your legacy
I pray they will teach you
the ancient prayer
Yisgadal v'yisgadash ....
and to say it
without bitterness
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Once again
It never fails me that no matter what the cause, who the fighting parties are, what part of the world, if there is a Jew in the area then there is a target of opportunity. What in the world could these children of God had done to deserve this fate. What will there little son do when calls for MOMMY. How will he ever enjoy a birthday knowing that his parents were murdered the day before?
Posted By David M. White (US Army Retired), Spokane Valley, WA. USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
I am so saddened
Having enjoyed the hospitality of Chabad in Boston and the company of a Chabad rabbi in Israel, I find myself with a heavy heart filled with grief regarding the attacks in Mubai. May the memories of those who died at the Mubai Chabad Center be eternal.
Posted By Anonymous, Katrineholm, Sweden

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Why?
Genesis 12:3: CURSE THOSE THAT CURSE ISRAEL: "And I will bless them that bless thee and curse him that curseth thee; and in thee shall all nations of the earth be blessed."

Bomb the Al Queda mamzers back into the stone age!
Posted By William Clarke, Opunake, NZ

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
May the Quiet Voice Be Loud Once again
I know the Chabad Mantra is for Moshiach and we need him - Now. Once again heretics are at our doorstep. May our prayer be answered and may justice be brought to those that have tried to steal more light from this world. May their souls be protected with our other souls that were taken for Kedushat Hashem (the sanctification of G-d’s name).
Posted By a loving soul

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Terrible tradgedy
Myy heart is saddened for the loss of these precious souls. I send my heartfelt condolences to the families and pray that G-d gives them strength to cope. May Moshe have a long and happy life and fulfil the Torah commandments that was so tragically unable to be compleed by his pious parents, may the righteous be remembered for a blessing.
Posted By Anonymous, Toronto, Canada

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
India,no longer a second home for jews..
For years, jews felt that India is their second home. So friendly and so native.
But the attack on Chabad Rabbi make us to think otherwise.

My heartfelt condolences to Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg and Rivika who lost their lives at Nariman House in Mumbai.

The two year old Moshe Holtzberg symbolises that hope is eternal.
Glorified and sanctified be G-d's great name throught the world which he will renew, reviving the dead and raising them to life eternal;
Posted By D.Siva Rami Reddy, hyderabad, india

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Mumbai
Steve Finson wrote:
>We cannot fathom the intensity of this
>tragedy until we understand why people
>murder each other.This is not why we
>are here.

With the greatest of respect, evil murdered these good people and we do not need to know 'why'. To "understand why people murder each other" is not what G-d and His Torah demand. Rather, we are divinely commanded to drive the evil from our midst -- It matters not a whit why these good and holy Jews died in this fashion.

On the other hand, Jews around the world are reacting in ways that honor G-d and his teaching. Acting ethically and with chesed, especially following such evil, is the greatest testament to G-d.

Peace be upon you,
Posted By Michael Peterson, Sammamish, WA
via chabadissaquah.com

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
demand condemnaton from UN and other coutnries
Pressure officials at the UN and your government officials to support an official condemnation on terrorism and especially clergy sanctioned violence and suicide bombers. we must react immediately and spread the stories of the tragedy far and wide and recognize that this is another cog in the wheel of hatred felt in so many countries in communities in this world. Let us create a more compassionate world to counter the evil tying to erode it the memory of my friends brother and niece, The Scherr from Baltimore is a tragedy among thiese victims , whose lives were sustained on loving and peaceful relatonships. My daughter spent shabbat with the Hotsbergs in Mumbia last year when she worked for AJWS an spoke of how special there were. And the heroes of thei tragedy should be brought before the world courts to testify against those who created the terror. Let us honor the heros and condemn the terrorist.
Posted By Sondra, Baltimore, MD/USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
My prayers
My blessings go out to the victims of these evildoers.
Posted By Paul , Los Angeles, CA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Strength to carry on
What a waste of human life. That goes without saying. May their souls live on in the way G-d has decreed that they do.

To the families and survivors who must live with this-may G-d give you the strength you need to carry on. May your lives be as normal as possible.

For little Moishe- who will someday learn of why his folks were no longer here to see him and help him grow-may he be reared as his mother and father would have wanted with people who have the strength to teach him not to live with hate in his heart. May he know love and laughter and the ability to cry when needed and be able to smile. May he recall a little of his folks thru his own memories and remember that they were not saints but human beings who did the best they could while on earth and loved him very much, May G-d give him special strength to carry on.
Amen
Posted By Laura Mushkat, schenectady, new york

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Mumbai
It seems that once we are settled into our daily routines, that we think nothing can startle us. How wrong we are. Thanskgiving Day turned into a Day of Mourning . Even though this horrific attack took place thousands of miles away, in a distant land, the horror of what unfolded on t.v. was unbelievable. How dare they? How dare they? And, yet they did. Mumbai will recover, but the lives snuffed out by these brutal demons will forever impact the rest of the living. I wept bitterly for all that were lost. I think some of the best words I heard were from a young Jewish man, one of the lucky ones who managed to escape the hotel. It went something like this..."We will not let this change us, we will not let these terrorists make us afraid, intimidate us, our lives will not change. In fact we should all be buying plane tickets to Mumbai right now. We will show them they can not win."

Our condolences to all who were lost.
Posted By Cindy, Ft. Towson, OK, USA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
hope
The heaviness in my heart remains, but the promise of a light in the brutal darkness comes from the words of the many Muslims, Hindus and Christians who believe as I, an observant Jew do, that only when we all join together in the common cause of peace and acceptance, will we once again be able to experience humanity on earth. Please, everyone, have the courage to stand by your words, and together, let us build a world of peace.
Posted By Anonymous, W. Hempstead, N.Y.

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Hakoras hatov
The initial appropriate response to this is silence as we learn from Aaron Hacohen (the High Priest) as it says in the Holy Torah that he kept silent upon the untimely death of his sons.
I feel like I have lost family members, even though I have never met Rabbi and Reb Holtzberg.
The only suitable consolation would be to have the resurrection of the dead right away, and the Holtzbergs and other martyrs can be reunited with their loved ones.
Posted By Benjamin, brooklyn, New York

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Tragedy in Jewish community in Mumbai
We are deeply, deeply saddened to hear of this terrible tragedy among the Jewish community in Mumbai.
Posted By The Churchman family. Durban. S.Africa

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Thank You and Condolences
Thank you and condolences to the wonderful people of India who have suffered so much from Islamic terror and yet have shown such tolerence to the minorities, especially the Jewish people.
May the Al-Mighty bless your nation, shield it from any pain and tribulations and grant success in your fight against the evil-doers.
Posted By Anonymous, new york, usa

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
They are so cruel.
Posted By Rivkah

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
We will not be deterrred
The Chabad emissaries around the world will not be deterred in their efforts. This movement has helped energize observance and reignite flames of Jews around the world, including me. The world is a better place because of the work of Lubavitch emissaries around the world and we all need to help this movement however we can.
Posted By Anonymous, New York, NY

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Tears in the Eyes of a Gentile
I did not know Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg , but I have now shed tears several times over the past days for them and their family and their precious son. Every time I look at pictures of the boy I am truly stricken with grief for him and for all the people of Israel. My prayer is that this boy will grow up strong and mighty in the land of Israel, and may his heart be healed of this evil crime by the enemies of Judah and Israel.

May God restore, heal, and protect the people and land of Israel.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
India carnage
Yes, I too am very sad about what happened to the Holtzbergs -- and sad for the children they left behind. But, I am equally sad for all the other families that have been torn apart in these (and other) senseless acts of terrorism. Why are they not mentioned more herein? As Jews, we can not forget these others -- especially the brave men who lost their lives trying to end this carnage -- only to be shot and killed through their "bullet-proof" vests. They all have a place in my heart and in my prayers. They deserve equal time from all of us!
Posted By Molly, Los Angeles, CA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
My condolences
Tears fall from my eyes as I write this. I am a mother and a grandmother. A Jew and an Israeli. A Chabadnick who tried to live according to the teachings of the Rebbe. I will not be at the funeral though all I want to do is to go. Instead I will be teaching a small class of women in a class that I give every Tuesday..this class will be dedicated to their memory. Why did it happen, I am in no place to understand why thngs happen only to realize tht to conquer the darkness we must bring light. A young man stopped by my house to say Psalms only because his life was saved by the Holzbergs. He was "off the path" no interest in anything but being "high" He learned from them what really being high is. They gave him back his life. We must all follow in their example to defeat the darkness. May their memory be for a blessing.
Posted By Alizah Hochstead, Efrat, Israel

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Horrible
I ' an Indian living in Mumbai,. I am not Jewish. I am deeply shocked and hurt. Jews have lived in peace and safety in India for at least a thousand years; this must be the first instance of the organised killing of Jews. My heart goes out to all Jews everywhere.By becoming victims along with my countrymen, they have become my family. I shall make it a point to visit Chabad House frequentlly after it resumes functioning.
Posted By Gowri Shankar, Mumbai, India

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Very sad
I am so saddened by the senseless destruction of this young Rabbi's family. As a father, my heart goes out to their young son (Moshe I believe) and the folks now taking care of him. I pray that God give them the courage and strength to overcome this terrible ordeal.
Posted By Prakash Siva, Petaluma, CA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Moishe
I broke into tears when i heard the news about Moishe. never expected that jews would be the target. My love for Moishe, forget not, G-d loves you so much.
Posted By Shalem

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Senseless killing Mumbai
I have sent messages to many Muslim and Christian families. I ask them to help stop the growing hate in my heart for people who are so intollerant as to resort to murder. I beg one Muslim friend to stand up and make a statement against this kind of horror. I find their silence so loud and clear.
My heartfelt sympathies to the families of the victims of such senseless killings. When will the world stand up and support a resolution condemning suicide and other terrlorist attacks on innocent people a CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY. They are not winning friends but creating enemies.This is GENOCIDE and the victims are anybody who does not subscribe to their beliefs. I am fearful for the future generations. If we dont make a change we will have let all the children and grandchildren a bleak future.
People in different coutries should take full page advertising space and fill it with the people who are not afraid to publicly disclaim the evil being perpetrated around the world.
Posted By Rachel seskin, Johannesburg, S. Africa

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
This is very sad for me and everyone.
I don't know what I have to tell and write down about it. Every day each way of the world attack by terrorists or by violence. When I heard the news about two person of chabad killed by terrorist. Make me sad and make me sad. I pray for their parents and god kill the terrorists. That's my words I can tell.
Posted By Mehran Jackmehr Morad, Los Angeles, Ca

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Condolences
I will enclude Chabad India in my prayers.

Sgalom from Berlin.
Posted By Matt, Berlin, Germany

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
May their memory be for a blessing
My heart goes out to your family and to all Chabad and to all of us who felt this tragedy as ours as well...May we know no more such sorrow. And may the world always know the blessings of such people as the Rabbi and Rivky.
Posted By Frances, Tel Aviv

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Artwork honoring the Holtzberg
To honor the lives of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg murdered in Mumbai, I am creating a memorial artwork Rotate Light Before Darkness / גולל אור מפני חשך that will be shown in the “Darkness to Light” exhibition on Chanukah at Emunah College in Jerusalem, travel to museums worldwide, and be accessible as an Internet artwork.

I am inviting synagogues throughout the world to collaborate in creating this digital artwork in which morning tefilah will be seen beginning in Jerusalem and circling around the global.

Please send a photograph of weekday morning tefilah in your shul to melalexenberg@yahoo.com as a jpg image. Since it is already Kislev, I would greatly appreciate receiving your photograph as soon as possible so that the computer-generated artwork will be ready for the Chanukah exhibition in Jerusalem.

Thank you,
Menachem Alexenberg, Professor of Art and Jewish Thought at Emunah College in Jerusalem.
Posted By Professor Menachem Alexenberg, Jerusalem, Israel

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Deeply Saddened
Words cannot express my profound sorrow for all members of our beloved chabad. My rabbi attended school with this rabbi who was murdered in Mubai. I have experienced such warmth and acceptance for both me, and my autistic son through the gracious members of our chabad in Annandle, NJ. They have gone out of their way to show us kindness, and what it truly means to be a member of the Jewish community. For such souls to be taken in this mindlessly brutal manner, is beyond all rational thought. Though my dear rabbi would counsel me to reflect upon my thoughts, I can't but look to the United States and to Israel as to their response. May it be a wise and just one.
Posted By Madelynne Miller, Clinton, NJ/USA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
This tragedy has me in tears daily. I am sad to admit that it took this to call me out of a stupor that started with many personal difficulties this year. Rivka's example in life, as exemplified by so many stories and comments, was one I did not know for myself this year until this happened. It was stunning to me that the Rashi for this week's parsha (Toldot) included that Rivka (our matriarch) had encouraged her son Yaacov and told him she would take any curses in a manner which exhibited the nature of women to shield their children from any harm, even at their own peril.

I can only hope that I am able to live up to not only that but the example of keeping positive, open, and hospitable, even during times of personal difficulty. I can only imagine what was through her mind. I am so sorry she did not see that her Moishele survived.
Posted By Anonymous, Westminster, CO

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Angels of G-D
Angels are messengers of the God / /
Every religion and it's angels Repa-el and Ari-el.

Angels are messengers for justice and tidings missions / /
To the birth of boys and to the work of poetry.

Angels are guards of every herb and every beast / /
They are people in the semblance,
But with different spirit, other means for creation.

Angels are gate to God, to the humans-either rich or poor / / angels to their task created, and once it done- they destroyed.

So atrocious destruction, annihilation without bridle / /
Made helpless orphans with no merci .

How come the God's scales of justice broke down//
Dying in pain while terrorist counting down.

Please, preserved on us, messengers of people in the sky / /
Rebecca and Gabriel the angels from Israel Jerusalem.
*******************
A sad day to all pepole of israel.

the written above is a translate of a hebrew poem written when the bad news arrived..

Posted By Avihai (Even) Ben Naim, ASHEQELON, ISRAEL

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Building for the future
Cape Town, South Africa held a unity evening last night, where over 200 Jews gathered together and listened to words of strength delivered by Rabbi Goldman and Rabbi Derrin. Everyone thereafter took upon themselves Mitzvos in order to beseech mercy from G-d and to bring more light into this apparently dark world at present.

The Holtzberg's and all those Jews who unfortunately passed on to the next world are heros of Israel who are inspiring all of us to serve G-d and move forward by building stronger foundations in Torah observance.

They are all truly missed!
Posted By Eitan Kagan, Cape Town, South Africa

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
terrorist attack
i am very sad
i cry at different times of the day thinking of these wonderful people
G-D BLESS MOSHE
Posted By Anonymous, new york, ny,usa

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Mumbai tragedy
Having enjoyed the hospitality of Chabad Houses in Los Angeles, it is especially painful to feel the loss of such kind and gentle people like Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg and his wife Rivka. May they rest in peace forever, and bring joy and happiness to those in heaven above.
Posted By Ira Trattner, Tel Aviv-Jaffa, Israel

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
i am so heartbroken
I am a grandmother of many and one of these precious souls is in heaven with G-d. It is because of these precious souls that torah mitzvos and judaism is in my life serving mitzvos and learning more. The role of these delicious humans THE HOLTZBERGS is the reason many souls return to G-d with love compassion and a true heart. They were too young to be counted among the departed souls but they were. They will always be part of my life and memory for being able to remember my role in G-d’s world and to know the reminder of the truth can only be set by following the laws of the Torah...
I do not seem to be so blessed with loving those who do bad things in this world but am so blessed to be connected to the race of people who set standards higher than most in the world.....G-d’s world...
Posted By sara rifka, toronto

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Deepest sympathy
In the end good will triumph. It now seems this is the hour of darkness but the Lord has the whole world in His hands. Do not buckle under this evil, be sad yes; this is a devestating tragedy but don't let you'r hearts be hardened, this is the mystery between free will and the ever merciful providence of Him Who Loves us. May the good Lord give comfort and console all who's hearts are broken by this; the worst kind of evel man is capable of. We all mourne at your horrific loss. - Rene (a Catholic from Ireland)
Posted By Mrs. Rene O'Riordan, Dublin, Ireland

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Kiddush Hashem
No doubt the sanctification of G-d's name they did in India and being selfless in their mission. Chabad always is this way and we have much to learn from them. They have many merits and I ache inside about their loss especiallly for their parents and son Moishe. Their place in India was a home away from home for others who need direction or just a warm place. There is no doubt the good they did there while compromising. I wish their famiilies the courage and strength at this time.
Posted By NAB, Beit SHemesh, Israel

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Never Again!
All muslims aren't terrorists, but all terrorists are muslims.

The terrorists want to murder Jews and others.

Who will avenge their deaths?
Posted By Anonymous, Cleveland, OH/USA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Condolences
May He who makes peace comfort all those who mourn for these martyred souls along with all those who mourn for Zion.

It grieves me greatly when any star in the universe of Israel is extinguished.

I feel so inadequate for the task of combatting such evil and call upon all my fellow Jews to do what they can to combat evil in their own sphere of influence and to redeem the world from such horrors and human atrocities by doing mitzvos and practicing charity to the strangers within our gates.
Posted By Bryan Shane, Toledo, OH/USA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Arming Rabbis
All Chabad Rabbis and employees in Chabad houses outside of Western countries, should be trained in self defense, and in the use of weapons.

Today, there are no longer hostages, but victims of terrorists who intend to kill until there last breaths. If we learn that the new Islamic extremists have no intention of freeing any hostages, all terrorists should be confronted with immediate opposition, whether the victims are armed or not. Violent opposition to terrorists by hostages, will serve to deter future Chabad house attacks.The nazis like their modern counterparts (Islamic extremists) had no intention of ever freeing their Jewish captives. Thus, violent opposition to any hostage situation today, is a worthy alternative to certain death, of inaction.
Posted By Mark Carmel, Wellington, Florida

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Time to unite
With a heavy heart, I am writing this. I am neither a Jew nor a Christian but a Hindu and Indian by birth but currently an American living in US. I feel as if I have lost a family member and would like to apologize for what has happened in the country that I love. I sincerely hope we the people will not allow cruel people to win and express my strong feeling that there cannot be a more critical time for us to unite and tackle the menace. May the souls of everyone who lost their lives, rest in peace.
Posted By Anonymous, Birmingham, AL, USA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Tragedy
I want to express my deepest sorrow for the victims of this horrible tragedy. I also want to express my gratiitude to Chabad for the wonderful Passover that I had in Rome 25 years ago in Rome when I was a medical student in Italy, far away from my family. Chabad allows Jewish people to connect to their roots all over the world. I have always been grateful for the generosity and kindness shown by Chabad and the sacrifice made by its Rabbis.
Posted By Mitchell, Hermitage, US

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
The weak and the strong
Chabad in India, like everywhere else is a force for good. It does not harm. It helps. These are people who read books and do acts of charity. They are not warriors. So naturally, they are targets.

A few weeks before, Islamic forces paid $1,300 for each teenage girl in Afghanistan who received a face burning with acid. The purpose: to teach them not to go to school.

What does one do with people like that? Reason does not work. They are enemies of reason, enemies of education, of enlightenment, of humanity, and of God. How many innocents must suffer until justice finally is served?

Chabad will not be burned away by terrorism.

Remember Akiva's words as he also was a victim of terrorism: "My dear children, do not mourn over me! I have attained what I wished for most, the sanctification of God's Name."

Fire did not destroy the Torah, terrorism will not stop the good works of Chabad.
Posted By Edward M. Roche, New York, NY

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
So tragic
Baruch Dayan Emes - may the souls of the Rabbi and his wife and other Jewish victims rest in peace.
Chabad have helped us many times and in many places. May you continue to spread the light of Judaism all over the world, without fear.
Posted By Rivka and Eliezer

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Humanities Crossroad
This is profoundly upsetting. While we wipe the tears of shock and disbelief, we must also remember that holocausts are happening all over the globe, to all peoples, all species, to Mother Earth herself.
We MUST NOT allow ourselves the comfort of revenge as we see it back-firing in Iraq, a nation that had NOTHING to do with the attacks on the WTO. We must never call for acts of violence that end up causing MORE innocent deaths of men, women, children, animals, as we see happening ALL over the globe.
We are never to jump to the conclusion that extremists, "Islamists", or any media given reason or group is responsible as the media today is , in my opinion, inciteful, complicit, and unAmerican in protecting the real culprits who operate like proxy mercenaries .
As Jews, it is our duty and obligation to do the least harm and the most to heal and repair , alleviate suffering from our plates the perameters of possibility.
The world is calling for non-violent ways of living, eating, LIFE
Posted By Laura Aaron, Bartlett, NH

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
In Greivence
My husband and I celebrated our 25th wedding Anniversary this past shobbos. Although I am still saddened at what took place in Mumbai; I have to be thankful for the wonderful friends and relatives that we were gathered around. The Rabbi at the Chabad House where I attend services made a beautiful speech in regards to this horrific tradgedy. My family and I knew Gabriel when he was 11. His parents were our landlords and my 3 older children used to play with Gavriel and his siblings. My deepest condolences to the Holtzbergs as well as the Rosenbers. I'm glad that the Nanny got Moshe out safe Yasher Koach! This is the start of Moshiach coming our way. All the letters I have read were an inspiration. 30 years ago who would have thought that there would be so many people having a strong belief in G-d let alone converting. someone has once told me that Moshiach will be coming in economical straits.
Posted By Anonymous, Lauderhill, Florida

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
G-d Bless the souls of those murdered in Mubai
I pray that this horror spurs all Jews, no matter their affiliation, and all non-Jews--all thinking human beings, to see this as a human rights issue and finally stand up against the twisted scapegoating and hatred toward the Jewish people and Israel. Demand that the United Nations weed out anti-Semitic rhetoric and attitudes that they foster around the world-which now lead to the desk of the President of the General Assembly--appalling! These slanderers give cause and create fear & hatred in the minds of most of the world's population that has never even met a Jewish person! This has to stop. I urge every thinking person to look squarely at the subtle signs, the jokes, the loose comments in their own lives, and sadly, the distortions in children's history books, in art museums and even in travel books. See how the Jewish people, their contributions to the world's religions & cultures are being minimized and erased. A fertile ground for lashing out without recourse.
Posted By Anne Teush, New York City, NY - USA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
EXTOL THE G-D OF JACOB
Who can really go against the G-d of Jacob? He will triumph, all violence done against the Holy People and all men of goodwill is futile.
G-d allowed this for a divine purpose to glorify His Name, however difficult and painful it must be to divine that purpose right now.
Blessed be the G-d of Israel
I, a Gentile who loves the Jews, humbly bless Israel! I bless the peace of Jerusalem!
I humbly bless the Chabad martyr of Mumbai and his family his son. Wonderful holy person.
"Ye shall go out with joy and be led forth in peace, the mountains and the hills shall break forth before you...and all the trees of the field will clap their hands..."
I bless the beloved Jews, wonderful people! In the Name of G-d, amen and amen and amen!
Posted By Anonymous, manila, philippines

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Rabbi Holtzberg was a true example of a good Jew
I remember the Rebbe delivering a talk about how every word and every letter in the torah are exact.
And then the Rebbe said that the torah uses an extra word to describe an animal that is "not pure" instead of just getting to the point and saying "tamei"
The phrasing that the torah uses is a lesson to us how our language should always be pure and positive.
Then I read that Rabbi Holtzberg's final words to the Israeli consulate were "the situation is not good"
Even under duress Rabbi Holtzberg preferred to say "not good" instead of saying "bad"
To me that epitomizes the heart and soul of the Rebbe's shluchim, and makes the loss that much more unbearable.
Posted By Moshe G., Brooklyn, NY

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Zionism
Such a sad ending. This is a perfect tragic example why ZIONISM must remain strong in the Jewish Community. IF we forget, IF we give up more Israeli land back to the arabs, more tragedy will continue! Chabad has brought me back from being a passive Jew, to a very involved Zionist!! Thankyou Rabbi New! Chabad is the best! We will NOT forget you Gavi and Rivky!!
Posted By Joseph, Pompano Beach
via chabadbocabeaches.com

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Bless you
Chabad brings goodness and light into the world while these savages bring evil and darkness. Is it any wonder why Chabad would be a target? I sincerely hope that you will continue G-d's work of bringing Jews closer, but at the same time be vigilant against the forces of evil. I hope Chabad reinforces security at all its locations.
Posted By Reuben Weinstein, Newton, ma/usa

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
For all the innocent lives and for the beautiful souls lost in Mumbai we cry and pray
Posted By galla, Brookline
via russianboston.org

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Read more feelings on Aish.com
Read more feelings on Aish.com

Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Saints and Martyrs
Gavriel Holzberg, ZK"L, HY"D
Rivky Holtzberg, ZK"L, HY"D
Rav Bentzion Chroman, ZK"L, HY"D
Rav Leibish Teitelbaum, ZK"L, HY"D
Norma Schwartzblatt-Rabinowitz, ZK"L, HY"D
Yocheved Orpaz, ZK"L, HY"D

May the memory of the saintly be for blessing,
May G-d avenge their blood.
Posted By Lawrence Schmerel, Chattanooga, TN

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
I wanted to say how personally touched and moved and more importantly saddened I was by the events in Bombay. I think that we should pray more, give more charity and not to speak badly of others. This way as Jews, we can honor their memories. All Jews throughout the world should unite and try to help the family in any possible way. Let us never forget what happened.
Posted By Kevin Khodabakhsh, M.D., Oak Park, MI

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
Condolences from Rio de Janeiro Brazil
with our heart broken, our sympathy and condolences to chabad members, Holtzberg family and all the innocent people who died in those terrible days in India.
Posted By silene Balassiano in name of all Wizo's Rio de Janeiro Chaverot, Rio de Janeiro, Brasil

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
The Holzberg Family
Our family is saddened by the tragedy that occurred. Our thoughts and prayers are with the Holzberg family. My husband returned from Mumbai a week before the attacks and had been in the Taj Hotel. It could just as easily have been him who had been attacked and we are so thankful to
g-d that he is okay. Chabad has meant a lot to our famuly recently. My husband and I practice Conservative Judaism and our 3 sons have been relatively non-observant. Recently, my 28 year old son has become very involved with Chabad in the Philadelphia area. They have really embraced him and he has a new-found appreciation for Judaism. Thank you!
Posted By Anonymous, Maple Glen, PA

Posted: Dec 1, 2008
to our fellow brothers
We Catholics mourn the loss of our fellow brothers Jews in Mumbai.

May their families find strength and faith at this time. My heartfelt sympathy to all who are suffering now from this or any other act of terrorism and hatred.
Posted By Jesus Hernandez, Miami, Fl / USA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Gabi and Rivkah of blessed memory
Gabi and Rivkah endured personal suffering but selfelssly did Mitvot from morning to night. Their lives are an inspiration to us all. Moishe is an orphan but he has millions of aunts and uncles - the Jewish people. Please let us know how we can contribute to rebuilding Chabad House.
Posted By Eve, Jerusalem, Israel

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
The Loss of the Wonderful Rabbi and his Wife..
Although, I never met these two magnificent people, after everything I have read about their remarkable lives, I want to express my heartfelt sadness to their families. Especially their miracle child who survived, Moshe!!!!

May they rest in peace always with G-D!!!!
Amen...........
Posted By Miriam Jakubowitz, Philadelphia, PA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Bombay Tragedy
we should answer very soon, on the similar way, as we did after the Munich Olympic Games 1972..,, before they kill us one-by-one! But not the terrorists only, their mothers, fathers, children! as well. Our human rights feelings and our democratic feelings will kiill us one day. All this is a theater, we can not fight on other way against them. Believe me, I kmow, what I am saying...
Posted By Tom, Munich, Germany

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
tears
i don't know them personally, they were I'm sure the most wonderful people. My brothers are shluchim in the United States I know what a shaliach is... Maybe peeople should start looking out when they want to speak badly of others or do something bad to someone else -- how much they make people suffer! Why hurt others? The righteous suffer on the account of them...
Posted By rochel, kfar chasidim, isreal

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Condolences
I am so sorry for the loss of such a beautiful husband and wife. It's terrible that their beautiful son will have to grow up without his parents. Such a tragedy.
Posted By Anonymous, Woodstock, NY

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
How long shall the wicked rejoice?
Please, please take the time to read Tehillim/Psalms 94, the Song of the Day for Wednesday, perhaps not ironically the day that the Mumbai massacres started. We Jewish men almost always mumble our way through this psalm in a rush to take off our tefillin and get to work ... but the psalm deals with exactly these issues. King David asks G-d how long will the wicked rejoice, whether or not those who commit violence can in any way be associated with G-d, and what will become of the evildoers. May we all see G-d repay the murderers in kind, and then we will sing to G-d, the rock of our salvation.
Posted By Heshy, Long Beach, NY

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Holtzbergs
My deepest condolences to the Holtzberg family and the Chabad community.
Posted By John Kalinowski

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Condolences
when I read news about them it felt like family of a saint left world.. I am hindu and came thru this so wanted to post. I feel saddened by events. I am very impressed by Jewish culture and unity and sure about good future of their son..
Posted By Chirag, USA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka opened their hearts to others and cared for many. The horrible grief over seeing these two loving people slaughtered is too great. The horror of the evil ordeal is too great. Their lives were ended by those who embrace death, and yet this couple gave life with their abundant acts of kindness toward others. It is this love they gave which I hope to think of, even in the hours of grieving. May G-d bless and keep their children safe, held in arms of kindness and peace for all their days.
Posted By elaine , westport, CT

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Why was the Chabad House Targetted?
This question needs to be asked and perhaps answered by someone, even if the answer is unpleasant.

These terrorists knew exactly where, when and who they were after. Nothing they did in Mumbai was by mistake, so to speak. In other words, it does not seem that this was not a random act of Anti-Semitism.

Perhaps the Chabad Houses all over the world must speak up now and write to the public at large about their real mission, which is mainly to provide "a safe place" for people of all faiths and all manners of Jewish belief to experience Jewish Religion and Jewish Culture.

I think that many non-Jews do not understand that the Orthodox Community is quite varied in their approaches and levels of tolerance etc... It could be a good idea especially in light of these brutal attacks to stress some of these particular differences that I myself noticed in the Hasidic Community.
Posted By Dorothea, Berlin, Germany

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Response
Dear All, i believe we need to have a full satellite link up of all continents and express the Chanukah message of light and of Torah as " life is given to us, not to lift or point a finger, but to extend a hand to anyone and everyone in need. There are Seven universal Laws for all Mankind, that the Rebbe, the leading educator of morality in our time, asked us to spread world wide, so that there will be the rule of Law according to mercy and Justice and belief in One, the universal G-d, the G-d of Abraham, G-d of the Jews.
Extend a hand to help another in need, whoever they may be and save, in the Name of G-d, the magnificence of His diversity".
Posted By Yaacov Myers, Melbourne, VIc/Australia

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
HOPE!
Very sad indeed! But we must not lose hope... for no one can phanthom G-ds great purpose for humanity. What will be even more significant is to watch (in the coming years) what will come of their sons, or perhaps the next measures for that very chabad center?

Remembering the Holocaust our deaths were not in vain -- hence the great state of Israel could not have been born.

We are simply not to question WHY such things happen, but to continue to keep FAITH!

We must keep remembering that there is a grand purpose!
Posted By HOPE!, Kenosha, Wisconsin

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Where there is hate, sow love.
G-d is Love. When we are insulted and killed, I understand it to be our duty to remain silent, like dust.

We don't know all the details that has lead up to this horrific tragedy.

G-d is Truth, He knows the truth.
There is nothing that escapes the Eye of G-d, He seen everything.

This too will heal, somehow. Maybe not right now, but this too will heal.

We need to Love stronger and really love from the heart and try to really love each other. This could be anyone of us.

True Love will protect us.
Posted By Anonymous, Denver, Co

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Outrage/Numbed
Once again Jews were targeted and once again Jews were murdered. Once again women were put through uninmaginative circumstances prior to be murdered in front of their husbands by those creatures who believe in Islam. Once again others were murdered as well because they are "kaffirs". And once again a gentile took it upon herself to save a Jewish life.

Didn't the Holocaust teach us anything? When will we learn that the Muslim Brotherhood, the main partner of the Nazis is alive and healthy and creating this terror on innocents around the world? When do we say NO MORE and mean it?!

May Moshe's life be so different than our own in which he won't have to see the Amaleks (Nazis/Muslims) in his time. May his parents' memory never be forgotten.
Posted By Hinda, Petaluma, CA/USA
via jewishsonoma.com

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Never Again, yet it never ends.
I have listened to fellow Americans attack us. When possible I stop them in their tracks.

If I had an opportunity to take up a gun and help to erradicate ignorant hate and pointless martydom I would.

We sit back comfortable and safe, while our brothers and sisters go in harms way by just doing good.

Please let us know what we can do after we are finished wringing our hands over mindless acts against all of us.
Posted By Harry, Ft Myers, Florida

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Tragedy
I am not Jewish. But I have been to India and Mumbai many times. I am previously aware of the great work of Chabad Lubavitch; it has a fine reputation in India. It is ironic that many of the killed people in the senseless attack were people of peace and love. I, like you, struggle in my own head to work that out and hope God will provide answers. I wish you well and hope for a positive outcome to this very difficult time. God picks times like this to bring blessings.
Posted By Ted Wilson, Salt Lake City, Utah
via jewishutah.com

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
The tragic murders
The world will never change. Jews are hated and will continue to be targeted throughout the world. Only now, it is done in smaller increments but it is just a matter of time when more incidents will occur. The people that perform these acts of terror are pathetic and unhappy and will always look for blame. We are lucky to have Israel still viligilent but the terror will continue. It grieves me to say this but I believe it is true.
Posted By Anonymous, Vero Beach, FL
via jewishbrevard.com

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Did They Need to Torture Them and Affect The CHild
To hate with such depth that killing will not satisfy....no....they had to torture their victims as well. It saddens me even more to think what that t2 year old boy actually saw and experienced. Although he could not comprehend his experience, it will affect and haunt him forever. May G-d comfort and guide him throughout his life.
Posted By Jill ERichsen, NY

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
The Jewish Response
I too feel a great deal of anger, frustration, and resignation at the tragically misguided actions of an equally misguided group.

I am, however, equally gratified, proud, and appreciative at the peaceful, yet powerful, response of the Jewish Community to this outrage.

I fervently hope that this Response will further demonstrate to those who wish us harm our strength and resilience.

We will never forget our Fallen Heroes!
Posted By Danny Bobrow, Chicago, IL
via lubavitchchabad.org

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Our Hearts Are With You Moshe and Grandparents
Unfortunately we find ourselves in the midst of a new tragedy for the Jewish people. All I would like to do at this moment is take time to pray that G-d pour out his overwhelming mercy, comfort, peace, tranquility and love on baby Moshe that survived this unbelievable tragedy. To his family I pray for strength and serenity to move on and that they may be able to transmit the love and peace that this child needs to go on in life. May G-d bless you and keep you like he has done until now for the rest of your days, Moshe.

Love, The Ramos-Montanez Family
Posted By Sharon E. Montanez, 00735, PR

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
A few days passed by.....
With a few days passed by, I thought I would feel a little better, but I am afraid it has not been the case, there is not a minute of the day that I do not find my mind thinking about what has happened, I don't think months or years will change what I feel and many millions of us around the world I am sure will feel the same. There has to come a time were we as Jews say enough is enough, No More will we take this, this is not G-Ds will. Would it be G-Ds will to have people doing his work removed, murdered, slaughtered? No it would not, otherwise all we believe in as Jews would not be. I pray that we find the strength as a nation to unite for once and stand up to this and say NO MORE! This is a Holy war not only for Jews around the World but every so called "Infidel" as they these dirty cowardly evil disgusting terrorists refer to everyone that is non muslim. We should no longer wait for them to come to us, but we should go to them! lets not wait for another of our people to Die!
Posted By David Trepp, London, United Kingdom

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Words are not enough
No word can express the pain of rabbi family and families of hundreds of others who were slaughtered or injured.

These terrorists have no religion and they should be wiped out from the face of the earth.

My deepest sympathies to the rabbi's fmly and others. Hopefully Indian govt will wake up and will not let this go as another unfortunate incidence
Posted By Srikant, toronto, canada

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Why do Jews forget history? These murders are nothing new. Every Jewish installation in the world chould have security guards. The world puts precious little value on Jewish lives. We must look out for ourselves.
Posted By Rosalie Brosilow, Rehovot, Israel

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
My heart cries for Moshe
My sincere condolences for Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg and his wife, Rebbetzin Rivka Holtzberg. I pray that their son, Moshe gets all the love, care and comfort he needs from everyone around him. Everytime I see his picture crying for his parents, my heart yearns to comfort him. I wish that he gets the very best in life always. My prayers are with him.
Posted By Sonal, New Delhi, India

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
I can't express how sad I am right now. even though I`m not a Jew. but I really care for the human life. no human soul deserve to be slaughtered like this way. Not Jew or Christian or Muslim.
We need to live in a peaceful world.
Posted By Naglaa, Cairo, Egypt

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
G-D bless the family, Chabad and all Jews
I am very sorry for your loss. These are wonderful people who continue to do great things through inspiration and I'm sure Moshe will do great things. I spent many Shabbosos in Chabad in Boston and the warmth, learning and greatness is always evident. I love Chabad and they do some of the greatest work in the world. May there be goodness for all the family, Chabad, all Jews and all of G-d's children and some day we'll all be reunited with the coming of Moshiach, may it be soon.
Posted By Rich, Boston, MA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Our hearts go out to you all
What can a human being say but that evil again showed it's ugly head, and we all pray for the family of the murder victims that G-d will give them peace. My family is Catholic, and I will go to church this week and pray for the Jewish people that they will be given some rest from relentless war against them by the Islamic world.
Posted By Bill, CA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Condolences from an Indian
I am an Indian. I am deeply saddened by the Rabbi and his wife’s death.
I hope you all can build a thousand Chabads in India, because I have been living in the United States for 18 years and wherever there are Jewish People, there is prosperity. I like the Jewish People.

I pray to G-d for Rabbi and his wife (don't under stand why the "O" is hyphened”)
Quick Question: Can anybody become an orthodox Jew? I will appreciate an answer from somebody.
Sincerely,
Posted By Percy Lazarous, Virgina, USA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
For the Rabbi and his Wife and...
The Rabbi and his wife and for all our brothers and sisters murdered in the criminal attack in Bombay -- may their memories be blessed. We had a special kadish for them in our synagogue in Guatemala City, and we are really sad. May G-d Bless them for ever.
Posted By Hannah Cohen, Guatemala, Guatemala

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
May there be abundant peace from Heaven
In the aftermath of such tragedy, let us not lose sight of the meaning behind this prayer in Jewish scripture:
Grant us peace, Thy most precious gift, O thou eternal source of peace. May our nation always be a stronghold of peace and its advocate in the council of nations.
Posted By Robert Mendelson, Pittsburgh, PA, /USA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Condolences
I am a Catholic, but I am so saddened by your loss. This wonderful little boy will never know the love and warmth of his parents as he enters into childhood and eventually adulthood. I wish he receives all the love, warmth, and care from all of those who now surround him. I hope he is taught how his parents loved him and cared for others. Hopefully he will follow in their footsteps and teach of love and peace.
Hatred is an evil act and is growing stronger every day. It is so sad to see the world growing darker and darker.
Posted By Vanessa, Brooklyn, NY

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Sensless Tragedy
Dear all

It was with absolute shock and horror that I heard about the attacks on the Mumbai center

I am sure that the hopes of the world are with the victims of this senseless tragedy.

We will never forget our Fallen Heroes!
Posted By Tezab, Paris, France

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
To Chabad
I never met the Holtzbergs, but I have been a frequent guest at Beit Chabad across Asia. Their loss is devastating to our community. However, I hope that the example of their love and kindness helps inspire us all.
Posted By Joshua, Chicago, IL
via lubavitchchabad.org

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
FOrgive
ALthough i cant say Im much knowledageable of the TOrah. I beleive I have faith in G-D. and I beleieve in Forgiveness and that whomever is responsible needs to look at there own evil straight in the face. I feel so bad mostly for the immediate family, G-d will be stronger now. Let this be a motivator to bring peace among all nations. excerting our hate and anger will only exasperate the problem. we must look at the root cause. I believe love and compassion will be the way to heal those wounded .
Posted By Anonymous, Los Angeles, CA
via chabadsmc.com

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Mumbai
This is the first time , as far as I know, that a Rebbe's Shaliach has such a tragedy.
May G-d Bles your souls.
Posted By Avraham efraim, Brazil

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Chabad House Security- Tefiillin and guns
We are all terribly affected by this horrific nightmare.
Besides doing Mitzvahs to counteract this, we should protect our Chabad houses with extra security as well.
I read in an Israeli newspaper that Israel will provide more security to Chabad houses.
In addition to this:
Are the Chabad rabbis receptive to carrying guns?
It seems like the Chabad houses in exotic locations will need to carry a gun besides having security. The Rebbe teaches us that we must protect ourselves. These are 2 ways of adding protection. Maybe tefillin and guns do go hand in hand after all.
To all Chabad rabbis:
Thank you for making this world a better place.
Please keep on changing the world, just add security and please carry guns for your sake our sake as well.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Condolence and encouragement
I am neither Indian nor Jewish but all lives were touched by this violent act, and I want to join my condolences with the others.

The whole world watches you, Israel, even as you mourn. We see you face challenge after challenge and still you hold to your Divine legacy and inheritance.

My thougts and prayers are with you as a friend.
Posted By Jeanne, Bedford, IN

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Still crying in anger and in sadness
Why do they hate us so much? How do they know to hurt us in the worst possible way? May G-O-D avenge their blood.
Posted By Hannah Ben Porat , Paramus, NJ

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
I never met them BUT
I never met them but like every other Chabad house Rabbi and Rabbi wife I am sure they were loving and kind and open hearted people, who invite you with a unique spiritual love and welcoming way to their house and life.

Because of college and travel I have been to a few Chabd houses and every house is as loving and friendly as the other.

Rock on Chabad Rock on

p.s. I will put on teffiline today remembering them
Posted By Ramin Rabieian, Beverly Hills, CA

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
this mumbaite...
mourns your loss. our city was unprepared to protect them and others against the menace of terrorism. i was touched to hear of their good work in mumbai. my heart goes out to their families, especially their young son.

let the passage of time not forget their sacrifice
Posted By david d, arlington, va, usa

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Terrible terrible
Even though not a jew, I find it terrible these attacks against jews. But Gods revenge will come....
Posted By Goldmann, Sweden

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Little Moishe and Sandra
My gratitude goes out to Sandra. My love goes out ot Moishe and Sandra. May the Lubavitcher community do everything it can to keep them together. She is his surrogate mother. Rivkah chose her wisely. I pray that Moishe will be taken in by a loving couple who will raise him as their own. He does not belong in an orphanage. He should not become a "mascot" for the Lubvaticher community. He needs to be raised in a normal environment, not in an institution. He needs an abba and ima.
Posted By Chaye Sara, NYC, NY

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Sorrowful
I am posting again after having seen the pictures of this young couple whose lives were so tragically and senselessly truncated. The more I read about the execrable carnage that took place in Mumbay, the more my heart aches. I am a catholic and supposed to be forgiving, but I cannot forgive the bloody terrorists who took so many lives with their vile actions. May all victims rest in peace after their untimely deaths.
Posted By Hector C, McAAllen, Texas

Posted: Dec 2, 2008
Love
The cry of little Moshe for his mother during the funeral brought tears in my eyes.

But if we reply to hate with hate we bring ourselves down to their level.

As Mahatma Gandhi rightly said, "An eye for an eye will make the whole world blind."

So with Love we have to conquer hate.

The work and dedication of the Holtzbergs have not gone in vain. Through their death we have come to know of their Life and their works.

Let there be Peace and Love.