Tanya with Rabbi Ronnie Fine

Thanks very much for asking Rabbi Mendel Fine to give me the possibility to hear you on the web teaching our Tanya lesson .

I really appreciate your patience and understanding toward me to climb yet the lowest levels of your teaching but thank G-d I soon will be abble to ask some good questions about Tanya as i am building up a better reasoning sens ,and i also hope to give on other students on the web anywhere on the globe share with me the clear understanding and explanations yo provide us at everyday's tanya course in Montreal.

I miss you so much, listening you tanya classes are the best investment, I sold all my EUROS to invest in Rabbi Fine's Tanya classes.

Big hugs,

Hi Ronnie,

Since I watch your class, but have no way to participate, I want to thank the people who ask the questions, and with your answers, make it easier and clearer for me to understand.

Thank you all,
Ronnie's MOM.

Yesher koach to R. Fine and the men who ask important questions about the Alter Rebbe's teachings.
R. Fine brought the example of food being described as the " refuse of angels" as a way to deal with attachment to food for its own sake. If this expression regarding food diminishes one's "respect" and so desire for food, that is a good thing.
The potential problem with the expression"vessel filled with filth" is that men are supposed to love and respect their wives. If one's respect for women is diminished by employing a similar device, harm could be done (G-d forbid ) to the proper relationship between a man and his wife.
The Alter Rebbe labored over every letter, punctuation and word; so surely this expression teaches something valuable to us that in my ignorance, i do not yet grasp.
Toda rabba to R. Fine and the men of the daily Tanya shiur for their frank discussion.

As a woman, i also find some difficulty with the Alter Rebbe's choice of methods for dealing with a man's selfish desires regarding a woman. I wonder why he didn't choose to state that the woman is a holy vessel because she is the vehicle through which souls enter the world, and it is disgusting to use her as a tool for satisfying one's physical cravings.
The man's semen has been called " a putrid drop" but that doesn't seem to make a man less likely to desire physical relations.
I am not in the place of the Alter Rebbe, so i accept that each letter, punctuation and word is correct, but Moshe Rabbeinu was instructed to speak gently to women. It is hard to read what seems to be implied by some of his statements about us.
Are we the cause of men's unholy desires if we are modest? It is difficult to be referred to in such harsh terms, even for a good reason. That said, my desire to learn Tanya is not diminished in the least and neither is my respect for the Alter Rebbe.

B"H

Grateful for the past year of Tanya Live. And also to you Rabbi Fine for your continuing service. Thank you....