HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Ask the Rabbi
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Questions & Answers » Ask the Rabbi » Latest Questions » The Details » What if the tenth guy walks out?
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment4 Comments

What if the tenth guy walks out?


Question:

If the service begins with eleven men, and two leave the room for some unknown reason, is there still a minyan?

Answer:

If there are not ten men in the room, there is no minyan. Nevertheless, whatever was begun while ten men were in the room can be concluded—provided that at least six men (a majority of the minyan) remain.

However, to figure out which sections of the prayers constitute a singular unit, and as such can be concluded even if the minyan has been depleted, is tricky, and there are varying customs in different communities. Here are some rules following the rulings of Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi:

  • If the one leading the services begins the repetition of the amidah in the presence of a minyan, and then a person or persons walks out, leaving less than ten men present, the leader may finish the repetition, and may even recite the full kaddish that follows (as it is considered an extension of the amidah).
    In most other instances, kaddish can not be said unless ten men were present when the kaddish began.
  • On a holiday, the kohanim cannot bless the congregation unless a minyan is present when they begin reciting the blessing.
  • If kaddish was begun in the presence of a minyan, it may be concluded even if the quorum is depleted. However, the barchu that sometimes follows kaddish may not be said.
  • If the first aliyah blessing was begun, the entire Torah reading may be concluded, and the blessings recited. The haftorah, however, is considered a separate unit, and its blessings cannot be recited if there is no minyan present when it is begun.
  • During the evening prayer, if the minyan was depleted during the Shema or its blessings, the kaddish that follows it may be said. The kaddish that follows the amidah can be said if there was a minyan present when the amidah was begun.

I should also point out that if there are only ten men present, for anyone to leave is forbidden since doing so causes the Divine presence, which manifests itself amongst the minyan, to depart prematurely.


Sources:
Shulchan Aruch Harav Orech Chaim 55; Mishnah Berurah ibid. 143.
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment4 Comments

By Menachem Posner   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Menachem Posner is a member of the Chabad.org Ask the Rabbi team.
All names of persons and locations or other identifying features referenced in these questions have been omitted or changed to preserve the anonymity of the questioners.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Dec 9, 2009
Women
They are just as "important" as men, and perhaps even more so. However, for a number of reasons, the Halacha is quite clear that only men can make the magic ten for the minyan.
Posted By Michoel Shraga HaKatan

Posted: Dec 9, 2009
Ten "jews"
I thought now that woman are recognized as important, it is ten people...right?
Posted By Anonymous, new haven, ct
via jewishmilford.com

Posted: Aug 27, 2009
Minyanism
You realize this is complete sophistry?
Posted By Boris Strongin, mountain view, ca

Posted: Aug 27, 2009
Full kaddish
Regarding recitation of full kaddish without a minyan, when ten men were present during the amida: it is well to point out the opposite scenario. When there was not a minyan for the amida, and before the point where full kaddish is normally recited, the minyan is completed, it is still not possible to recite the full kaddish, as it is considered a continuation of the amida, for which no minyan was present.
Posted By Rabbi Boruch Myers, Bratislava, Slovakia



 


The Details
Why Babylonian Names for Jewish Months?
Naming a Baby Girl at the Earliest Opportunity
What Sort of Fruit Tree was the Tree of Knowledge?
Why didn't Adam eat from the Tree of Life?
Can a Jew raise swine?
When were the angels created?
What is the fast of Behab?
What if the tenth guy walks out?
Personal Fast Days
Why can't Yom Kippur begin on a Saturday night?
Are Priests Descendant from the Tribe of Levi?
Whom did Cain and Abel marry?
What does Shalom mean?
When was the Book of Lamentations written?
What is the function of a wedding's officiating rabbi?
Showing 32 - 46 of 348