HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Ask the Rabbi
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Questions & Answers » Ask the Rabbi » Latest Questions » The Details » Why didn't Joseph notify Jacob that he was alive?
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment3 Comments

Why didn't Joseph notify Jacob that he was still alive?


This question has troubled many of the biblical commentaries. How could Joseph have allowed his father to mourn him for so long? Why didn't he let Jacob know that he was alive? Egypt is not so far from Canaan, and it was certainly within Joseph's means to dispatch a courier to his father with the good news that he was alive and well.

Here are a few of the answers that are given:

Nachmanides explains (in his commentary on Genesis 42:9) that Joseph understood that his dreams (detailed in Genesis 37) were actual prophecies and would be fulfilled in their entirety. In Joseph's first dream, his eleven brothers were bowing down to him. In the second, his father was included too. Joseph concluded that the first dream must be realized in its entirety before the second one would be fulfilled. Had he sent a message to Jacob, he certainly would have come to see him immediately—and the second dream would have come true before the first. He therefore waited until after all eleven of his brothers – including Benjamin – had come to him, in fulfillment of the first dream, before revealing his identity to his brothers and instructing them to bring Jacob down to Egypt.1

Iturei Torah (a collection of Torah thoughts by Rabbi Aharon Yaakov Greenberg) cites a suggestion that Joseph was concerned that G‑d would punish his brothers for selling him. He therefore wanted to ensure that they repented. The optimal level of repentance is when the transgressor finds himself in the same situation as when he was tempted to sin in the first place, and this time chooses not to sin. The brothers sold Joseph into slavery out of jealousy. Joseph gave his brothers gifts, and he gave Benjamin a bigger gift (ibid. 43:34) to arouse their jealousy. He arranged for Benjamin to be framed as a thief so that he could claim Benjamin as his slave. When the brothers fought for Benjamin's release, without the slightest hint of envy, Joseph saw that their repentance was complete. He immediately revealed himself and told the brothers to let Jacob know that he was still alive. Had Joseph let his father know earlier that he was still alive, his brothers would never have had the opportunity to demonstrate complete repentance.

The Lubavitcher Rebbe answers this question (Likutei Sichot vol. 10 p. 129ff) based on Rashi's assertion (in his commentary on Gen. 37:33) that Isaac, Jacob's father, prophetically knew that Joseph was alive—but didn't tell Jacob. "How can I tell him," Isaac reasoned, "when G‑d chooses to keep it a secret from him?" Joseph simply followed the same logic. He knew that G‑d had sent him to Egypt for a reason, and that G‑d didn't want Jacob to know where he was. Joseph, therefore, refrained from sending a message to his father—though the knowledge that his father was mourning his supposed demise must have certainly pained him immensely.

Rochel Chein for Chabad.org

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment3 Comments
FOOTNOTES
1.

Based on this interpretation, Nachmanides explains the verse (Genesis 41:9): "And Joseph remembered the dreams that he had dreamed about them, and he said to them, 'You are spies...'" Because Joseph remembered the dreams, and because he saw that the first one had yet to be completely fulfilled – because Benjamin was not present – therefore he devised an elaborate scheme, which included accusing his brothers of espionage, in order to orchestrate that Benjamin, too, should come down to Egypt.


By Rochel Chein   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Mrs. Rochel Chein is a member of the chabad.org Ask the Rabbi team.
All names of persons and locations or other identifying features referenced in these questions have been omitted or changed to preserve the anonymity of the questioners.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: July 31, 2009
Kosher Dreams...
Yosef never contacted his family because G-d told him not to do so, but to wait till they came to him.

Thus the question is more aptly put: Why did G-d want Yosef to refrain from contacting his father & family?

Well then, on the same note, why did G-d put the Jewish people in bondage before redeeming them? There are a million similar whys we can ask about throughout history.

The true answer to all of them is that G-d has made a covenant to make the Jews into His people. And G-d determined that Yosef's silence would serve to bring the brother's newfound awareness of their misdeeds and serve to integrate Ya'akov's family into a perfect whole. Yosef was doing his job as a Ish Elokim, a messenger of G-d, to re-orient his entire family's understanding of how G-d works and how important it is to get along with each other. We are all G-d's children. If you want something in life: put your hope to G-d, and He will make your dreams kosher, and then grant them!
Posted By Yosef, ny, ny

Posted: July 23, 2009
I think Joseph never sought out his family because he knew that G_d was grooming him for what was to come. Joseph knew that Jacob loved him - that never was a question. As for the repenting, I believe it was threefold: 1) required by G_d of a broken heart and contrite spirit (truly remorseful) so that G_d would forgive them and bring them back into His grace, 2) if Joseph was grudgeful the remorse allowed Joseph to forgive therefore bringing him into G_d's grace; ; 3) for the brethren, it allowed them to forgive themselves, because surely they were carrying that guilt that must have tormented them for all those years and bring themselves in G_d's and Joseph's good grace.
Posted By Truth Seeker, Fresno, CA

Posted: July 21, 2009
Very Interesting...I heard a dif one
I remember learning that Yosef (Joseph) thought that possibly Yakov (Jacob) wanted to get rid of him as well. It says in the Torah (Bible) that Yakov sent Yosef and then all of a sudden Yosef goes on a winding trip to find his brothers and then they kidnap him and sell him. One opinion explained that Yosef figured that Yakov was part of the scheme...picture yourself in the situation...Thank you Chabad for the amazing succicntability of such broad ideas!
Posted By Ben, Lost, America



 


The Details
Are Priests Descendant from the Tribe of Levi?
Whom did Cain and Abel marry?
What does Shalom mean?
When was the Book of Lamentations written?
What is the function of a wedding's officiating rabbi?
The Biblical Basis for the 13 Principles of Faith
What are the six "perpetual mitzvot"?
Why didn't Joseph notify Jacob that he was alive?
Can I delete G‑d’s name on a computer screen?
What day is it really?
Does the number 70 have any significance?
Eating Before Praying?
On which days is it forbidden to shave?
Which blessing is said upon seeing a rainbow?
Did Solomon Marry Out?
Showing 42 - 56 of 348