Contact Us

Does A High Arab Birthrate Threaten Israel?

Does A High Arab Birthrate Threaten Israel?

 Email

Question:

I'm living in Israel, which is supposed to be a Jewish state, and I'm surrounded by Arabs, Russian gentiles and other assorted non-Jews. They tell me the Arab birth rate continues to outstrip the Jewish rate—and the government continues to discourage large families. What should our attitude be towards the Arab population in Israel? How are we ever going to ensure that this place remains the Jewish homeland?

Answer:

Just so happens that a fellow editor recently emailed me a dialogue between the Lubavitcher Rebbe and the Rebbe of Sadigura, Rabbi Avraham Yaakov Friedman.1

They touched on this topic, and to tell the truth, I myself was stunned by the Rebbe's straightforward answers. The meeting occurred almost 30 years ago, but is amazingly relevant right now.

In the course of their conversation, they spoke about the need to encourage Jews to have larger families. The Rebbe spoke of the irony of the situation. "The government spends $30,000 dollars to bring a family to Israel," he lamented, "while spending—I have no idea how much—to encourage small families and decrease the birth rate."

The first solution, the Rebbe said, was to increase the stipend to large families. The Sadigura Rebbe, however, was concerned that stipends for large families in Israel go to large Arab families as well. The Rebbe responded that discriminating solutions are simply not tenable and would be interpreted as racism. When the Sadigura Rebbe suggested that perhaps it would then be better not to provide family stipends at all, the Rebbe responded with a discussion of the Jewish obligation towards non-Jews under the "Laws of Noah." Basically, a Jew should do everything he can to prevent a non-Jewish mother from performing an abortion, and support her bringing more children into the world. And if the stipend will encourage large families among Arabs as well as among Jews—very nice. Human beings are meant to have children.

You have to read the transcript several times for it to sink in. I'll attempt to translate a few excerpts. But first, let me lay out some context:

There is a common ground of "The Laws of Noah" which establish the basis for harmony between all peoples and for a sustainable planet. The basics are already addressed at length by the sages of the Talmud and later redacted by the great codifier, Maimonides. All of these laws and guidelines, with their many branches and corollaries, are derived from the Tanach—principally from the Book of Genesis. As Jews, we are responsible to educate and encourage other people to stick to these laws. Especially if they are living in a land under Jewish dominion. And if they keep those laws, we have a responsibility to respond to their needs and attend to their welfare.

These laws include prohibitions against murder and abortion, as well as an imperative to bring children into the world.

Now for the excerpt, beginning with the Rebbe's reaction to the Sadigura Rebbe's suggestion to withhold family stipends (all citations in this article are my own translations from the published Hebrew transcript):

"All children of Noah are instructed that, 'the world was made to be inhabited.' They are also instructed not to murder. This is one of the seven mitzvahs incumbent on all of humanity. Consequently, it is also incumbent upon the Jew to encourage the non-Jew to fulfill those mitzvahs in which the children of Noah are obligated. I don't believe in an attitude of 'Let me die with the Philistines'—to withhold support from Jewish families just so that Arabs will also not receive it."

If so, what will be with demographics? The Rebbe replies :

"...since this is an approach based on the Code of Jewish Law, we need to rely on the Holy One, blessed be He. We can trust that things will work out. If we were deciding this on our own, in contradiction to the seven mitzvahs of the children of Noah, or if we were doing something irrelevant to those laws—then matters would be different."

"However, by Torah law a Jew has an obligation (when he has the capacity) not to permit a non-Jew's transgression of his mitzvahs. So when we are the governing party—as is the situation in Israel—it is forbidden for us to facilitate a possible abortion of an Arab child since this is one of their seven mitzvahs…"

Pondering this, it strikes me that the Rebbe is presenting a repetitive theme in halachah: The Torah provides us a certain degree of control over our world. When it comes to matters of those standing on the doorstep waiting to enter our world, however, the Torah tells us, "Hands off—this is G‑d's business and not yours."

So humanity as a whole is commanded to have children. We don't decide who can bring children into the world and who cannot. On the contrary, our job is to see to it that every human being, Jewish or otherwise, has whatever s/he needs to raise a family and that every fetus is granted the right to live. We do our job and we let G‑d take care of His.

You can read between the lines that the Sadigurer is struggling not to fall off his chair. The Rebbe is showing concern for those he considers an existential threat to Israel—and saying that this is Torah. The Sadigura Rebbe insists, "But it would seem this is a matter of self-defense. The situation in Israel today is very serious. The demographical situation is very threatening. It doesn't seem right to contribute to the problem."

The Rebbe responds by simply reiterating his position, "This does not release them from their obligation to keep their mitzvahs—and from the obligation of a Jew to ensure that the non-Jew will not transgress one of his seven mitzvahs."

If Israel is a Jewish state, then its attitude must be a Jewish attitude. A Jewish attitude is not determined by personal sensitivities, gut reactions or even pragmatic reasoning alone. All of these are of necessity focused around the individual or society making the determination. Quite simply, a human being—all the more so a society of human beings—is incapable of viewing any social situation objectively. Torah, on the other hand, presents us with the reasoning of He who formed all of humanity in His image and rules over all nations. The Jewish approach, therefore, is to look in the Torah and see what its instructs us.

Nevertheless, we are rarely capable of seeing past our own tendentious reasoning to perceive the message the Torah is giving us. We read into its words what our egos wish to read and find justification for whatever prejudices we started with. Fortunately, for that we have tzadikim, righteous men who transcend their own egos and see G‑d's truth shining in His Torah.

A person who sees the truth can't be fit into a little box of right wing or left wing, humanitarianism or authoritarianism, liberalism or conservatism or any other ism. He is neither a hawk nor a dove nor any other animal; he is a thinking human being who happens to have at his fingertips the all-encompassing wisdom of Torah to guide him. The Mishnah warns, "Be deliberate in judgment," and the sages explain, "Never assume you have seen this before. Judge each situation on its own merits." That's called wisdom—and wisdom is often surprising.

As if to prove this point, immediately after this interchange, when the Sadigurer asked the Rebbe for his opinion on surrendering the territories acquired by Israel in the Six Day War, the Rebbe firmly reiterated his long-standing position, "not to give back an inch." Is this the same man who a moment ago had no problem encouraging and even assisting Arab mothers to have more children? Yes—and his insistence is based on the very same reasoning: Surrendering territories in the current situation will endanger lives. Even speaking about it endangers lives. Jewish lives and Arab lives. It has nothing to do with whether these territories belong to us by right of conquest or heritage or any other such legalities. It certainly has nothing to do with party line. The first and foremost determinant is the protection of human life.

(See the articles at Land for "Peace" for more on this last point. For the humanitarian angle on this, Should I Pray for the Death of Terrorists?)

As we pray three times a day, may G‑d restore to us our leaders and advisors, our rebbes and our tzadikim, and may He alone rule over us, "with kindness and with compassion, with righteousness and with judgment." And may it be very soon, sooner than we can imagine.

Footnotes
1.

Wednesday, Tammuz 4, 5740, (June 18, 1980). Published in Siach Sarfei Kodesh pp. 273-276.

Rabbi Tzvi Freeman, a senior editor at Chabad.org, also heads our Ask The Rabbi team. He is the author of Bringing Heaven Down to Earth. To subscribe to regular updates of Rabbi Freeman's writing, visit Freeman Files subscription. FaceBook @RabbiTzviFreeman Periscope @Tzvi_Freeman .
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with Chabad.org's copyright policy.
 Email
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
37 Comments
1000 characters remaining
Jeremy McCandlish pittsburgh, pa April 21, 2017

What a beautiful perspective. I've never heard anything like it on the situation in Israel.

I'm worried I might start being seen as the "bad guy" if I start encouraging my non-jewish friends to get married/have kids...maybe better to leave that to family. Reply

Nechamah Goldfarb Brooklyn February 20, 2017

Mixed feelings about this Although ultimately I trust the Rebbe's take on matters, and I even understand the halacha here, I also keep thinking about amalek. I do believe that the behaviour of many with whom Jews are dealing is reflective of amalek, and although according to halacha we can no longer wipe them out physically, I wonder if we can at least not support their increase. On the other hand, since we don't know for sure (the actual physical sign, I believe, is gone) who is amalek (even though I think we see it in behaviour), I look at babies as babies, and hope that even amongst our enemies and those sworn to destroy us, G-d forbid, there will be at least one child who will reject that. in the end, we have to trust that following and supporting halacha will give us the support and blessings from Hashem. Reply

Sam Boston October 30, 2013

Not quite there yet... Whenever I've read the Rebbe's wisdom, I feel blessed to have this other way of seeing things reinvigorated in me. And, even though I go back into my "dream" so-to-speak, it is less so than before. But, I am not so sure about this dovishness. I do agree with the general idea that it is profoundly unethical to tamper with the birth process of any race of people. But I also recall a story... from Canada, I believe... of missionaries that convinced a native tribe to put down their weapons and attempt peace with an enemy tribe.

The result was the tribe that disarmed and sought peace was wiped from the face of the map. Reply

Tzvi Freeman January 29, 2013

Re: Ethiopian From what I've read, this was not an official policy, but a bad idea on the part of certain doctors. They've been instructed by the government to stop. Reply

Anonymous Pikesville, Md January 27, 2013

Ethiopian Why not stop giving Ethiopian-Israeli Jews birth control against their will to increase the Jewish population? Reply

alice December 30, 2012

The days of the demographic threat are over. See link.
Do a search for "The Demographic Success of the West Bank Settlements" by Yinon Cohen. Reply

Anonymous Miami, FL November 22, 2010

Fear The Rebbe had a command of his emotions and his mind. His teachings surpass most of our own abilities to overcome our own fears of self preservation. I enjoyed this article immensely. Reply

Anonymous via ichabad.org July 4, 2009

phobic concern of islamic birthrate i wonder did hitler and his goons think the same thing when they wanted to be rid of the hebrew population? Reply

Simcha Frankel Los Angeles July 3, 2009

This article takes emuna (faith) and "guts" to write. I am impressed with the authors knowledge and ability to articulate the Rebbe's stance. Thank you Reply

Craig Hamilton Sandwich, MA July 3, 2009

Birth and Death Insignifiant To Future Events I believe that birth/death rates will be insignificant in the near future. Efraim Halevy (former Israeli spy chief) says WWIII has begun, as nations around the world work on nuclear weapons. Christians and Muslims, billions of people are at odds over the state of Israel. Muslims say, "Move." Christians say, "The land is yours." Israelis are in the middle. Israelis won't and shouldn't move, as the threat of nuclear holocaust will soon be a global threat. I predict that possibly within my lifetime Israel will be a nuclear wasteland, but moving would be a futile exercise in buying more time. Moving to America is possible, but then suicide bombings in NYC are likely. It seems that there is no escape. I do not believe that a Messiah will come and save the world. Christians and Islam are destined to fight it out with Israel in the middle. It will be the war to end all wars, the one the Essenes believed in 2,000yrs ago. Reply

Rabbi Tzvi Freeman July 2, 2009

For Isser Zalman The point of the article is that the Rebbe cannot be hijacked into any camp or ism. He is neither a dove nor a hawk, neither right wing nor left. To fix the world, you can't use turnkey solutions. Each situation must be approached according to its parameters, and that is what Torah guides us to do--when taught by a true master. Reply

Mrs. Celine Bennett July 2, 2009

prayer agreement I agree in prayer, Amen! Reply

Sarah Brooklyn, NY July 2, 2009

real integrity It's beautiful to see the consistency and integrity shown by the Rebbe and the Chabad movement, and the commitment to the value of human life, even the lives of those who threaten us.

If only these values were more widespread, especially in the Arab world. There are some hopeful signs of greater openness and increasing impatience with injustice and oppression in these societies. Let's hope that soon the Rebbe's trust will pay off, and we will see these populations rise up, depose their dictators, and create healthy and peaceful countries. Reply

Tzvi K. Jerusalem July 2, 2009

beautiful The Rebbe's emunah continues to connect us to the One Above. Tremendous article, Reb Tzvi. Reply

Moshe Morgenstern Morristown, NJ USA July 1, 2009

Jewish Fertility Ms Eisenmann is correct. Jewish-Israeli fertility is the highest in western world. In 1995 69% of all births in Israel were Jewish. Today it is 72%.

Do a search on "Yoram Ettinger" on google and read some of his work on Israeli Demographics. Reply

isser zalman Thornhill, Ontario July 1, 2009

Kiddush Hashem I applaud the great Kiddush Hashem you are creating by publicizing such a positive view on the growing Arab population in Israel.
But why stop here? I suggest Rabbi Freeman move his family to a nice picturesque Arab village in Israel to show the world that he means what says, and that he truly does not feel threatened by the Arab population in Israel. There will be no need for security arrangements as the Arab population is not at all threatening.
I further suggest that Rabbi Freeman meet with PM Netanyahu and encourage him to stop being so stubborn in his refusal to agree to “The Right of Return” of Arab refuges to Israel. This seems to be the major stumbling block in reaching a comprehensive peace agreement with the non-threatening Arab population in the Middle East. To the contrary, please explain to the PM, that a large Arab population in Israel is a very positive thing. Reply

chaim azriel jerusalem July 1, 2009

AMAZING Rabbi Freeman, you hit the jackpot again.
Your articles are works of art. Reply

Yael Pedhatzur Omer, Israel July 1, 2009

no stipends I believe that there are many things we do not understand and cannot control. But those that are within our ability must be addressed.

Israel's child subsidies are a travesty. They should be stopped immediately for all sectors. The government needs to provde real services such as long school days, 2-3 meals during the school day, and a year round curriculum so that kids do not hang out unsupervised for over 3 months a year. This can be covered by the subsidies and ensure that the money is really spent for the children's welfare.

If the subsidies (150 shekels per mo./per child), is what determines having/or not having more kids then that's just too bad.

The threat from the Arab demographic can be better solved by more people participating in shouldering the burden of army service & paying full taxes.

Those wonderful people living in Yehuda & Shomron who have large families & are full participants in all aspects of Israeli society are the example for all of us to follow Reply

sara channa eisenmann June 30, 2009

what should be our.... your comments are all interesting, but there is a change in the Jewish Israeli population: the number of abortions has gone down. Secular families have more children as well. More Israelis return than before. And I am told that no other country in the world has so many twin-and triplets born as in Israel. This have created many hateful comments from our enemies. I think that Israel doesn't fit any regular model of a nation: what is happening here can only be explained by what the Torah says. As a young bride I was told there would be no children due to medical expriments in KZ-lager, and my doctore didn't believed me when I called and said I was pregnant. But I have 5 and have 5 grandkids........ Reply

Kayo Kaneko Tokyo, Japan June 30, 2009

Now I am comfortable walking in a mall As I live in Tokyo, when I go to malls, I see people from all over the world, including Islamic people. Because of our history and current situation between Israelis and Islamic people, I did not know what I should think of them when I saw them. Now I am comfortable to see them. Reply