Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Economy
 
Chabad.org » Inspiration & Entertainment » Contemporary Voices » Daily Life » Economy » Stories » Hard to Swallow
  Inspiration   Stories   Tips   Charity   Multimedia
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment7 Comments

Hard to Swallow


It was with an uneasy heart that Reb Yitzchak entered the study of his Rebbe, Rabbi Moshe of Kovrin. For decades he had been visiting and consulting with the Chassidic master, but never before had it entered his mind to approach him on the subject which he now intended to raise.

Always, when he spoke to a Rebbe it was about his spiritual affairs only. Reb Yitzchak lived in grinding poverty: so it had been since his youth and so he imagined it would always be. But is that any reason to interrupt a tzaddik from his holy work? Yitzchak was fond of saying that G-d doesn't need advice from anyone, not even the Righteous, about who to make rich. No, the only justification to bother a tzaddik was to elicit help and instruction from him in how to serve G-d properly and not to slip from the true path.

Indeed, Reb Yitzchak never let his desperate economic plight trouble him; not even for a moment. Always he was cheerful, and full of gratitude to G-d for his lot. "Rejoice my stomach," he would say, "that you are light and not a heavy burden to carry around."

But now a number of his daughters were nearly of marriageable age, and there wasn't a coin in the house to make them a wedding and to help set them up. His wife and daughters were sunk in bitter depression over the situation, and as one of the great Rebbes had said, depression is a highly contagious disease that infects anyone who comes into its presence. He already noticed that it was affecting his ability to serve G-d purely.

So here he was, about to do the unthinkable. He was going to ask his Rebbe to bless him that G-d should send him a respectable livelihood.


"Rebbe, I... I..." The words froze in his mouth. He felt like a thief caught in the act. "Rebbe, I... I ... I can't.... M-m-my wife, my daughters...." He froze again, in mid-sentence, too embarrassed to continue.

But it was enough. The Rebbe raised his eyebrows quizzically and said, "Yitzchak, is it a comfortable life you want? Is that it? Well, I will grant it to you, but only if you do one thing for me first.

"Take these two gold coins," the Rebbe instructed the dumbstruck Chassid, "and when you get home, spend both of them on the fanciest, most expensive food you can find. Good wine, the choicest meats, gourmet dishes, and an assortment of fresh fruits, sweets and baked goods for dessert. Don't leave anything out and don't let a single penny be left over. Bring it all into your house and set it out on your table for a banquet. There should be enough for two full meals for one person, one in the day and one in the evening.

"What you must do," concluded the Chassidic master, "is eat it all up, both meals, all by yourself, in utter silence. If your wife or your children ask to eat some of it, or just to taste, ignore them. And say not a word in explanation. I'm warning you, do exactly like I am telling you. Exactly! Afterwards, come back here, and I will grant you what you ask."

All the way home, Yitzchak marveled at what he had promised the Rebbe to do. How could he spend all that money on fancy food? And how could he eat it all? Who cares about food anyway! And how would he be able to not share any of it with his family?

It turned out to be even harder than he expected. He sat down to the table with all the dishes of food set out just for him, while his family looked on pleadingly. He could barely manage to swallow it down. Each mouthful was more painful than the last. "G-d, take my soul and spare me this terrible trial," he screamed silently.

By now all his children were wailing and his wife was sobbing and castigating him for his cruelty. "G-d in Heaven! His own children are begging him for scraps and he has no mercy for them. They cry and he averts his eyes. Only he can eat! Yitzchak, have you gone out of your mind?!"

With those words, his poor wife collapsed and fainted. Reb Yitzchak the Chassid did not faint. He gulped down the last morsel and turned his face toward Kovrin.


"Welcome, Yitzchak!" the Rebbe called to him. "I presume you did what I told you to. You did, didn't you?"

"Yes," murmured Yitzchak, his eyes glistening with tears.

The Rebbe noticed, of course. "And now, Yitzchak," he continued gently, "are you prepared for G-d's blessing for wealth that will enable your house to be filled with all the good and desirable things that money can buy? Are you ready for that lifestyle? Are you ready to eat like you did that day in your house at my command? For what difference does it make if your wife and children share your table? Even if you dispense generously of your blessings to the needy--what about all those who you won't feed, the many thousands of impoverished families, your brothers and sisters and their sons and daughters? They will all be hungrily longing for what is on your plate. Do you want the pleasure of wealth like you had at that meal? If so, take it; it's yours. Will you? Can you, Yitzchak?"

"No," Yitzchak whispered. "No!" he said more firmly. "No, I can't and no, I don't want to..."


Biographical note: Rabbi Moshe Pallier of Kovrin (1784-1858) was a close follower of the Cassidic master Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch and afterwards of his son, Rabbi Noach. In 1833 he became the first Rebbe of the Kovrin dynasty, with thousands of Chassidim, many of whom subsequently moved to the Land of Israel.

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment7 Comments

By Yerachmiel Tilles   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
A master storyteller with hundreds of published stories to his credit, Rabbi Yerachmiel Tilles is co-founder of Ascent of Safed, and managing editor of the Ascent and Kabbalah Online websites.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Mar 5, 2009
the lesson
Let’ see what reb Yitzchak was doing with his family spirits. He was cheerfully enjoying the highs of Torah study while his wife and daughters were depressed. He was only concerned with their emotional state because that interfered with his own spiritual life! That was like sitting alone at the spiritual table while his family was starving. I am afraid he did not learn from his eating physical food alone to share hid spiritual food with his family.
Posted By Alexandra Malamud, New York, NY

Posted: Feb 14, 2009
The Rabbi got the point about weath and his wife received the brochot for the family...they WERE able to give to the many other hungry people and pay for their daughter weddings as the ending goes.
Posted By Anonymous, northbrook, il
via chabadnorthbrook.com

Posted: Jan 9, 2007
the uncensored ending
Although Yitzchak turned his back on wealth, his wife most certainly did not. She came herself to the Rebbe and received the blessing he was happy to bestow.

From that time on, his wife lived and dressed well, and spent much time and money seeing that the poor Jews of their town also had all that they needed. Her own husband, however, refused to let their new wealth affect his lifestyle at all. He dressed as he always had and ate as he always had eaten. *

"How can I enjoy a life of abundance?" he would say, "when my poor brethren never have enough for their basic needs. How can I sit down to a full table when I know others are starving?

"I never want to eat another meal like that again!"

~~~~~~~~
Editor's note:
According to one version, he actually moved out of his home and took up residence in the community poor house. He would join his family for meals only on special occasions, when all the poor were invited.
Posted By Yerachmiel Tilles, Tsfat, Israel

Posted: Jan 7, 2007
Other version
I've read another version of the story (not sure if the Rebbe's name was the same) that ended slightly differently : The Chassid accepted the Bracha and got wealthy, however he only ate at the Soup kitchen for the needy (that he was paying for).
Posted By Anonymous
via rtchabad.org

Posted: June 8, 2005
I find the motto of this story to be antithetical to the teachings of traditional Judaism.

First, one with much money can give much to charity and do much good in the world. Second, aspiring to a life of poverty only ensures that not only will you not be able to give charity, you will become a charity burden on others.

For instance, the man in this story never solved his original problem: how would he be able to help his daughter marry?
Posted By Eric D.

Posted: Apr 24, 2005
hard to swallow
I have only started studying on this site within the last few months. But I have found a truth that I have searched for all my life. I can find this believable, simply because I have had to choose the life of luxury or the life of lack in order to follow truth. I can not set and feast while others do without. In today's world many teach prosperity, what has happened to that idea being one of spiritual growth instead of material possessions. The priceless things are what makes our life meaningful. Not how well we eat, dress or live. But how truthful we live and acknowledge our neighbor.
I understand this story very well. I read the reply "story does not sound true" but life experience has taught me different. Where one has been makes a difference in what one can perceive or receive. The truth is many set and eat and don't think of others, so why is it cruel to establish that through an example. It is truth.
Posted By Anonymous, Roanoke Rapids, NC/USA

Posted: Nov 22, 2004
Story does not sound true.
Im sorry to post something not positive - but I read this story and find it almost impossible to be true.

Although the lesson MAY be a valid one - in SOME sense - the method of teaching the lesson is definitly not charachteristic of Chasidic Masters, not at all. Far from it. The method sounds much too cruel to be true.
Posted By Chaim Alevsky, Plano, TX



 


Stories
Impeccable Logic
The Traveler
The Fire
Hard to Swallow
The Mirror
Six Hundred Dinars Minus Six
The Snake in the Wall
Showing 1 - 7 of 12
Share a Practical Tip or Thought
Inspire Others: Send cards to Family & Friends