Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Editorial & Commentary » Legacy of Mumbai » Personal Reflections » Tragedy in Mumbai
  Their Legacy   The Events   Six Holy Souls   Sharing Memories   Video
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment19 Comments

Tragedy in Mumbai


I was sitting in the office yesterday afternoon when I clicked on to cnn.com to check on what's happening. As the moderator of this news blog, I'm in the habit of checking the news a few times a day—always on the lookout for breaking stories or interesting news items.

The big red lettering sprawled across the top of the page immediately caught my attention. Another terror attack. A big one. at least 80 people killed, countless other injured, and many others taken hostage.

"Hello, I have a friend who I think might have been a victim of the shootings..."

"What a tragedy... what a crazy world," I thought to myself as I returned to the article I was in middle of editing. "When will all this madness and grief end?" I sighed to myself.

A few minutes later, I'm totally engrossed in my work again, and some snippets of conversation emanating from an adjoining cubicle pique my attention.

"Hello, I have a friend who I think might have been a victim of the shootings... Were any of the victims brought to your hospital?... Were any of them Jewish?"

Huh?

It seems that they've been unable to establish contact with the Chabad-Lubavitch emissary to Mumbai. The shootings are in the vicinity of the Chabad House, and some of my co-workers were calling the various local hospitals, hoping for some information as to his welfare.

Not much work was accomplished in the office yesterday afternoon. Same story this morning. Eyes are glued to the various newscasts, as news slowly trickles in.

The Chabad House of Rabbi and Mrs. Holtzberg, the Chabad representatives in Mumbai, is occupied by terrorists. As I write these words, their fate is unknown. Thank G‑d, their young son escaped in the hands of a nanny a few hours ago. According to news reports, Indian commandos are preparing – or have already begun – to storm the Chabad House. We all hope and pray to hear good news very soon. May G‑d have mercy...

People just like me

A tragedy that is occurring 8,000 miles from me has hit home. An event that would have normally elicited from me a sigh and a few moments of thought is now consuming me. It's not "numbers" of casualties; it's real people with real faces. People just like me.

What is this supposed to teach me? Am I really expected to be this affected by every tragedy that is reported? Is that humanly possible? Would I be able to continue on with life in such a fashion?

I don't know.

I do know, though, that for the moment, I suddenly have perspective.

Meanwhile, let us continue saying Psalms and prayers for Rabbi & Mrs. Holtzberg – Gavriel Noach ben Freida Bluma and Rivkah Bas Yehudis – and all the others impacted by this monumental tragedy.

May G‑d have mercy.

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment19 Comments

By Naftali Silberberg   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Naftali Silberberg resides in Brooklyn, NY, with his wife Chaya Mushka and their three children.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

19 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Dec 5, 2008
A Question Of Language
The only thing I object to is the characterization of what happened as a "tragedy." I think it equates human evil with an act of nature and they're not the same. The latter is a tragedy since no one can control it. Human beings on the other hand do not have to commit evil. The evils of Man and of nature are qualitatively different. Nevertheless some word has to be used to describe what occurred. The word used obscures and does not really convey the enormity of the atrocity that happened and perhaps that is the term that most fits what we witnessed last week. Its a reminder that language can never completely capture for us the full horror of what happened, which will always haunt our memories.
Posted By Norman F Birnberg, Salida, CO/USA

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
God Bless & Protect The Chabad Movement
I am proud to call myself a member of chabad although i am not frum. I was born in Israel and have lived in the USA since 1973 . Regardless of where my many travels have taken me around the world and in the USA Chadab can always be counted on to feed my hunger both at a sabbeth table and my jewish mind. LETS ALL MAKE SURE THAT THE KIDS OF THESE TWO BRAVE PEOPLE ARE TAKEN CARE OF . MAKE A PLEDGE TO TAKE CARE OF HOLTZBERG KIDS. Thank you Chabad for being there for me and many others . Its our turn to be there for you. May God Bless And Protect This Jewish Movement .
Posted By Alon Touti , New York, NY

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
Mumai Tragedy
We are very sorry for the loss you are suffering. We have been and are praying for the families and friends of all who were killed. Bless you all.
Posted By Joe & Diana Korman, Plano, Tx/USA
via chabadindia.org

Posted: Nov 30, 2008
We need to take more responsibility for the world
I was reading The Midrash says for the portion of Toldot today. At the end of the parashat, it mentioned clearly, that the Jewish Nation has an enormous responsibility to study Torah and to behave according to the law. If we are all doing that, the other nations of the world will serve us. If not, they will all be angry at us because we are not doing our work. The Midrash says in the portion of Toldot clearly explain the reason of Anti-Semitism in the world. The Midrash even mentioned that we should not be concerned about expensive luxuries such as a car, for example, since a car requires money and to make money we need to dedicate time to business away from our Torah studying. I am very sad but what happened in Mumbai, I still cannot believe it. May this event serve us to awaken our hearts and work on our true purpose to do Tikun Olam.
Posted By Sarah Ricci, Jefferson City, MO

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Mumbai attacks
I am a regular reader of Chabad articles which i subscribe through email and my sincere thoughts are with the family of the rabbi and all others who lost thier lives in this merciless attacks. As a Indian I am full of grief at this merciless attack on civilians and peace loving people.May all thier souls rest in peace.
Posted By Harris Moideen, London, UK

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
Terror in Bombay
The events in Mumbai marks a watershed in the Indian Jewish history. Throughout the more than two millennium history of Judaism in India, we Indians are quite proud that India has been completely free of antisemitism. Not a single finger has been pointed at Jews, not a single one killed. Prominent Indian Jews for a miniscule community include the Sassoons ( Vidal Sassoon), General David & the poet Nissim Ezekiel.

Now comes these terrorists from the Sea with these senseless acts, coupled with utter carelessness for the part of Indians. It is clear that Israelis and Jewish cultural symbols worldwide stand as targets for Islamists.

Probably this level of carelessness is because of our past heritage, but looking now to future this has to change.
Posted By Sandeep Chowdhury, Delhi, India

Posted: Nov 29, 2008
We stand united
Dear Friends

Whatever India's official stand is and whatever the govt. says. The Indian people love Israel and love Jewish people. I am proud to come from a country which has been most hospitable to Jewish people. My feelings have been reciprocated by Jewish people in Israel and Antwerp.
Posted By Naren, Bangalore, India

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
I am not Jewish - I am a Christian - but I want to extend my deepest sympathies to the entire Chabad community at the death of this wonderful young rabbi and his dear wife. My prayers are that you all will be comforted, and that G-d will watch over and bless those sweet children - now orphans; I am sure they will grow up knowing how much their parents loved them and what wonderful work their parents did...all in the name of helping others. If more people of any faith worked to help others as the Holzbergs did, this world would be a better place!
Posted By Anonymous, Lansing, Michigan, USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
'Tragedy' in 'Mumbai'
My deepest condolences to the Holtzberg' and Rosenberg families

I wish you wouldn't use the word 'tragedy'. It marginalizes the pure evil acts of murder and terrorism which have taken place.

'Tragedy' is when a car slides on an icy patch when trying to brake, or a cable snaps on a construction krane.

Premeditated terrorism and murder is not accidenta. Make no mistake - the people murdered in the name of Islam in Bombay are dead as a result unadulterated evil, not some tragic accident of fate.
Posted By Stephen Sacks, NY, USA

Posted: Nov 28, 2008
Time of Sorrow
It is hard to find hope for Jews in the world under the circumstances of exploding hatred and anti-semitism. When ones life is terminated in such horrific manner, it remains us that such is a perpetual and non-ending tragedy. For every life that is terminated, many others cease to exist. For these couple, one just wonder how many others.... These were beautiful people, kind, loving, generous...these were our people, unique and chosen. I never met them, but I love them deeply. My family mourns their loss. To their families - we love you and somewhere in the world, there is someone that feels your pain and shares your sorrows. We, the Jewish people are one and for those here we must have hope. I love you. Shabbat Shalom -
Posted By Mia David, Chicago, IL/USA



 


Personal Reflections
Broken But Not Crushed
Enough is Enough!
Spiritual Lifesavers
Tragedy in Mumbai
A Tragedy Survivor’s Guide
What is our response to the massacre?
Where did all our prayers go?
Showing 32 - 38 of 43
News Archive
News Archive
News Archive