Here's a great tip:
Enter your email address and we'll send you our weekly magazine by email with fresh, exciting and thoughtful content that will enrich your inbox and your life, week after week. And it's free.
Oh, and don't forget to like our facebook page too!
Contact Us

Why do Jews sway while praying?

Why do Jews sway while praying?

The Swaying Candle

 Email

Here are two explanations given by Jewish tradition:

a) King David writes (Psalms 35:10), "All of my limbs shall proclaim: Who is like You..." When we praise G‑d, we do so with all of our being: the mind, heart, and mouth express the prayer through speech, and the rest of the body does so by moving. Every fiber of our self is involved in connecting to our Creator.

b) "The soul of man is a candle of G‑d" (Proverbs 20:27). The candle's flame constantly sways and flickers as it attempts to tear free of its wick and ascend on high. Our soul is also engaged in a constant effort to escape the corporeality of this mundane world and cleave to its G‑dly source. This is especially true in the course of prayer, those islands in time when we concentrate and focus on our relationship with G‑d. Our body mirrors this effort as it sways back and forth like a flame.

Rabbi Menachem Posner serves as staff editor for Chabad.org.
Image: Detail from a painting by Sarah Kranz. Ms. Kranz has been illustrating magazines, webzines and books (including five children’s books) since graduating from the Istituto Europeo di Design, Milan, in 1996. Her clients have included The New York Times and Money Marketing Magazine of London.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with Chabad.org's copyright policy.
 Email
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
24 Comments
1000 characters remaining
Bonnie lieberman Detroit January 27, 2017

What is proper for a woman praying Is it proper for a woman to shukle? Reply

Anonymous California September 17, 2016

Lie as usual to know anything about cabal ist,you have to really have good source to understand. When they bow down they are saying "blessing be the holy one ". That gives you a good idea how rapid there minds work. Everything that is hidden shall be revealed. Reply

Steven 47412 August 18, 2016

Nice thoughts. Reply

Kathy December 28, 2015

I just want to say thank you for sharing this so I can understand better. I am sure I will be back with more questions. May God bless you and your family Reply

Amichai Schneller Cloudy town. February 13, 2014

Swaying? I like to think of it as...flowing through space and time. Reply

Mika Planet Earth November 28, 2013

Swaying In my experience, I have begun swaying naturally and found this page while searching the internet for an explanation about why prayer causes swaying. I feel it relates to an energetic/physical benefit that is given to the prayer.

Maybe the prayer is like a signal being transmitted, and swaying helps it transmit. It's kind of an ugly motion though, on its own. Though, it kind of feels like a rock band guitar player if I get really into it.

I want to understand the science of why I'm urged to do this when I think strongly about what I want for myself/others.

Love! Reply

Natacha Mann September 16, 2013

I am not Jewish, yet I found myself swaying back and forth when praying in a standing position within seconds of reciting my prayers. It is the natural thing to do. The body simply cannot remain upright too long. A certain restlessness sets in and if one wishes to be comfortable and able to concentrate in the praying process, rocking back and forth is the only thing to do. It helps the body stay in balance and relieves back pressure.
I strongly believe that this is at the root of this ritual. Simply comfort. Everything else (metaphor of the candle flame, inducing trance-like experiences, etc...) is embellishment. Reply

Llandon Ross April 8, 2013

Thank You!!! Thank You So very Much Rav Posner! This realy helps me alot. :)
Tzadok Reply

SS Montreal, Qc, Quebec, Canada May 20, 2011

swaying
The Neshama (soul) is compared to a flame, always in the upward direction.
Kaballah explains that swaying signifies the soul yearning for closeness to G-d, just like a flame rising upward. Reply

Anonymous Blacksburg, VA April 24, 2011

My take... My experience is somewhat similar to Alexandra. I'm ger...never felt the need to sway when I was being raised Christian, but the first time I really truly hooked into group davening on shabbat I was so filled with light and energy that I couldn't stand still. And it just sort of comes naturally so that half the time I don't even notice I'm doing it. If I catch myself at it, I try to tone it down a little bit, especially as I go to a very reserved shul and I don't want the other folks to feel uncomfortable. My take on it: complete and total willingness to follow the divine will and forego all selfish desires (think Abraham/Isaac level of selflessness) + intimate prayer + minyan = overwhelmingly awesome experience. Reply

Karen Joyce Chaya Fradle Kleinman Bell Riverside, Ca, USA April 21, 2011

I would leave out the King David reference. The reason is that he also said OTHER things we totally not only disregard, but disobey. He said to praise Him with the harp and tambourines, etc., and we don't do that at all. We rationalize our tradition of not following King David's wish that we praise and pray to G-d with joy, music, dance by saying we are in mourning because the temple was destroyed. So, the second part of the answer above is valid. The first part is negated by the example I cited. Reply

Luzy 6791684 October 28, 2008

re: anonymous from Atlanta? Do you feel free to ignore all of rema's rulings, because you have issues with a couple of them? Reply

Alexandra New York, NY October 28, 2008

Swaying is natural I grew up in Soviet Union with no religion. When I started to light candles and pray in my late thirties nobody taught me to sway. I found that I swayed naturally with the flow of prayer. There is something in the energy of Jewish prayer that makes you sway whether you daven aloud of pray silently. Maybe thousand years ago or more someone has made conscious choice, or maybe it comes from the Source and Recipient of all prayer. You let go of and immerse in the flow of prayer, and it sways you. Reply

Anonymous Atlanta, GA August 16, 2008

Clarity What Joel says, does indeed, have some merit. First, the shakers were founded in Manchester, England- so to the person claiming it was an American group- check your history. The second point worth noting is that not all "sephardim" sway; some have been influenced by Ashkenazic practices, others choose to sway. I urge a check on the translation of haredi, which, does in fact, translate to shaker. Eliezer Liebermann in Dessau 1818, contrasts the typical Jewish service with that of the non-Jew: "Why should we not draw a lesson from the people among whom we live? Look at the Gentiles and see how they stand in awe and reverence and with good manners in their house of prayer. No one utters a word, no one moves a limb..." I understand that the rama says that it is acceptable; however, the rama also permitted Moravian Jews to drink non-kosher wine. And, while we are quoting the Rama, lets remember that it was the Rama who said it was necessary to lay tefillin during Chol Hamoed. Reply

Menachem Posner for Chabad.org July 21, 2008

RE: DId the Rebbe Sway? You are correct; the Rebbe did not sway in the almost frenzied manner often associated with Chassidim. He did, however, rock slightly. One can suggest that this is consistent with the traditional Chabad aversion to ostentatious displays of devotion. Reply

Rick Stern NY, NY July 20, 2008

DId the Rebbe Sway? I had the honor of praying with the Rebbe multiple times, and have seen videos or him praying. I do not recall ever seeing him sway. Any insights Rabbi Posner? Reply

luzy July 18, 2008

To Joel Hareidi, literally does mean shaker. But god-fearing Jews have been called Hareidim way before the Shakers came around. See Isaiah 66:5 "Hear the word of the Lord, all those who shake/tremble (hareidim) to his words." Reply

luzy July 18, 2008

To Joel Your theory doesn't make too much sense. Jews swayed before the Shakers even came around. Plus, the Shakers were an American group. When they were big, there were very few Jews in America, so how could the Shakers' shaking reach the Jews in Europe?

Plus their shaking was not at all like our swaying. Reply

Itche July 17, 2008

Response to Joel The Rama in the Code of Jewish Law (sec. 48) says that those who are scrupulous "Medakdekim" sway during prayer. The Mogen Avraham says that there are Poskim (codifiers of Jewish law) who argue; and he concludes that both ways are fine as long as the person has Kavana - concentration. Reply

Anonymous Orlando, FL July 16, 2008

Swaying I sway because I have plantar fascitis (inflamed muscle along the bottom of my feet). Swaying relieves the pain. Reply

Related Topics
This page in other languages