Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Ask the Rabbi
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Questions & Answers » Ask the Rabbi » Latest Questions » Advice » Lonely and Sad Cancer Survivor
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment7 Comments

Lonely and Sad Cancer Survivor


Question:

I am a young woman suffering deeply from depression and anxiety after having gone through cancer treatment and surgery. I have much guilt about my state of mind and heart. I wish so much to feel grateful instead of angry and sad. I fear my faith has run away and left me very lonely. I'm constantly wondering why I have to be here on this earth.

Do you have any suggestion for ridding me of these thoughts?

Answer:

What you describe is not unusual for survivors of cancer and other illnesses. Not feeling well, being diagnosed with cancer, facing the reality, undergoing the treatment... I can only imagine the whole cocktail of emotions. Yet, during all that time the focus was on healing. And now that that's been done, you find yourself depressed and anxious, angry and sad. Surviving an illness is not just about curing the body, it's also about healing the mind and heart. And there are steps you can take to accomplish that.

First, as you've already done, it's important to acknowledge your feelings. Understand that they are normal and common. Many survivors fear recurrence of the illness, are anxious about possible symptoms. Anger, undirected or misdirected anger, is often an emotional byproduct. A feeling of loneliness, too—not because of lack of faith, but because you live in a reality that's not shared with those around you. Eventually, though, these feelings become less and less pronounced, and although they may never completely disappear, they do begin to fade. Accept that your feelings are a normal part of the process of healing. And realize that these feelings are not antithetical to feelings of gratitude to G‑d. These feelings do not, in any way, indicate a loss of faith. Your feeling of loneliness in no way mitigates G‑d's actual presence.

There's a Yiddish saying, "Tracht gut vet zein gut," if you think positive thoughts, it will be positive. Two opposing thoughts cannot coexist in your mind. So, make a list of positive thoughts. Really, an actual list. And practice these thoughts. It may help to say them aloud, and then think them. One at a time. Over and over again. And like any exercise, as you use them, they get stronger. And then, when a negative thought enters your mind, willfully bring to the forefront of consciousness one of the positive thoughts you've been practicing. This means that you don't have to start searching for positive feelings—you've got your list of thoughts ready to be accessed.

Be around positive people. And if someone around you, even someone near and dear, gives off a negative vibe, banish that person from your presence. Allow only positive vibes to surround you. And if it's yourself that's giving off a negative vibe, dance a little jig. Really, use your feet if you have the strength, or your hands... your shoulders... your body—get your body to act as if your mind were feeling happy. Whistle a happy tune. Snap your fingers in rhythm. Use your knees as bongos. Practice the behaviors of "happy."

Pay particular attention to a specific mitzvah. Choose either one, or all three, of the mitzvot that are traditionally a woman's mitzvah: Separating challah (this is representative of the mitzvah of kosher), lighting candles for Shabbat, and/or mikvah. If these are not yet part of your life, incorporate them. And if they are part of your life, then take it up a notch—perhaps by introducing someone else to one of them, perhaps by doing some additional learning about it, perhaps by taking the time, when performing the mitzvah, to add an additional thought for G‑d.

Wishing you all the best, Shabbat shalom,

Bronya Shaffer for Chabad.org

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment7 Comments

By Bronya Shaffer   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Mrs. Bronya Shaffer is a noted globetrotting lecturer on Jewish women's issues, and serves as a personal counselor and mentor for women, couples and adolescents. Mrs. Shaffer, a responder for Chabad.org’s Ask the Rabbi service, lives with her ten children in Crown Heights, Brooklyn.
All names of persons and locations or other identifying features referenced in these questions have been omitted or changed to preserve the anonymity of the questioners.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Apr 21, 2010
Please Mam dont bee sad, its awful to be alone and to want to die, people are so harsh. We all make mistakes, G-d loves you
Hope be with you I hope you see this
Posted By Worried
via chabadmt.com

Posted: Aug 18, 2008
I've been there myself and ...
I had cancer, which, thank G-d, was successfully treated more than 20 years ago. I've also been treated for depression for more than 40 years, very successfully for the most part.
When I got cancer, I knew intuitively that it meant I was not living my life correctly, and I redoubled my efforts at tikkun haneshama. It turned out that I learned valuable things about myself, that made a much richer life possible for me.
Much of depression is a result of self-reproach, which may have roots in a mistaken assumption that you have to be something you're not,
Look at all the good things in your life, and be more forgiving of yourself for suffering. and "Tracht gut vet zein gut!" (Think positive and you'll get positive results.)
Posted By shlomo dror, jerusalem, israel

Posted: July 27, 2008
Oy!
Although I do not have cancer, I suffer from intractable pain: 24-7-365. People around me usually never guess my true condition because I do what Mrs. Shaffer suggested: I act happy when I am with others. The subconscious mind can't tell truth from fiction so I tell it that I am FINE and HAPPY and pain free.

Nu? It works! Something many people never even think about doing is seeing a qualified hypnotist. There is a relatively new form of therapy called EFT. Ask around, IT WORKS and it's not toxic. May Hashem give you a perfect healing; I am sending you all the love I can, I hope you feel it and the hugs that go with it.
Posted By Beverly Kurtin, Ph.D., Hurst, TX/USA

Posted: June 27, 2008
I'm happy I found this article
I just happened to stumble upon this article and I'm very happy I did. I had a tumor (not cancer, thank G-d) in 1997 that took three operations to remove. I've felt everything that you described so well in the 2nd paragraph, but I never, in all the time since, got to a point where I thought my feelings were a normal part of the healing process. What an absolutely freeing thought! I always felt they were a mark of something wrong with me (and more recently, something wrong with my faith). I appreciate this article and your suggestions and will look for a way to apply it personally. Thank you!
Posted By Michael, Minnetonka

Posted: June 4, 2008
After going through deep depression, and being told to be happy I'm alive, reading this has for the first time given me a glimmer of how to proceed emotionally. Mrs. Shaffer, how could you know my every feeling and thought? No one understands the loneliness because, as you so perfectly phrased it, it's a reality that I inhabit all alone even with all the jabbering around me. I am decided that starting this Friday I will light my candles which are gathering dust for years now. Thank you for your wisdom and your empathy and your suggestions and your positive thinking.
Posted By Rena Saul, LA, USA

Posted: June 2, 2008
Fellow survivor
I understand how you feel, being a survivor myself. What you are going through is called remission. And I believe Rebbitzen Schaffer addressed it very well in the article. I would just like to reiterate her point through my own experience. When finding out you have cancer you have the clearest vision on perspective possible. It is like taking off a pair of blinders that have been on for years. And now you see what is important in life and you want to accomplish that goal. But because you are to sick from chemo you cannot accomplish anything you wanted and that can make you very depressed. The best solution I can suggest is do small things one at a time. And get others to do it as well. For ex. the three mitzvos listed above. Just get friends to join you in not only doing these mitzvos but recruiting others to do it as well. And you can do things so simple as post it as your mood on facebook.

Be a link in the survivor chain and stand strong.

moshiach now.
Posted By A fellow jew

Posted: June 2, 2008
stay connected
You may be upset, but you are being honest about how you feel, you are sharing your feelings, and you are asking for help. These are three great virtues that not all people possess. I wish you strength in your pursuit of happiness. I'm sure you'll find it, and I know that no one can deny it to you.
Posted By Mike, Elizabeth, NJ



 


Advice
How can I go about regaining my spirituality?
How do I find the energy to handle my difficult situation?
Should I marry and move away from my family?
Is it normal to have pre-wedding doubts?
How do I get my children to appreciate their heritage?
I want to convert—despite my Jewish boyfriend...
Why no Family Purity laws after menopause?
Lonely and Sad Cancer Survivor
Can a homosexual be Jewish without losing his or her identity?
Why is my mother irked that I am becoming more observant?
Is there a prayer for infertility?
How do I maintain my Jewish observance despite family opposition?
I want to convert but I have a non-Jewish boyfriend...
Can we throw a homeless person out of our synagogue?
Help! I ate something that wasn’t kosher!
Showing 86 - 100 of 154