Contact Us

The Rebbe on the Holocaust

The Rebbe on the Holocaust

What the Rebbe Said (and Didn't Say) About the Holocaust

 Email
Detail from ''Pogrom I'', a painting by Chassidic artist Zalman Kleinman
Detail from "Pogrom I", a painting by Chassidic artist Zalman Kleinman

The Lubavitcher Rebbe, of righteous memory, is widely recognized as one who played a singular role in defining post-Holocaust Jewry. But what did the Rebbe say and teach about that event itself?

Like millions of his generation, the Lubavitcher Rebbe was personally touched by the Holocaust. His younger brother, DovBer, was shot to death and thrown into a mass grave, as were tens of thousands of other Jews in a series of massacres conducted by the Germans shortly after their occupation of Dnepropetrovsk in the fall of 1941. A beloved grandmother and other family members were also killed. The Rebbe's wife lost her younger sister Sheina, who perished in Treblinka together with her husband and their adopted son.

In his writings and discussions on the subject, the Rebbe rejected all theological explanations for the Holocaust. What greater conceit -- the Rebbe would say -- and what greater heartlessness, can there be than to give a "reason" for the death and torture of millions of innocent men, women and children? Can we presume to assume that an explanation small enough to fit inside the finite bounds of human reason can explain a horror of such magnitude? We can only concede that there are things that lie beyond the finite ken of the human mind. Echoing his father-in-law, the Rebbe would say: It is not my task to justify G‑d on this. Only G‑d Himself can answer for what He allowed to happen. And the only answer we will accept, said the Rebbe, is the immediate and complete Redemption that will forever banish evil from the face of the earth and bring to light the intrinsic goodness and perfection of G‑d's creation.

To those who argued that the Holocaust disproves the existence of G‑d or His providence over our lives, the Rebbe said: On the contrary -- the Holocaust has decisively disproven any possible faith in a human-based morality. In pre-war Europe, it was the German people who epitomized culture, scientific advance and philosophic morality. And these very same people perpetrated the most vile atrocities known to human history! If nothing else, the Holocaust has taught us that a moral and civilized existence is possible only through the belief in and the acceptance of the Divine authority.

The Rebbe also said: Our outrage, our incessant challenge to G‑d over what has occurred -- this itself is a most powerful attestation to our belief in Him and our faith in His goodness. Because if we did not, underneath it all, possess this faith, what is it that we are outraged at? The blind workings of fate? The random arrangement of quarks that make up the universe? It is only because we believe in G‑d, because we are convinced that there is right and there is wrong and that right must, and ultimately will, triumph, that we cry out, as Moses did: "Why, my G‑d, have you done evil to Your people?!"

But the most important thing about the Holocaust to the Rebbe was not how we do or do not understand it, nor, even, how we memorialize its victims, but what we do about it. If we allow the pain and despair to dishearten us from raising a new generation of Jews with a strong commitment to their Jewishness, then Hilter's "final solution" will be realized, G‑d forbid. But if we rebuild, if we raise a generation proud of and committed to their Jewishness, we will have triumphed.

[Editor's note: The 10th day of the Jewish month of Tevet is a most tragic date in Jewish history. On Tevet 10 of the year 3336 from creation (425 BCE), the Babylonian emperor Nebuchadnezzar laid siege to Jerusalem -- a siege that resulted in the conquest of the city, the destruction of the Holy Temple, and the exile of the people of Israel from their land. To this day, Tevet 10 is observed as a day of fasting, mourning and repentance. More recently, it was chosen to also serve as a "general kaddish day" for the victims of the Holocaust, many of whose day of martyrdom is unknown (Jewish law stipulates that if the day of a person's passing is unknown, an appropriate date is selected on which to say the kaddish prayer in his or her merit). On one occasion, the Rebbe devoted a significant part of a Tevet 10 address to speak about the Holocaust and convey some of the ideas expressed in this article.]

By Yanki Tauber; based on the teachings of the Rebbe.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with Chabad.org's copyright policy.
 Email
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
110 Comments
1000 characters remaining
Norman Hauptman Yonkers July 1, 2017

No, it was not "the German people" who did government genocide. This is incorrect speech. It was a fraction, "some German people" who committed it.

If I were to say "The Israeli Jewish" people deceive investors thru binary trading, it would be inaccurate. "Some Israeli Jews" deceive investors" is accurate.

Thanks for your essays and reporting on Rebbe, Torah & Judaism

Israel & The Nations Reply

Anonymous October 26, 2016

Willa from henrico
Just read your feedback very pragmatic reading
Thank you Reply

Anonymous Myrtle Beach via jewishmyrtlebeach.com August 12, 2016

God did not do this evil. Men did. Reply

Analesia cassels Liverpool August 12, 2016

Absolutely fascinating article. Reply

Reuven green Israel March 28, 2016

Morenu ve Rabeinu I would very much like to hear the opinión of our Master and Teacher Rabbi Tsvi Freeman. I believe his insights will be more than helpful.
Rabbi: can you shed light for us please? Reply

Devorah Philadelphia March 25, 2016

Rebbe of righteous memory on the Holocaust What our Rebbe had to say about the Holocaust is perfect. He is absolutely right. What I would like to add is perhaps imperfect and I am truly not trying to run for first place in any competition but one has to inquire how so many upstanding citizens of an enlightened and educated populace managed to perpetrate a crime against Humanity. Specifically a life unexamined. By shielding people from the danger of examination of conscience it teaches them to hold fast to whatever the prescribed rules of conduct be at a given time in a given Society. Thou shalt not kill becomes mass murder is OK, thou shalt not bear false witness, becomes tear down anyone who dares to stand against us. Good is bad and bad is good. No good deed goes unpunished. No Law will stand in the initiation of lawlessness. Including the Courts. Which is what happened in Germany. The complete lack of personal accountability is indeed striking and yet most of them managed to get away with it. As if it never was. Reply

Willa Henrico November 29, 2015

And yet... And yet today, these very atrocities are still being committed all over the world. Look to Herzegovina/Bosnia in the 90's, Somalia, (both the first and second civil wars), Tibet, Rwanda, Uganda, Brazil, North Korea and Dafur... and the list goes on and on. It is not for us to question G-d why, but instead, for us to stand up against these horrific atrocities and demand that those who are able to stand. This is the lesson we must take away from the Jewish Holocaust, where so many other countries and peoples are in the midst of their own holocausts today. It is the responsibility of the righteous, to make a stand against those who do evil, and would wipe whole peoples off the face of this earth. Reply

Anonymous via jewishthailand.com February 25, 2015

Yes, that is so true! Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a leading light in Christian theology, was murdered by the final orders of Hitler. Many Christians lost their lives in the death camps as well as Jews, because they were seen as sympathetic to the Jews - indeed many Jews owe their lives to Christians who risked their own lives to save them. To question why this insanity happened is, perhaps, as the Rebbe said, not a valid question at all. Why is their such insanity - doesn't this beg the question of why is their sin? That's a tough one - why is there an evil inclination in most of us? What is the purpose of this? It's a really tough question. Reply

Marco Galbiati London, UK February 24, 2015

While it is true that Jews were the main target of the naxi madness, thousands of non-Jews suffered the same atrocities in the concentration camps. So it is correct to speak of common suffering. Moreover, I think the Holocaust was a crime against humanity as a whole, and as such it touches anyone. And by the same token, the lessons it teaches are for all humans, now and in the future. Reply

Shoshana - Jerusalem Jerusalem September 14, 2014

Holocaust - to anonymous Sept 10 While I do not understand every thing you wrote, you said something about the non-Jew's interest in the subject because of "common suffering".

What " common suffering?" The non-Jews never suffered anything even remotely similar to what the Jews went through. Perhaps you should read up on the Holocaust and find out what it was all about. Reply

Anonymous September 10, 2014

Some sort of a paradox What could be the reason for a non-Jew by which the holocaust attracts so much his attention. May be, perhaps, because Holocaust partakes a common point with suffering. Whenever it's spoken of Holocaust horrors the interior mind mirrors those horrors with its own horrors. This of course is a magnifying process but as well a spiritual process of strengthening. May be that all this is as it is because the more thinner the dog, more the fleas he can carry. Reply

Sientje Seinen Canada January 23, 2014

holocaust-shalom Somehow I have a different perspective on when the Israelites asked Aaron to make a golden calf in the absence of Moses, when Moses saw this he broke the two tablets. I believe he asked for the people who were on the "Lord's side to step to the right, and those who did not the earth opened up and swallowed them. But I do believe that Moses did intercede at another time when they had angered the Lord and He was going to destroy them, and Moses pleaded that G-d would lose His own glory by leading the Israelites out of Egypt and then destroying them on the way to the promised land. Also and forgive me for this thought, but am wondering if the Jewish people would have returned to Israel without the persecution, so that Israel would become a state and the Lord fullfilling His promise and "I will save a remnant of them and bring them back to their former estate" and today isnt that exactly what is happening? Reply

catherine ny January 17, 2014

human nature One thing for sure....the holocaust is a testament to the nature of man. it is a dark world ...evil beyond imagination is possible. if one does not do anything to stop it before it grows then it will stop you .
the problem is Once evil is in power there is no way to stop it from growing. God of course allows this to occur. why....that is a question that cannot be answered. however we know evil exists and we know we have the power to stop it. vigilance is the key..good people are the key. choice to fight it is the key. evil hides behind lies. that is why it is hard to know exactly where evil is. the insidious nature of evil is what makes it hard to prevent until it is too late. Reply

Avraham USA August 12, 2013

There are no reasons ..for the "massive hatred" and as the article notes,"What greater conceit -- the Rebbe would say -- and what greater heartlessness, can there be than to give a "reason" for the death and torture of millions of innocent men, women and children? ".
That is the message of the article! It is one's individual responsibility to "prevent hatred against anyone and to bring peace". Reply

Marvin Falz Germany August 12, 2013

Shoshana, I was not trying to justify the Nazis, I am trying to find out the reasons for this massive hatred and ways to prevent hatred against anyone and to bring peace. I am sorry if I have stirred heavy emotions in you, it wasn't my intention. Reply

Shoshana Jerusalem August 12, 2013

Holocaust answer to M. Falz and R. Green How can you try to justify the perpetrators of the Holocaust because of their bad upbringing? A person has to know that torture, killing and all the atrocities the German's did are wrong, and he cannot say, as Eichman said, "I was only following orders". No educational system can turn an entire nation into robots. Only evil people could do what the Germans did.
Mr. Green: Yes. We do have to live according to H-shem's Word.

We are three weeks to Rosh Hashanah. Our temporary resident visas are about to expire. We all want them renewed for another year. None of us are permanent residents here. Whoever doubts that has only to visit a cemetery. We also want it to be a good and healthy year. Sometimes we take it all for granted. But a visit to a hospital shows us that there are no guarantees. We tend to think that we made it until now, we'll continue to make it for a good many years to come. But how many haven't?

So let's pray and beg. He's very close to us now. Reply

Avraham USA August 11, 2013

Mr Fatz- while your sentiments are appreciated, to whom do you offer an apology? Those who require apology are dead! "Mass Psychology" is nonsense! It was the complicit collusion of a big part of the German populace that allowed the mass murder of millions ( Jews and non Jews) to occur. They had no excuse. I recommend the documentary Hitler's Children to gain a perspective of German collusion and remorse. Reply

Marvin Falz Germany August 10, 2013

I am very sorry for the holocaust. I was born 1976 on German ground and according to my ID I am Deutsch. I still cannot fathom the cruelties that the Germans have subjected the Jews to and it frightens me that a whole nation came together in crime. Fiona Farrell wrote a comment on January 27, 2013 about understanding abusive behavior. Science says that children who were abused are more likey to become abusers themselves than those whose parents were/are loving.

German children of the 18th century were raised applying "poisonous pedagogy". Alice Miller wrote about that as quoted in the Wikipedia article of pp: "I understand 'black pedagogy' to be a parenting approach that is directed toward breaking the will of the child, in order to make it an obedient subject, with the aid of open or concealed use of force, manipulation, and repression."

Wilhelm Reich used the term "emotional pest" in "Characteranalysis" and he wrote "Masspsychology of Fascism" to explain Nazi-Germany. Reply

Reuven Green Israel August 9, 2013

The Holocaust Shalom! I'd like to share some things I thought about after reading this article, so that you can help me become more clear about the Holocaust issue and its ramifications:
(1) The fact that human values and ethics "allowed" for the Holocaust to happen -or even "made" it happen, does not mean we must live according to Hashems' Word.
The fact that human values, culture and moral allowed for the Holocaust to happen testifies that human values and culture are flawed, and that we need other values. But which other values -cannot be known from the Holocaust.
If I try a certain type of medication -and it doesnt help me- that says a lot about that certain medication. It does not however -say anything- about which medication I must take.
(2) Those who are "outraged" at G-d because of the Holocaust? They are atheists so they're not outraged at Hashem. They're outraged with those who believe in Hashem -in spite of the fact that (in their eyes)- Hashem didn't prevent the Holocaust from happening. Reply

Mechel ben Dov ( Marshall S. Dicker ) West Orange, NJ May 16, 2013

beyond our understanding Why would something like the Holocaust happen?? A generation of Tzadics destroyed....those who devoted their lives to Torah Study and Observance....

We cannot, as human beings, even BEGIN to understand the ways of Hashem and
why and how He causes things to happen. Once we pass away, only then MAY the
reasons....the whys and wherefores.....MAY be revealed to us....

I sit here alone....90% of my Father's family ( RIP ) were murdered...i have only distant cousins....whom I have not seen nor heard from in many years are left...
i dont think any of them are religous or even spiritual......Do I wish i had a family
like there existed in Poland before WW II??? Only every day.....

Hashem is Omnipitent.....There is none other.....never has been never will be.....
He was here before time.....He is here now.....He will be here after time has ended........

We MUST accept the mantle of responsibility as his Children and His Chosen Ones......what an incredible honor.......we are so lucky......
. Reply

This page in other languages