Here's a great tip:
Enter your email address and we'll send you our weekly magazine by email with fresh, exciting and thoughtful content that will enrich your inbox and your life, week after week. And it's free.
Oh, and don't forget to like our facebook page too!
Printed from chabad.org
Contact Us

Can a circumcision be conducted on Shabbat?

Can a circumcision be conducted on Shabbat?

 Email

We read in the Mishna1 that we perform circumcisions on the eighth day of a child's life, regardless whether it is a weekday, Shabbat, a holiday, or even Yom Kippur. If, however, the circumcision was postponed – for health or other considerations – then the brit cannot be held on Shabbat or a Jewish holiday when "work" is prohibited.

There are two exceptions to this rule, when a brit cannot be scheduled for Shabbat: if the child was born via c-section, or if he was born between dusk and nightfall, the halachic "gray area" known as "Bein Hashmashot" (see Days for more on this topic).

Although the circumcision is performed on Shabbat, the preparations for the brit (such as bringing the implements to the brit's location or preparing bandages) must be done before the onset of Shabbat.

Normally, causing a blood-letting wound, even for a productive purpose, is forbidden on Shabbat. Why is circumcision an exception?

(The Talmudic sages debate the biblical source for the obligation to circumcise on the eighth day—even if it falls on Shabbat. Technical aspects aside, though, why does the Torah make this exception?)

There are several angles we can take to answer this question:2

a) On select occasions we find that the observance of various mitzvot supersedes others. Examples: Sacrifices were offered in the Temple on Shabbat; the mitzvah of tzitzit supersedes the prohibition against wearing shatnez; practically all mitzvot are suspended in order to do the mitzvah of saving a life. The One who commanded the mitzvot told us that in certain instances, when certain mitzvot "clash," one mitzvah takes precedence over another. Performing a circumcision on Shabbat can be viewed in the same light.

b) "The children of Israel shall observe the Shabbat, to make the Shabbat throughout their generations as an everlasting covenant."3 The purpose of sanctifying the Shabbat, as well as abstaining from work on this holy day, is in order to maintain the everlasting covenant between G‑d and His people. As such, the brit, which is the ultimate expression of G‑d's covenant – etched in our very bodies – does not pose a contradiction to Shabbat observance. According to this reasoning, circumcision doesn't supersede Shabbat, rather it is completely in line with the spirit of the Day of Rest. We honor the Shabbat by conducting circumcisions.

c) The covenant of circumcision symbolizes our essential bond with G‑d. This essential bond transcends the Torah and mitzvot and their observance (which is why a "sinful" Jew is just as Jewish as his most righteous counterpart).4 Accordingly, circumcision doesn't supersede or complement the Shabbat—it exists on a level that transcends all the do's and don'ts of the Torah.

Rabbi Naftali Silberberg,
Chabad.org Editorial team

Footnotes
1.

Tractate Shabbat ch. 19.

2.

See Likkutei Sichot vol. 35 p. 54 ff.

4.

The purpose of Torah and mitzvot is to reveal this innate connection and to thus sanctify the individual and his environs. They do not affect the essential connection between a Jew and his Creator.

Rabbi Naftali Silberberg is a writer, editor and director of the curriculum department at the Rohr Jewish Learning Institute. Rabbi Silberberg resides in Brooklyn, New York, with his wife, Chaya Mushka, and their three children.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with Chabad.org's copyright policy.
 Email
Join the discussion
1000 characters remaining
Email me when new comments are posted.
Sort By:
Discussion (4)
August 17, 2016
C-section
Regardless if it was an emergency C-section or scheduled, The Brit will not be performed on Shabbat. A Brit will supersede Shabbat only if Shabbat is the eighth day from a natural birth.

Simcha Bart for Chabad.org
August 12, 2016
C-sections
There should probably be a distinction between a c-section where the mother can control the day on which the surgery is performed and one where the mother has no choice e.g. emergency or surgeon/hospital availability etc.
David Stafford
Melbourne, Australia
January 22, 2016
To Chana
The mohel will need to sleep in or within reasonable walking distance of the location will the bris will be (and bring his instruments over before Shabbat if he's staying elsewhere).
Chabad.org Staff
chabadone.org
January 20, 2016
How does the mohel gets to you if it is Shabbat?
Chana Engelman