HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Ask the Rabbi
 
Chabad.org » Ask the Rabbi » Latest Questions » The Big Picture » I've been thinking that Life after Death is a fairy tale...


Share thisPost a CommentPrintSend this page to a friendSubscribe
3 Comments Posted

Lately I've been thinking that Life after Death is a fairy tale...



Question:

Lately I've been thinking that Life after Death is a fairy tale created by man to give people hope that once we die, consciousness continues to exist (it's a frightening thought to think otherwise). My gut tells me that the brain and body is what controls everything around me, and that once they shut down consciousness ceases to exist. I even ask myself why I am writing this to you because I know that no one can prove the existence of an afterlife and what happens next, but I guess I have nothing to lose.

Answer:

Thanks for expressing your thoughts. Thinking about life beyond this material existence is daunting to say the least. What is existence after I pass on? What type of "life" will it be? Will I be ready for it? These are the type of questions I ask myself when pondering this subject.

Perhaps, better than asking what life is after death, one should ask what life is prior to death. Is life merely a material existence that I live for today, for the here and now? Is there then no greater goal, a mission that is larger than life? What is the meaning of existence today, before I die? I think that by answering these questions you might be better equipped to begin delving into the subject of an afterlife.

A person doesn't live by the power of his brain, through the energy of the heart. If that were the case then what is the cause of someone's death when there is no apparent change to the brain or heart? There must be something beyond that, deeper than that, which causes the brain to think and the heart to feel and energize. This is the soul—a part of G‑d that is vested within each one of us. It drives us and energizes us. It is the element which connects us to something greater than ourselves—to G‑d. Without the soul we would be no different than the animal that lives for that green pasture and a nice bit of shade to nap in. Is that the life you ascribe to? I don't think so. I think you feel impelled to be part of the greater good; to look beyond yourself and the here & now. It is the soul that, perhaps unknowingly, adds this dimension to your life.

When we speak of afterlife it is the soul we are referring to. Yes, the body is interred and returned to its maker. It is the soul dimension of man, perhaps the true dimension that continues to "live." It continues to seek out ways to be part of the greater good, to reach greater heights to become closer to G‑d, as it did during the person's physical lifetime.

I hope that this has been a help to you. You might find this article of interest.

Wishing you a Happy Chanukah,

Rabbi Shmuel Kogan,
Chabad.org


Share thisPost a CommentPrintSend this page to a friendSubscribe
3 Comments Posted

By Shmuel Kogan   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Shmuel Kogan of Brooklyn, NY, is a responder for Chabad.org's Ask the Rabbi feature.
All names of persons and locations or other identifying features referenced in these questions have been omitted or changed to preserve the anonymity of the questioners.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: July 7, 2009
Life after death
There are many, many people who have died, went somewhere else, and came back here. I know, I was one of them.

There is something after this.
Posted By Saul, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA

Posted: Dec 31, 2007
Life after Death is a fairy tale...
April 25, 1098, I was severly struck in the throat. Ambulance, red lights, and siren on the way to Harborview Trauma Center, Seattle.

My wife and daughter were summoned and when they arrived my wife stode into the room and marched up the the two doctors and said, "what's wrong with him, he's sitting up there and looks good?" Dr. Prinzower said, "well he is sitting there, but we can't explain how he is sitting there AND we can't explain how he's getting oxygen." His throat is sweld closed and he's a hematoma the size of a "salami". But if he goes again we'll trac. him. Debbie said, "what do you mean...if he goes again?" We know he died once already!
Once I could get air to go in and out of my throat/nose the doctors relaxed a bit. One doctor came to ask me those very same questions.
This I am positive about... we are a soul with a body encasement and we shed it. The brain stays, but the mind/memories you take with. Prepare! I walked into a great shul & finding answers...new eyes!
Posted By R. Murray, Seattle, WA/USA

Posted: Dec 15, 2007
Consciousness
I am delighted by Rabbi Kogan's answer, which is a beautiful explanation of the Jewish teaching on the subject.

As this is a question that bothered me for many years, I hope I may be forgiven for adding my two cents' worth of insight, especially as I approached the question from a different perspective (that of cognitive science and neuroscience) in my own studies.

The question asked refers to the so-called "mind-body problem": Is consciousness a process in the brain, or is it something else? As the phrase implies, this has been indeed a "problem" for Western thinkers over the last 400 years, and no consensus has yet been reached. Since the beginning of the 20th century, most serious Western cognitive scientists have been working with the assumption that consciousness is indeed a physical process. However, so far this has proven to be only an arbitrary assumption, and one that fails to account for all the data. While most psychological processes could be explained in neurological terms, there is at least one mental phenomenon (but a crucial one) which defies such explanation: the very fact of bare awareness (that is, that cognitive processes are actually experienced rather than taking place "in the dark"; that there is something it is "like" to experience things) remains as elusive to the materialist theory as it ever was. Not only do we have no theory of what a physical basis of bare awareness might be, we have no idea what such a theory might even look like.

If you truly wish to explore this question in depth, I recommend the first half of David Chalmers's book "The Conscious Mind," which provides a very rigorous discussion of the subject.

Now, if it indeed turns out that consciousness is not merely a process in the brain, but a parallel (though certainly interdependent) process, two questions naturally arise: How does it begin? And how does it end?

Ultimately, whatever you may think of the question of the continuity of consciousness, there is simply no logical argument (including Occam's razor and other scientific paradigms) or empirical evidence presently available to allow us to dismiss the hypothesis as a mere fairy tale.
Posted By GC



 


The Big Picture
How and why have Jews survived through the ages?
Is repentance meaningless if I later repeat the mistake?
Understanding Human Suffering
How does Judaism contribute to world peace?
Response to an Agnostic
Why does the orthodox community promote gender-segregated schools?
Where is G‑d?
I've been thinking that Life after Death is a fairy tale...
Why the Rebbe pictures?
Why is it important to dress modestly?
What is the Jewish perspective on hate?
How can any human claim to know of "other worlds"?
How does one find atonement in the absence of sacrifices?
Is Judaism an elitist religion?
Why are some people more talented than others?
Showing 75 - 89 of 115