Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Ask the Rabbi
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Questions & Answers » Ask the Rabbi » Latest Questions » The Big Picture » Why does the orthodox community promote gender-segregated schools?
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment10 Comments

Why does the orthodox community promote gender-segregated schools?


Question:

Why does the orthodox community so strongly promote gender segregation, especially in schools? How will these children eventually know how to communicate with the opposite gender in marriage if they don't have any opportunity to learn inter-gender social skills in school?

Answer:

The orthodox community is privy to what psychological tests have recently discovered—that men and women, or girls and boys, do much better in their own environment, with their own gender, away from any sexual pressures or intimidations. When girls are in classes surrounded by only girls, studies show that their confidence level is higher and they take greater risks at working on new areas of learning. Boys, too, show higher success rates in classes with only boys.

This is true, because, as Torah explains, men and women are very different—biologically, psychologically, physiologically and in just about every area. We communicate differently (thus the best seller "Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus") and we learn differently. When we are with peers of the same gender we feel less of a need to prove ourselves and we can each learn in a more comfortable environment conducive to academic growth.

This is true with young children but becomes increasingly obvious when they get to teenhood. The pressures on teenagers in mixed gendered schools to become involved in sexual experiences way before they are ready is astounding and evidence enough for the problems of such a system. Add to that the plummeting self-esteem of so many teens (girls especially, but boys as well) and their self-critical body images (sometimes leading to food disorders and other serious illnesses) and you can see how the system is ripe for disaster.

As far as learning to communicate with one another, I guess it comes naturally enough, when the time is right. Built into the human psyche is the attraction that each gender feels to one another. Being a part of the "segregated" orthodox communities, I have never heard this to be a problem. When the time is right, the young man and woman might feel shy at first, but the barriers are quickly broken, if the two are meant for one another, and they quickly learn the necessary social skills.

Chana Weisberg for Chabad.org

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment10 Comments

By Chana Weisberg   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Chana Weisberg is the Director of Editorial Management at hC Chabad.org. Her latest books include Tending the Garden: The Unique Gifts of the Jewish Woman and the best selling Divine Whispers on finding spirituality in daily life. She has served as the Dean of several women's educational institutes and lectures internationally on issues relating to women, faith, relationships and the Jewish soul.
All names of persons and locations or other identifying features referenced in these questions have been omitted or changed to preserve the anonymity of the questioners.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Dec 10, 2009
To anonymous from Toronto
I'm glad that Chabad.org is liberal enough to post all comments; it really demonstrates that they are not afraid of diverse opinions and views. But sometimes, this freedom leads to malicious and false comments like yours.

Do you have ANY way to corroborate what you write here?

Not only are you dead wrong about your "facts", the truth is that more and more people are coming to see the wisdom and many benefits of single-sex schools. I recently saw a write up on cnn.com about a school that separated boys and girls and saw a very marked rise in both groups’ test scores.
Posted By Jared

Posted: Dec 10, 2009
Please do some research.
I know you orthodox types dont like to admit it but abuse occurs in a significant amount of Jewish marriages (15-25%).

It is largely due to the fact that these young men and women come out of segregated schools, date for a few months and then get married. They have no idea how to communicate with each other or resolve conflicts.

When it doesn't work out, however, the women are trapped. The social stigma of divorce is too high for her to leave an abusive marriage.
Posted By Anonymous, Toronto

Posted: June 16, 2009
you are correct
exactly, good interpretation of the Torah right there. I appreciate you standing up for what is right and competent.

I see the need in high school age, before that perhaps, but the disrespect begins as a freshman in high school it is common, well known and each gender needs to learn this skill, we have to teach each other to appreciate their neighbors no matter what their rank and it begins with development of puberty.
Posted By kathy jordan, north myrtle beach, sc

Posted: Apr 26, 2009
too simple
The issues are not this simple. How can u live in such denial w/o being aware of the problems our "frum" system creates. It works well for the (naturally?) rigid boy or unattractive girl. Otherwise it can be disastrous. Look out the window.
Posted By Dover Amiti

Posted: Apr 3, 2008
First, having gone to co-ed school my whole life, let me say, I wish I had gone to an all-girls' school. There is too much pressure, catfights, drama, etc. And many fall along the way to teen sex, drugs, etc, in order to look good to someone else. To Tarek-don't worry or feel embarrassed that you are 16 and not dating. I did not date in high school either, except once when friends set me up and it lasted a month. It is not worth it; you will probably just find yourself competing with and comparing yourself to your friends and where they're at in their relationships. It is really not worth it, when you should be concentrating on school.
Posted By cr

Posted: Dec 1, 2007
Congratulations
I am happy to hear that.

I will take this story to heart because sometimes I feel like im the only boy in my school not dating (there is an all girls school right next to ours and we share some classes so it is not very separate). It is nice to hear that you have only dated two people because I am 16 and have dated one, but it doesn't even count lol. All the guys at my school are all dating and stuff like that so it is nice to hear.
Posted By Tarek
via chabadaz.com

Posted: Dec 1, 2007
tried both-seperate is better
I attended a "modern orthodox" yeshiva high school that was co-ed (including the religious studies) and then I went to an all girls seminary in Israel- and I must say the Israel experience was much better. I learned so much more factually and spiritually, and experienced much more personal growth in an all women's environment than in my co-ed high school environment. Plus, thank G-d, I had had no problem on the dating front -- I am getting married, G-d willing, in three months to the second boy I ever dated, and I do not credit my high school experience -- rather I credit the growth and maturity I attained in seminary.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: Nov 29, 2007
I agree
I am in a Jesuit Highschool lol

Not Jewish yet lol, I love this site though.
Posted By Tarek
via chabadaz.com

Posted: Nov 28, 2007
Not only Orthodox Jewish day schools
I am Jewish and I do not necessarily agree with having gender segregation in schools. However, I hate when some people are so ignorant that they act as if Orthodox Jewish day schools (and Conservative ones as well; if I'm not mistaken, the Schechter day schools have gender segregation also) are the only parochial schools that have this practice. Plenty of Catholic and Protestant parochial schools similarly segregate genders.

So stop acting like it's some odd practice exclusive to Judaism, people! :)
Posted By Anonymous, NY

Posted: Nov 27, 2007
So True
I love reading articles that deal with this subject, because I agree so strongly. Being in an all boys high school I can relate to this strongly. I have 2 classes with girls and this is completely true.
Posted By Tarek
via chabadaz.com



 


The Big Picture
Why thank G-d for rescuing us from predicaments He created?
Is there special significance to events wherein G‑d's hand is obvious?
How and why have Jews survived through the ages?
Is repentance meaningless if I later repeat the mistake?
Understanding Human Suffering
How does Judaism contribute to world peace?
Response to an Agnostic
Why does the orthodox community promote gender-segregated schools?
Where is G‑d?
I've been thinking that Life after Death is a fairy tale...
Why the Rebbe pictures?
Why is it important to dress modestly?
What is the Jewish perspective on hate?
How can any human claim to know of "other worlds"?
How does one find atonement in the absence of sacrifices?
Showing 88 - 102 of 196