Here's a great tip:
Enter your email address and we'll send you our weekly magazine by email with fresh, exciting and thoughtful content that will enrich your inbox and your life, week after week. And it's free.
Oh, and don't forget to like our facebook page too!
Printed from
Contact Us

Who Needs a Human Moshiach?

Who Needs a Human Moshiach?

Moshiach and Mortgage Brokers



I appreciate the point about the world having a goal and destiny and how the world is evolving towards a state of perfection and redemption. But why the focus on a human being as the redeemer? If redemption is that crucial, couldn't G‑d do it on His own?


In typical rabbi fashion let me explain with a parable.

I've recently noticed that mortgage brokers are sprouting up all over the place. More and more people prefer to use mortgage brokers rather than the old-fashioned system of setting up an appointment with their bank. The reason? With so many different loans and lenders in the market, it's highly advisable to rely on a mortgage broker to do the legwork for you. With a broker you have access to a greater range of mortgage options, better service and you can use the broker to negotiate with lenders on your behalf. The banks also benefit from this trend, as they can now conserve manpower by outsourcing to the brokers the task of finding and qualifying borrowers. Most importantly, the broker "understands the language" of both the lenders and the clients. Thus, the broker acts as a successful intermediary.

No one else other than us can do the job. All others have a "conflict of interest"...What would happen if it was discovered that a mortgage broker is actually an employee of a particular lending institution? That's what we call a dishonest broker. He would lose his license and possibly be culpable for a variety of legal penalties. It would be like two conflicting parties finally agreeing to mediate, only to discover that the designated arbitrator has a direct financial or personal interest in the outcome of the arbitration.

Same thing with Moshiach. Our duty is to create a union between the world's material substance and its spiritual reality, to marry Heaven and Earth. Call it arbitration, negotiation, brokerage or match-making. We have been entrusted with the sacred mission of perfecting this world by bringing spirituality and G‑dliness into an otherwise ungodly world. Our observance of the mitzvot all center on this ideal of bridging the chasm between G‑dliness and Worldliness. Every time we engage in the physical act of performing a mitzvah we speed up the process of "drawing down" the Divine into our environment.

No one else other than us can do the job. All others have a "conflict of interest" and represent one of the two parties. Who do you propose to use as the negotiator between both parties? G‑d? He, as it were, can't do it on His own. He's representing one of the parties...

We, on the other hand, possess a soul which is "part of G‑d above," yet this G‑dly soul is garbed in a physical and corporeal body. We "understand the language" of both parties and are therefore the perfect candidate for the task of merging the two.

The consummation of this process will be realized in the Era of Redemption when every dimension of our worldly existence will be truly permeated by G‑dliness. In the words of our Sages: "Currently we are in a state of betrothal; in the World to Come—will be the Marriage."

Moshiach, the one who will usher in the redemption, is a "man of this world," a flesh-and-blood human being who undergoes physical challenges such as stress, opposition and health-considerations. Yet, his soul is as pure and pristine as they come. He will have nullified his ego and intellect to be consistent with the Divine will. He has a good take on both Heaven and Earth.

Indeed, an honest broker.

Rabbi Yossi Braun lectures on Talmud, Jewish law and Chassidism in Sydney, Australia.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with's copyright policy.
Join the discussion
1000 characters remaining
Email me when new comments are posted.
Sort By:
Discussion (16)
July 22, 2016
Re: Messiah
It may seem impossible, but we believe that it will happen nonetheless, as one of the Messiah's great accomplishments will be to unite all Jews.
Eliezer Zalmanov
July 21, 2016
Impossible. The Jews of the world would not agree a person was the Messiah. The Hassidim of different sects won't even eat together.
The Messiah is inside you already, just meditate on the oneness of creation, the big bang seed, all things interconnected by the quantum foam. This is how G-d reveals himself.
stan miller
July 24, 2015
Lifetime in moshiach
Where does it say in Tanach all the prophecies, all of the tasks will be done all at once in a lifetime? Thanks
January 1, 2015
To Menachem Posner in response to Jemal
In Deuteronomy 17, G-d is not telling the Israelites to have a king rather He predicts a future where Israel will be tempted to ask for a king so that they may look like other nations (Deut 17:14). And what He gives them is instructions on what kind of king to have and in no way does this point to the Moshiach or a desire for Israel to have a human king. Israel already has a King (G-d), why would they need another king?
April 30, 2014
Moses was lifted up to G-d. He spend such time with Adonai on Earth that when the people saw him come down from Sinai, they were extremely discomforted by beams of light pouring from his skin. Also, recall that he was so poor with direct communication, he used Aaron as his prophet. My only point being that while Moshiach will serve a purpose similar to Moses, this mediator characteristic must surpass that of Moshe. A king for today's people must be very ordinary and extraordinary at the same time. The glory and power of Hashem has proven to overwhelm our humble state. To understand the amount of organisms on the Earth or how many stars are in the sky is literally out of our realm of perception. To think that G-d would attempt to reveal His wonder without a very relatable intermediary is shortsighted and inconsiderate of Hashems love and compassion for us.
June 28, 2010
There is a paradox here. On one hand, you so aptly quoted the verses from Samuel where the monarchy is soundly rejected as an ideal. Yet, on the other hand, we read (in Deuteronomy 17) that “you shall set a king over you, one whom the L-rd, your G-d, chooses…”

So is the monarchy good or bad? The key is that it depends how it is to be used. If we choose a king to further our own nationalist ideals, to become a nation like the nations, to grow wealthy and fat, it is a tragedy. On the other hand, if the king serves as a guide and an inspiration to his people and a servant of his Creator, he will have done something truly great.

I recommend that you read Are You a Monarchist? for a fascinating perspective on this matter.
Menachem Posner for
June 26, 2010
No broker needed
In a messianic world, human beings and G-d would have same goals and thus there would be no need for a broker. Banks and lenders have different goals, banks want to make maximum profit off the lender, lenders want the best deal and these goals are contradictory, therefore a broker is needed. Historically a broker was needed our prophets. Jews wanted miracles, G-d wanted mitzvah, so Moses brokered between the two. Jews did mitzvot, the Red Sea was parted. In a perfect state of humanity, Jews would not need to be bribed in this way, they would automatically do mitzvot for the sake of mitzvot. This is the highest level of good. For example, the Holocaust victim who still did mitzvot without any physical evidence of its effectiveness in our world. The ultimate faith is when G-d is hiding and we still do good. In this world, a physical moschiach is counterproductive because it nixes the need for faith. Moschiach I believe will be a state of mind with no evidence at all.
Shenyang, China
June 25, 2010
Re: Who needs a human Moshiach?
You raise important questions as to the meaning of what "being" human actually is. These questions are answered right at the beginning (or thereabout) in Genesis 1:26-28.
June 24, 2010
Who needs a human Moshiach?
But when they said, "Give us a king to lead us," this displeased Samuel; so he prayed to the LORD. And the LORD told him: "Listen to all that the people are saying to you; it is not you they have rejected, but they have rejected me as their king." (1 Shmuel 8:6-7)

"...they have rejected me as their king." This is heartbreaking. When will we choose only G-d? Why would we yearn for a human king instead? Why would we want anyone or anything to stand between us and G-d?
Los Angeles, CA/USA
April 28, 2009
Posted By Anonymous, Malta
Posted By Steve i was asking Posted By Anonymous, Malta and not Posted By Steve
David Marton
Trabuco Canyon, Ca/USA