HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Editorial & Commentary » The Anti-War Movement
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment15 Comments

The Anti-War Movement


For several years now, the leading news story has been the war in the Middle East, with much of the world community, and a growing segment of the American population, opposed to the "unjust" invasion and "occupation" of Iraq.

While I will refrain from offering an uneducated opinion on the issue, I am amazed and encouraged by the reaction this war has generated – on both sides of the political spectrum. To me, the debate revolving around this war emphasizes how much our world has changed in a positive direction. It represents a mind-boggling worldwide movement towards ideals of peace and human rights.

In previous generations, a monarch or leader who led his nation to war was heralded as a hero. The bards sang tributes to the patriotic conqueror who annexed territories and increased the prestige of the homeland. No one asked Alexander the Great or Napoleon why they were leading their countries in battle! Today, however, the world has progressed to the point where it is globally recognized that war is in essence evil and undesirable--even in those instances when it is unfortunately necessary. Invading a sovereign state merely to expand borders or for financial considerations is ethically unthinkable. On this subject there is no debate.

The ironic side of the “Iraq Debate” is that it actually demonstrates how much we do agree on basic principles So what is the debate? Whether this particular war is justified for the sake of defending our borders, the maintenance of world peace, and/or liberating the Iraqi people from the cruel reign of a tyrannical dictator. Is this war advancing all these above-mentioned noble causes, or it is perhaps a red herring which is backfiring and will not bring us closer to any of these objectives?

The ironic side of the "Iraq Debate" is that it actually demonstrates how much we do agree on the principles involved; how basic morals have finally become a mainstay of society. The way I see it, the debate is only a healthy expression of the natural human tendency to have different views regarding the implementation of an agreed-upon goal.

It is this phenomenal shift in how we view war and violence that has brought freedom to hundreds of millions of people--people who less than twenty years ago lived in constant fear under repressive regimes, and now possess freedoms of speech, religion and determination.


And G‑d led the sea with a strong easterly wind all night and He made the Sea into dry land and the waters split – Exodus 14:21.

Did G‑d really need a wind to split the sea? Was it, in fact, the wind that split the sea for the length of time necessary for millions of men, women and children and all their possessions to pass through?! Even if one can envision a wind powerful enough to part a sea, can it also dry the muddy seabed, and transform it into firm ground? Furthermore, according to rabbinic tradition – based on the words of the Psalm "Who split the Sea of Reeds into sections" – the Sea actually divided into twelve corridors, one for each Tribe. Somehow, it is difficult to conceive of a wind intelligent enough to accomplish such a feat!

The wind was a diversion, dispatched by its Creator to lure the Egyptians into the watersThe venerable sage Nachmanides (Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman, 1194-1270) explains that the miraculous parting of the waters had little to do with the easterly wind. The wind was a diversion, dispatched by its Creator to lure the Egyptians into the waters where they would be subjected to the punishment they justly deserved. "You feel that strong wind?" the Egyptian pursuers exclaimed. "The splitting of the sea is not a divine act; it's a freak of nature. After 'em!"

In hindsight, such foolishness is absurd. But on second thought, perhaps we too are guilty of similar misjudgment.

Every year on the last days of Passover, we focus on a dream whose realization we have been awaiting for close to two thousand years. The anticipation has reached a fevered pitch in recent years, following the announcement by the Lubavitcher Rebbe that the Era of Redemption is upon us, and we must only increase in acts of goodness and kindness in order to be worthy to greet our redeemer. The Rebbe pointed to various global phenomena which are clear indicators that the process of redemption has indeed started.

The world's embracing of morals and ethics of peace is astounding and nothing short of miraculous. The question is only how we choose to account for this phenomenon. Is it the orchestrated precursor of the promised era of world peace, or is it simply the result of a strong wind...?

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment15 Comments

By Naftali Silberberg   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Naftali Silberberg resides in Brooklyn, NY, with his wife Chaya Mushka and their three children.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by our content partner, Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

15 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: July 6, 2007

That really is an interesting idea, that most of the world now accepts certain ground rules for war.

Does that idea stay with humanity forever or can it be lost? and if so how?

Also, are there countries that never acceped these understandings and if so, who are we refering to?
Posted By morgan grossman, napa, ca
via jewishnapavalley.com

Posted: Apr 29, 2007
Anti-War Protesters Are They Genuine
Unfortunately many are not as genuine and altruistic as they make out to be. While there is the veneer of care for humanity, there are often more hidden sinister agendum underneath, such as anti-semitism. The arab states have been waging are war of words against Israel in the media for many a year by obscuring plain facts and truths thereby influencing public opinion in their favour. This is dangerous because ignorance has becomes the basis for a significant number of governments' foreign policy.
Posted By Anonymous, Sydney, Australia

Posted: Apr 12, 2007
comment
Regardless what one thinks of war, is it right to torture people? It is right to send people off to secret prisons in foreign countries where torture is sanctioned? Is it right to invade a neighborhood and remove family members, (esp. males) and put them iin prison because we "suspect' they might be engaging in terrorist activities?

If this is the new morality, I want no part of it.
Posted By bob, Boston, MA

Posted: Apr 10, 2007
Baklava for World Peace
Interesting article. Thanks for posting this. Yes, we are all a lot more alike than we care to admit. There are non-violent angles we can all start working on, and end the cycle of violence around the world.
Posted By The Baklava Fairy, Hollywood, CA
via chabadlosfeliz.org

Posted: Apr 8, 2007
War a necessary evil
Thought without action or change is a study in futility.
Posted By Patsy, Texas

Posted: Apr 8, 2007
Hashem's Enemies Take Comfort
The author's comments would be funny if they were not so tragic. While the author revels in our political discourse, people in Iraq, Darfur and North Korea, among other places of death, will continue to die as G-d's enemies take comfort in the lack of cohesion in the West and in the US in particular. To have this article appear on Pesach, when we celebrate our liberation for a despot similar to the one the US overturned in Iraq, leads me to think that the author should be less concerned about how the sea split and more concerned about why the sea split, to lead people to G-d and to freedom.
He might also think about the over three million souls whose death was hastened because the US pulled out of Vietnam in large part because of political dialog similar to today.
Posted By Stuart Davis, Princeton, NJ

Posted: Apr 7, 2007
collective suicide
I find it disgusting that so many American Jews are behaving like such suicidal cowards. I have served in Iraq and let me tell you: HITLER IS BACK AND HE"S WEARING A RAG ON HIS HEAD!!! Those people hate Jews and want to destroy any token of Jewish autonomy in the Middle East. On both sides, Sunni or Shia, the plan of the Islamists after they have driven the U.S out of the Middle East is to drive the Jews out of Israel. And when I hear these liberal Jew's in the media and elsewere attacking the Military, the Police, the war on terrorism; in other words the very institutions that will stand in the way of the next Hitler coming to cut our heads off after yelling Allahu Akbar it makes me sick to my stomach. If my grandfathers had not chose to fight in the woods with the partisans during WWII, and had instead accepted "transportation" and cooperation with the Germans I would not be here today. Lets fight and survive rather than cooperate with the enemy and die....
Posted By Anonymous, san ramon, ca
via chabadcoco.com

Posted: Apr 6, 2007
it's necessary
I am a wife of a U.S. Marine who has been to iraq and now likely going back, i support him and all our troops and the president and the war, yes we do need war, sometimes it is necessary and thank G-d that we fought against germany when the consentration camps were taking place, if it wasn't for war we would not even be writing on a chabad website. all the best
Posted By Leehee, pleasanton, ca
via jewishtrivalley.com

Posted: Apr 6, 2007
re Vietnam
I was a kid. If you have the time, maybe you would google: Vietnam antiwar movement and see for yourself.

In fact, being that the Rebbe said "open your eyes" and see that the Geula is here, this might be an interesting angle to pursue, i..e. the change in attitude towards war, trace the origins.

Good term paper topic :)
Posted By YH

Posted: Apr 6, 2007
Response to YH
To be honest, I am not old enough to remember the Vietnam war and the sentiments which accompanied it. Perhaps you can share your feelings on the matter?
Posted By Naftali Silberberg (author)
via mychabad.org



 


Editorial & Commentary
The Pursuit of Happiness
Expand Virginia-Tech Massacre
Virginia-Tech Massacre
Whose Money Is It Anyway?
The Anti-War Movement
Are We Melting?
Left or Right?
Lawsuit City
Showing 16 - 22 of 96