![]() |
| Detail from a painting by Sarah Kranz |
Question:
I don't pray every day. Sometimes I'm not so sure that I believe in G‑d enough to pray. I just don't think I can have the unwavering faith that people like you seem to have. I'll never be so sure. Can you pray and be a good Jew if your faith is unsteady?
Answer:
To be a Jew means to struggle. The very name Israel means "one who struggles with G‑d." Faith is not a light switch that you turn on and it stays on. Faith is a fire that you need to tend to and fuel, and sometimes rekindle. It is a wrestle that never ends.
The name "Israel" means "one who struggles with G‑d." There are days that your faith shines through and everything fits into place. On these days, you feel at one with yourself and G‑d, and prayer comes naturally. Then there are days that you wake up and all is dark, your faith seems to have dried up. G‑d, soul, prayer, goodness--all seem like annoying insects buzzing in your ear, and you just want to just roll over and go back to sleep.
But even on those days, you have to find the motivation to get up and get on with it. Perhaps your faith won't get you out of bed, so how about trying another approach. Putting aside your faith in G‑d, what about G‑d's faith in you?
There is a powerful prayer that we say as soon as we wake up in the morning:
I give thanks to you, Living and Eternal King, for You have returned my soul to me with kindness. How great is Your faith.
The faith referred to here is not our faith in G‑d, but rather "Your faith"--G‑d's
faith in us.
If your faith in G‑d doesn't get you out of bed, what about G‑d's faith in you?
The very fact that we have woken up is proof that G‑d believes in us. He knows that we are not perfect, is well aware of our failings and knows
the mistakes we have made. And yet, in the morning after our sleep, He returns
our soul to us and gives us another chance, because He trusts us. He has faith
in our ability to change and make today a bit better than yesterday. We may or
may not believe in Him, we may or may not believe in ourselves, but G‑d believes
in us.
Humans are fickle; G‑d is constant. His faith in us is firm and unchanging, even if our faith in Him is shaky. That's the faith of an Israelite, one who struggles with G‑d. We may be struggling, but we are struggling with G‑d - He is always there.
If you woke up this morning, if your soul was returned to you to see another day, then give thanks. Start your day with a prayer, if not out of your faith in G‑d, then at least out of G‑d's faith in you. He trusts you enough to give you a precious soul. Use it.
Is faith the same as belief? If I don't believe in a G-d (as most others understand that word) can I still say that I have faith? It has been my experience that the answer is a big 'Yes'. Ex.; Is the soldier on a battlefield not acting upon faith when he (or she) stands up in the midst of battle, shots of hot lead whizzing by, as he (she) charges forward regardless of fear, and consequence to take on say; an enemy tank, or machine gun nest in order to save the lives of his fellow countrymen. Whether he (or she) believes they will succeed or not, does not come into their mind when making the decision to act. 'Faith' has an element of courage and the bravery to act even without certainty. Of 'Belief'; courage is not a requirement. You do not have to have 'Belief' in order to have Faith. IT IS AS IT IS (Eyeh Asher Eyeh)- Is a name of G-d. All of Reality, including the greater part of it, which is unknown to us. Is 'belief' the same as acceptance of reality? "Use the Force Luke!"
Pasadena, CA
Riverside, CA, USA
Faith? I don't know. It's not a talent one acquires nor a disease one may catch -for lack of better comparison, sorry about that. I think one, all of us, are born with it, knowledge of a Creator.
Perhaps, later in life, after a few disappointments, realizations that fighting our evil inclination is not as easy as we first thought and will go on to the day we die, that free will is a double edged sword, that it will require WORK to grow up, than perhaps something inside gives up, perhaps just out of plain laziness or whatever.
If ones never looses one's sense of wonder - because all the Creator has made IS wonderful - worlds within worlds, infinite, from the macro to the micro universe, it's all wonderful, awe-full, in any direction one looks...
I think one has just to open one's eyes, and there is no need to have "faith." What is that anyway?
Riverside, CA
I'm not so atheistic as OJB, but I am a skeptical Jew. My thoughts about G-d tend to morph between Deism, Pantheism, and of course, Panenthism (which is found in Chassidic philosophy). I often tell people that I have an "agnostic faith." I told Rabbi Altein, that I worship nature, but that I am skeptical of miracles. He made an announcement in shul: "Remember, Folks, there's just one G-d. G-d of Nature, G-d of Miracles; same G-d!"
Pittsburgh, PA / USA
Pasadena, CA
I understand from your post that you are depressed since your husbands death. And i completely get you. I have experienced depression and it has taken me 3 years to start coming out from its spell. My advice is to keep moving. Find activities to keep you active and busy or the depression gets worse and drags on and on. I tried to find answers in my mind but there weren't any, it's better to just get moving in life and find something meaningful to do. Volunteer maybe. I have recently started doing that, it's not easy but it does help.
WOW I am so embarressed. On the other hand i think its wonderful that we can express these baddies within us so that we can see them instead of them lurking under the surface within us derailing us in silence
I don't know whether women "ruling the planet" is likely to result in things being much better. The women who are in positions in power generally seem neither better nor worse than the men!
Dunedin, NZ
G-d is arrogant and only interested in his plan. G-d was made up by men.
So glad women are finally beginning to rule the planet. Now we will finally start to live instead of life just being about ego, status and power.