Question:
A friend gave birth to a baby with a rare condition that has rendered her severely handicapped. She is not expected to live much past her tenth birthday. I just can't understand why G-d does that. If life has a purpose, what is the purpose of such a short and sad life?
Answer:
Every birth is a gamble. A soul enters the world innocent and pure. But it may not stay that way. This world is a maze of diverging pathways, both good and evil, and the choice is ours which way we go. Once a soul enters a body, it is free and therefore vulnerable to corruption. While acts of good elevate the soul, every act of evil makes a blemish on the soul.
Some souls are so lofty, it simply isn't worth the gamble. These souls are too precious to risk being compromised by life in a body. They are too high to come down to this world. But the other option, not to be sent down at all, to never reach this world, would mean that we would miss out on meeting these holy and lofty souls and hearing their message.
So these souls do come down. But in order to be protected from the potential evils of an earthly existence, they are sent down into a body that will not compromise their holiness. They enter this world in a form that is above sin, above evil. From a purely physical perspective we call them "disabled" or "handicapped"; from the perspective of the soul they are protected. They will never sin. Their sojourn in this world is often brief, and in terms of this world may seem sad. But they have retained their purity. And they have fulfilled their mission.
These special souls remind us that true love doesn't need a reason. We often love others for what they give us -- we love our children because they are cute, smart, and high achievers; we love our spouse for the pleasure and contentment they give us; we love our parents because they care for us. This is love, but it is not pure.
When a child is born that will never achieve worldly success, cannot provide the usual source of pride for her parents, all extraneous reasons to love her fall away and what's left is the purest love that there can be. These children are lovable not because of what they do for you, and not because of what they will one day become, but simply because they are.
These pure souls remind us what love should be. Only such a pure and holy soul can elicit such a pure and holy emotion. We can only stand in awe of them, and the parents and friends who care for them. And we can only thank them all, for giving us a glimpse of what true love really means.
G-d makes everything beautiful in His own time, and He is making my heart more and more beautiful with His precious gift. Rebecca Rose is my hero.
California
new zealand
Metairie, La
There is no reason to allow preventable suffering. Your god is no more merciful than Hitler or Pol Pot. Take your god, please.
Private, US
Riverside, CA, USA
Gloucester, Gloucestershire
which can brighter the dark side. With my will power and God Almighty's strength I have completed my master degree in first class and now preparing for phd. So keep faith in God and in yourself.
bangalore, india
This however is normal to me. The advantage is that I can automatically identify suffering in others and assisting others makes me happy.
I do not see my life as tragic. I have purpose.
Leeds, UK
Columbia, SC
I have zero self-pity; I do pity some folks, but not me. Following a massive stroke I was repeatedly told I'd never walk, talk or work again. "I" knew better and returned to work six months to the day I had the stroke.
Despite it all, I'm HAPPY most of the time because after I say modeh and shema in the morning I say out loud, "I want to have a great day and help others have one too."
Happiness is between the ears. My new doctor told me once, "You are one of the sickest people I know of, but you're also one of the happiest people I know." I'm heading to the hospital sometime this week for carotid artery surgery and the surgeon can't understand why I'm not worried. What? ME WORRY?
Hurst, TX