Here's a great tip:
Enter your email address and we'll send you our weekly magazine by email with fresh, exciting and thoughtful content that will enrich your inbox and your life, week after week. And it's free.
Oh, and don't forget to like our facebook page too!
Contact Us

The Problems of Intergalactic Travel and Jewish Continuity

The Problems of Intergalactic Travel and Jewish Continuity


In the 1960s and ’70s, those working in the NASA program were preparing to launch the first rocket that would land on the planet Mars. In 1976 we landed two manmade objects on Mars—Vikings I and II. Never before in history had mankind penetrated that far into space. I was one of the principal investigators on the Viking program, having designed two major research projects.

The timing of these programs is unique: We were the microbiologists, and we were required to have our projects designed and ready six or seven years before launch. The engineers needed adequate time to design the spacecraft to hold it all. So several years before launch, we had essentially finished our work. But since we were still getting paid by NASA, they felt compelled to find something useful for us to do.They felt compelled to find something useful for us to do

One of the program managers called a meeting for the 30 or so of us involved. He began talking about the real challenges of space flight, predicting that after we explored our own solar system, we’d move into interstellar space—go to the stars. This was the topic we were to explore.

The nearest star is Alpha Centauri. It’s 4.1 light-years away from earth, which means that a beam of light traveling at a speed of 186,000 miles per second would take 4.1 years to reach Alpha Centauri.

Needless to say, we were a long way from traveling at that speed. I did the calculations, and even if we managed to build a rocket that would travel 100 times faster than anything we’d ever designed, it would still take 830 years to get there and another 830 to come home again, of course!

As someone said, “No more coffee breaks—we’d better get going!”

Obviously, sending an astronaut wouldn’t work; no one could live that long. There have been movies made about suspended animation—putting humans into some kind of deep sleep, where they don’t age—but we don’t know much about that. What we do know is that humans live 60–80 years, and then we die.

The only real solution is to put men and women together on a spaceship, and then advise them to follow the first commandment: Be fruitful and multiply. They would have children, who would marry other children, on and on and on, for many generations.

But it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to see that this plan presents sociological problems, as well as an engineering issue. How would successive generations of people survive for the 830 years out and the 830 years back?

Food is an obvious problem: What will they eat? Remember, there is nothing out there. Absolutely every scrap of everything they will need to live must be taken along or grown. There are no resources in space. Nothing.

Pondering this problem occupied a lot of NASA time. One possible solution is the extensive use of algae. There’s sunlight in most of outer space, so algae could be grown on the collected sweat and urine from the humans. But people don’t like to eat algae. Russian scientists at one time considered feeding the algae to chickens, and then the people could eat the chickens. But that leaves you with a feather problem. Feathers can’t be recycled. What can you do with the feathers?

Of course, it didn’t take long to realize that the problems of space travel are almost the same as the problems of planet Earth: feeding a growing world population, supplying clean water, dealing with wastes of all kinds. This NASA project had many useful applications.

Waste was a big issue. What to do with it? Throw it out, or jettison it, like the spent fuel containers? But one of Newton’s theories is that if you throw something out of a capsule traveling that fast, it will just go along with you. You can’t get rid of it—but neither can you afford to waste it, whatever it is.

Other problems abound: If a group of people are confined together for 830 years, how can you make them get along? The history of mankind tells you that there’s never been a 40-year period without one group of people deciding to eliminate another. In Jewish history, 40 years of peace is a very long time indeed.

Leisure is another issue: What will the people do? Once the spaceship is en route, only a few minutes a day will be required to run it. What will everyone do with all that leisure? Unless we can design projects to successfully occupy time, problems will result.

As our seminar progressed, we discussed all these issues. Then another one popped up that fascinated me: How would the adults teach their children about themselves and their mission?

Think about it: For 830 years, all they have is the one instruction manual they started out with. But we know how we feel about old instructions—if an appliance handbook were written in Elizabethan English, we’d ignore it. Junk it! It’s too old to be practical. Even maps—we don’t follow old maps, we correct them!

But here’s this spaceship full of people. If they junk the old instruction manual, what will happen? If they start fiddling around, tinkering with the maps and the navigational system, one thing is guaranteed: They’ll get lost. And then how will they land the thing? And get back? Would that happen?

At the NASA meeting, a professor then made an interesting suggestion. “There are very few precedents for this kind of situation,” he said. “How does a society pass down its mission and beliefs to succeeding generations? I think we need to study the Jewish system. So far as I know, they’re the only group of people who, for thousands of years, have managed to hand down their traditions intact to each new generation. We should study the Jews, and see how they did it.”

Now that was interesting, more than enough to set my own mind to work, long after the session ended. I came to some additional considerations myself.

As Jews, we do indeed have a continuous debate going on. Every day, wherever there are Jews, they still debate and discuss what exactly Moses heard from G‑d, and how that applies to the problems we face this afternoon.

For several thousand years, our concept of our mission has remained real. It’s not a hypothetical. You can’t study the Talmud without gaining the sense of the continuity. I can look and see what was added. I may know that this did—or that did not—come down from Sinai, but the message we received at Sinai is undiluted. It’s as clear and precise today as it was when the Torah was given. The people who are guiding Jewish destiny know exactly what they’re doing. They’re successfully transmitting it to their children.

But the truth is, there’s a bigger problem for How does a society pass down its mission and beliefs?multi-generational space travel than just retaining a sense of mission. The real problem is that after the first two hours, after the ship leaves the gravitational pull of the earth, from that moment on, everyone, for all generations, will live in a weightless environment. Don’t get me wrong: I love weightlessness. Leaping from place to place, dropping things that don’t fall. It’s great.

The point is, for 830 years, they all will live in a world with no gravity. The very memory of gravity will become so distant that it won’t be more than a legend, something that existed far in the past. But assigning the concept of gravity to the ancient bin of legends—along with trolls and angels and talking snakes—means that when they need to deal with it again, when 830 years later they come within the gravitational pull of Alpha Centauri, they won’t have the vaguest notion of what gravity is, or how it works.

It’s not even something as basic as figuring out how to land the ship. It’s more fundamental: In a weightless environment, there is no up or down or front or back. There is no direction. So how do you know how to orient the spaceship when you want to land? And if you tore up that part of the instruction manual 800 years ago, you’ve got a problem. Even if you saved the manual, you have to learn—from scratch—what gravity is.

How can you teach the concept of gravity? It’s different than transmitting a common mission. It’s much harder: you have to transmit a concept that’s not real, something that no one present ever experienced. The concept of reality that the spaceship people lived with for 830 years is not the model they can live with once they land.

So I thought about it. If I were a principal investigator on that mission, I’d do it this way: I’d choose one man in the entire group. Make it a trustworthy guy, maybe someone who’s a little naïve, but someone I could trust.

Then I’d say to him, “Abe?”—and yes, I’d call him Abe—I’d say, “Abe? In addition to all that other stuff you’re worrying about—where the food will come from, how to get rid of waste, how to keep wars from breaking out—there’s something else you have to consider. You have to learn which way is up.”

I’d tell him, “Abe, learn which way is up, which way is down. Learn the difference between transient and permanent. Learn to distinguish between ephemeral and real. And Abe, you have to teach that to your children, and have them teach it to their children, and on and on and on. Because if you miss even one generation, you’re all lost. It will all disappear. People will not like the message; they will ridicule you, beat you, shoot you, gas you. But you must do it, or the whole mission was a waste.”

When you think about it, the fact that you are reading this essay is pretty good evidence that when Someone tried this experiment once before, it must have worked. Not perfectly, of course. But well enough.

A former Fulbright scholar and pioneer in exobiology, Professor Velvl Greene spent years working for NASA searching for life on Mars. He continued to lecture right up until his passing in 2011. Read more about Professor Greene’s life, scientific research, and relationship to the Lubavitcher Rebbe here. This story is adapted from Curiosity and the Desire for Truth (Arthur Kurzweil Publishers, October 2015).
Sefira Ross is a freelance designer and illustrator whose original creations grace many pages. Residing in Seattle, Washington, her days are spent between multitasking illustrations and being a mom.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with's copyright policy.
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
1000 characters remaining
Marty Calif via March 26, 2016

To add to Harry's comment, Carl Sagan named about a dozen characteristics that a planet had to have to sustain life. We now know there are about 400 characteristics including a BIG planet (Jupiter) way out there to block bad things from hitting us and killing life on earth. My point is not only can we not get there from here, but if we did get there, there probably is nothing there. This is also why the SETI program is a waste of money and time. Reply

Feivel Toronto March 19, 2016

Wonderful and marvelously farcical I kept reading and wishing this was an illustrated children's story. Bravo!

Really deeply appreciate the intelligent criticism from those who've commented... had those same thoughts myself many times and disregarded them as incorrect, ... gives one a marker of how much we are bullied by iconoclastic scientists who are essentially re-creating some kind of golden calf idea or another ... My personal philosophy is that we live on the 'only planet of choice'; Peace and preparation for continued sustained peace is the mission for us. I'd be much happier if NASA continued to de-classify documents containing evidence that we are not alone here; ... so that we are better able to discern and receive inter-galactic "refugees" per se... Reply

Anonymous Tampa via March 18, 2016

This author is wacky! Gravity is replicated by having the spaceship revolve, thus creating centrifugal gravity.

As for making a religion out of 830 years together I say
"Oi vais meir..."
Alan Reply

Rafael March 17, 2016

Truth and Tradition If I could talk to Abe...Abe Lincoln and tell him in about 110 years there will be a man on the Moon , or he can travel across the USA in one day ...he would say impossible . Abe is basing his answer on the technology and wisdom of his day . He would be correct however incorrect in the future .
Abe was a bright light in his day but would be unprepared to tackle todays problems with yesterday's solutions . Truths of the past are debunk and new truths solve answers that were once mysteries.
Scientist are humble enough to say they are Agnostic . What they haven't learned
( which is a lot ) falls under gods domain . The "God of the gaps" to be exact . This God is not derived from the divine revelation used by any ancient culture . God is a synonym for unknown and undefined . The Torah says G-d is without predication and omnipotent yet the Sages went ahead with Torah revelation and Talmudic explanation . It is here where todays truth and yesterday's tradition are not compatible Reply

Kristin Rutland March 17, 2016

Love it! Love it! Reply

David Palm Springs March 17, 2016

But we are commanded to only gaze towards the heavens for to plunder their depths is to rob heaven and spit in God's face. How dare we be so brazen! Reply

Harry Norte América March 16, 2016

"Land?" Alpha Centauri is a STAR, a giant "flaming" ball of superheated gas - plasma. Have any solid planets been discovered orbiting AC?
And, if the Bible is accurately understood, the only reason the earth sustains life is that the Creator set it up and created living organisms to live on it. The earth:
• Is just the right size to have the right gravity
• Has just the right proportion of ocean to land to sustain life
• Is orbiting at just the right distance from the star ("Sol")
• Which is just the right size
• And of the correct composition
• And a plethora of other characteristics that if any one was very different, life would be impossible
So unless the Creator established another planet out there somewhere that is essentially just like our earth, just with no humans, there is no destination for anyone to good to.
Mars is mostly wrong. A Mars settlement will be forever dependent upon a continual supply system from the earth. Reply

Chava M March 14, 2016

Fantastic!! Excellent! Love it!
SO so so great. Reply

Sylvia U.K. March 14, 2016

Everything to plan This article reminds man that he is really not very intelligent. HaShem created everything to plan, our world is one huge eco system. In comparison to the universe we are a tiny planet. The money invested in space travel would be better invested in teaching Torah globally. Mankind would be much better off focussing on our purpose for competing HaShems will and not our own will.

I will ponder, the waste of space travel now with renewed enlightenment from ChaBaD. Thank you. Reply

eitan ma March 14, 2016

what if you made a planet you could recycle the feathers,they can be used in the production of a wide variety of products
Pillow stuffing Diapers Insulation Upholstery padding Paper Plastics Feather meal
and making jobs by farming cooks musicians like earth if we leave clues to the people who wont tinker with it they can learn how to use the planet and pass on jobs like a mini earth Reply

Leah WI March 14, 2016

Brilliant perspective! Reply

Brenda Toronto, Canada March 14, 2016

The Problem with Distance From Spiritual Word And The Jewish Community After the fall of the Second Temple due to the close bonds that were breaking between the Jewish people, the followers of our forefathers, they also became detached from their spiritual roots.

The actions and rituals they perform today are detached from their higher spiritual meaning. All that remains are the symbols, lifeless without their true connection to the spiritual world.
- Like a body without a soul.
What is spiritual Sabbath day, kosher etc ? Reply

Lisa Montana March 14, 2016

Awe inspiring! Reading this makes me realize how amazing is our Gd. His ways are perfect. Thank you for this reminder. Reply

Related Topics
This page in other languages