Get Think Jewish Delivered to your Home or Office
HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info News & Current Events
 
Chabad.org » Community & Family » News & Current Events » Editorial & Commentary » Gaza "Disengagement" Plan » The Expulsion of the Jews
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment7 Comments

The Expulsion of the Jews


Jews being forcibly removed from their homes in Gush Katif, August 17, 2005
Jews being forcibly removed from their homes in Gush Katif, August 17, 2005

Over the last few days I have been watching, together with people all over the world, the heart-rending scenes that have come out of the Gaza Strip. Beyond the immense sympathy I have for the Jewish residents of Gaza and their cause, I am deeply bothered and troubled by the ramifications this expulsion has in the wider context.

Since antiquity Jews have been evicted from many countries. There was the expulsion of the Jews from England in 1290 and from France is 1306 and from Spain in 1492 and then from Lithuania in 1915 and many others before, in between and since. The most brutal expulsion was by the Nazis who not only kicked Jews out of their homes but gassed them as well. The singular reason Jews were expelled from their homes throughout the ages was because non-Jews could not tolerate living beside them.

In 1948, after the decimation of Jewish life by the Nazis, the State of Israel was established. This gave many Jews new hope--never again would Jews be thrown out of their homes solely because the gentile neighbors could no longer tolerate them. Never again would fascism cause Jews to be killed and displaced. The new Jewish state would eliminate non-Jewish aggression towards Jews. This was seen as the raison d'etre for Israel’s creation and its continued existence.

This week, Israel has failed its own litmus test. Not only has Israel not prevented Jews from being expelled from their homes due to gentile aggression, but its own government, police and military have now actually acted as proxies for that aggression.

I have lived amongst non-Jews in Britain and the USA for most of my life. Admittedly, there were times when anti-Semitic comments made me feel uneasy; however, I was never made to feel that as a Jew living in a gentile land, my life was in danger. The reason for this is that Britain and the USA are tolerant countries where Christian, Muslim, Jew, Shikh and Hindu can all live peacefully side-by-side. These countries avow, and their laws enforce, the principle that no person should be discriminated against because of his or her race or religion.

Not so the Middle East--there is not a single Arab country where Jews can live safely and peacefully. The only reason this expulsion of Jews is taking place is because without Israeli military protection Jews living in Gaza are in mortal danger from their Arab neighbors who would like to murder them. Clearly Israeli government is evicting Jews out of their homes solely because their fascist Arab neighbors cannot tolerate living next to them. Unbelievably, we are witnessing an Israeli government working in tandem with anti-Jewish fascists. Unfortunately therefore, Ariel Sharon has now debased the very foundation upon which Israel was built.

Inevitably, albeit reluctantly, the only conclusion I am able to draw from the events of the last few days is that we can no longer trust Israel to look after the interests of the Jewish people. Our trust rests solely with our Father in Heaven, the Almighty Himself.

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment7 Comments

By Levi Brackman   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Levi I. Brackman is director of Judaism in the Foothills and the author of numerous articles on issues of the day.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Dec 17, 2005
Fighting over the sandbox.
I'm aware of how heart-breaking the scenes were ~ but I have to add one comment here.

I don't think you're aware of how hard it was for Sharon (who founded those settlement programs) to swallow his pride and admit his work was not in the best interests of Israel. To un-do what he'd done - that took courage!

I don't see why Israel should believe they owe nothing to the nations who were responsible for the survival of their remnants. Israel must acknowledge Palestine... and Iraq, as I'll demonstrate the moment Zarqawi is no longer a threat to my interests there.

Let them have Gaza. Let them have Hebron. But Palestine will have to make concessions too - these lands are offered in good faith in exchange for Palestine's claim to Jerusalem.

I know King David would make these sacrifices himself if it were for the betterment of his kingdom. Let's not fight over who owns the sandbox - there's plenty of room for all.
Posted By Sheila E. Lord, Orleans, MA
via chabadcapecod.com

Posted: Sep 20, 2005
Gaza
I do not feel sorry for the Jewish settlers of the Gaza strip or the West Bank. They should never have created settlements. It was Sharon's stupid idea that only cost a lot of lives and money to gain nothing.
Posted By Eli, Dresher, PA

Posted: Sep 19, 2005
You are not correct re the road to Shalom
I live in Chicago. I am glad the Chabad got a Menorah into Daley Square 20 years ago. I am glad you folks are on College Campuses.

But for all your discussion of unity etc - and a wondeful movie - the more I looked at your site, the more I saw that Chabad was stubbornly for a biblical Israel. I can not suport that position.

I wish you all well and Shanah Tovah,
Posted By Ted Raichel

Posted: Sep 17, 2005
a very narrow view.... lacking forsight or vision
This is truly a sad view. Who could possibly believe that Sharon does not have the best interests of Israel at the forefront of his thoughts? Of all the old warriors, who fought so hard and who has come a great distance in his own thinking of how... HOW.. to find security for Israel, and to find a path to peace.
I was never a fan of Sharon, especially during the Lebanese misadventure, but I never ever doubted the passion of his intentions to secure Israel.
Levi, don't be so quick to be a judge. The exit from Gaza was inevitable. I feel terrible for the settlers who had to leave and that their passage was not better planned, but the balance between keeping territory and finding peace is a difficult difficult task.
If you turn to prayer to the Almighty, ask that Sharon be kept well and healthy so he can lead Israel through this time.
Posted By sam, toronto, canada

Posted: Sep 14, 2005
never again again?
Once more the ghetto, the denial, isolation, DEEPLY disappointed pushed into a boundary of hatred. Perhaps 70 years ago or more, my mother, living in a small town in illinois, spent much of her time raising funds for a hospital on Mount Scopus, proud, she was, that the hospital would treat everyone, without regard to ethnicity. In spite off ghettoization once more, we cannot abandon the possibilities that honoring the humanity that even our outspoken enemies possess.

Nor can we abandon the absolute and urgent need to defend ourselves aggressively. I don't think we're doing enough to stop antisemitism in america. It is my personal commitment to vocally call to task the slightest anti-Jewish statement or action.
Posted By Donald David Israel, Lake Florida, Fl
via showmechabad.com

Posted: Sep 10, 2005
Those who believe that God's miracles in our days work through the efforts of the good men and women who, like us, want peace and prosperity for Israel and all Jews everywhere. Israel's existence is the miracle. Perfection will not come on earth unless God sends it and when perfection exists, humans will no longer exist. No human is perfect; no human effort is perfect.
Israel is not perfect.

We cannot know the future. Sharon is not perfect, but I believe he is doing God's work to protect the Jews the best he can.
Posted By Anonymous, Richmond, VA, U

Posted: Sep 5, 2005
If Ariel Sharon had sent 45,000 troops against the enemy instead of his own people, no pullout would ever have been necessary. If Sharon were the U.S. President and had done something similar, he would be impeached as a traitor.
The elections in Israel will come none too soon.
Posted By Keren, Disconent, AZ



 


Gaza "Disengagement" Plan
The Fate of Gush Katif
The King's Gift
Peace or Piece?
The Expulsion of the Jews
Manna Bashing
Galut, 2005
Broken Hearts, Unbreakable Faith
Showing 2 - 8 of 14