Here's a great tip:
Enter your email address and we'll send you our weekly magazine by email with fresh, exciting and thoughtful content that will enrich your inbox and your life, week after week. And it's free.
Oh, and don't forget to like our facebook page too!
Contact Us

Challahs from Heaven

Challahs from Heaven


Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa was so poor that he and his wife often had nothing to cook for Shabbat. Every Friday, before Shabbat, she would throw a burning coal into the oven, so that smoke would drift out of her chimney and the neighbors would assume that she had what to cook.

A nasty neighbor said, “I know that they don’t have anything. Let me go and see what all that smoke is about.”

When she knocked on their door, Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa’s wife was mortified and went to hide in an inner room. The nosy neighbor entered anyway. A miracle occurred, and she found the oven full of loaves of bread and a mixing bowl full of dough.

She called, “Come! Come! Bring the spatula. Your bread is starting to burn, and you need to get it out quick!”

Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa’s wife said, “That’s what I went into the inner room for.”

Indeed, the sages say, she was telling the truth. She was so accustomed to miracles that she wasn’t surprised that coals had turned into bread.

Later, Rabbi Chanina’s wife asked him, “How long will we have to suffer like this?”

“What should we do?” he replied.

She said, “Pray that we be given something of value.”

He prayed, and a hand-like apparition stretched down from the heavens and gave him a golden table leg.

He later dreamed that he saw all the righteous people in the world to come eating at three-legged tables, while he and his wife were eating at a table with just two legs.

He asked his wife, “Will it be okay with you if all the other righteous people are eating at three-legged tables, while you and I are eating at a table that’s missing one of its legs?”

“What should we do?” she asked. “Pray that it should be taken from you.”

He prayed, and it was taken from him.

The sages remarked that the second miracle was greater than the first, because tradition says that the heavens give but they don’t take back.

Babylonian Talmud, Taanit 24b–25a
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with's copyright policy.
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
1000 characters remaining
Anonymous South August 23, 2017

I'm a relatively intellectual & spiritual but I'm reading the last part of this story and it makes not one iota of sense. The first miracle yes & got excited about the rest until I read it. Prayed for something of value, then prayed for it to be taken away & IT WAS. How is that the "heavens not taking back"? Reply

Zelma Thompson USA June 4, 2015

Miracles do happen, we must be in a position to receive that miracle when God wants to send it. Faith and confidence, and don't forget to be thankful for the little miracles as well as the big ones. Reply

Yehudis Shoshanna Feinstein Tzfat June 2, 2015

The hidden blessings are hard to accept with joy With G-d's help.
If only there was enough to pay bills and give Tzedaka. Azoi. Reply

Anonymous USA June 1, 2015

Challahs from Heaven What a beautiful teaching! Wonderful story! B"H Reply

Related Topics