Contact Us

Never Too Late

Never Too Late


The fourteenth day of the month of Iyar is Pesach Sheini, the "Second Passover." When the Holy Temple stood in Jerusalem, this day served as a "second chance" for those who were unable to bring the Passover offering on the eve of the "first" Passover one month earlier, the 14th of Nissan.

Today, we mark and commemorate the date by eating matzah (in the same way that we eat the afikoman-matzah at the Passover seder in remembrence of the Passover offering).

In the 9th chapter of Numbers, the Torah relates the circumstances that led to the institution of the Second Passover. On the 1st of Nissan in the year 2449 from creation (1312 bce), two weeks before the first anniversary of the Exodus,

G‑d spoke to Moses in the Sinai desert ... saying: "The children of Israel should prepare the Passover [offering] at its appointed time. On the fourteenth of this month, in the afternoon ... in accordance with all its decrees and laws...."

There were, however, certain persons who had become ritually impure through contact with a dead body and therefore could not prepare the Passover offering on that day. They approached Moses and Aaron ... and they said: "...Why should we be deprived, and not be able to present G‑ds offering in its time, amongst the children of Israel?"

And Moses said to them: "Wait here, and I will hear what G‑d will command concerning you."

And G‑d spoke to Moses, saying: "Speak to the children of Israel, saying: Any person who is contaminated by death, or is on a distant road, whether among you now or in future generations, shall prepare a Passover offering to G‑d. They shall prepare it on the afternoon of the fourteenth day of the second month, and shall eat it with matzahs and bitter herbs...." (Numbers 9:1-12)

The Power of Return

The eternal significance of the Second Passover, says the sixth Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn (1880-1950), is that it is never too late to rectify a past failing. Even if a person has failed to fulfill a certain aspect of his or her mission in life because s/he has been "contaminated by death" (i.e., in a state of disconnection from the divine source of life) or "on a distant road" from his people and G‑d, there is always a Second Passover in which s/he can make good on what s/he has missed out.

The Second Passover thus represents the power of teshuvah — the power of return. Teshuvah is commonly translated as repentance, but it is much more than turning a new leaf and achieving forgiveness for past sins. It is the power to go back in time and redefine the past.

Teshuvah is achieved when a negative deed or experience is applied in a way that completely transforms its significance. When a person's contact with death evokes in him a striving for life he would never have mustered without that experience; when his wanderings on distant roads awaken in him a yearning for home he would never have otherwise felt — these hitherto negative experiences are literally turned inside out. Contact with death is transformed into a more intense involvement with life; distance into a greater closeness.

Beyond Torah

This explains the unique circumstances under which the institution of the Second Passover became part of Torah.

Virtually all of the mitzvot of the Torah, including those governing rare and unforeseeable circumstances, were unilaterally commanded by G‑d to Moses. The law of the Second Passover, instituted in response to the outcry of those who protested, "Why shall we be deprived?" is one of the few cases in which a mitzvah was elicited from G‑d by a petition from mortal men.

Why wasn't the provision for a Second Passover included in the Torah's initial legislation of the laws of Passover? Because the gift of teshuvah could not have been granted through the regular channels of Torah law.

Torah is the articulation of the divine will via a body of 613 commandments and prohibitions. In other words, the very definition of Torah is that there are certain things that G‑d desires that we do, and certain things which He desires that we not do. So if Torah defines a certain deed or situation as contrary to the divine will, it cannot subsequently regard it as positive and desirable. In the words of the Midrash:

They asked Wisdom, "What is the punishment for the sinner?" Wisdom replied: "Evil pursues sinners."

They asked Prophecy, and Prophecy replied: "The soul who sins shall die."

They asked Torah, and Torah replied: "He shall bring a guilt-offering and he shall be forgiven."

They asked G‑d, and G‑d replied: "Let him do teshuvah and he shall be forgiven." (Yalkut Shimoni, Tehillim 702)

Torah can provide a formula for repentance; but it can see no way of escaping the fact that the person has transgressed the divine will. At most, it can forgive the deed and reconnect the person to his source of life. But it cannot change the negativity of sin — the fact that, at a certain point in time, the person had been in a state of disconnection from G‑d. Teshuvah, in its ultimate sense of return to redefine and transform the negativity of a past deed or state, can only come from G‑d Himself — from a place in Him which supersedes His articulation of His will via the commandments of the Torah.

So the Second Passover, with its premise that nothing is beyond rectification, could not have entered our lives through the conventional chain of command of Torah. It took a small group of Jews, contaminated by death and languishing on a distant road, to elicit the gift of teshuvah from the Almighty.

Their cry of "Why shall we be deprived?", expressing a depth of yearning for attachment to G‑d that only their currently distant state could have evoked, prompted G‑d to supersede the formulation of His will as articulated in the Torah and grant them a mandate to redefine the past with a second Passover.

An Instant Life

A central principle in Chassidic teaching is that the entirety of the divine wisdom, from the most technical deliberations of Halachah (Torah law) to the most esoteric Kabbalistic passage, form one Torah. The Torah may possess a body and a soul, but these together constitute a single, wholly integrated organism: the soul, or the spiritual significance, of a law is reflected in its body, and every limb and organ of its body has its corresponding significance in its soul.

The same is true of the laws governing the first and second Passovers. An entire tractate in the Talmud (Pesachim) details the hundreds of laws that apply to the Passover offering. Most of these apply equally to both Passovers; but there are several significant differences. These technical differences reflect the deeper spiritual import of the two Passovers: the original Passover observed by the straight and true, and the Second Passover established for the baal teshuvah, the returnee.

One of the primary differences between the two Passovers is that the Passover offering brought on the afternoon of Nissan 14 is followed by a seven-day festival, while the Second Passover is but a single day.

The number 7 signifies a process, a routine, a natural course of action. G‑d created the world in seven days and thereby stamped a seven-day work/rest cycle into the very fabric of the natural reality. The heart of man possesses seven major attributes (love, restraint, harmony, ambition, devotion, connection and receptiveness), reflecting the seven divine attributes (sefirot) that G‑d invested in His seven-day creation. So when we speak of a seven-day Passover, we speak of the graduated, step-by-step accomplishments of the tzaddik — the righteous individual who builds his relationship with G‑d and fulfills his mission in life in accordance with the formula and game-plan set forth in the Torah.

Not so the baal teshuvah, the one who strays from the natural course of his soul and then rebounds with a thirst for life that only those who have wandered in a deathly wasteland can experience. The Talmud tells the story of Elazar ben Durdaya, a man who transgressed virtually every sin in the book. One day, a harlot said to him, "Elazar ben Durdaya could never repent." The recognition of how far he had gone shook him to the very core of his soul; "he placed his head between his knees, and wailed and sobbed until his soul departed from his body." Upon hearing the story of this man, Rabbi Judah HaNassi wept and said: "There are those who acquire their world through many years toil, and there are those who acquire their world in a single moment."

The essence of teshuvah is a single wrench of self, a single flash of regret and resolve. There are those who acquire their world in many years, said the greatest tzaddik of his day, building it brick by brick with the conventional tools of achievement; and there are those who acquire their world in a single moment — in a single instant that molds their future and redefines their past.

Not every baal teshuvah achieves the instantaneous transformation of Elazar ben Durdaya. But the one-day duration of the Second Passover expresses the nature of teshuvah: not the conventional, processional life of the tzaddik, but the baal teshuvah's drastic leap from extreme to extreme.

Conquering Inflation

Another Halachic difference between the two Passovers is the prohibition against leavened foods.

The first Passover wages an all-out war on all leavened substances: not only is the eating of any form of leaven severely forbidden, but every last speck and crumb must be banished from our premises. Not so on the Second Passover. Although the Passover offering is then, too, eaten with the unleavened matzah, there is no need to rid ourselves of leaven; in the words of the Talmud, "leaven and matzah are with him in the house."

The Chassidic masters explain the spiritual significance of the prohibition of leaven on Passover: leaven, dough that has risen and inflated, represents the tendency of the human ego to rise and swell. Leaven must be completely eradicated from our premises, since a risen ego is the source of all evil. The entire Torah is based on the premise that "There is none else besides Him" (Deuteronomy 4:35) — that G‑d is the only absolute reality, since every created thing is completely dependent on Him who continually supplies it with life and existence. One who perceives himself as an existence in his own right, ultimately rejects the entire Torah. The Talmud goes so far as to say that G‑d says of the egotistical person, "He and I cannot dwell in the same world."

The tzaddik's reality consists of two distinct spheres: the permissible and the forbidden; that which he develops and that which he disavows. The 248 positive commandments of the Torah relate to those elements of his environment and his own being which he utilizes in his service of G‑d; the Torah's 365 prohibitions define what is not within his power to redeem and sublimate, and is therefore off limits to him. Leaven and everything that it represents has no place in his life.

The baal teshuvah, however, is one who, having already wandered off into the forbidden realm, now exploits these negative elements and experiences to fuel his quest for divine life. In his home, leaven and matzah both reside; what is beyond the ken of the tzaddik and his first Passover forms an integral part of the baal teshuvah's service of G‑d.

Indeed, the story behind the Second Passover is a classic example of how the "me" instinct, generally a most destructive force to man's relationship with his Creator, was transformed into an impetus for greater commitment to G‑d. A group of Jews approached Moses with the prototypically selfish complaint, "Why should we be deprived?" But in their case, these words did not express a need to have and be, but a desire to give and serve. In their petition, the ferment and leavening of their selves was not the antithesis of humble and self-effacing matzah, but rather its complement. Leaven and matzah coexisted in their souls, ego and self-abnegation jointly giving rise to a desire to serve one's Creator.

On the Second Passover, the festival that came into being out of their egotistical cry, there is no need to banish leaven from our homes. For when the self asserts itself in such a manner, it is a welcome participant in our celebration of the freedom we achieved at the Exodus — the freedom to actualize our quintessential identity as servants of G‑d.

The Repentant Righteous

The Talmud cites a dispute between several sages regarding the status of the Second Passover:

Rabbi Chanania ben Akavia is of the opinion that the Second Passover is a fulfillment of the first... Rabbi [Judah HaNassi] is of the opinion that it is a festival in its own right. (Talmud, Pesachim 93a)

[There are several practical ramifications to this issue. For example, if one reaches the age of legal maturity (bar mitzvah) during the month between the two Passovers, or if a non-Jew converts to Judaism during this period, should they bring a Passover offering on the Second Passover? If the Second Passover is defined as "a fulfillment of the first," then it would apply only to those who were obligated to observe the first and failed to do so. The new adult or new Jew has no lack to fulfill. On the other hand, if it is "a festival in its own right," then anyone who has not brought a Passover offering on the First Passover can do so on the Second Passover.]

These two definitions of the Second Passover apply to its soul as well as to its body. In fact, it is only in the soul of the law that both opinions can be fully applied. Regarding the body of Torah law, we can only follow one opinion: though we regard both as legitimate Torah views (in the words of the Talmud, "these and these are both the word of the living G‑d"), in practice, we follow the majority opinion. But when it comes to the soul of Torah — to the conceptual-spiritual significance of the law — all opinions are equally applicable.

On the most basic level, teshuvah is the result of a sin in the literal sense, making the terms baal teshuvah and tzaddik mutually exclusive: one who hasn't actually transgressed the divine will cannot experience teshuvah and the powerful attraction to G‑d only it can bring. This is the equivalent of seeing the Second Passover exclusively as a fulfillment of the first — a phenomenon that comes only as the result of actual failing.

Yet there is also another, more universal teshuvah. The essence of teshuvah is the drive to return to one's former, unblemished state — a drive that is fueled by the presently deficient state itself. Ordinarily, we consider the sin-free soul of a tzaddik to be perfect in its relationship with G‑d, and thus devoid of the possibility for teshuvah. Yet in truth, the very placement of a soul into a physical body, and its subsequent enmeshment in material needs and concerns, is itself a compromising of the soul's original, uninhibited bond with G‑d. The very birth of a human being means that the physical faculties of the body are now the medium through which the soul must perceive, experience and relate to its Creator, greatly limiting the quality and scope of its spiritual life.

But as with the standard teshuvah for real sins, the "distant road" of physical life holds the potential for an even more intense, more meaningful bond with G‑d than before. In this sense, the Second Passover is "a festival in its own right", offering an opportunity for a teshuvah that is not limited to the literal sinner — an opportunity to exploit the distance and spiritual lifelessness of the material world as an impetus to greater and deeper connection with one's source.

Based on the teachings of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson; adapted by Yanki Tauber.
Originally published in Week in Review.
Republished with the permission of If you wish to republish this article in a periodical, book, or website, please email
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with's copyright policy.
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
1000 characters remaining
Debra A.Hanover (Michaelson, Hunovich) Goose, SC via May 12, 2012

Thank you... Reply

gutman strasbourg, france via May 23, 2010

an excellent commentary and very profund in its simplicity Reply

hannah Jersey City, NJ May 7, 2009

baal teshuvah I can relate to Elaza ben Durdaya. I have been in the same place. Every day is a struggle as well as the greatest joy. That lost world is always a temptation that must be overcome by the blessing of teshuvah. After having lived so long in one's own questionable state it is difficult to change into something new. Only G-d can do this and lo and behold he seeks out baal teshuvah. If you try He does. And he never lets go. Reply

Karen Joyce Chaya Fradle Kleinman Bell Riverside, CA May 6, 2009

This saying is so true. I had breast cancer, I had to face possible death, and now love life much more fully. I can appreciate now what G-d has given to us. Reply

Anna medford, Oregon February 7, 2008

second passover thank you sooo much for this wonderful teaching it has changed my life.
My whole Life I have wanted to serve my creator faultlessly, which was always a great burden to me and prevented me from finding any Joy in life, as I found myself always "lacking perfection" and also reminded of my lack of perfection by others.
It was so simple all along But I was blind to the truth as most are in this regard.
Thanks again, Reply

Heleen Abramson via May 11, 2006

Pesach Sheini I had never hreard of this before. Tod ah for the enlightening article. I rather like the idea of teshuvah that there is always hope to return to an unblemished state.................. Reply

Janice Denver, CO May 11, 2006

2nd Passover Wouldn't this be the Passover yet to come, for the ingathering of the lost tribes? Who were afar, scattered to the ends of the earth, in the diaspora (a relm of death) contaminated from being outside Israel and the Torah? Reply

Shifra Chana Hendrie Morristown, NJ May 10, 2006

This article was magnificent. Thank you. Reply

Yoav Dattilo Rome, Italy May 8, 2006

Very deep article! It touches the heart and the intellect at the same time. It is extremely important for us to remember that Pesach Sheni is connected to the power of Teshuvah, and it's not just a tradition, but a concrete, spiritual opportunity.
Todà rabbà! Reply

Anonymous May 8, 2006

I would just like to highlight a point about pesach sheini that i find especially interesting. As you mentioned in the midrash, based on Torah these people could not be part of this mitzvah. The Torah stipulates the do's and don'ts and these people simply could not fulfill the mitzvah. They complained to Moshe saying, "we understand that the Torah says we can't but it is not fair." Moshe Rabbeinu did not listen sympathetically only to reiterate the Torah ruling- sorry; he was bothered by the injustice and said i will speak to G-d directly. He felt their pain and did something about it. And then G-d changes the Torah to accomodate these people.... Indeed, pesach sheini is the holiday for those who are halachikly outcasts... -- don't worry someone is listening, it is not right and there is rachamim beyond Torah. There is a father beyond the law who is listening.... Reply

Raul F. Corral-Moreno El Pao, Tx., USA April 13, 2006

Second Passover The festival of Passover on the 14 day of the month of Nissan is a command given to us by G-d.
The festival of the second Passover on the 14 day of the month of Iyar is a petition to G-d by people who were astray and did not comply with the observance of this commandment, so G-d accepted their petition and gave them ( us ) this command as a second chance to correct our faults and sins by the act of the baal teshuvah, a real and sincere repentance and return to Hashem will.
It is a beautiful exposition about this so important passage of the Torah. Reply

Stacey Greene Greenacres, Florida March 6, 2006

2nd passover Fantastic article on the 2 Passovers and the meaning of the second one. Chabad provides so much illumination in the lives of those it touches, especially the not-too observant. Thanks. Reply

Anonymous Jax, FL February 20, 2006

Thank you for this article...I have passed it along to my husband who has returned home...G-d bless his soul. Reply

Sandra Greer Brooklyn, NY via July 8, 2005

Pesach Sheini - Second Chance "Leaven and matzah coexisted in their souls, ego and self-abnegation jointly giving rise to a desire to serve one's Creator."

I fell over this by accident today, while looking for a place to observe Yom Kippur during a planned visit to Cape Cod. It is a beautiful description of my life, going from one extreme to another as chronic Baal Teshuvah.

How thoughtful of HaShem to create a special holiday just for those who for whatever reason need a second chance; how extraordinary for it to be done as the result of a request from us!

How incredible your wisdom in describing the eternal struggle between the human and the divine impulse in all of us, and the holiday (unknown to me) that recognizes it, as a "festival in its own right". Reply

Anonymous May 18, 2005

Thank you Thank you for the article on Pesach Sheini.
I've felt HaShem calling me back.. and your article explained how and why. Reply

Chaim Dov Albany, New York via April 26, 2005

The Second Passover Although I think one should certainly oblige the talmudic and tanya rulings regarding pesach, it has crossed my mind what does one do in the hospital? A diabetic? The Second Passover, providing in a sense tehuva, and another chance at earning the Neshomas Divine will. Truly the best article I've ever read on Tesuhva. Yasher Koach! Reply

doug hippchen Ventura, CA USA May 5, 2004

the Second Passover Thank You,
I was unaware of this and now I must go and perform this duty.
Bless You All Reply

Related Topics