HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Ideas & Beliefs
 
Chabad.org » Ideas & Beliefs » Questions & Answers » Ethics & Religion » How Do We Know Whom To Believe?


Share thisPost a CommentPrintSend this page to a friendSubscribe
11 Comments Posted

How Do We Know Whom To Believe?



A recent damning television exposé of a purportedly religious (Kabbalah) group has forced me to re-examine my own religious beliefs.

Many of my beliefs have been influenced not just by intellectual arguments but in a large part also by exceptional teachers. Indeed, beliefs, by definition, cannot be verified with certainty by empirical evidence. So perhaps, like members of the aforementioned religious group, I, too, have been inveigled and ultimately deceived by charismatic teachers? Maybe the beliefs that have been inculcated in me since my youth are fantastical?

The question is a frightening one, because it turns the very things that most convince us into a reason for doubt. When we find a teacher inspiring and compelling, when we are enthused by people who seem spiritual and pious, how can we be sure that they are not just megalomaniac, demagogic charlatans who are playing on our vulnerability for their own selfish gain? Is there a way of ensuring that we do not become conned into accepting religious beliefs that are in fact false?

A fascinating insight by Judaism’s great codifier and philosopher, Maimonides (Rabbi Moses ben Maimon, 1138-1204), sheds light on this dilemma. After Adam, the primordial man, sinned, the Torah tells us that he was now able to differentiate between good and evil (Genesis 3:5). Maimonides asks a fundamental question: is it not absurd that after having sinned, Adam was rewarded with the power of differentiation? In answer, Maimonides makes a profound distinction: he explains that before the sin, by virtue of his intellect alone, without any experimental evidence, Adam was able to distinguish between eminently true facts and those that were false. After the sin, Adam lost this ability and was now capable of differentiating only between the morally good and the morally corrupt. This is why Adam and Eve now felt naked -- the innate immorality of being naked in public was now apparent to them, something to which they had been given immunity by their previous higher intellectual perception (Guide for the Perplexed 1:2).

This is now human nature: without empirical evidence it is impossible to discern truth from fiction. We can, however, differentiate between the morally good and the morally corrupt. This is a powerful barometer. We can easily detect moral corruption and be sure that it brings falsehood in its wake. Interestingly, in the Bible there is no prohibition against lying. Instead it says, “Keep away from falsehood” (Exodus 23:7). The reason for this seems clear: without empirical knowledge we cannot completely avoid falsehood, but by avoiding morally corrupt people we can "keep away" from it.

Unfortunately, history is littered with people who have hijacked holy teachings for their own mendacious gain. Since their teachings are based on the books of sublimity, the teachings themselves can be inspiring. However, one can be sure that eventually their inner sordidness will lead them to corrupt the teachings as well.

The teachers that made the most powerful impression on me, the teachers who earned my trust and devotion, were those who not only were sincere but also lived in accordance with the teachings they preached and fled from any type of moral corruption as from the plague. In matters of faith, this is the best indicator of truth I am ever going to get in this lifetime. For now, this is good enough for me.


Share thisPost a CommentPrintSend this page to a friendSubscribe
11 Comments Posted

By Levi Brackman   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Levi I. Brackman is director of Judaism in the Foothills and the author of numerous articles on issues of the day.
About the artist: Sarah Kranz has been illustrating magazines, webzines and books (including five children's books) since graduating from the Istituto Europeo di Design, Milan, in 1996. Her clients have included The New York Times and Money Marketing Magazine of London

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

11 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Nov 8, 2009
How do we Know Whom to Believe
It's true that a highly charasmatic leader can be a sociopath who misleads others into evil. We have to realize that if they have an evil intent, it may not be obvious at first. Before joining any religious or political movement, it may be a good idea to watch from the sidelines for a while, to see what develops. Then you can weigh the benefits of the teaching as it is being applied against the negative effects.
Posted By Susan, Chicago, IL

Posted: Nov 6, 2009
"How do we know who to believe?"
I did not see the damning TV expose' of Kabbalah, but I think another question to ask might be WHO produced the expose' and for WHAT purpose...political or religious or humanistic persuasion or just one more topic, overly sensationalized by media.
Also...I thought the criteria used for decision making before 'The Sin' was obeying what G-d told them.
Posted By rivkah, holt

Posted: Nov 6, 2009
Don't just let the teacher's lesson wash over you!
It's nice to have some direction from a teacher, but the only way you are going to know if the knowledge of a teacher is good is if you check his/her sources and take it upon yourself to read them whether or not an individual teacher stresses this. Usually, there is never a source that is 100% good, so broaden your search, and get a feel for what different teachers and authors say about the same subject. Then, formulate your own opinions on the subject.
Posted By Craig Hamilton, Sandwich, MA



 


Ethics & Religion
Getting Forgiven
What is Humility?
Are Religious Jews Narrow-Minded?
How Do I Choose a Rabbi?
Why Do Observant Jews Have Such a Tranquil life?
Cult or Religion?
Is it Okay to be a Hypocrite?
How Do We Know Whom To Believe?
Why is My Family Insulted by My Kosher Diet?
Why Honor the Rich?
Must I Forgive Everyone?
What's Wrong with Pornography?
What If I'm Not in the Mood?
How could a Religious Person Commit a Crime?
Are You Jealous?
Showing 25 - 39 of 41