Contact Us

Lost Tribe in New Guinea?

Lost Tribe in New Guinea?

 Email

Did you see the video of the tribe in Papua New Guinea singing the Shema Prayer in Hebrew? I found it fascinating!

Are they one of the lost tribes of Israel?

Answer:

It’s a cute clip, but don't be fooled. Their ability to sing Hebrew songs doesn't make them Jewish. I can sing Awimbawe but that doesn't make me a long lost African. And anyway, parts of that clip just don't add up.

If indeed they were a lost tribe of Israel, clutching to their traditions for thousands of years in spite of their dislocation from other Jews, why do they chant the Shema in a distinctively modern European tune? Why do they sing it in English after singing it in Hebrew? And what is the explanation for the placards they display with English quotes from the Bible?

The explanation is simple. These tribesmen are not performing an ancient rite; they are singing the Hebrew songs that missionaries have taught them.

Jews do not missionize. We don't believe in converting the world to our ways. Non-Jews don’t need to fulfill the 613 commandments given to the Jews. But there certainly is an ethical obligation of monotheism - belief in one G‑d Who expects us to live morally. In fact, this is actually what they are declaring in the shema prayer they are singing, “The L-rd is our G‑d, the L-rd is One.” If you continue your search for this tribe and need some ideas of what to teach, tell them about the Seven Noahide Laws for all mankind.

Aron Moss is rabbi of the Nefesh Community in Sydney, Australia, and is a frequent contributor to Chabad.org.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with Chabad.org's copyright policy.
 Email
Join the Discussion
Sort By:
3 Comments
1000 characters remaining
Anonymous karmiel February 20, 2017

? The tribe may have Jewish ancestry.
Possibly from Sefardic traders after the inquisition.
The video is obviously not enough to prove anything, however more study needs to be done before ruling them off completely.
Last but not least if they feel Jewish and they wish to convert, they should have the chance to do a full giur.
Please see the Jewish press article on the matter. Reply

Yehoshua Langman Tamworth December 30, 2015

Hemshech From the time of Avraham Avinu we have proselytised, but generally since then its became too dangerous.
Yaakov Avinu according to the Midrash, after his two sons destroyed Shechem. He was afraid people would be too scared now to convert to Juidaism.
Yet today we ignore these teachings about respecting converts, because of the great dangers this used to imposed on the Jewish communities, in the way of Pogroms, and outright warfare against us. And out of respect for those countries laws.
If Golus dictates our Holy Torah. We can expect to remain as such. R'L (G-d forbid!)
Since my Father is a Levi through both his Father and Mother. I'm a direct decendant of Yaakov Avinu. When most Jews were being killed somehow my Family survived. Yet many years ago my conversion would have been rejected by Chabad. But the orthodox Rabbi's on the Beit Din pushed it through, and I went on to study at Yeshiva.
How can only following the 7 Noahide laws be respectfull to my ancestors if I strive for more?! Reply

Anonymous Deale, MD December 11, 2011

Temple restored How is the model of the temple that is being rebuilt coming along? Reply

Related Topics