HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org Ideas & Beliefs
 
Chabad.org » Ideas & Beliefs » Questions & Answers » Jewish Identity » What's the difference between Orthodox, Conservative and Reform?


Post a CommentPrintSend this page to a friendSubscribe
22 Comments Posted


What's the difference between Orthodox, Conservative and Reform?



Question:

What is the difference between Orthodox Judaism, Conservative Judaism and Reform Judaism?

Answer:

I may be the wrong person to answer this question. Because, personally, I don't believe there are any "isms" in being Jewish. There are just Jews, our Torah, and our willingness to do it.

However, I'll try to give an objective description of what these "isms" mean in practical terms:

All the way up until the 19th century, there were just Jews. We kept the halachah -- which means the rabbinical interpretation of the rules and guidelines of the Torah -- and kept a steady tradition for 3,000 years since Sinai. If some individual or group went astray from halachah, they were generally estranged from the Jewish people.

Then came Reform. They said, "Things are changing. We are smarter now. We know there is no need to keep kosher, Shabbat, circumcision or believe in a return to Zion." In Germany, they said, "Berlin is our Jerusalem." In America, it was Washington.

Then came Conservative. They said, "These Reform rabbis have gone too far. We need to conserve some of the basic traditions of Judaism." So they revived a form of kosher eating, Shabbat and circumcision. And they weren't so convinced about the Washington thing.

The Jews who did not go along with any of this were labeled "Orthodox." They never asked for it, but that's what they got called. Personally, I cannot see myself as orthodox, since I think of my Jewishness as something very radical and, well, unorthodox.

I also don't see the point in reforming my Jewishness. I would much rather my Jewishness reform me. After all, all these things that the fathers of reform saw as obsolete back then have now come back into fashion and are rising in popularity every day. The number of kosher foods on the market, for example, rose by about 2000% in the last ten years. As for Jerusalem, well that's pretty obvious. The Reform movement had to make a sharp about-turn in 1948.

Now, I'll bet I've provoked more questions than I've answered. But that's okay. Because that's part of what being Jewish is about -- thinking out of the box and asking questions.


Post a CommentPrintSend this page to a friendSubscribe
22 Comments Posted

By Tzvi Freeman   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author

Rabbi Tzvi Freeman heads Chabad.org's Ask The Rabbi team, and is a senior member of the Chabad.org editorial team. He is the author of a number of highly original renditions of Kabbalah and Chassidic teaching, including the universally acclaimed "Bringing Heaven Down to Earth." To order Tzvi's books click here.


The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

22 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Oct 18, 2007
Re: Re: Rob Ramsey's comment to Daniel
Isn't the whole problem the fact that different sub-sets (sects??) of Judaism hod differing views on Halacha. So, a Reform conversion probably won't insist on the Brit, won't accept the philosophy ot Torah as direct word of G-d etc. So, other Reform jews will accept the conversion but more orthodox sects won't consider it to be according to Halacha.
Personally, I feel that a Jew is a Jew, and that includes the converts from all sects bit I'm aware that others disagree. Isn't what's in the heart more important than the formalities?
Posted By simon, London, UK.

Posted: Oct 14, 2007
Re: Rob Ramsey's comment to Daniel
Reform/Orthodox ≠ Methodist/Catholic. Christianity is a religion--being a Christian is a matter of belief. Jewishness is a matter of belonging. Reform Jews belong just as much as Orthodox--as long as the mother was Jewish or the conversion was according to halacha.

I know, now we're really confused.
Posted By Tzvi Freeman (author), Thornhill, Ontario

Posted: Oct 13, 2007
Re: Daniel vs. Rob
Daniel is correct. Once a Jew, always a Jew. It's a one-way street.

The only exception might be if the giur was performed due to intentional misinformation--but then the person was never really a ger to begin with.
Posted By Tzvi Freeman (author), Thornhill, Ontario



Post a Comment
Subject:
Comment:
  1000 Characters Remaining
Name*:
Email*:
City:   State/Country:
* indicates a required field
 


Jewish Identity
Why Do Jews Exclude Other People?
Why are my Non-Religious Parents Against my Marrying a Non-Jew?
Does Intermarriage Work?
Why Not Make it Easier to Convert?
Why Do Rabbis Discourage Conversions?
Couldn't the Jews and Greeks Get Along?
Unorthodox Judaism
What's the difference between Orthodox, Conservative and Reform?
What's this "Jewish soul" Thing? Aren't We All One?
Can a Jew believe in Jesus?
Jewish Fundamentalism?
Is Judaism the Truth?
Is Diversity Good for the Jews?
Judaism or Lennonism?
The Shtetl Jew: Relic or Role Model?
Showing 13 to 27 of 29

Related
  More articles on
Orthodox Judaism (11 articles)
Jewishness; Jewish Identity (369 articles)
Halachah (294 articles)