HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Ask the Rabbi
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Questions & Answers » Ask the Rabbi » Latest Questions » Advice » Vegetarians and Sacrifices
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment27 Comments

Vegetarians and Sacrifices


Question:

I'm a vegetarian. I'm having trouble reading about sacrifices in the Temple and harmonizing that with my worldview. Can you give me a hand here?

Response:

I can see your quandary, but then, as a vegetarian and a lover of animals, you should appreciate the idea of the sacrifices more than someone else. Here's why:

The Temple turned eating meat into a meaningful experience. A mindful act. A meal that made you a better person. It wasn't like eating a hamburger for lunch or munching on chicken nuggets while on the road.

The individual was quite aware of what it took for the meat to get to his plate. He saw the slaughtering and together with it, the singing and prayers of the Levites. Most vital were his own thoughts of repentance while bringing the offering. Without such self-reflection, the sacrifice was meaningless.

Torah acknowledges that eating meat is serious business. It isn't just another food. After all, if it's only about filling one's stomach, there are many foods that can do the job that don't require killing a living being. Eating meat therefore carries with it a greater sense of responsibility.

The nicely packaged lamb-chop in the refrigerator section of the grocery store comes from a place no different than the Paschal offering. The former is a mundane dinner—the latter, a mindful act and transformative experience.

Today, meat or no meat, it's our dinner table that takes the place of the altar. By inviting guests, enjoying a Shabbat Seudah, or engaging in a meaningful discussion with our children, we too can turn a meal into a holy experience.

You can find some excellent articles on the topic of vegetarianism under that keyword in our knowledge base.

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment27 Comments

By Yisroel Cotlar   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Yisroel Cotlar is a Chabad rabbi in Cary, North Carolina. He is also a member of the Chabad.org Ask the Rabbi team.
All names of persons and locations or other identifying features referenced in these questions have been omitted or changed to preserve the anonymity of the questioners.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

27 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Dec 23, 2010
semi-vegetarian
I also do not eat meat of Mammals, but only fish. In my case, I guess it's for sentimental reasons - I feel sorry for the animals that are "warm and fuzzy". No rhyme or reason to it, I just feel that way. I do not judge anyone that eats meat and I'm perfectly aware that it's part of the culture and history of many nations, including ours; and I respect that. Cheers.
Posted By Mark R, Reston, VA

Posted: Sep 20, 2010
Vegetarians and Sacrifices
Before the Flood angelic beings copulated with women and a race of giants were born that eventually occasioned the Flood. Greek mythology is also full of such irregular unions. Sometimes these gigantic beastly are reincarnate such as Gengis Khan, Napolean, Hitler, Stalin, etc. The third Temple will not be constructed until a earthquake flattens the present buildings there.
Posted By David Flinkstein, London, UK

Posted: Sep 19, 2010
Dear Unlisted
It is a mitsvah for the Kohanim to eat the meat of certain sacrifices. You are mistaken in some points. And also the Paschal Offering was to be eaten by all of Israel.

Originally, only sacrificial meat was eaten, in the times of the Tabernacle, before they settled the Land of Israel. And if permission was given, then it is not appropriate to say that it was not a mitsvah.

After the return of the temple, there will be a sacrifice offered by the "prince" Moshiach, as is described in Ezekiel, ch 40, ch 41.

but at some point there will be a world free of sin.
Posted By Yonatan, Shomron, Israel

Posted: Sep 17, 2010
To RostikAviel
With the coming of Moshiach we will once again offer sacrifices. This is fact as stated many times throughout Jewish texts.
Why did G-D institute sacrifices? Its a good question which might only be answered satisfactorily when Moshiach comes. But let us not dismiss something just because we dont understand as of yet.

(on a side note: most of the sacrifices are eaten by man so it will be more of a barbeque )

Have a happy healthy sweet New Year,
Posted By Lee

Posted: Sep 16, 2010
Highest Purpose for animal to be sacrificed?
I'm not a vegetarian; however- I don't think that animal sacrifices apply when our temple is destroyed. Maybe when third temple will be built we can justify sacrifices but than we won't need them as Mashiach will abolish the need for blood shed, even if Halaha-justified. example: i prefer charity over the atonement rooster. G-d initially didn't mean for us to shed blood but thanks to Kain that has changed.
Posted By RostikAviel, port hueneme, ca
via chabadofoxnard.com

Posted: Sep 4, 2010
Non-animal rights vegetarian
I have been a vegetarian for many years.

Now I am a KOSHER vegetarian, which means I am eating the best possible way for both my body and my Jewish neshama (soul).

However, I am NOT an animal-rights advocate. I recognize that G-d put animals on earth for Man to have dominion over them, and He gave Jews permission to eat them after the flood (although having permission doesn't mean there's a mitzvah to do so).

And I recognize that for an animal to be a corbon (sacrifice) to G-d is the highest purpose that any animal can have! What a great honor!
Posted By Unlisted, Unlisted, USA

Posted: Sep 1, 2010
Sol
Thanks, but your praise is misplaced....I eat fish, but no chicken or red meat. I don't like meat, never have. I find the idea of it over whelmingly off putting. (I'm trying to not offend, so my language is soft.) But I know the halachic ground I am on, (that is why I eat fish.) Generally I don't like to discuss this topic. For one, I don't want to push my halachicly borderline ideas onto other people. Also, this conversation frequently happens around a table, and it isn't nice to tell a person that the item on their plate is disgusting! (I've become very good at not looking at other peoples' plates!)
Posted By Sarah Masha, W Bloomfield, MI/USA

Posted: Sep 1, 2010
keep it up Sara!
that's the way to go. keep strong and don't bow down to the vegetarianism-deity.
Posted By sol

Posted: Sep 1, 2010
Response to Sara
Sara,

When I eat meat, I do so with the animal's purpose in mind, and then I try to do some mitzvah afterward with the energy I got from that meal. I feel kind of funny typing this, but it's true.
Posted By Anonymous, Philadelphia, PA

Posted: Aug 30, 2010
Anonymous, Kanata, ON
"How many Jews actually take a shred of animal meat to save the animals' trapped soul? More people are out ther gobbling huge deli slices in subs, half a pound of beef at once, and without thinking."

They do so because it has become common, and people don't think about the common occurrances. That is a problem of education, not action. We can't prohibit a permited act, we do need to think about those actions.

I quote you again:
I say that all religious belief has tended to screen out animal meat form the diet,
I don't think that is correct. While some do, many either want the person to realize what they have done, or to thank the animal, many do not promote vegetarianism. Muslims generally eat meat, halal proceedures mimic kosher (no surprise there). Except for a few sects, Chistians also eat meat. For Hindus it depends on which caste you are, Higher castes don't, but lower ones do.
Posted By sarah masha, w bloomfield, mi/usa



 


Advice
On the Yartzeit of a Child
I'm a Slander Victim!
My Husband Has a Temper!
Why Are Guys So Immature?
Dealing With Past Baggage
Aren’t We Being Nudniks on Yom Kippur?
How to Let Go of a Grudge
Vegetarians and Sacrifices
How To Beat Laziness
When the Passion Dies
Best Friend's Wedding on Yom Kippur
I Love My Friend's Husband!
Keeping Out of Unethical Business
The Torah on Dirty Words
Guidelines for the Wealthy
Showing 5 - 19 of 165