Printed from Chabad.org
Contact Us
Visit us on Facebook
Meet the new Chabad.org
Switch to OLD version

Jews Without Shoes

Print
E-mail

Question:

My grandmother always told me not to walk around the house in just socks and no shoes. Is there anything to this or is it an old wives tale?

Answer:

There is no law that forbids you to walk around in socks. But our sages teach us to never ignore the sayings of our grandmothers, for there is always some wisdom in them. Indeed, your grandmother's aversion to shoelessness does have some basis.

Jewish law states that one who is mourning the loss of a loved one removes their shoes. Thus walking around in socks makes you look like a mourner, and we don't even want to look like a mourner. This is part of a general Jewish attitude to death. We don't like it. We do whatever we can to stay away from it.

There are many Jewish customs that stem from the desire to avoid anything associated with death. Some people don't sleep with their feet facing the door, because that is how a corpse lies before burial. We don't speak about what will happen when someone dies, but rather what will happen "after 120 years." We wash our hands after attending a funeral, to rid ourselves of the impurity of the cemetery.

This dislike of death is not so much a superstition as an allergy. Our tradition trains us to love life and be allergic to death. Unlike some traditions that venerate death as an ideal and view life as a wretched curse, the Jewish tradition cherishes life as a blessing. Through customs that distance us from death and its trappings, the Jewish people has inculcated a worldview that is life-affirming and this-world focused.

Your grandmother had a point. Death is a part of life. But it need not be given any more space than necessary. Keep your shoes on.

By Aron Moss
Rabbi Aron Moss teaches Kabbalah, Talmud and practical Judaism in Sydney, Australia, and is a frequent contributor to Chabad.org.
The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
Print
E-mail
Sort By:
Discussion (30)
July 10, 2011
Source?
All jokes aside, does anyone know of a source for this in Jewish (halachic) texts?
Anonymous
OP
July 7, 2011
Hahaha, Richard. This reminds me of ...
A story my rabbi told in Chabad on one Friday evening. He said that there was a SPECIAL pan you had to use to bake a beef roast. It was a religious edict, you had to use a pan of those dimensions. His wife said her mother said yes, they had to use that size pan. Why? Her own mother said they had to use that size pan, so it must be in the scriptures somewhere. Not being able to find it, the man decided to fly to the "Old Country" in Europe where his wife's great-great grandmother was still living. (This is, of course, a story). When he got there, he asked, "Bubbe, where in the scriptures does it say we have to use this size and kind of pan to bake beef?" Her answer, "It doesn't say that. But, it was the only pan I had." Her daughter had assumed because it was used, it was a holy edict, and handed that info down to her own children, etc. It could be that one family, long ago, couldn't afford shoes? So, they made a rule. No shoes. Then, it was copied...
Karen Joyce Chaya Fradle Kleinman Bell
Riverside, CA
July 6, 2011
Jews Without Shoes - bubbies
Simple Answer. By bubbie (father's side)and my mother, who got it from her mother and grandmother, etc., etc. etc.
I would bet that that is where everyone got it.
Richard
Lauderhill, Florida
July 5, 2011
Source?
Can someone point me to a source for this?

Thank you.
Anonymous
OP
May 4, 2011
If this is the custom, then be sure...
To keep your rugs and floors clear of such things as fallen staples, thumbtacks, broken glass, dried food, etc. Diabetics must protect the bottom of their feet so they won't become infected and need amputation.
Karen Joyce Chaya Fradle Kleinman Bell
Riverside, CA, USA
April 22, 2011
Flip side...
I don't have any such custom in my family, so I can't speak to that. What I can speak to is the fact that when I pray barefoot, I feel much more intuitively connected to creation in it's "she-ha-kol ni-yeh bi-dvaro" sense. I feel physically and spiritually planted in the tangible expression of divinity. I would be interested whether there is any talmudic/scriptural basis for that?
Anonymous
Blacksburg, VA
April 6, 2011
shoes off
Although there is such a custom by many Jews,the vast majority do not follow this custom and allow walking around the house in socks or barefoot
david zitter
skokie, il.
January 26, 2011
Jews without shoes
I think the subject of removal of shoes could be addressed by having some simple slippers near the front door. Also some clean and acceptable ones for visitors. When sitting shiva one must wear slippers. Perhaps all the family could keep slippers ready. As for taking outdoor shoes up to the bedrooms, I am told by an expert that bringing outerwear into the bedroom is almost certainly the cause of infested mattresses.
Leo35
London, U.K.
January 25, 2011
Many reasons for shoelessness
I have relatives living in Japan. There, wearing shoes inside is seen as highly unclean, as it tracks dirty and sidewalk germs into the living space. One wears slippers, socks, or bare feet there out of both respect and physical cleanliness standard.

I have the same practice in my home, because I've had lots of foot surgeries and have become very sensitive to dirty floors. I let people know about it before they come over, so it's not a surprise, and they can decline an invitation if it makes them uncomfortable -- but it is an absolute household rule with me, no exceptions.
Judith Epstein
Chicago, IL
December 21, 2010
Anon in Santa Clara,
When I first moved into my apartment in Riverside, I tried to have people take off their shoes. But, most of them ANGRILY said it was too much effort to take them off and put them on. These are family members who don't live with me. I could have been firm and then NOT SEEN them again. So, I wasn't. Now, my rug is A TOTAL EYESORE and even washing it does not work. In an apartment, they usually do NOT install the highest quality rug. I think people should be POLITE and ASK the host or hostess if they should remove their shoes. In a Korean household, you MUST remove shoes. They put all shoes in a neat line up at the front door. Often, in apartments, they put them OUTSIDE the front door on the landing or porch. I think this would be NICE of us to do with each other even if we choose to disregard the REASONING or tradition behind the practice. After all, we aren't all rich enough to be able to afford a rug washer on a weekly basis.
Karen Joyce Chaya Fradle Kleinman Bell
Riverside, CA, USA
Show all comments
1000 characters remaining
Email me when new comments are posted.
FEATURED ON CHABAD.ORG