HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Ask the Rabbi
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Questions & Answers » Ask the Rabbi » Latest Questions » Advice » Should I Remarry?
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment37 Comments

Should I Remarry?


Question:

My wife was killed in a car wreck 21 years ago, yet to this day I find it hard to fall in love with another woman. How can I be totally committed to her when I still long for my late wife? I would feel so guilty.

I am 52 years old now and really want to move on.

Response:

They say that the soul of a spouse is not at rest until his or her other half has found another partner in life. I do not know the source, but it makes sense. After all, the only thing in the entire creation upon which G-d pronounced "not good" is a man alone. "It is not good that man is alone,” He said. “I will make a helpmeet for him."

Don't seek complete satisfaction, complete commitment, complete anything. It does not come in this world. Life in this world is about learning to live with the imperfect, learning to harmonize a band of poorly tuned rubber bands and kazoos and making a symphony of them. A second marriage, as well, may be something like playing a violin sonata on a guitar. No, it may not be the real thing, but it’s better than silence. It may even be beautiful, nonetheless. And so too, a second marriage is better than loneliness. Much better.

Will you be totally committed? You will do what you can. You will provide for her needs, physical and emotional, and you will surprise her with flowers, jewelry and gifts. You will travel together, have fun together, commiserate together and laugh together. You will remain two people, each with the baggage of past years, but you will learn to ignore all that. And at those special moments, you will become one.

You have much life still ahead of you. Find another with whom to share it.

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment37 Comments

By Tzvi Freeman   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Tzvi Freeman, a senior editor at Chabad.org, also heads our Ask The Rabbi team. He is the author of Bringing Heaven Down to Earth. To subscribe to regular updates of Rabbi Freeman's writing, visit Freeman Files subscription.
All names of persons and locations or other identifying features referenced in these questions have been omitted or changed to preserve the anonymity of the questioners.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

37 Comments Posted  |  Post A Comment
Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Nov 7, 2011
Trying
I didn't try to find a mate the second time around -- and a beautiful mensch came into my life and we shared Laughter Love and so much more.

I do not try to find another ... if it happens, then it's G-d's Will.

G-d is with me all the days of my life.
Posted By Meira Shana, Vista, California

Posted: Oct 13, 2011
Oneness with Hashem First!
My thoughts are we have to learn to love ourselves first and have that special realationship with Hashem," then when Hashem decides we are ready to build a future with someone else our paths will simply merge to a brighter future! So until then just keep that relationship with Hashem and find peace and oneness in your relationship with the most Holy!
Posted By Michelle Andre, cc, fk
via chabadcape.com

Posted: Oct 8, 2011
Hubby wanted me to remarry
He said if I find a nice man I should remarry. I asked him how will I know if another would be nice -- he said: I'll tap you on your left shoulder.

After his death, this is the first time I ever lived by myself. I am fine. I am enjoying solo times - although it was much better being solo when my beloved was with me.
Posted By Meira Shana, Vista, California

Posted: Oct 5, 2011
remarry
Absolute NO: MANAGE ur loneliness ; its better; u cannot love another woman again only her warm body; ur soul will never match again; remain single please don't complicate ur life and ur kids they will never agree , it never happened and will not;
Posted By anony, pl, ng

Posted: Nov 9, 2010
Don't seek complete satisfaction...
It will come the moment you will let it come.
I am a widow myself (for 11 years) trying to find my soulmate for some years.
And I know, G-d willing, I will.
The same I wish to you.
Just "commit" yourself...
G-D bless you.
Posted By Yola, Warsaw, Poland

Posted: Aug 18, 2010
Beloved died 9 years ago
Although my beloved husband died in 2001, and he said I should remarry if I meet someone nice ... I don't feel the need or the desire.

Perhaps if I was younger I would feel differently . . .

This month I'll be 72 ... and my husband died when he was 55 of Esophageal Cancer.

To the gentle man whose wife died and he's 52 now ... I don't put myself into dating situations. Do you?

Ask G-d to give you the strength to do what is right for you . . .
Posted By Marl, San Diego, CA/USA

Posted: July 29, 2010
Re-Marriage
This widower needs bereavement counseling before seeking a new relationship. It's not fair to any woman he meets if he still has the emotional attachment to his first wife. the Torah considers an unmarried man "not whole" but it doesn't say that about women.

There are many second marriages that are even better than a person's first marriage. He should consider another marriage only if he's fully committed to being a husband to his new wife. Does he have children? Would they approve or not? Would he marry someone with children? Would her children approve or not? Blending families is not easy but very successfully done. They should sign a pre-nup so there's no fights about inheritance. I wish him well.
Posted By Savvy Savta, San Diego, CA

Posted: July 22, 2010
Anon - comment 2
I think that the man should be advised to undergo counseling until he feels ready to love again. Then he is ready to enter a real relationship, but not just to have some kind of partnership with a warm body.
Posted By Anon

Posted: July 22, 2010
What a depressing response
As someone dating to get married, first time, this would totally put me off of meeting a widow.

Also, I wonder if the rav would have given the same advice to a 52 year old woman.
Posted By Anonymous

Posted: June 14, 2010
Shmuel
I agree with Shmuel. Rabbi Freeman in simple words is saying that the 2nd marrige isn't going to be as good as th first. I especially didn't like the anology with the musical instruments. For all you know it the second marriage will sound much better than the first! It may not be the same, but why say it's not going to be as good?
Posted By Mendy K, Milwaukee , WI



 


Advice
I Love My Friend's Husband!
Keeping Out of Unethical Business
The Torah on Dirty Words
Guidelines for the Wealthy
Forgiving Infidelity
My Orthodox Friend Cut Me Off!
I Never Agree with My Dad!
Should I Remarry?
Am I Wrong To Forgive a Murderer?
How Much Can I Get For My Brother?
Going Kosher on a Budget
Do Criminals Deserve Kosher Food?
Coping With Suicide
Why Do They Hide Their Pregnancy?
Is Genetic Testing Kosher?
Showing 16 - 30 of 165