Why do we care?
Why does it disturb us when tens of thousands of people are killed by an earthquake in Turkey? Why are we outraged when a crazed gunman mows down a flock of children in a schoolyard? Why are we pained by the sight of a homeless man dying a slow death in a doorway?
There seems to be something that we all -- male and female, rich and poor, religious and secular, hippie and yuppie -- agree on: that human life has value. That we not only exist, but also should exist. And that anyone who thinks otherwise is evil, crazy or both (remember the "crazed gunman"?).
But why? If our existence is an accident, something that just happened to have happened, why should it make any meaningful difference if we are or are not? Why, indeed, is the word "meaningful" in our vocabulary? If there is no purpose to our existence, why is "suicidal depression" an illness?
Atheists, too, believe in G-d -- they just call Him something else Atheists, too, believe in G-d -- they just call Him something else. They believe that human life is purposeful -- that there is something beyond our existence which our existence serves. Rationally, a person may reject this truth, but his every instinct affirms it. And when it doesn't, the race will unanimously label him "not normal."
Take a look at today's headlines: "Heroic 30-Hour Effort by Surgeon to Save Mom's Life"; "Tragedy on Mountainface: Mudslide Buries Four"; "Outlook Good for Burn Victim." These are news items, supposedly devoid of any moral or religious value judgements. So why do they presume that their readers will agree that the doctor's efforts are heroic, the mudslide tragic, and the possibility that the burn victim will survive "good"?
Why do we care? Because in the beginning G-d created the heavens and the earth.
moral standards.
San Diego, California
"They believe that human life is purposeful -- that there is something beyond our existence which our existence serves."
Actually no we don't. At least none of the atheists I know. We aren't like hammers which are created for the purpose of pounding nails.
There are different kinds of purpose that I can think of and none of them describe a relationship between me and something outside existence.
One kind of purpose implies a goal and I don't believe my existence serves any particular goal.
I'm not sure why it makes some people feel happy to be like a hammer in this regard. I like being autonomous. With your beliefs don't you feel like a pawn being some mere cog in some uber-plan? I sure would.
It doesn't bother me in the least that Jupiter has no purpose outside existence or inside it either, not like a hammer.
Long Island, NY
chabadnashville.com
Atheists, too, believe in G-d -- they just call Him something else. They believe that human life is purposeful -- that there is something beyond our existence which our existence serves. Rationally, a person may reject this truth, but his every instinct affirms it. And when it doesn't, the race will unanimously label him "not normal."
Point by point:
- Atheists do not "believe in G-d". By definition. We also believe you can spell the name in full in any language without any problems. I won't do it here out of respect, but millennia of experience tell us that. Oh, and give what the "thei" part of the word means, shouldn't you perhaps write it "ath-ists"
- As we don't believe, we don't give it another name. We give gods the name their believers give them. Anything else would make discussion difficult, if not impossible.
chabadnashville.com
Animals don't commit suicide.
Animals, even if hungry and thin, do all that is possible to keep alive.
It is as if they appritiated life even more than humans. Why?
And, then, why do humans not respect life as much? Is this a degeneration of the human race?
Animals don't make wars.
Have humans become too many on earth?
Thanks for giving me this opportunity,
Caracas, Venezuela