HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE LoginLOGIN Ask the RabbiASK THE RABBI
Chabad.org - Torah, Judaism and Jewish Info Ask the Rabbi
 
Chabad.org » Learning & Values » Questions & Answers » Ask the Rabbi » Latest Questions » Advice » Coping With Suicide
PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment8 Comments

Coping With Suicide


Question:

Recently, my nephew was found dead in his room. We know it was suicide. His father—my sister's husband and my husband's brother—was against his choice of fiancée.

We've told everyone it was a heart attack—he had heart problems before. My sister is not coping well—she seems to be in denial. Nobody wants to discuss this. Please give me some advice.

Response:

This is not something you can just forget about and get on with life. This is something that must change the course of life, or it will be forever sending life in circles.

Tragedy is an implosion of negative energy, draining away all warmth and light, sucking the spirit out of our lives like a monstrous leech. And yet, we have the power to grab that energy by the reins and turn it around into a power for good—a greater good than any positive energy could have provided.

How do we do that? Certainly not by stewing over our remorse and guilt. Neither by attempting to keep it stuffed under our pillows. But if your nephew's early demise will lead you to be a more caring person and your sister to be a more caring mother, then he did not die without meaning.

Really, nothing is without meaning. We believe in one benevolent G‑d who directs all of heaven and earth. If so, we also believe that every event of life is meant to propel us forward. G‑d does not allow tragedy in His world just for the heck of it. Everything must have meaning, only that the meaning can only be known from the final result. That final result is in your hands.

Here is the best therapy for you: There are people in your family—your children, your sister and others—who need your care right now. They need a soothing voice, a warm heart, a word of encouragement, a dose of optimism. Most of all, they need an open ear into which to pour the bitterness of their souls and a shoulder upon which to cry. You will become that person. Even if you did not have the capability to do such before, that does not matter. You will channel the horror and guilt over your nephew's death into your own transformation. And there all the bitterness will become sweet.

What can you tell your sister? To tell you, I would have to imagine myself as her—and, honestly, I am afraid to even begin to do that. All I can say is that G‑d must have given you much strength to be able to deal with this. Listen to her, listen deeply, and the words will come.

We mourn death because we cherish life. That is why we place a limit to the days of mourning--seven days of intense mourning and one month more of remembering, and then life continues, yet higher. We don't destroy life by mourning the past. We learn from death to count our days as one counts jewels. For the only vantage point from which we can measure their value is from that of the very last one. That is when we will ask, "What did I do with the life G‑d gave me? Was it a worthwhile gift? Was it all worthwhile?"

PrintSend this page to a friendShare this
Comment8 Comments

By Tzvi Freeman   More articles...  |   RSS Listing of Newest Articles by this Author
Rabbi Tzvi Freeman, a senior editor at Chabad.org, also heads our Ask The Rabbi team. He is the author of Bringing Heaven Down to Earth. To subscribe to regular updates of Rabbi Freeman's writing, visit Freeman Files subscription.
All names of persons and locations or other identifying features referenced in these questions have been omitted or changed to preserve the anonymity of the questioners.

The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.
 

Reader Comments
Latest Comments:
Posted: Dec 28, 2009
Tzvi's Reponse
Thank you Tzvi for responding in the excellent way that you do. You are a thoroughly thoughtful person. For the person involved I wish much success and love your way for your family and loved ones.
Posted By Anonymous, Brisbane

Posted: Dec 25, 2009
Suicide
I believe your Family should be honest about the Suicide. This is not a death by natural causes. Deal with reality now and it will not be back to haunt someone else in the Family.
There is a certain Stigma that comes along with a suicide. What was he trying to escape?
What statement has his death made? Those are questions that will not be resolved by calling it a "heart attack". The truth might just set you free.
Posted By Anonymous, Platteville, WI

Posted: Dec 1, 2009
Heart attack - good idea
You did a right thing you called it heart attack. Some people simply thrive on other people's misery and you should not give them such pleasure.
Posted By Anonymous, Zion, Neverland

Posted: Nov 21, 2009
coping with suicide
Very thoughtful & appropriate response.There is a nat'l organization called the compassionate friends (www.compassionatefriends.org). I have attended their support group meetings. The organization exists for support after the death (from any reason) of a child or sibling (at any age). There is no fee of any kind. It is not a religious organization. It has been helpful for me. I do wish that I lived in a bigger city, so that there might be a bigger Jewish voice. There are participants whose children & siblings have died from suicide as well as drug overdoses. One piece of advice they offer is to try to leave a small part of your grief behind & not to take on someone else's grief (which is often times hard not to do). I have learned that one does not get OVER a thing like this, but it is possible to get THROUGH it, especially with the support of others in similar circumstances.
Posted By Anonymous, Tucson, Az

Posted: Nov 19, 2009
suicide

Thank you for posting that reply. Last December my son's best friend committed suicide and it has been devastating to their family. They seem to have shut people out, by not answering the phone or door. I look for ways to connect with them. I may send her the link to your reply. Thank you.
Posted By Anonymous, Ventura, CA
via chabadventura.com

Posted: Nov 19, 2009
Wisdom
Very well spoken. This is the hardest tragedy for anyone to process, Jew or non-Jew. The psychologists will say that it takes a long time to recover. But we have lost something in the Tradition of the Jewish Community to limit mourning, all communities could learn from this tradition. Extended mourning can become destructive to life. The Community all followed the same Tradition of mourning so it strengthened the individual. May G-d grant you the strength and wisdom do be the anchor that the family so needs right now.
Posted By Bill Hill, Virginia Beach, VA

Posted: Nov 17, 2009
Coping
While G-d is ultimate Peace and Goodness, and can and will heal all, I would encourage the poster's sister to engage in therapy (no, I'm not a therapist) either individually, or perhaps there are groups of individuals going through similar losses that can assist (grief/trauma programs). I would not encourage your sister to go through this alone. As Tzvi noted, you are key to her recovery as well.
Posted By Gershon Garber, Casselberry, FL

Posted: Nov 16, 2009
Answer
Three weeks ago the family of my wife's cousin had to deal with the same tragedy.
I prayed and studied Mishna, but I didn't know what to think about this family. A worthwhile meaning that can change the course of life so that the tragedy was not in vain is the answer we were looking for.
Posted By Anonymous



 


Advice
My Orthodox Friend Cut Me Off!
I Never Agree with My Dad!
Should I Remarry?
Am I Wrong To Forgive a Murderer?
How Much Can I Get For My Brother?
Going Kosher on a Budget
Do Criminals Deserve Kosher Food?
Coping With Suicide
Why Do They Hide Their Pregnancy?
Is Genetic Testing Kosher?
Conversion Process Taking Too Long
How to Change in Spite of Failure?
Is It Okay to Wish That Your Parents Die?
Abort Down Syndrome Baby?
When Does Nice = Push-over?
Showing 21 - 35 of 165