Printed from chabad.org
All Departments
Jewish Holidays
TheRebbe.org
Jewish.TV - Video
Jewish Audio
News
Kabbalah Online
JewishWoman.org
Kids Zone

To a Child of a Jewish Father

To a Child of a Jewish Father

E-mail

Question:

My mother was Protestant. My father's father was Catholic, but his mother was Jewish. My family survived the holocaust in Europe, with great struggle.

I know that by traditional Jewish law I am not Jewish, but I feel that I more than qualify to be a Jew. I read books about Jews. I support Israel. I even had a bar mitzvah. The worst part is that the people who tell me I am not Jewish are rabbis! They said I would have to convert to Judaism. I do not understand why they say this. My family survived the greatest atrocities in the history of the Jews. How can I convert, when I feel that I already am Jewish....

Response:

In Biblical Israel, every citizen was landed. If you were a descendant of one of the twelve tribes, you owned a plot of land. If you sold it, it came back to you--or to your inheritors--on the jubilee year, which occurred every 50 years. You were tied to the land and the land was tied to you. Inheritance of land was through the paternal line--just as tribal affiliation is patrilineal.

I'm mentioning this because, in Torah law, a very similar relationship exists between the Torah and a Jew, between a Jew and his Jewishness. A Jew can abandon the Torah, but the Torah never abandons him--eventually it will return, if not to him, then to his children, if not to his children, then to his children's children. So too, a Jew may imagine that he has abandoned his Jewishness, and yet always remains a Jew--as do the children of that Jew, and the children of those children.

There are two distinctions, however, between the relationship of a Jew to his share of the land and the relationship of a Jew to Torah and Jewishness. One is that it is possible to sell one's plot of land--although it will still return, for that period of time, it is sold. Torah and Jewishness, on the other hand, are not for sale. No matter how hard a Jew may try, he never truly can let go of either.

The other distinction is that Jewishness--and therefore the relationship to Torah--is not patrilineal, but matrilineal. Perhaps these two distinctions are related: The maternal line strikes much deeper to the essence of who you are, and that essence is something that not only will always return, but can never truly be abandoned.

Despite all this, the child whose father married out of his people can still claim his father's heritage. His challenge is greater than the child whose Jewish mother brought him by default into her people. In his case, it is up to him to decide whether he wants to make the commitment to join his father's people and to fulfill all the obligations the Torah places upon this nation. He must also become circumcised and immerse in a mikvah before a qualified bet din.

If this is the path you wish to follow, I am willing to assist to whatever degree is within my capacity. If not, it is good to have you as a friend of the Jewish People. The righteous of humankind, no matter to which family, tribe or nation they belong, all have a share in the world to come.

Rabbi Tzvi Freeman, a senior editor at Chabad.org, also heads our Ask The Rabbi team. He is the author of Bringing Heaven Down to Earth. To subscribe to regular updates of Rabbi Freeman's writing, visit Freeman Files subscription.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with Chabad.org's copyright policy.
E-mail
1000 characters remaining
Email me when new comments are posted.
Sort By:
Discussion (151)
June 10, 2014
Come home to us!
I am happy to hear from Rabbi Moshen that he would convert a teen before the age of 18, even though he requires that the teen be attending a yesiva high school.

But I understand why. Committing to a jewish lifestyle for all eternity (including future gilgulim) is a serious matter. A child or a teen may not realize the seriousness of the commitment. But if s/he is attending a Bais Yaakov or a yeshiva, s/he realizes the serious of his (and especially her) commitment.

I want to emphasize how very welcome among us are the children of Jewish fathers. Please go through the technicality of "conversion" without feeling insulted. I'm speaking as a lay person: we love you. We want you back. You are OURS. We are YOURS. Just do the ceremony, and come home to us. Please! Get out of this limbo. It's not that hard. And it means everything to you and to us. Gd bless you.
Chana
Austin
June 9, 2014
To the writer from Washington
I am unaware of any orthodox rabbi who will be willing to convert children living with their non-Jewish mother (even if they live with both parents, including a Jewish father). I would also be very wary of any rabbi who claims to be orthodox and says that he would convert pre-Bar Mitzvah children living with a non-Jewish mother.

If both parents were supportive, then I would consider working with a teen who strongly wanted to convert, and possibly converting the teen while attending a Yeshiva High School.
Rabbi Aryeh Moshen
Brooklyn, NY
June 3, 2014
married to a Jewish man
I have two daughters, 1 and 3.5 years old. My husband is Jewish. I was born and raised in a catholic family. I no longer attend church. Some of my close friends are Jewish and we celebrate and observe the main Holidays. I don'ty think I will convert, but will continue to expose my kids to Judaism. Thinking of the future, if my kids choose to convert when the are a bit older, but still kids, is that possible. Do I have to convert for them to be able to?
Anonymous
washington, dc
May 11, 2014
When the wrong part is Jewish
I know a few dozen of them (many of whom converted). They self-identify as Jews. Many would not even consider marrying a non-Jew. They may be proud of their Jewish background and very Zionist. If they truly want to be Jewish then we should encourage them to complete their becoming 100% Jewish (as in conversion). These are not only my words. Rabbi Reuven Feinstein said them in a public forum several years ago. He even went as far as to say that it is our obligation to bring them through the conversion process.

Some may be hurt by telling them that we don't consider them 100% Jewish. We are sorry that they are hurt and welcome them with open arms. The situation in the USA is not quite as bad as it is in Europe but it has gotten to the point when a Jewish name and nose do not mean that someone is Jewish. And conversely there are those walking around with non-Jewish names and features who are truly Jewish.

Let us bring all of them into the fold.
Rabbi Aryeh Moshen
Brooklyn, NY
May 9, 2014
Thank you Rabbi
Thank you for your answer Rabbi.
I see your point. What I try to mean, is that 2 independ groups of Jewish people found different answers to the same question based on the same texts.

I am 100% Jewish from Orthodox tradition but this question interest me.
Nowadays, we all have in our entourage people known as Zera Yisrael who feel Jewish but are not legally Jew. These people go to our synagogues, go to the same summer camp/organisation, share the same names (Cohen, Levy or other) and we know them since we are children as they are sometime the child of our parent friends, a neighbourg or even sometime a cousin...
We celebrate the same holidays, we have the same background and we all feel part of the Jewish people like brothers and sisters but... still they are not legally Jew. It is likely they will marry with Jewish people which deepen the problem.

What should be the approach with them? Should it only be a legal point and talk about a " regularisation " instead of conversion?
David
Paris
May 6, 2014
Regarding David's Comments
If you're going to deny everything that is not written explicitly in the Torah then you're going to dismiss almost all of Judaism. Not even your Karaites are willing to do that. As far as someone who is willing to consider that possibly the Karaites are right, that person is not ready to discuss conversion to Rabbinic Judaism. The Book of Ezra is pretty explicit, having the men who intermarried divorcing their wives and sending their children away. IF the children were possibly Jewish why would Ezra send them with their mothers?

That said, I know quite a few Mischlingen who have successfully converted to Orthodox Judaism. It's far from impossible.
Rabbi Aryeh Moshen
Brooklyn, NY
May 5, 2014
If it was wrong...?
I have been thinking about this question which is central for the life of a lot of people and while I am not a professional of the halacha, I tried to made some modest research...
From what I understand, there is no clear black on white mention confirming the child of a Jewish man and a goya is not Jewish... It is based on deduction and analysis of several texts.
Given the importance of this question, how can we be 100% sure we should not recognise them as Jewish?
What if we were wrong and we were pushing a part of the Jewish people out of their home?
From what I know, some Jewish communities (e.g. the karaite) recognised the patrilineality... based on the analysis of text as well!
How can we be 100% sure who is right and who is not? How can we be ready to take the risk of having wrong given the importance of this question which change the life of millions of people?

David
David
Paris
December 25, 2013
oy vey
My father is Jewish, his parents left Russia in 1916. Rabinowitz was their name, they landed in Brownsville Brooklyn and opened a fruit stand. My father raised me, he told me stories of his life, of his parents life. My fathers genetic material runs through me and into my daughter. It is wearisome to hear Jews talk as if religious practice is what defines them as Jews when we know, Jews know, we define ourselves culturally as well. There are religious Jews and there are secular Jews. The Jewish culture and history is deep within me, no-one can take that from me, it is simply there. I do not care to be accepted by ANY religious group, I do not ask you for acceptance, I define myself, I know my family and my family's history, they are my people, and they were, from my fathers, side Jewish. My fathers family, his ethics, his viewpoint and his soul are a part of me, they are deeply bound in being Jewish...ergo...I am bound. Let us keep our hearts open to others and to G-D
K.B.F
Santa Fe, NM
November 25, 2013
To the Georgian
In terms of Israel: If you can prove that your grandmother is Jewish then you could be welcomed as an Ethnic Jew returning home. You will not be recognized as a Jew for the purpose of marriage or burial in a Jewish cemetery.

Locally: There are orthodox synagogues in Atlanta and Savannah.
Rabbi Aryeh Moshen
Brooklyn, NY
November 24, 2013
My father's mother was a Jew but she lived in "the south". She gave birth to my father in 1941. She did not share her heritage with everyone. Her name was Mayer Simmons. My father died when I was four and my mother took me away from her. It was not until later that she shared with me her secret and shared her traditions. She planted a Chuppah tree for me...all her children and grandchild. I remember this clearly. I was afraid to do anything with it at the time since I still lived with my mother, who was not Jewish. I was told that is was her that wanted me to be born and that I was an accident by my birth mother. I was put into my Grandmother's will with a child's portion not a grandchild portion. I took my father's place since he was not alive when she past away. So I feel that I have a Jewish mother. I wonder where I stand...I feel lost and I have never felt that I belong anywhere...
Anonymous
Georgia, USA
Show all comments
Load next 50